WBAUnofficial
Players we need to move on. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Players we need to move on. (/showthread.php?tid=11702)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Players we need to move on. - SW4Baggie - 07-24-2020

(07-24-2020, 07:56 PM)Cunningham1979 Wrote: Joe Hart has forgotten more about goalkeeping that Sam will ever know. As an additional experienced keeper he would be a terrific signing. Palmer out on another loan

Defence 

Gibbs is good enough but cannot he relied upon. We definitely need a left back and to ship Townsend out.

Ajayi has potential and deserves a shot at the PL. Hegazi and Bartley will do as back up but we definitely need a first choice centre half.

O’Shea and Furlong may or may not be good enough. Priorities elsewhere so they will have to do

Midfield

Pereira, Sawyers, Livermore, Grosicki, Phillips to remain. Harper, Edwards, Field, Leko out on Championship loan. Burke to leave with Brunt and Barry

Strikers

None of our three are good enough so I’m pretty sanguine about who stays. Whatever happens we need two new ones. Tulloch out on loan

Big business to be done. I’d like to see a GK, Left back, Centre Half, Box to box midfielder and two strikers. As an absolute minimum

Fair assessment. I’d keep Field around. He can play the Sawyers role, and with Brunt and Barry leaving he’d be a good player to have around. We need someone with strength and energy in the middle as we’ve conceded far too many goals through not tracking runners.

XXXX, Livermore, Sawyers and Field is perfectly capable, with Harper on loan. Krov will definitely play further forward with Pereira.


RE: Players we need to move on. - Moore Than - 07-24-2020

If I had my way - ignoring how practical it is to get rid of them or not, I’d get rid of:

Johnstone
Peltier
Bartley
Hegazi
Townsend
Barry
Zohore
HRK
Austin
Burke

Matt Phillips, I’d probably just about keep as a squad filler.

None of these guys are going to be good enough for the Premier League.


RE: Players we need to move on. - GunsOfNavarone - 07-25-2020

Must just be me, but I can't help thinking Ajayi's brittle. Often misjudges the flight of the ball and I'm generally left asking myself where the fuck he is positionally. Pace to get back into position is fine so long as you're close enough for it to matter. As I say, probably just me though.


RE: Players we need to move on. - ChamonixBaggie - 07-25-2020

What's everyone's issue with Townsend? If you read most of the ratings threads he gets praised and has played well. Then a few days later he's "not good enough" again?? I think he's had... Maybe 2 outright bad games this season?

Some selective memory going on


RE: Players we need to move on. - Sliced - 07-25-2020

(07-25-2020, 05:42 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: What's everyone's issue with Townsend? If you read most of the ratings threads he gets praised and has played well. Then a few days later he's "not good enough" again?? I think he's had... Maybe 2 outright bad games this season?

Some selective memory going on

People decided he wasn't good enough before they'd ever seen him play. 

It's hard to accept being wrong so he's still a "league one player".

Personally I'd have much more concern about both CB and RB positions than Townsend


RE: Players we need to move on. - HLS - 07-25-2020

(07-25-2020, 08:15 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(07-25-2020, 05:42 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: What's everyone's issue with Townsend? If you read most of the ratings threads he gets praised and has played well. Then a few days later he's "not good enough" again?? I think he's had... Maybe 2 outright bad games this season?

Some selective memory going on

People decided he wasn't good enough before they'd ever seen him play. 

It's hard to accept being wrong so he's still a "league one player".

Personally I'd have much more concern about both CB and RB positions than Townsend

I agree. No issue with Townsend myself. At this point, I'd probably keep him moreso than glass-bottle Gibbs. Hasn't stopped improving since he's been here.


RE: Players we need to move on. - Duffers - 07-25-2020

(07-25-2020, 05:42 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: What's everyone's issue with Townsend? If you read most of the ratings threads he gets praised and has played well. Then a few days later he's "not good enough" again?? I think he's had... Maybe 2 outright bad games this season?

Some selective memory going on

Spot on. He’s easy target when the spacegoating starts.


RE: Players we need to move on. - Hopalong - 07-25-2020

(07-24-2020, 08:25 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(07-24-2020, 08:23 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Zohore scored 1 in 19 games for Cardiff in his last season there. Top scouting that FFS

Pure Panic.

He was bought (and for nowhere near 8m) based on what he achieved in the Championship which was virtually getting Cardiff promoted single-handedly. The problem was, Dowling forget to check with Bilic whether he wanted him/would fit the way he played. 

Zohore has never had a proper opportunity and never been backed by his manager hence he has not been a success, yet. Had he had the same pitch time as  HR-K - based on his last season with Cardiff in the Chump it's likely he'd have scored 15-20 goals given the number of chances we create, as he tends to score when presented with a decent chance. 

Let's deal in simple facts. He scored 5 goals this season. He started 6 games. 6 games ffs. 

People say 'oh Fatty Phillips needs 6 games to get up to speed'. This guy has never been given a chance to even stretch his legs! Whilst week after week we have suffered the total ineptitude of HRK and the Busted Flush. Finally Bilic wakes up and plays a pacy striker, (who is capable of running past the last defender) in the last game of the season and bingo!


RE: Players we need to move on. - Birdman1811 - 07-25-2020

(07-25-2020, 09:57 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(07-24-2020, 08:25 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(07-24-2020, 08:23 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Zohore scored 1 in 19 games for Cardiff in his last season there. Top scouting that FFS

Pure Panic.

He was bought (and for nowhere near 8m) based on what he achieved in the Championship which was virtually getting Cardiff promoted single-handedly. The problem was, Dowling forget to check with Bilic whether he wanted him/would fit the way he played. 

Zohore has never had a proper opportunity and never been backed by his manager hence he has not been a success, yet. Had he had the same pitch time as  HR-K - based on his last season with Cardiff in the Chump it's likely he'd have scored 15-20 goals given the number of chances we create, as he tends to score when presented with a decent chance. 

Let's deal in simple facts. He scored 5 goals this season. He started 6 games. 6 games ffs. 

People say 'oh Fatty Phillips needs 6 games to get up to speed'. This guy has never been given a chance to even stretch his legs! Whilst week after week we have suffered the total ineptitude of HRK and the Busted Flush. Finally Bilic wakes up and plays a pacy striker, (who is capable of running past the last defender) in the last game of the season and bingo!

That's one of the most sensible and thought out posts you've ever made. Agree. I don't think we've seen the last of Zohore.


RE: Players we need to move on. - devonstroller - 07-25-2020

I'd sooner get rid of Austin than HRK. Concern with HRK is whether the first half of this season (he was excellent - remember!?) was a particularly purple patch never to be seen again. Hegazi, Ajayi and Bartley are all good enough for a mid to lower prem team (which is all I'm happily aiming for this season) and I think we'll stick with Johnstone too. Townsend also - he's done fine. I don't want to see a complete overhaul - this team deserves a shot at the premier league pretty much as it is.