WBAUnofficial
100, 000 daily tests - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: 100, 000 daily tests (/showthread.php?tid=10136)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: 100, 000 daily tests - baggy1 - 05-13-2020

I think he meant it in the sense of it being difficult to process rather than not believing anyone who didn't have his viewpoint tbf


RE: 100, 000 daily tests - billybassett - 05-13-2020

(05-13-2020, 11:32 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 11:29 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 08:53 AM)JOK Wrote: I appreciate there will be variables B1. I also acknowledge that the death rate in care homes is pretty bad. What I would say though is that the home mom is in isn’t particularly well appointed. In fact my sister and niece regularly clean mom’s room themselves. The dining area and lounge are cramped and again not particularly hygienic. I must say though that the staff a wonderful though stretched at times.
Call me a cynic but I can’t help thinking there are some, shall we say, exaggerated anecdotal evidence being written for effect.

What does frustrate / baffle / intrigue me (not sure what word to use) is the randomness of the outcomes, which can’t be denied. My mother, who tested positive,  will be 100 in September, is in very poor health particularly her lungs. She has vascular dementia and can barely walk. She showed no symptoms apart from some fluid on her lungs, which she is hospitalised for often anyway and is now “back to normal”. Yet perfectly healthy young people have died  within days! I wonder if we will ever know the reasons.

Under 45yrs only a few hundred people have died. Mainly due to underlying health conditions. So perfectly healthy people in 99.99% of cases haven't died. It is almost exclusively a killer of those who are already weakened in some way. For example, overweight, smokers, drinkers, diabetics with circulatory issues.

So Americans then?

By the way be careful out there now you can go out more. Way way more likely to die on the roads/rail and footpaths of britain than that pesky covid


RE: 100, 000 daily tests - fuzzbox - 05-13-2020

"I fear advocates of eugenics and white supremacism are going to dine out on this hypothesis."

Possibly. Perhaps I should have added the 'unlikely' at the start.

Though if you're tolerant to something it would be a likely indicator that 'you started it'! Most likely with your dirty, devil-worshipping, goat-fucking ways....

So white supremacists are going to be able to dine out either way. Although, statistically, it will probably be at a mcdonalds.


RE: 100, 000 daily tests - baggy1 - 05-13-2020

(05-13-2020, 01:05 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 11:32 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 11:29 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 08:53 AM)JOK Wrote: I appreciate there will be variables B1. I also acknowledge that the death rate in care homes is pretty bad. What I would say though is that the home mom is in isn’t particularly well appointed. In fact my sister and niece regularly clean mom’s room themselves. The dining area and lounge are cramped and again not particularly hygienic. I must say though that the staff a wonderful though stretched at times.
Call me a cynic but I can’t help thinking there are some, shall we say, exaggerated anecdotal evidence being written for effect.

What does frustrate / baffle / intrigue me (not sure what word to use) is the randomness of the outcomes, which can’t be denied. My mother, who tested positive,  will be 100 in September, is in very poor health particularly her lungs. She has vascular dementia and can barely walk. She showed no symptoms apart from some fluid on her lungs, which she is hospitalised for often anyway and is now “back to normal”. Yet perfectly healthy young people have died  within days! I wonder if we will ever know the reasons.

Under 45yrs only a few hundred people have died. Mainly due to underlying health conditions. So perfectly healthy people in 99.99% of cases haven't died. It is almost exclusively a killer of those who are already weakened in some way. For example, overweight, smokers, drinkers, diabetics with circulatory issues.

So Americans then?

By the way be careful out there now you can go out more. Way way more likely to die on the roads/rail and footpaths of britain than that pesky covid

50,000 excess deaths this year in a total of 250,000 to week 18 would tell you differently, unless you are suggesting that more than 20% of our deaths occur on those three each year.

You can't hang on to this 'it's just the flu' approach for much longer now the stats are saying otherwise.


RE: 100, 000 daily tests - billybassett - 05-13-2020

(05-13-2020, 01:22 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 01:05 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 11:32 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 11:29 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 08:53 AM)JOK Wrote: I appreciate there will be variables B1. I also acknowledge that the death rate in care homes is pretty bad. What I would say though is that the home mom is in isn’t particularly well appointed. In fact my sister and niece regularly clean mom’s room themselves. The dining area and lounge are cramped and again not particularly hygienic. I must say though that the staff a wonderful though stretched at times.
Call me a cynic but I can’t help thinking there are some, shall we say, exaggerated anecdotal evidence being written for effect.

What does frustrate / baffle / intrigue me (not sure what word to use) is the randomness of the outcomes, which can’t be denied. My mother, who tested positive,  will be 100 in September, is in very poor health particularly her lungs. She has vascular dementia and can barely walk. She showed no symptoms apart from some fluid on her lungs, which she is hospitalised for often anyway and is now “back to normal”. Yet perfectly healthy young people have died  within days! I wonder if we will ever know the reasons.

Under 45yrs only a few hundred people have died. Mainly due to underlying health conditions. So perfectly healthy people in 99.99% of cases haven't died. It is almost exclusively a killer of those who are already weakened in some way. For example, overweight, smokers, drinkers, diabetics with circulatory issues.

So Americans then?

By the way be careful out there now you can go out more. Way way more likely to die on the roads/rail and footpaths of britain than that pesky covid

50,000 excess deaths this year in a total of 250,000 to week 18 would tell you differently, unless you are suggesting that more than 20% of our deaths occur on those three each year.

You can't hang on to this 'it's just the flu' approach for much longer now the stats are saying otherwise.

Probably should have been clearer but my statement 100% correct if you're under 45. 45-55 on a par. Over 55 it rises


RE: 100, 000 daily tests - baggy1 - 05-13-2020

No shit it rises! And as I'm on a par but pushing towards the over 55 then I'll take my chances staying at home thanks. It's a dangerous thought process to have BB because it makes under 45s complacent and more likely to asymptomatically pick up the virus which makes it more likely to pass that on to on older relative.


RE: 100, 000 daily tests - billybassett - 05-13-2020

(05-13-2020, 01:37 PM)baggy1 Wrote: No shit it rises! And as I'm on a par but pushing towards the over 55 then I'll take my chances staying at home thanks. It's a dangerous thought process to have BB because it makes under 45s complacent and more likely to asymptomatically pick up the virus which makes it more likely to pass that on to on older relative.

Fully take on the point about under 45s passing it on to those more vulnerable. But let those who want to stay at home stay there, let those that are vulnerable stay in lockdown, but let's get the younger populus out there fixing the wider damage as quite frankly they are probably more likely to die from stress/mental health/economic issues than covid


RE: 100, 000 daily tests - baggy1 - 05-13-2020

There is some logic to that argument BB and I would say that there needs to be a very limited approach to this - workers in construction, manufacturing, tied in with proper safety measures in place. However what happens then is that the virus survives for longer, which in itself means that the lockdown of the over 45s lasts for longer, which again has longer term damage.

We have ended up in a shit position because we acted slowly, let's not exacerbate that position by acting hastily at the other end. I appreciate people are getting impatient and want to return to normal, but unfortunately the decisions taken so far have meant that we have to maintain the lockdown longer and restrict measures to getting back to normal.


RE: 100, 000 daily tests - Derek Hardballs - 05-13-2020

(05-13-2020, 01:42 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(05-13-2020, 01:37 PM)baggy1 Wrote: No shit it rises! And as I'm on a par but pushing towards the over 55 then I'll take my chances staying at home thanks. It's a dangerous thought process to have BB because it makes under 45s complacent and more likely to asymptomatically pick up the virus which makes it more likely to pass that on to on older relative.

Fully take on the point about under 45s passing it on to those more vulnerable. But let those who want to stay at home stay there, let those that are vulnerable stay in lockdown, but let's get the younger populus out there fixing the wider damage as quite frankly they are probably more likely to die from stress/mental health/economic issues than covid

It really isn’t that simple. Two points one many who fall into the under 45s category are shielding someone and not just older people. They can’t just go out and work without some proper community testing in place and the numbers far lower than they are now. Secondly those shielded do what for the next year, two years? Become prisoners in their own home? Nothing is in place currently to make it safe for them to venture out.


RE: 100, 000 daily tests - billybassett - 05-13-2020

(05-13-2020, 01:50 PM)baggy1 Wrote: There is some logic to that argument BB and I would say that there needs to be a very limited approach to this - workers in construction, manufacturing, tied in with proper safety measures in place. However what happens then is that the virus survives for longer, which in itself means that the lockdown of the over 45s lasts for longer, which again has longer term damage.

We have ended up in a shit position because we acted slowly, let's not exacerbate that position by acting hastily at the other end. I appreciate people are getting impatient and want to return to normal, but unfortunately the decisions taken so far have meant that we have to maintain the lockdown longer and restrict measures to getting back to normal.

Couldn't agree more about that. Lock the bloody borders at the start of March ffs it was only going to get here over the sea. The govt has a lot to answer for on this.

We're talking about a situation where we are saving the over 65s at any cost whilst as usual the under 30s bear the brunt of the future pain and misery. A much smaller economy, costs rising, fewer jobs, brexit - add that to a lack of housing that costs an absolute fortune, tuition fees that run to tens of thousands, the planet dying and nobody doing anything about it etc etc

I'm a man over 50 but my son is of an age where he will have to operate in this world we are leaving him