WBAUnofficial
The Ashes - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The Ashes (/showthread.php?tid=39314)



RE: The Ashes - Gzbaggy - 12-21-2025

(12-21-2025, 06:50 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: The scale of the missed opportunity will be apparent when you see the Australian side on Boxing Day. There will be no Lyon and no Cummins. Australia are very good in their own conditions, but rarely do you get an Ashes tour where they give you so many chances. To be staring down the barrel of a whitewash in these circumstances is so poor.

No Josh Hazelwood either, have a look at his Test record


RE: The Ashes - Cheshire East Baggie - 12-21-2025

Stokes talking about moments. McCullum saying they didn't BazBall enough.

Win percentage now below 50% since the beginning of the 2023 Ashes.


RE: The Ashes - Josh1873 - 12-21-2025

You're not allowed to analyse recent Test results, you're only allowed to acknowledge the early wins and those wins against Test playing Nations at the lower echelons of the rankings, Zimbabwe, Ireland etc.


RE: The Ashes - Hughie Reed 31 - 12-21-2025

This central contracts bollocks needs to be looked at if you sign one
That should commit you to playing at least half the county championship games
That’s how we should be building a test team instead of just bash it around games


RE: The Ashes - pindgill - 12-21-2025

(12-21-2025, 09:06 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: On the Archer and Stokes front I agree that they have some credit from the first 3 tests. The former especially so. Should Archer be rested for the next test? With the Ashes gone, I suggest he should, bringing him back for the 5th.

Stokes future as captain rests on his relationship with BMc. If he is still supportive of his tenure to remain, then Stokes must be relieved of his skipper duties, though a suitable replacement within the current squad is nowhere to be seen.

There probably will be a significant bit of movement going forward, but Bazball should definitely be jettisoned. England have to start again and build a squad that befits test cricket. Under the current regime and squad that would require a huge transition. Heads have to roll and must start at the top.

The point is England,Australia & India have NOT got great pool of talented kids to rebuild a test squad all the kids are focused on franchise cricket and who can blame them!!… Angry


RE: The Ashes - Hughie Reed 31 - 12-21-2025

(12-21-2025, 10:36 AM)pindgill Wrote:
(12-21-2025, 09:06 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: On the Archer and Stokes front I agree that they have some credit from the first 3 tests. The former especially so. Should Archer be rested for the next test? With the Ashes gone, I suggest he should, bringing him back for the 5th.

Stokes future as captain rests on his relationship with BMc. If he is still supportive of his tenure to remain, then Stokes must be relieved of his skipper duties, though a suitable replacement within the current squad is nowhere to be seen.

There probably will be a significant bit of movement going forward, but Bazball should definitely be jettisoned. England have to start again and build a squad that befits test cricket. Under the current regime and squad that would require a huge transition. Heads have to roll and must start at the top.

The point is England,Australia & India have NOT got great pool of talented kids to rebuild a test squad all the kids are focused on franchise cricket and who can blame them!!… Angry

Isn’t that why these central contracts were drawn up to try and develop & keep players fresh
For international games seems to me that the players are signing them and still playing as much franchise stuff as they can.


RE: The Ashes - Beachboysbaggie - 12-21-2025

Win percentage was 6% before McCullum/Stokes
Since 2023 we’ve played 20 tests against Australia and India, among the best 2 test nations. No other team plays 5-test series against them. Clearly playing so often against the best teams will have a bearing on win percentage


RE: The Ashes - Jacko - 12-21-2025

There aren't going to be changes to the captain and coach imo. This series will see off 3 or 4 players though.


RE: The Ashes - Josh1873 - 12-21-2025

If the ECB don't remove Key and McCullum they're more clueless than I already think they are.


RE: The Ashes - Cheshire East Baggie - 12-21-2025

I'm a bit bemused that Aggers is now saying Stokes/McCullum should have a future as captain and coach. His take seems to be that if Key hadn't "let them do it", they wouldn't have made such mistakes in selection, culture and training. So Key gets the chop.

That's a bit weak for me. Stokes and McCullum have made some seriously faulty decisions based on nothing more than their "gut feel" and an increasing croneyism within the closed circle of the squad. They talked up this Ashes as being where it would all bear fruit. Which it hasn't - even if they claw it back to 3-2, I'm not having it that "it's not too bad after all". They've been inexcusably crap and have been hammered twice and beaten once.

I'm particularly exercised by the whole Shoaib Bashir situation. Stokes saw a few minutes of YouTube footage of this guy bowling and decided he would win us the Ashes in 2025/26. On which basis he canned the best spinner in the English game. For that alone, he needs to go IMO. Pathetic and arrogant behaviour from a man who doesn't have the brain to captain at the highest level.