![]() |
|
PSR breach reported by John Percy - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: PSR breach reported by John Percy (/showthread.php?tid=41270) |
RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - throstle - 04-21-2026 The £5.2m was used in the accounts to boost Albion's revenue - specifically it was used to increase 'other operating income'. The Swiss Ramble's excellent analysis explains: In fairness to West Brom, they have not exactly been sitting on their hands when it comes to confronting their PSR issues, as the pre-tax loss halved from £37.6m to £18.8m, including an increase in profit on player sales from £3.5m to £9.2m. However, the largest increase was in other operating income, which shot up £7.3m from £0.5m to £7.8m. One of the main reasons for the reduction in West Brom’s loss was a significant increase in other operating income, which shot up from £0.5m to £7.8m. This included a £5.2m recharge to owners Bilkul of all the interest arising on the MSD loan taken out during the club’s previous ownership. In addition the club received £2.5m in compensation from La Liga side Valencia after they recruited head coach Carlos Corberan and his staff. RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - SW4Baggie - 04-21-2026 (04-21-2026, 09:40 AM)throstle Wrote: The £5.2m was used in the accounts to boost Albion's revenue - specifically it was used to increase 'other operating income'. I think this is the closest we're going to get to genuinely understanding the problem, so thanks for posting this. What we don't know, and I suspect what will come out of any deliberations is whether or not we were transparent with the EFL around Bilkul's plan to do this and that will determine the severity of the punishment. We also do not know if any other clubs have injected cash in this way in their accounts... Given the complexities, I have no faith that this will be sorted this season, unless we achieve safety and both us and the EFL agree to a deduction that impacts nothing and we can brush the whole matter under the carpet. I think there will be no shortage of administrators hoping we post a healthy win tonight and neither Oxford nor Leicester pick up any points. I think a bigger question will be next season's numbers when we pay off the loans - until now we have only been paying interest... RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - throstle - 04-21-2026 (04-21-2026, 08:59 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:(04-20-2026, 10:18 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: And worth pointing out that the earlier reports indicated a PSR shortfall of around 1 million. The 5 million quoted was the total amount of the loan interest and it is likely that some (or much) of this would have been covered by some headroom in our PSR calculations. (04-21-2026, 09:55 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(04-21-2026, 09:40 AM)throstle Wrote: The £5.2m was used in the accounts to boost Albion's revenue - specifically it was used to increase 'other operating income'. I don't think any other clubs have injected cash in this way. Swiss Ramble comments: Few clubs book much money in this category, so West Brom’s £7.8m was actually the highest in the Championship last season, comfortably ahead of Plymouth Argyle £2.7m (insurance claim) and Norwich City £2.3m (player loans). RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - BristolCityInPeace - 04-21-2026 Paying off the Loans won't impact Profit and Loss, that isn't a concern IMO. Cash Flow kinda thing. It's only the Interest that goes against P&L in general. What I don't altogether get, is given Club and League were seemingly liaising quite closely, why it took so long to aeise as a potential debate/disputed item, sticking point whatever. The MSD Loan Cash Interest recharge since this possible Charge arose, I've thought this would be the difference between narrow compliance and narrow fail depending on accounting treatment. (04-21-2026, 09:18 AM)MrBater Wrote:(04-20-2026, 07:51 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:(04-20-2026, 07:01 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Thank you all, pleased to hear O'Leary is doing nicely ticking along. He split opinion with us but he could be prone to error and wasn't great technically but is a serviceable keeper in the Championship.Good post and it is a worry for the period just ended too and that may yield a bigger penalty. Yeah you sold well tbh, Wages surely will be lower than £37m, Diangana saves a £2m, £2.5m in amortisation alone. I just wonder if future compliant Forecasts in any way contingent on this method as a narrow pass or fail but selling well, Wages presumably falling more should remove the risk. (04-20-2026, 10:11 PM)Peachofacross Wrote:(04-20-2026, 09:56 AM)CIM Wrote:(04-20-2026, 08:35 AM)MrBater Wrote:(04-19-2026, 09:41 PM)throstle Wrote: Under the EFL sentencing guidelines, a loss of £5m receives a 5 point deduction. So, it is possible in the worst case scenario that Albion receive this punishment. A few articles - including unsurprisingly the Leicester press - have pointed this out. I reckon 2 or 3 points at the top end based on Reports, perhaps could even make a case for 1. Basically there is a sliding scale in EFL..but Leicester was messier as it is across 2 divisions so they take a % of the adjusted Upper Limit whereas if under EFL jurisdiction it is straight numbers. ie £20m/£83m with 1 back for improvement..relevant % under EFL guidelines. EFL is like this..roughly £1.00-£2m=3 Points £2m-£4m=4 Points £4m-£6m=5 Points £6m-£8m=6 Points £8m-£10m=7 Points £10m-£12.5m=8 Points £12.5m-£15m=9 Points £15m+=12 Points Mitigation and aggravating factors and so on too. Under pure EFL Rules Leicester probably would've got 12 Points minus one for improving Numbers. RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - SW4Baggie - 04-21-2026 Putting my conspiracy hat on, could it not be that someone from Leicester has got access to our accounts and leaked it to Percy, without there being any actual charge from the EFL? It could well be that both us and the EFL have been in discussions about this and no action was being taken, only for a digruntled outside agent to have leaked this and created a bit of a non story? Would certainly explain the radio silence from both sides. RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - MrBater - 04-21-2026 I thought Leicester got a reduction for being helpful in the investigations?? So we could be 3 minus 1 for better figures and minus 1 from improved financials... Either way let's fuck it in the bin a D just go a D get the wins we need to make it irrelevant RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - tHEgLASSdOORS - 04-21-2026 One point - announced tomorrow. RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Jacko - 04-21-2026 (04-21-2026, 05:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: One point - announced tomorrow. By Luke Williams being carried on FF's shoulders after a 30 mile walk. RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - CarlosCorbewrong - 04-21-2026 (04-21-2026, 11:10 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Putting my conspiracy hat on, could it not be that someone from Leicester has got access to our accounts and leaked it to Percy, without there being any actual charge from the EFL? It could well be that both us and the EFL have been in discussions about this and no action was being taken, only for a digruntled outside agent to have leaked this and created a bit of a non story? The leak was definitely from the FA to Percy, I have an impeccable sauce. RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Remi_Moses - 04-21-2026 (04-21-2026, 05:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: One point - announced tomorrow. Reminomics estimate Six points to keep Liecester and the other clubs with us at the bottom happy. |