![]() |
|
Bloody NIMBY’s… - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Bloody NIMBY’s… (/showthread.php?tid=43313) |
RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Borin' Baggie - 11-17-2026 How about we start at the same size warehouses that were part of the full planning submission by Peel when those houses were built and sold instead of the significantly bigger warehouses that were actually built, and adequate screening built to the same bund heights outlined in the earlier planning applications which were 2 to 3 times taller than what was actually built even considering that those plans were for lower warehouses, and any screening planted on proper topsoil, and proper drainage, and proper noise softening, and proper permanent noise restrictions put in place before operations started instead of months later because the residents had to pay for their own independent noise assessment. I think the residents would have preferred that, seeing as that's what Peel either promised/submitted planning for when those houses were sold or are basic common sense for any employment usage backing onto a residential development. RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Protheroe - 11-17-2026 How about caveat emptor? The conceit that a landowner with a broad allocation in a Local Plan should be bound by the original application in the absence of any other policy amendment since, is for the birds I'm afraid. Planning just doesn't work like that, or at least that's what the Planning Inspectorate would say. A wholly inadequate, badly screened, badly serviced site on a dangerous bend has just been given consent for travellers' pitches a mile and a half from me by the Inspector - because the Council had ignored its own policy in both under providing alternative sites and turning it down. All of the issues you have described (apart from the massing) ought to be delivered under reserved matters - if the Council wanted them done beforehand then they should have said so. They didn't. RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Borin' Baggie - 11-17-2026 So what? Residents aren't allowed to be pissed off at something being built right next door to them that wasn't what the existing planning permission covered when they bought their houses? Peel shouldn't be criticised for developing a site that fails to account for the basics for something next to a residential development? Wigan shouldn't be criticised for failing in their duties allowing the 2024 application to be rushed through and failing to put adequate conditions? What exactly is your point? You've defended Peel, argued the residents shouldn't be upset and that Wigan weren't negligent and then admit this situation is absurd. You're shadow boxing. I know how planning works, did you forget that I brought up that this is the exact type of thing that zoning would prevent in my very first comment in this thread? And I've already called out Wigan's incompetence. RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Protheroe - 11-17-2026 Yes, zoning would have ruled this out. Which is exactly why I'm in favour of zoning. I haven't defended anyone. I have told you how the current planning system works, what you can and can't do, what residents can and can't expect. I haven't said that Wigan can't be criticised, far from it - but there is a limit to what they can do given the ridiculous circumstances they created for themselves in the first place. (11-17-2026, 05:55 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: …and that ladies and gentlemen is why you can never trust a developer in this country. Absolutely no desire to do what’s right, no empathy whatsoever and only cares about profit. Profit is hard to come by because of the land rationing system you support. If planning were liberalised there would be far more options away from housing for developers to build big sheds on. RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Derek Hardballs - 11-18-2026 (11-17-2026, 10:50 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Yes, zoning would have ruled this out. Which is exactly why I'm in favour of zoning. The developer had a choice, to create a reasonable and proportionate industrial units, that worked alongside the housing development or they could simply maximise their returns because it was possible. Surprise, surprise they chose the latter, that doesn’t make it right or ethical, it just reinforces the view that both the council and developer don’t care at all about the quality of life for those living in that area. You want less ‘nimbyism’ then don’t ride roughshod over people’s lives, treating them with contempt and collateral damage when inexcusable developments like the one in the opening post occur. RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Protheroe - 11-18-2026 (11-18-2026, 01:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You want less ‘nimbyism’ then don’t ride roughshod over people’s lives, treating them with contempt and collateral damage when inexcusable developments like the one in the opening post occur. If only it were that simple. Most people are anti any development on their doorstep. RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - baggy1 - 11-18-2026 Thankfully the ones in the opening post are not the norm, however the amount that will object to any development of housing is the norm I'm afraid. You've only got to take a look at the outskirts of any major conurbation to see protests against any development at all. Do a search on 'Keep Tidbury Green' to get the idea. RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Protheroe - 11-18-2026 To be fair everyone agitating against development on their doorstep should instead by agitating for what this country actually needs; a new city for 500,000 at the lower end of the M40 and the rapid development of settlements and infrastructure on the Oxford / MK / Cambridge corridor. |