WBAUnofficial
Budget 2026 - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Budget 2026 (/showthread.php?tid=43165)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Budget 2026 - man in the corner shop - 10-30-2026

"Given it's predecessors, maybe we should thank the heavens for those small mercies"


RE: Budget 2026 - Protheroe - 10-31-2026

Day-to-day departmental spending will grow by 2.4% this year. From next year it is meant to rise by only about 1% a year. In 2029-30, a supposed election year, it is scheduled to grow by just 0.5%.


RE: Budget 2026 - Protheroe - 11-01-2026

Matthew Syed in The Sunday Times Today:


"I don’t want to do myself out of the job I love but this column has reached a logical end point. The purpose of opinion pieces is to inform, and this column will tell you nothing you don’t already know.

The budget was a charade. But you know that already. Its purpose was not to act but to offer the illusion of action. Sixty minutes of nothingness, of drift, of performative theatre. John Healey (a classic example of what they call a non-player character) offered irrelevant announcement after irrelevant announcement, confetti after confetti, pointless tax tweak after tweak, while calling it “decisive”.

This is what British politics has come to: as much hot air as possible to distract from the absence of what policy should be about. Growth.

The Office for Budget Responsibility confirmed it even as Healey sat down. Living standards will not have budged, except within the margin of error, between 2020 and 2030. They didn’t grow much in the previous decade, either, or the one before that. Having just returned from America, whose economy has grown by 20 percentage points more than the UK over the past 20 years, the difference is palpable. We are going nowhere. And thus in relative terms against America, India, China, Taiwan, Poland and the like, we are sinking.

This is depressing but you know it already. You also know what the chancellor should have said. Every person reading these words, or commentating on them, knows that there is a sure route to growth. Not just growth but the kind of expansion that could outstrip our rivals given our huge assets such as leading universities, AI sector and rule of law.

I am talking about radical planning reform to build homes and energy infrastructure. I am talking about cuts to welfare and the merging of income tax and national insurance (as part of a programme of tax simplification). I am talking about ending the self-harming assault on non-doms, who have left this nation in droves, and stopping the small boats. I am talking, too, about a broader shift in favour of risk-takers, enterprise and striving rather than a system set up to punish those things and encourage their opposite. Regulation, too, should be aimed not just at the risk of action but of inaction. In a fast-changing world, the nightmare is not innovation that fails, but a rigid status quo that has become a deadweight around our necks.

I could go on, but you get the picture. These policies are not just doable, but eminently so. I have talked to special advisers who say the problem is not implementation but political will. So why doesn’t it happen? It would be easy to blame the Labour government, which is what most right-wing commentators have done in recent days. Bloody Burnham and Healey, Starmer and Reeves. Socialists, all. If only we could get the Tories back in power. But this is utter hogwash. Growth was virtually non-existent under the Tories for 14 years, for heaven’s sake. Moreover, growth would have been non-existent under Reform, the Conservatives or the Lib Dems if their 2024 manifestos had been implemented. All were offering the same growth-sapping, debt-escalating insanity. Isn’t this fascinating? It seems as if everyone knows how to drive growth except the politicians who are paid to do so.
Are we living in a Kafka short story? As you ponder this question, consider another aspect of this grim surrealism. You’ll have noticed that when ministers leave active politics, they suddenly see the light. The scales fall from their eyes. All the things they should have done in power, but failed to do, become as obvious to them as to the rest of us. It’s like they’ve been unplugged from the matrix.

Take the triple lock, defended by every minister (even “brave” Burnham isn’t going to change it for at least four years and only then to partially fund the even greater cost of social care) until the moment they leave office. Jeremy Hunt eulogised the policy as chancellor, then abruptly noticed that it was an “anchor drag on growth” after losing his job. He sounded like Neo after swallowing the red pill. I could tell the same story of David Gauke, Gillian Keegan, Michael Gove, Uncle Tom Cobley and Cypher, Neo’s mate. The only Conservatives defending the triple lock today are on the front bench. Hold that thought.

Or take the testimony of Rishi Sunak, perhaps the most important columnist in the UK today on account of his intelligence and honesty. And what emerges is a good man of huge talent who knew he was plugged into the matrix but couldn’t quite free himself. On the triple lock, he proposed an even more expensive quadruple lock at the 2024 election. He approved job-harming increases in the living wage, later saying he should have rejected them (“I wish I’d been braver”). He diluted housing targets, increased spending and taxes and failed to liberalise planning. He now says these were errors and that he should have prioritised growth.

And this pierces the heart of our predicament. The problem isn’t this government. It is all governments. Go back and read the manifestos at the last election. Look at the Tory record in power. All are offering the rhetoric of growth but the policies of decline. None are saying what only becomes obvious the moment they leave power.
So is it not obvious what is wrong? The problem is not politicians; it’s voters. Politicians get sucked into the matrix only because this is the unreality the people whose votes they need inhabit. Sure, the voters are not homogeneous, and many people despair of what is happening, but a political system must be judged on its results. And ours have been clear for almost a generation. We are sinking because democracy — a system designed to implement the wishes of the electorate — is working precisely as intended. Jean-Claude Juncker put it this way: “We all know what to do, we just don’t know how to get re-elected after we’ve done it.”

And this is the truth nobody wants to hear. Every confetti announcement is a performance staged not for politicians but voters. Every budget is a charade designed not to generate growth but to avoid it. Voters have demanded higher spending, taxation and debt — the perfect recipe for stagnation — for years at a time. I mean, do you really think the record under Ed Davey or Nigel Farage would have been different, given that we have had near-zero growth under Labour and Tory, Cameron and Starmer, Hunt and Reeves and, for that matter, both inside and outside the EU?

Wake up, folks. There are no magic solutions here except those that come from within. Because remember this too: in the film, Morpheus offered the red pill, but Neo had to reach out to take it. He only exited the matrix via his own volition. So the next time a politician promises growth without asking you to give up something you value (no new homes ruining your view, no change to your pension, no pain except for someone else), ask who that speech was written for. Then ask the vital follow-up question: would you vote for the alternative? Because until enough of us say “yes”, budgets will remain a charade. And our great nation will continue its heartbreaking decline."


RE: Budget 2026 - Pontificator - 11-02-2026

(11-01-2026, 01:13 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Matthew Syed in The Sunday Times Today:


"I don’t want to do myself out of the job I love but this column has reached a logical end point. The purpose of opinion pieces is to inform, and this column will tell you nothing you don’t already know.

The budget was a charade. But you know that already. Its purpose was not to act but to offer the illusion of action. Sixty minutes of nothingness, of drift, of performative theatre. John Healey (a classic example of what they call a non-player character) offered irrelevant announcement after irrelevant announcement, confetti after confetti, pointless tax tweak after tweak, while calling it “decisive”.

This is what British politics has come to: as much hot air as possible to distract from the absence of what policy should be about. Growth.

The Office for Budget Responsibility confirmed it even as Healey sat down. Living standards will not have budged, except within the margin of error, between 2020 and 2030. They didn’t grow much in the previous decade, either, or the one before that. Having just returned from America, whose economy has grown by 20 percentage points more than the UK over the past 20 years, the difference is palpable. We are going nowhere. And thus in relative terms against America, India, China, Taiwan, Poland and the like, we are sinking.

This is depressing but you know it already. You also know what the chancellor should have said. Every person reading these words, or commentating on them, knows that there is a sure route to growth. Not just growth but the kind of expansion that could outstrip our rivals given our huge assets such as leading universities, AI sector and rule of law.

I am talking about radical planning reform to build homes and energy infrastructure. I am talking about cuts to welfare and the merging of income tax and national insurance (as part of a programme of tax simplification). I am talking about ending the self-harming assault on non-doms, who have left this nation in droves, and stopping the small boats. I am talking, too, about a broader shift in favour of risk-takers, enterprise and striving rather than a system set up to punish those things and encourage their opposite. Regulation, too, should be aimed not just at the risk of action but of inaction. In a fast-changing world, the nightmare is not innovation that fails, but a rigid status quo that has become a deadweight around our necks.

I could go on, but you get the picture. These policies are not just doable, but eminently so. I have talked to special advisers who say the problem is not implementation but political will. So why doesn’t it happen? It would be easy to blame the Labour government, which is what most right-wing commentators have done in recent days. Bloody Burnham and Healey, Starmer and Reeves. Socialists, all. If only we could get the Tories back in power. But this is utter hogwash. Growth was virtually non-existent under the Tories for 14 years, for heaven’s sake. Moreover, growth would have been non-existent under Reform, the Conservatives or the Lib Dems if their 2024 manifestos had been implemented. All were offering the same growth-sapping, debt-escalating insanity. Isn’t this fascinating? It seems as if everyone knows how to drive growth except the politicians who are paid to do so.
Are we living in a Kafka short story? As you ponder this question, consider another aspect of this grim surrealism. You’ll have noticed that when ministers leave active politics, they suddenly see the light. The scales fall from their eyes. All the things they should have done in power, but failed to do, become as obvious to them as to the rest of us. It’s like they’ve been unplugged from the matrix.

Take the triple lock, defended by every minister (even “brave” Burnham isn’t going to change it for at least four years and only then to partially fund the even greater cost of social care) until the moment they leave office. Jeremy Hunt eulogised the policy as chancellor, then abruptly noticed that it was an “anchor drag on growth” after losing his job. He sounded like Neo after swallowing the red pill. I could tell the same story of David Gauke, Gillian Keegan, Michael Gove, Uncle Tom Cobley and Cypher, Neo’s mate. The only Conservatives defending the triple lock today are on the front bench. Hold that thought.

Or take the testimony of Rishi Sunak, perhaps the most important columnist in the UK today on account of his intelligence and honesty. And what emerges is a good man of huge talent who knew he was plugged into the matrix but couldn’t quite free himself. On the triple lock, he proposed an even more expensive quadruple lock at the 2024 election. He approved job-harming increases in the living wage, later saying he should have rejected them (“I wish I’d been braver”). He diluted housing targets, increased spending and taxes and failed to liberalise planning. He now says these were errors and that he should have prioritised growth.

And this pierces the heart of our predicament. The problem isn’t this government. It is all governments. Go back and read the manifestos at the last election. Look at the Tory record in power. All are offering the rhetoric of growth but the policies of decline. None are saying what only becomes obvious the moment they leave power.
So is it not obvious what is wrong? The problem is not politicians; it’s voters. Politicians get sucked into the matrix only because this is the unreality the people whose votes they need inhabit. Sure, the voters are not homogeneous, and many people despair of what is happening, but a political system must be judged on its results. And ours have been clear for almost a generation. We are sinking because democracy — a system designed to implement the wishes of the electorate — is working precisely as intended. Jean-Claude Juncker put it this way: “We all know what to do, we just don’t know how to get re-elected after we’ve done it.”

And this is the truth nobody wants to hear. Every confetti announcement is a performance staged not for politicians but voters. Every budget is a charade designed not to generate growth but to avoid it. Voters have demanded higher spending, taxation and debt — the perfect recipe for stagnation — for years at a time. I mean, do you really think the record under Ed Davey or Nigel Farage would have been different, given that we have had near-zero growth under Labour and Tory, Cameron and Starmer, Hunt and Reeves and, for that matter, both inside and outside the EU?

Wake up, folks. There are no magic solutions here except those that come from within. Because remember this too: in the film, Morpheus offered the red pill, but Neo had to reach out to take it. He only exited the matrix via his own volition. So the next time a politician promises growth without asking you to give up something you value (no new homes ruining your view, no change to your pension, no pain except for someone else), ask who that speech was written for. Then ask the vital follow-up question: would you vote for the alternative? Because until enough of us say “yes”, budgets will remain a charade. And our great nation will continue its heartbreaking decline."

I’m usually impressed by Syed’s columns, and he’s always been a progressive. To write this without mentioning the disaster of Brexit, though, he’s lost the plot. Inside the EU we’d be an estimated 6-8% better off in GDP terms. In my view, the division sown by anti-EU activists, Russian interference, a toxic, divisive debate, made it far more likely Putin would feel free to invade Ukraine. We should by now have been moving towards a federation of states and with an uncompromising military. The Tories have been an absolute disaster and Mat decides to join them - fuck my old boots


RE: Budget 2026 - Protheroe - 11-02-2026

(11-02-2026, 08:59 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(11-01-2026, 01:13 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Matthew Syed in The Sunday Times Today:


"I don’t want to do myself out of the job I love but this column has reached a logical end point. The purpose of opinion pieces is to inform, and this column will tell you nothing you don’t already know.

The budget was a charade. But you know that already. Its purpose was not to act but to offer the illusion of action. Sixty minutes of nothingness, of drift, of performative theatre. John Healey (a classic example of what they call a non-player character) offered irrelevant announcement after irrelevant announcement, confetti after confetti, pointless tax tweak after tweak, while calling it “decisive”.

This is what British politics has come to: as much hot air as possible to distract from the absence of what policy should be about. Growth.

The Office for Budget Responsibility confirmed it even as Healey sat down. Living standards will not have budged, except within the margin of error, between 2020 and 2030. They didn’t grow much in the previous decade, either, or the one before that. Having just returned from America, whose economy has grown by 20 percentage points more than the UK over the past 20 years, the difference is palpable. We are going nowhere. And thus in relative terms against America, India, China, Taiwan, Poland and the like, we are sinking.

This is depressing but you know it already. You also know what the chancellor should have said. Every person reading these words, or commentating on them, knows that there is a sure route to growth. Not just growth but the kind of expansion that could outstrip our rivals given our huge assets such as leading universities, AI sector and rule of law.

I am talking about radical planning reform to build homes and energy infrastructure. I am talking about cuts to welfare and the merging of income tax and national insurance (as part of a programme of tax simplification). I am talking about ending the self-harming assault on non-doms, who have left this nation in droves, and stopping the small boats. I am talking, too, about a broader shift in favour of risk-takers, enterprise and striving rather than a system set up to punish those things and encourage their opposite. Regulation, too, should be aimed not just at the risk of action but of inaction. In a fast-changing world, the nightmare is not innovation that fails, but a rigid status quo that has become a deadweight around our necks.

I could go on, but you get the picture. These policies are not just doable, but eminently so. I have talked to special advisers who say the problem is not implementation but political will. So why doesn’t it happen? It would be easy to blame the Labour government, which is what most right-wing commentators have done in recent days. Bloody Burnham and Healey, Starmer and Reeves. Socialists, all. If only we could get the Tories back in power. But this is utter hogwash. Growth was virtually non-existent under the Tories for 14 years, for heaven’s sake. Moreover, growth would have been non-existent under Reform, the Conservatives or the Lib Dems if their 2024 manifestos had been implemented. All were offering the same growth-sapping, debt-escalating insanity. Isn’t this fascinating? It seems as if everyone knows how to drive growth except the politicians who are paid to do so.
Are we living in a Kafka short story? As you ponder this question, consider another aspect of this grim surrealism. You’ll have noticed that when ministers leave active politics, they suddenly see the light. The scales fall from their eyes. All the things they should have done in power, but failed to do, become as obvious to them as to the rest of us. It’s like they’ve been unplugged from the matrix.

Take the triple lock, defended by every minister (even “brave” Burnham isn’t going to change it for at least four years and only then to partially fund the even greater cost of social care) until the moment they leave office. Jeremy Hunt eulogised the policy as chancellor, then abruptly noticed that it was an “anchor drag on growth” after losing his job. He sounded like Neo after swallowing the red pill. I could tell the same story of David Gauke, Gillian Keegan, Michael Gove, Uncle Tom Cobley and Cypher, Neo’s mate. The only Conservatives defending the triple lock today are on the front bench. Hold that thought.

Or take the testimony of Rishi Sunak, perhaps the most important columnist in the UK today on account of his intelligence and honesty. And what emerges is a good man of huge talent who knew he was plugged into the matrix but couldn’t quite free himself. On the triple lock, he proposed an even more expensive quadruple lock at the 2024 election. He approved job-harming increases in the living wage, later saying he should have rejected them (“I wish I’d been braver”). He diluted housing targets, increased spending and taxes and failed to liberalise planning. He now says these were errors and that he should have prioritised growth.

And this pierces the heart of our predicament. The problem isn’t this government. It is all governments. Go back and read the manifestos at the last election. Look at the Tory record in power. All are offering the rhetoric of growth but the policies of decline. None are saying what only becomes obvious the moment they leave power.
So is it not obvious what is wrong? The problem is not politicians; it’s voters. Politicians get sucked into the matrix only because this is the unreality the people whose votes they need inhabit. Sure, the voters are not homogeneous, and many people despair of what is happening, but a political system must be judged on its results. And ours have been clear for almost a generation. We are sinking because democracy — a system designed to implement the wishes of the electorate — is working precisely as intended. Jean-Claude Juncker put it this way: “We all know what to do, we just don’t know how to get re-elected after we’ve done it.”

And this is the truth nobody wants to hear. Every confetti announcement is a performance staged not for politicians but voters. Every budget is a charade designed not to generate growth but to avoid it. Voters have demanded higher spending, taxation and debt — the perfect recipe for stagnation — for years at a time. I mean, do you really think the record under Ed Davey or Nigel Farage would have been different, given that we have had near-zero growth under Labour and Tory, Cameron and Starmer, Hunt and Reeves and, for that matter, both inside and outside the EU?

Wake up, folks. There are no magic solutions here except those that come from within. Because remember this too: in the film, Morpheus offered the red pill, but Neo had to reach out to take it. He only exited the matrix via his own volition. So the next time a politician promises growth without asking you to give up something you value (no new homes ruining your view, no change to your pension, no pain except for someone else), ask who that speech was written for. Then ask the vital follow-up question: would you vote for the alternative? Because until enough of us say “yes”, budgets will remain a charade. And our great nation will continue its heartbreaking decline."

I’m usually impressed by Syed’s columns, and he’s always been a progressive. To write this without mentioning the disaster of Brexit, though, he’s lost the plot. Inside the EU we’d be an estimated 6-8% better off in GDP terms. In my view, the division sown by anti-EU activists, Russian interference, a toxic, divisive debate, made it far more likely Putin would feel free to invade Ukraine. We should by now have been moving towards a federation of states and with an uncompromising military. The Tories have been an absolute disaster and Mat decides to join them - fuck my old boots

Labour has singularly failed to address growth. Our economy has been remarkably resilient despite this. Imagine if they'd encouraged growth?

This narrative about Brexit is absurd when you look at what's happening to major economies inside the EU currently, and when you consider that exports to the EU of things we're actually good at (services) are up 28% in real terms since Brexit - for the rest of the world it's up 26%.

And instead of assisting the service economy to grow Labour puts further impediments to that growth is every Budget, and worse still gaslights us all about some vague notion of "reindustrialising" the UK economy when industry has been decimated by global competition and latterly the world's highest energy prices.


RE: Budget 2026 - Pontificator - 11-02-2026

(11-02-2026, 10:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-02-2026, 08:59 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(11-01-2026, 01:13 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Matthew Syed in The Sunday Times Today:


"I don’t want to do myself out of the job I love but this column has reached a logical end point. The purpose of opinion pieces is to inform, and this column will tell you nothing you don’t already know.

The budget was a charade. But you know that already. Its purpose was not to act but to offer the illusion of action. Sixty minutes of nothingness, of drift, of performative theatre. John Healey (a classic example of what they call a non-player character) offered irrelevant announcement after irrelevant announcement, confetti after confetti, pointless tax tweak after tweak, while calling it “decisive”.

This is what British politics has come to: as much hot air as possible to distract from the absence of what policy should be about. Growth.

The Office for Budget Responsibility confirmed it even as Healey sat down. Living standards will not have budged, except within the margin of error, between 2020 and 2030. They didn’t grow much in the previous decade, either, or the one before that. Having just returned from America, whose economy has grown by 20 percentage points more than the UK over the past 20 years, the difference is palpable. We are going nowhere. And thus in relative terms against America, India, China, Taiwan, Poland and the like, we are sinking.

This is depressing but you know it already. You also know what the chancellor should have said. Every person reading these words, or commentating on them, knows that there is a sure route to growth. Not just growth but the kind of expansion that could outstrip our rivals given our huge assets such as leading universities, AI sector and rule of law.

I am talking about radical planning reform to build homes and energy infrastructure. I am talking about cuts to welfare and the merging of income tax and national insurance (as part of a programme of tax simplification). I am talking about ending the self-harming assault on non-doms, who have left this nation in droves, and stopping the small boats. I am talking, too, about a broader shift in favour of risk-takers, enterprise and striving rather than a system set up to punish those things and encourage their opposite. Regulation, too, should be aimed not just at the risk of action but of inaction. In a fast-changing world, the nightmare is not innovation that fails, but a rigid status quo that has become a deadweight around our necks.

I could go on, but you get the picture. These policies are not just doable, but eminently so. I have talked to special advisers who say the problem is not implementation but political will. So why doesn’t it happen? It would be easy to blame the Labour government, which is what most right-wing commentators have done in recent days. Bloody Burnham and Healey, Starmer and Reeves. Socialists, all. If only we could get the Tories back in power. But this is utter hogwash. Growth was virtually non-existent under the Tories for 14 years, for heaven’s sake. Moreover, growth would have been non-existent under Reform, the Conservatives or the Lib Dems if their 2024 manifestos had been implemented. All were offering the same growth-sapping, debt-escalating insanity. Isn’t this fascinating? It seems as if everyone knows how to drive growth except the politicians who are paid to do so.
Are we living in a Kafka short story? As you ponder this question, consider another aspect of this grim surrealism. You’ll have noticed that when ministers leave active politics, they suddenly see the light. The scales fall from their eyes. All the things they should have done in power, but failed to do, become as obvious to them as to the rest of us. It’s like they’ve been unplugged from the matrix.

Take the triple lock, defended by every minister (even “brave” Burnham isn’t going to change it for at least four years and only then to partially fund the even greater cost of social care) until the moment they leave office. Jeremy Hunt eulogised the policy as chancellor, then abruptly noticed that it was an “anchor drag on growth” after losing his job. He sounded like Neo after swallowing the red pill. I could tell the same story of David Gauke, Gillian Keegan, Michael Gove, Uncle Tom Cobley and Cypher, Neo’s mate. The only Conservatives defending the triple lock today are on the front bench. Hold that thought.

Or take the testimony of Rishi Sunak, perhaps the most important columnist in the UK today on account of his intelligence and honesty. And what emerges is a good man of huge talent who knew he was plugged into the matrix but couldn’t quite free himself. On the triple lock, he proposed an even more expensive quadruple lock at the 2024 election. He approved job-harming increases in the living wage, later saying he should have rejected them (“I wish I’d been braver”). He diluted housing targets, increased spending and taxes and failed to liberalise planning. He now says these were errors and that he should have prioritised growth.

And this pierces the heart of our predicament. The problem isn’t this government. It is all governments. Go back and read the manifestos at the last election. Look at the Tory record in power. All are offering the rhetoric of growth but the policies of decline. None are saying what only becomes obvious the moment they leave power.
So is it not obvious what is wrong? The problem is not politicians; it’s voters. Politicians get sucked into the matrix only because this is the unreality the people whose votes they need inhabit. Sure, the voters are not homogeneous, and many people despair of what is happening, but a political system must be judged on its results. And ours have been clear for almost a generation. We are sinking because democracy — a system designed to implement the wishes of the electorate — is working precisely as intended. Jean-Claude Juncker put it this way: “We all know what to do, we just don’t know how to get re-elected after we’ve done it.”

And this is the truth nobody wants to hear. Every confetti announcement is a performance staged not for politicians but voters. Every budget is a charade designed not to generate growth but to avoid it. Voters have demanded higher spending, taxation and debt — the perfect recipe for stagnation — for years at a time. I mean, do you really think the record under Ed Davey or Nigel Farage would have been different, given that we have had near-zero growth under Labour and Tory, Cameron and Starmer, Hunt and Reeves and, for that matter, both inside and outside the EU?

Wake up, folks. There are no magic solutions here except those that come from within. Because remember this too: in the film, Morpheus offered the red pill, but Neo had to reach out to take it. He only exited the matrix via his own volition. So the next time a politician promises growth without asking you to give up something you value (no new homes ruining your view, no change to your pension, no pain except for someone else), ask who that speech was written for. Then ask the vital follow-up question: would you vote for the alternative? Because until enough of us say “yes”, budgets will remain a charade. And our great nation will continue its heartbreaking decline."

I’m usually impressed by Syed’s columns, and he’s always been a progressive. To write this without mentioning the disaster of Brexit, though, he’s lost the plot. Inside the EU we’d be an estimated 6-8% better off in GDP terms. In my view, the division sown by anti-EU activists, Russian interference, a toxic, divisive debate, made it far more likely Putin would feel free to invade Ukraine. We should by now have been moving towards a federation of states and with an uncompromising military. The Tories have been an absolute disaster and Mat decides to join them - fuck my old boots

Labour has singularly failed to address growth. Our economy has been remarkably resilient despite this. Imagine if they'd encouraged growth?

This narrative about Brexit is absurd when you look at what's happening to major economies inside the EU currently, and when you consider that exports to the EU of things we're actually good at (services) are up 28% in real terms since Brexit - for the rest of the world it's up 26%.

And instead of assisting the service economy to grow Labour puts further impediments to that growth is every Budget, and worse still gaslights us all about some vague notion of "reindustrialising" the UK economy when industry has been decimated by global competition and latterly the world's highest energy prices.

If it helps your guilt with the small part you played in BREXIT go with it, but the idea that BREXIT has not damaged the whole of the EU and the UK economically, socially and with the defence of our democracy is for the birds. Europe should be facing Trump's bullshit as near equals and yet look at the fucking state of it. I don't think Labour is doing a great job, but it's two years plus and it ain't easy is it? And without doubt the "least worse"


RE: Budget 2026 - Jacko - 11-02-2026

(11-02-2026, 08:59 AM)Pontificator Wrote: I’m usually impressed by Syed’s columns, and he’s always been a progressive. To write this without mentioning the disaster of Brexit, though, he’s lost the plot. Inside the EU we’d be an estimated 6-8% better off in GDP terms. In my view, the division sown by anti-EU activists, Russian interference, a toxic, divisive debate, made it far more likely Putin would feel free to invade Ukraine. We should by now have been moving towards a federation of states and with an uncompromising military. The Tories have been an absolute disaster and Mat decides to join them - fuck my old boots

Jesus Christ bananas. What the fuck?

Georgia? Crimea?

As to the US of E. I won't use the distasteful 4th Reich pejorative, but The New Rome is fair game I'd say? An unworkable, unwanted idea only deranged federalists are still pushing for.


RE: Budget 2026 - Protheroe - 11-02-2026

(11-02-2026, 11:20 AM)Pontificator Wrote: If it helps your guilt with the small part you played in BREXIT go with it, but the idea that BREXIT has not damaged the whole of the EU and the UK economically, socially and with the defence of our democracy is for the birds. Europe should be facing Trump's bullshit as near equals and yet look at the fucking state of it. I don't think Labour is doing a great job, but it's two years plus and it ain't easy is it? And without doubt the "least worse"

Indeed, look at the fucking state of it. Look at the fucking state of uber-federalist Merkel sucking up to Putin for gas even after Russia had taken Crimea.

Europe has sucked on the teat of American exceptionalism since WW2, has enjoyed decadent social benefits, early retirement and a post-Soviet "peace dividend" on the back of a compliant US. That support has now been cut and the Europeans, including us now have to tell our people the kind of hard truths they've avoided for decades.

Europe doesn't need to face "Trump's bullshit", Europe needs to stand its own two feet against tyranny next door.


RE: Budget 2026 - Borin' Baggie - 11-02-2026

The exact sort of piece that made me roll my eyes at every single Syed opinion piece before I cancelled my subscription.

I know he's a paid up member of the Tory party and wants to avoid praising other parties on policy but if he was entirely serious as a journalist he'd cite all the pro-growth policies that the Lib Dems have pushed for this parliamentary term - up to the growth policy platform at the last conference - in an effort to pressure the current government to adopt them. As Martin Lewis is doing on Plan 2 repayment thresholds.

You need only compare the output of our opinion columnists in the circulars and think tanks with Cato in the US to emphasise why the former are only good at writing a lot of words without saying anything.


RE: Budget 2026 - Protheroe - 11-02-2026

(11-02-2026, 04:55 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The exact sort of piece that made me roll my eyes at every single Syed opinion piece before I cancelled my subscription.

I know he's a paid up member of the Tory party and wants to avoid praising other parties on policy but if he was entirely serious as a journalist he'd cite all the pro-growth policies that the Lib Dems have pushed for this parliamentary term - up to the growth policy platform at the last conference - in an effort to pressure the current government to adopt them. As Martin Lewis is doing on Plan 2 repayment thresholds.

You need only compare the output of our opinion columnists in the circulars and think tanks with Cato in the US to emphasise why the former are only good at writing a lot of words without saying anything.

Maybe he prefers to see the Lib Dems in action. Like in Bromsgrove where they're completely anti-development.