WBAUnofficial
Letter from Shilen - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Letter from Shilen (/showthread.php?tid=41927)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Letter from Shilen - Josh1873 - 06-27-2026

(06-26-2026, 10:09 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 07:24 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: It’s communication that I’ve never seen in the 5 decades I’ve been going. But more importantly it’s action that mirrors what problems we have and where the game is going. It contains direction. I’ve no idea how anyone could find anything negative in it.

It’s Josh probably been on the piss again.

I actually wasn't. I had two pints in a lovely pub. Anyway, I didn't actually say the statement was negative. I'm merely pointing out that I'd rather see actions than words. So far the actions of Shilen and co almost led us to relegation. 

I have every faith he's well intentioned, and they're genuine mistakes, which hopefully he has learnt from. But only time will tell with actions over the coming months. Not statements. 

I even said it was a well written and a good letter - I'm just cautious, words are easy and cheap. I make no apologies for my stance, the results and our decline speak louder than any open letter. I'm not the only poster to share that view, it appears. I believe it's a reasonable stance.


RE: Letter from Shilen - Derek Hardballs - 06-27-2026

(06-26-2026, 10:27 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 08:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 08:38 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 08:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Flattered that I’ve been included in a couple of posters responses Wink I’m not sure where the letter contradicts my position on data, it’s a tool to be used but as the club stated at the end of last year it’s now part of wider consideration with regards to tactics and recruitment.

The plans for the coming season and beyond look sensible and pragmatic but I’m not seeing huge investment in those comments compared to some of our local rivals, so it’s going to take a lot of patience to build future success.

Anyway Josh is right, ultimately it’s a nice letter, the proof will be in the progress the club makes back to the Prem, no clubs thrive in the Championship if they get stuck in it for any length of time.

Apart from Coventry, Millwall, Leeds, Sunderland, that is. We are where we are Derek.

Coventry out of the top flight for twenty years. Homeless, potless and crap for much of that time. 
Millwall last appearance in the top flight was 1998-1989 season and relegated to Division One in that time 
Leeds have languished in the Championship for what ten years? 
Sunderland have been relegated to the third and been abysmal for several season 

The quicker you can get out of this shite division to the Prem the better.

And then they all reinvented their clubs. Invested behind the scenes. Lowered the ages of their squads. Did things 'differently' and got huge successes. 

*Millwall aside who have plugged away the 'old fashioned way'.

They got new owners who invested in their clubs. Without that investment none of them would have had success, no matter what the system they had put in place.


RE: Letter from Shilen - tHEgLASSdOORS - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 06:02 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 10:09 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 07:24 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: It’s communication that I’ve never seen in the 5 decades I’ve been going. But more importantly it’s action that mirrors what problems we have and where the game is going. It contains direction. I’ve no idea how anyone could find anything negative in it.

It’s Josh probably been on the piss again.

I actually wasn't. I had two pints in a lovely pub. Anyway, I didn't actually say the statement was negative. I'm merely pointing out that I'd rather see actions than words. So far the actions of Shilen and co almost led us to relegation. 

I have every faith he's well intentioned, and they're genuine mistakes, which hopefully he has learnt from. But only time will tell with actions over the coming months. Not statements. 

I even said it was a well written and a good letter - I'm just cautious, words are easy and cheap. I make no apologies for my stance, the results and our decline speak louder than any open letter. I'm not the only poster to share that view, it appears. I believe it's a reasonable stance.

His actions have prevented the club from going out of existence. So has his money. I’d focus on that first and foremost when assessing what he has achieved operating under enormous debt and restrictions.


RE: Letter from Shilen - Derek Hardballs - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 07:58 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(06-27-2026, 06:02 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 10:09 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 07:24 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: It’s communication that I’ve never seen in the 5 decades I’ve been going. But more importantly it’s action that mirrors what problems we have and where the game is going. It contains direction. I’ve no idea how anyone could find anything negative in it.

It’s Josh probably been on the piss again.

I actually wasn't. I had two pints in a lovely pub. Anyway, I didn't actually say the statement was negative. I'm merely pointing out that I'd rather see actions than words. So far the actions of Shilen and co almost led us to relegation. 

I have every faith he's well intentioned, and they're genuine mistakes, which hopefully he has learnt from. But only time will tell with actions over the coming months. Not statements. 

I even said it was a well written and a good letter - I'm just cautious, words are easy and cheap. I make no apologies for my stance, the results and our decline speak louder than any open letter. I'm not the only poster to share that view, it appears. I believe it's a reasonable stance.

His actions have prevented the club from going out of existence. So has his money. I’d focus on that first and foremost when assessing what he has achieved operating under enormous debt and restrictions.

Not sure why Josh is getting so much stick about this, all he has said is nice letter, let’s see what happens this season and beyond. Given the unforced errors of last year that were made I think that’s an eminently sensible position to take.


RE: Letter from Shilen - tHEgLASSdOORS - 06-27-2026

That’s not “stick”, jrs a reply that points out something that is missing in his assessment.


RE: Letter from Shilen - Derek Hardballs - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 08:07 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: That’s not “stick”, jrs a reply that points out something that is missing in his assessment.

It was more a general reply to the replies he’s had on this thread.


RE: Letter from Shilen - Vinebaggie - 06-27-2026

That’s a very good letter that makes me hopeful for the future. In particular the points on new additions, being out of the worst of the PSR mess and recruiting specialists to focus on the fan experience, all good stuff. I take the points on actions being louder than words, but at least he is creating a set of expectations, which he knows he will need to deliver on. More risk averse owners would say absolutely nothing and keep expectations low, I’m happy Shilen is not like this.


RE: Letter from Shilen - tHEgLASSdOORS - 06-27-2026

First time in my living memory we’ve had such a broad and purposeful structure, with clear direction. It’s no guarantee of success but it very likely puts a floor under how far we may fall.


RE: Letter from Shilen - Josh1873 - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 07:58 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(06-27-2026, 06:02 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 10:09 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 07:24 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: It’s communication that I’ve never seen in the 5 decades I’ve been going. But more importantly it’s action that mirrors what problems we have and where the game is going. It contains direction. I’ve no idea how anyone could find anything negative in it.

It’s Josh probably been on the piss again.

I actually wasn't. I had two pints in a lovely pub. Anyway, I didn't actually say the statement was negative. I'm merely pointing out that I'd rather see actions than words. So far the actions of Shilen and co almost led us to relegation. 

I have every faith he's well intentioned, and they're genuine mistakes, which hopefully he has learnt from. But only time will tell with actions over the coming months. Not statements. 

I even said it was a well written and a good letter - I'm just cautious, words are easy and cheap. I make no apologies for my stance, the results and our decline speak louder than any open letter. I'm not the only poster to share that view, it appears. I believe it's a reasonable stance.

His actions have prevented the club from going out of existence. So has his money. I’d focus on that first and foremost when assessing what he has achieved operating under enormous debt and restrictions.

What specifically has he done that has saved us from going out of existence? 

They've purchased us as an investment with the intention of making money out of us (I've absolutely no issue with that, btw) and a long term exit strategy, which if successful benefits all. They haven't invested as a goodwill gesture out of the kindness of their heart. They're using us to make money and self gain, nothing more. 

Other than being the group to take us on, and do basic accounting to get us within PSR regulations (which they haven't, and their mistake by sailing too close to the PSR wind almost relegated us, after Mozza kept us up), I'm not so sure what they've actually done that's so special to thank them for? 

I've previously asked on other threads why we should be so grateful, and I've never received a satisfactory answer. 

I don't dislike the ownership, they talk a good game, I believe they're well intentioned, however I haven't seen evidence, yet, that they're as good as people like to tell me. Maybe they'll learn from honest mistakes, and we'll have a successful season, then they'd be on their way to earning the reputation they seem to have on here. I hope that's the case. 

But ultimately we've gone backwards on the pitch (partly their fault, partly due to the mess they inherited) since they arrived, and I'm not thankful that under their stewardship we were almost relegated to League One, and I'm happy to maintain a reserved and sceptical approach to our ownership until I see actions and evidence to suggest they've learnt from their errors and are moving us forward as a club.


RE: Letter from Shilen - CarlosCorbewrong - 06-27-2026

Patel got off lightly with the PSR thing only because Morrison kept us up.

Letter or no letter, he’s been a fucking car crash - albeit a well intentioned one who is good at PR.

TGD is also right - the foundations seem sensible and would prevent us hurtling down the leagues. But another season like the last one and we’m flirting with danger. Hopefully Poppa Patel is getting closer to his investment and offering advice as, I assume, that’s where the talent lies in the family.

I’m desperate for him to do well. Not just for selfish reasons but because I’m totally bought into his ethos etc. but let’s be honest, this letter isn’t the first time he’s wowed us with his PR machine.