WBAUnofficial
Change badly needsd - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Change badly needsd (/showthread.php?tid=40451)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Change badly needsd - Stillclem4england - 02-02-2026

To me we need three in midfield with Price deeper which is where he wants to play. Let Mowatt hold and Molumby and Price can make runs into the box.


RE: Change badly needsd - backsidebaggie - 02-02-2026

(02-02-2026, 10:57 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: It's being over run in midfield that is the issue.  We can't play 442 because of the inabilities of our midfield.

Mowatt - too slow and pondoerous - doesn't have the legs to get up and down.  But can sit in a 3.
Molumby - lacks any sort of positional discipline or quality on the ball.  Shouldn't be the player getting ahead of the forwards as lacks ability, yet can't be trused to sit and hold the midfield.  Only effective in a 3 to run around a lot, press and be a link between a holder and more attacking midfielder.
Diakite - just seems to want to sit and break up play,  Doesn't get up and down, lacks Mowatt's passing ability.
Price - I know he's a little gobsite after the weekend, I've still no idea what he is as a footballer.  Could sill maybe be the attacking threat in a 3 or the legs alongside a sitter.
Styles - probably our most all round midfielder.  Has Molumby's energy but can control the ball as well, has some passing ability and overall positional sense to him.
Whitwell - ?

It has to be 3 in the middle, but not 2 sitters.  beyond that 3 or 4 at the back is less important.  I think we actually have defenders who would be better in a 3, they're just injured.  If a 3 means Charlie Taylor then got to a back 4.

And jusy play Dike.  What are we saving him for?  He'll only get match fit by playing and Maja wants to be anywhere bar our club and Heggey can't  do it on his own.

For those not paying attention, 451 saw us lose 10 in a row away from home, and sinking towards relegation.  We have to try something else.

4231 is our best bet, we were gash but were in almost every game and did not look like going down.

And not playing this system has killed MJ. Which is massive as he’s virtually our only attacking threat.


RE: Change badly needsd - Birdman1811 - 02-02-2026

How I'd set us up

Griffiths

Williams
Campbell/Phillips
Bielik/Mepham
Styles

Mowatt/ Diakate

Price / Whitwell
Molumby (only bloody energy we have)

Johnston/ Wallace
Bostock / SiJ

Dike /Heggebo

Maja to come in to play as a 10 if we go two-up top and sacrifice the holding midfielder. Play cautiously, keep the ball at all costs, only going forward using the wide channels when the opposition have over committed, it'll be tedious, it'll be boring, but when we've done it this season it's worked. Missing Grant sadly who helped make it work, but we'll make do with what we have.

Two new signing just add nothing in my.mind and can be used of needed with injuries and suspensions, and I'd rather get Griffiths through the bad form personally.


RE: Change badly needsd - Lurker#3 - 02-02-2026

(02-02-2026, 10:51 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: It also strikes me how many posters who have been saying we should play a back 3 for the last few months are now saying formation doesn’t matter. Well how come so many were pushing for a back 3 every week under Mason if it doesn’t matter?

It does matter, massively. The gaps Portsmouth exploited are very much to do with the formation, and the fact we haven’t got a squad suited to it. The fact we were shit for the full 90 is partly to do with the formation.

Because it's about finding the balance in the team that we all know we've struggled with. We don't have enough attacking outlet from fullback. Which doesn't matter if you have threat in central midfield, we don't. Both of the aforementioned don't matter if you have 4 electric, fast, ball carrying, dribbling forward players out wide and up top. We don't.

As it stands we have Heggebo who is a good all round forward. MJ who is a technically gifted player but needs other technically competent players around him to play those quick little passes. We have Price who is an 8 and I won't be told other wise, a player who should start deeper and attack the box late whilst using his running power,. But is being selected as one of our forwards. 

So those who have spoken about a back 3, have down so because wee know we've needed an extra attacking player in the team. 

Now we have signed Imray. I don't care if you write it as a back 4 as long as as the balance is right. 

Griffiths
Imray Campbell Phillips Styles
Mowatt Molumby
DVB#2 Price MJ
Heggebo

Would be balanced. But I still don't trust that back 2 as it stands.


RE: Change badly needsd - SeanFlynnsPressUps - 02-02-2026

It's weird seeing people say "It's not the system, it's just bad defending" when the defending is a feature of the system. It's not all the system, but if you wanted to design a way of playing that was particularly poorly suited to the current lot of players it would be this one because we have players with things they are good at and things they are bad at and the things they are bad at are hugely exposed in the system.

We were letting in soft goals under Mason because players kept getting caught in posession on the edge of the box and giving the ball away, yes that's bad defending and individual errors, but it was because the players were instructed to play it out at the back, the defenders were instructed to spread wide across the pitch and one midfielder was instructed to drop deep to pick up the ball and it often resulted in a player recieving the ball under pressure on the edge of our box. In the main, this isn't a terrible weakness to have because our midfield and defence are not awful at playing out from the back, but you saw the huge increase in those sort of goals when we switched goalkeepers and suddenly we had to play riskier passes because the goalkeeper didn't have the ability to receive the ball to feet.

Under Ramsey the instruction is to drop into a line of 5 with 4 ahead of them and to restrict the space rather than man marking or making challenges. The instruction is also for that 5-4-1 in defence to become a 3-4-3 in attack which means the wing backs need to cover the entire length of the pitch, the inside forwards need to drop onto the wings and the outside cbs need to tuck in.

On transition half of our team are moving back into position rather than paying attention to the other team and while they drop back we give away a lot of ground to the opposition and let them flood into our third of the pitch. There's a huge space in between the back 5 and the midfield 4 that neither the midfield or the defence are expected to move into and there's a huge weakness in the space between the outside CB and the wing back.

You can see the way the system makes it difficult for us to cope with transitions, and then you can see the instruction to hammer long balls up to Heggebo means we constantly hand the ball over to the other team and end up defending in this really innefective way. I think it's really highlighting the weaknesses in our defence, and we'd be much better off keeping hold of the ball and keeping it out of our third.


RE: Change badly needsd - Birdman1811 - 02-02-2026

(02-02-2026, 11:18 AM)SeanFlynnsPressUps Wrote: It's weird seeing people say "It's not the system, it's just bad defending" when the defending is a feature of the system. It's not all the system, but if you wanted to design a way of playing that was particularly poorly suited to the current lot of players it would be this one because we have players with things they are good at and things they are bad at and the things they are bad at are hugely exposed in the system.

We were letting in soft goals under Mason because players kept getting caught in posession on the edge of the box and giving the ball away, yes that's bad defending and individual errors, but it was because the players were instructed to play it out at the back, the defenders were instructed to spread wide across the pitch and one midfielder was instructed to drop deep to pick up the ball and it often resulted in a player recieving the ball under pressure on the edge of our box. In the main, this isn't a terrible weakness to have because our midfield and defence are not awful at playing out from the back, but you saw the huge increase in those sort of goals when we switched goalkeepers and suddenly we had to play riskier passes because the goalkeeper didn't have the ability to receive the ball to feet.

Under Ramsey the instruction is to drop into a line of 5 with 4 ahead of them and to restrict the space rather than man marking or making challenges. The instruction is also for that 5-4-1 in defence to become a 3-4-3 in attack which means the wing backs need to cover the entire length of the pitch, the inside forwards need to drop onto the wings and the outside cbs need to tuck in.

On transition half of our team are moving back into position rather than paying attention to the other team and while they drop back we give away a lot of ground to the opposition and let them flood into our third of the pitch. There's a huge space in between the back 5 and the midfield 4 that neither the midfield or the defence are expected to move into and there's a huge weakness in the space between the outside CB and the wing back.

You can see the way the system makes it difficult for us to cope with transitions, and then you can see the instruction to hammer long balls up to Heggebo means we constantly hand the ball over to the other team and end up defending in this really innefective way. I think it's really highlighting the weaknesses in our defence, and we'd be much better off keeping hold of the ball and keeping it out of our third.

+1

Exactly right. The problem is we can retain the ball quite well, just can't do anything positive with it a lot of the time, and we attack best on the counter out wide, which is the exact opposite to how we can defend.  Hence I said, how I set us up would be boring, mind numbing, low scoring and frustrating as fuck for fans and anyone watching.


RE: Change badly needsd - Derek Hardballs - 02-02-2026

(02-02-2026, 09:14 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-02-2026, 09:09 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-02-2026, 08:18 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: It was already broken... It was just slowly falling to pieces. I would still rather us smash it to pieces, try and find a new identity which could work and have a 10 game mini season to save our asses.

The change needs to be from a "vision" perspective. It needs to be firm, unmistakable and not for discussion. Hopefully Nestor and his appointments of Mowbray and Mason were a lesson learned for Patel that not having a firm identity/DNA is damaging. Ur doesn't matter what league we are in, this has to be the absolute minimum we see.

We really don’t need a ‘vision’ at this time, we need a manager to get the best out of the squad they have, get organised, play, players in the positions they understand and give them simple instructions as to what is expected of them individually and collectively. Going down will set the club back years on and off the pitch.

Visions, philosophies are for managers who talk a great game, if you like football management speak, which is getting more cliched every year it seems. We’ve gone from philosophies to visions, DNA and moments and it’s all meaningless drivel. By all means in the future have a preferred way of playing and recruit accordingly but the pseudo  intellectual drivel that surrounds football currently is just an endless list of buzz words and catchphrases.

Ramsay came with the reputation of being meticulously organised who got the best out of a bunch of players in Minnesota. 

His first game showed real promise, the game v Derby showed grit and determination and a level of ploddy organisation. Then the other 2 games have looked as devoid of a plan or approach as the rest of the year. 

I have seen so many suggestions of "going back to basics", "playing a formation that suits the players", "keep things simple". Those are the cliches that make my shit itch. They don't mean anything. They are throw away terms that have no real meaning.

What is basic is having a really clear idea of how we are going to approach a game both in and out of possession, and not once wavering from that between now and the end of the year. What that looks like is anybody guess quite frankly, but the only thing I am certain of is a flat back 4 with no offensive threat and a midfield 2 offering not much more has been proven NOT to work. What's the old saying about insanity?

The weird circle jerk about going back to what has failed all year is one of the most insane things I have ever read on this dump. It's like turkeys voting for Christmas.

The reputation that Ramsay has and the reality of what we have seen so far are miles apart. He came in and decided to completely change how we played, we went from a team that was comfortable if not spectacular in possession to a team that surrendered possession, placing players in positions they aren’t used to and in some cases can’t play. That isn’t a pragmatic approach it’s dogmatic and potentially could see us relegated. 

All this talk about DNA, visions etc and in reality all it means is a club setting out a style of play it wants all its team to employ over a sustained period of time. Vic Buckingham was doing this with us and then Barcelona nearly a century ago, just attaching bullshit buzzwords to age old method of working.


RE: Change badly needsd - Ted Maul - 02-02-2026

I am confused.

Since the dawn of time when approaching a problem you have an issue and a goal, do you not?

When Bilkul took over we were in a mess off the pitch but competent on it, unable to spend the money to really trouble the top of the league. The aim was to sort us out financially and build something approaching a self-sustaining model where, amongst other revenue streams, we can find low value players, develop them and sell them for profits, thus allowing us to turnover an ageing squad. To me that seems fair enough and it's not like it hasn't worked at tens of other clubs.

People seem to miss the fact that in football a result is an outcome that is a product of the process, tactics, strategy whatever you want to call it. There are two teams involved in a football match and sometimes shit happens. It's why you'll often a forgive a team that's doing the right things more often than not but losing the odd game.

It's pointless saying I'm not interested in "visions" or "projects" because - as you've pointed out yourself Dekka - football clubs have been doing this for a century or more. The HUGE problem at the Albion presently is not the vision or what ever you wish to call it, it's the lack of one. Disjointed at the top = a real fucking mess on the pitch.


RE: Change badly needsd - Derek Hardballs - 02-02-2026

(02-02-2026, 12:53 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: I am confused.

Since the dawn of time when approaching a problem you have an issue and a goal, do you not?

When Bilkul took over we were in a mess off the pitch but competent on it, unable to spend the money to really trouble the top of the league. The aim was to sort us out financially and build something approaching a self-sustaining model where, amongst other revenue streams, we can find low value players, develop them and sell them for profits, thus allowing us to turnover an ageing squad. To me that seems fair enough and it's not like it hasn't worked at tens of other clubs.

People seem to miss the fact that in football a result is an outcome that is a product of the process, tactics, strategy whatever you want to call it. There are two teams involved in a football match and sometimes shit happens. It's why you'll often a forgive a team that's doing the right things more often than not but losing the odd game.

It's pointless saying I'm not interested in "visions" or "projects" because - as you've pointed out yourself Dekka - football clubs have been doing this for a century or more. The HUGE problem at the Albion presently is not the vision or what ever you wish to call it, it's the lack of one. Disjointed at the top = a real fucking mess on the pitch.

Yeah it’s called a plan no ‘visions’ ‘’DNA’ ‘philosophies’ needed. I’ve been asking what the plan was since the owners arrived at the club beyond getting past the PSR problems. I’ve yet to see anything nearly two years in that is even close to affording us the ability to compete beyond midtblw on a consistent basis. 

Btw there are no self sufficient clubs in this league, most if not all are making a loss, and if flogging our best players every season is the best we can manage as a plan, then we are fugged for years to come.


RE: Change badly needsd - Ted Maul - 02-02-2026

(02-02-2026, 01:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-02-2026, 12:53 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: I am confused.

Since the dawn of time when approaching a problem you have an issue and a goal, do you not?

When Bilkul took over we were in a mess off the pitch but competent on it, unable to spend the money to really trouble the top of the league. The aim was to sort us out financially and build something approaching a self-sustaining model where, amongst other revenue streams, we can find low value players, develop them and sell them for profits, thus allowing us to turnover an ageing squad. To me that seems fair enough and it's not like it hasn't worked at tens of other clubs.

People seem to miss the fact that in football a result is an outcome that is a product of the process, tactics, strategy whatever you want to call it. There are two teams involved in a football match and sometimes shit happens. It's why you'll often a forgive a team that's doing the right things more often than not but losing the odd game.

It's pointless saying I'm not interested in "visions" or "projects" because - as you've pointed out yourself Dekka - football clubs have been doing this for a century or more. The HUGE problem at the Albion presently is not the vision or what ever you wish to call it, it's the lack of one. Disjointed at the top = a real fucking mess on the pitch.

Yeah it’s called a plan no ‘visions’ ‘’DNA’ ‘philosophies’ needed. I’ve been asking what the plan was since the owners arrived at the club beyond getting past the PSR problems. I’ve yet to see anything nearly two years in that is even close to affording us the ability to compete beyond midtblw on a consistent basis. 

Btw there are no self sufficient clubs in this league, most if not all are making a loss, and if flogging our best players every season is the best we can manage as a plan, then we are fugged for years to come.

So ultimately after months of moaning it's the terminology you're cross at.