WBAUnofficial
Team for Tuesday? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Team for Tuesday? (/showthread.php?tid=40195)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: Team for Tuesday? - Tom Joad 25 - 01-18-2026

(01-18-2026, 07:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: 3 at the back and wing backs bring me out in hives.

Wing back is a very niche position and I see no one who could do it well in our squad..

And there has to be a question why you need 3 centre backs.

I have no issue with Ramsey being happy with low possession . But I would say with our squad the way nuno had Forest set up last season should be the template.

I suspect he might be a bit more wedded to three at the back than I would personally like, so I'm going to take a break from commenting on the Albion for a bit, and see what transpires.

I agree, I just don't like the formation (although SGM made it work). Brutally speaking, 3 centre backs means we are starting with 3 poor players.


RE: Team for Tuesday? - Lurker#3 - 01-18-2026

Wingback, as in over lapping dribbling, crossing wingbacks are absolutely a niche position. Dorgu at Utd for example is the perfect one.

But you don't have to play that type of "wing back". You can have players that defend as a wide player who comes narrow in possession. Especially if you have Price/Grant/MJ more centrally who would likely drift wide in possession.

To be fair though. More important than arbitrary "formations" is the balance of the team. And as long as we have a minimum of 5 attacking threats in the team. Like Dekka suggested above it is more likely to work.


RE: Team for Tuesday? - Ted Maul - 01-18-2026

(01-18-2026, 07:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: 3 at the back and wing backs bring me out in hives.

Wing back is a very niche position and I see no one who could do it well in our squad..

And there has to be a question why you need 3 centre backs.

I have no issue with Ramsey being happy with low possession . But I would say with our squad the way nuno had Forest set up last season should be the template.

I suspect he might be a bit more wedded to three at the back than I would personally like, so I'm going to take a break from commenting on the Albion for a bit, and see what transpires.

Used properly it's more offensive than pretty much any other formation.

A set back three with a holding midfielder, then two wingers, two tens and a striker. Agree with you that we don't have an obvious candidate for RWB, should be a must for the next couple of weeks.


RE: Team for Tuesday? - Daffy_LeFrontas - 01-18-2026

(01-18-2026, 08:51 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-18-2026, 07:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: 3 at the back and wing backs bring me out in hives.

Wing back is a very niche position and I see no one who could do it well in our squad..

And there has to be a question why you need 3 centre backs.

I have no issue with Ramsey being happy with low possession . But I would say with our squad the way nuno had Forest set up last season should be the template.

I suspect he might be a bit more wedded to three at the back than I would personally like, so I'm going to take a break from commenting on the Albion for a bit, and see what transpires.

Used properly it's more offensive than pretty much any other formation.

A set back three with a holding midfielder, then two wingers, two tens and a striker. Agree with you that we don't have an obvious candidate for RWB, should be a must for the next couple of weeks.

Is it just me, or have you missed a player out... You've not mentioned the GK obviously. But not withstanding that, it's still only 10 players Ted. : )


RE: Team for Tuesday? - Ted Maul - 01-19-2026

(01-18-2026, 11:00 PM)Daffy_LeFrontas Wrote:
(01-18-2026, 08:51 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-18-2026, 07:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: 3 at the back and wing backs bring me out in hives.

Wing back is a very niche position and I see no one who could do it well in our squad..

And there has to be a question why you need 3 centre backs.

I have no issue with Ramsey being happy with low possession . But I would say with our squad the way nuno had Forest set up last season should be the template.

I suspect he might be a bit more wedded to three at the back than I would personally like, so I'm going to take a break from commenting on the Albion for a bit, and see what transpires.

Used properly it's more offensive than pretty much any other formation.

A set back three with a holding midfielder, then two wingers, two tens and a striker. Agree with you that we don't have an obvious candidate for RWB, should be a must for the next couple of weeks.

Is it just me, or have you missed a player out... You've not mentioned the GK obviously. But not withstanding that, it's still only 10 players Ted. : )

Yeah, you'd have one deeper, holding midfielder (Bielik or Mowatt).


RE: Team for Tuesday? - B68Baggy - 01-19-2026

I'd be happy giving Campbell a go at RWB, not the ideal candidate but we lnow he can charge forward and deliver a ball into the box. From what i've read Eric had success in the US converting wingers which would explain Mikey getting a go. He just looked frustrated and i dont think he has the mentality to play the role. Maybe Jed is given a go? He's got the mindset but does he still have the legs?

As has been mentioned i dont think formation is THE big thing; if the team can switch as they did against M'boro thats stops us being perdictable a la Mason. What the do need to work on is how to close a game out and/or shut it down when needed. He also needs to stamp out the CBs habit of coming out to win balls then being to powderpuff to come out with it.

If fit Molomby and Mowatt come back in. BIelek drops back into defence as leader. After that i think Grant picks himself with his workrate and running power in the final third. Griffiths is my first choice obvs. After that perm 7 from the remaining squad dependent on the formation chosen and expect positive rather than passive changes in game.


RE: Team for Tuesday? - BaggieSloth - 01-19-2026

JG
JW - GC - NP - KB - SIL
CS - IP
MJ - JM - KG

On the assumption that M&M are both not fit still. Although i do think i would try CS over JM in the middle to see how that goes.
I would even give JM a go at RWB maybe?


RE: Team for Tuesday? - Tom Joad 25 - 01-19-2026

(01-19-2026, 10:31 AM)BaggieSloth Wrote: JG
JW - GC - NP - KB - SIL
          CS - IP
    MJ  -  JM  -  KG

On the assumption that M&M are both not fit still. Although i do think i would try CS over JM in the middle to see how that goes.
I would even give JM a go at RWB maybe?

He's among the names mentioned, along with Grant. I don't see it myself as RWB is a very specialised position but you don't know until you try. (In training, obs!!!)


RE: Team for Tuesday? - AnelkasBeard - 01-19-2026

Griffiths

Campbell Phillips Bielik

Wallace Styles Mowatt/Molumby SIJ (assuming only one of M/M is fit)

Price Grant

Heggebo


Feels weird not getting Mikey into the team. Price and Grant's duracell bunny running is so vital to the team I feel like they're the defacto go to's for the two inside forwards. Maybe stick KG at RWB to get Mikey in. Feel like Jed can do a real job there though, he's looked very spritely in his cameos.

Can also absolutely see Price given the 8 role given how well he did there on Friday following the change, and getting Grant and Mikey in the two behind Hegg.


RE: Team for Tuesday? - BaggieSloth - 01-19-2026

(01-19-2026, 11:58 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(01-19-2026, 10:31 AM)BaggieSloth Wrote: JG
JW - GC - NP - KB - SIL
          CS - IP
    MJ  -  JM  -  KG

On the assumption that M&M are both not fit still. Although i do think i would try CS over JM in the middle to see how that goes.
I would even give JM a go at RWB maybe?

He's among the names mentioned, along with Grant. I don't see it myself as RWB is a very specialised position but you don't know until you try. (In training, obs!!!)

I can see why you dont see it - i see grant there as a worse option than JM. Although one thing a few coaches have said about JM is he does exactly what you ask him to do he does it. So maybe he is the most Coachable into the role? at least thats my hope as we certainly need MJ in a more attacking role.