RE: Reyes Cleary - Bob Fossil - 01-14-2026
(01-14-2026, 08:21 AM)MrBater Wrote: (01-14-2026, 01:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Tim I, Field, Cleary, O'Shea, Palmer, Taylor would all improve our squad and though you might not regret it they would be an improvement on Wildsmith, SIJ, Mepham, Taylor and Bielik
O'Shea and Palmer would improve most squads in this division, and we got much needed money for them (however we never properly replaced either)
We wouldn't be saying that about the others if we weren't where we are now, i.e. the other year when people were on about the missed youth, it was largely agreed that the others you list went for good reasons, and none of them were any better than we had at the time.
You can't keep the youth hanging around until you're shit and they're better. Also, some of them were poached and we had no option in their going. Fair point that.
Cleary a bit different for me as he was highly rated, generally, and showed enough on the rare occasions he got minutes. The most important factor though is that it was a position we were really struggling with at the time. That’s the frustration for me. If the players keeping kids out are clearly poor or underperforming, then there’s nothing to lose by giving them a chance. Same was true of Field and, more recently Bostock.
We can’t just “play the kids” for the sake of it, but if we have a weak area and a kid in that position with potential, then it seems madness not to try.
RE: Reyes Cleary - MrBater - 01-14-2026
(01-14-2026, 08:27 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-14-2026, 08:21 AM)MrBater Wrote: (01-14-2026, 01:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Tim I, Field, Cleary, O'Shea, Palmer, Taylor would all improve our squad and though you might not regret it they would be an improvement on Wildsmith, SIJ, Mepham, Taylor and Bielik
O'Shea and Palmer would improve most squads in this division, and we got much needed money for them (however we never properly replaced either)
We wouldn't be saying that about the others if we weren't where we are now, i.e. the other year when people were on about the missed youth, it was largely agreed that the others you list went for good reasons, and none of them were any better than we had at the time.
You can't keep the youth hanging around until you're shit and they're better. Also, some of them were poached and we had no option in their going. Fair point that.
Cleary a bit different for me as he was highly rated, generally, and showed enough on the rare occasions he got minutes. The most important factor though is that it was a position we were really struggling with at the time. That’s the frustration for me. If the players keeping kids out are clearly poor or underperforming, then there’s nothing to lose by giving them a chance. Same was true of Field and, more recently Bostock.
We can’t just “play the kids” for the sake of it, but if we have a weak area and a kid in that position with potential, then it seems madness not to try.
That's the thing though, when Cleary might have got a chance he was injured, overweight or showing signs of being a petulant child...
RE: Reyes Cleary - MrFizz - 01-14-2026
(01-14-2026, 08:39 AM)MrBater Wrote: (01-14-2026, 08:27 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-14-2026, 08:21 AM)MrBater Wrote: (01-14-2026, 01:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Tim I, Field, Cleary, O'Shea, Palmer, Taylor would all improve our squad and though you might not regret it they would be an improvement on Wildsmith, SIJ, Mepham, Taylor and Bielik
O'Shea and Palmer would improve most squads in this division, and we got much needed money for them (however we never properly replaced either)
We wouldn't be saying that about the others if we weren't where we are now, i.e. the other year when people were on about the missed youth, it was largely agreed that the others you list went for good reasons, and none of them were any better than we had at the time.
You can't keep the youth hanging around until you're shit and they're better. Also, some of them were poached and we had no option in their going. Fair point that.
Cleary a bit different for me as he was highly rated, generally, and showed enough on the rare occasions he got minutes. The most important factor though is that it was a position we were really struggling with at the time. That’s the frustration for me. If the players keeping kids out are clearly poor or underperforming, then there’s nothing to lose by giving them a chance. Same was true of Field and, more recently Bostock.
We can’t just “play the kids” for the sake of it, but if we have a weak area and a kid in that position with potential, then it seems madness not to try.
That's the thing though, when Cleary might have got a chance he was injured, overweight or showing signs of being a petulant child...
It's amazing what a reality-check of having to play for Hartlepool will do to your attitude.
RE: Reyes Cleary - Bob Fossil - 01-14-2026
(01-14-2026, 08:39 AM)MrBater Wrote: (01-14-2026, 08:27 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-14-2026, 08:21 AM)MrBater Wrote: (01-14-2026, 01:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Tim I, Field, Cleary, O'Shea, Palmer, Taylor would all improve our squad and though you might not regret it they would be an improvement on Wildsmith, SIJ, Mepham, Taylor and Bielik
O'Shea and Palmer would improve most squads in this division, and we got much needed money for them (however we never properly replaced either)
We wouldn't be saying that about the others if we weren't where we are now, i.e. the other year when people were on about the missed youth, it was largely agreed that the others you list went for good reasons, and none of them were any better than we had at the time.
You can't keep the youth hanging around until you're shit and they're better. Also, some of them were poached and we had no option in their going. Fair point that.
Cleary a bit different for me as he was highly rated, generally, and showed enough on the rare occasions he got minutes. The most important factor though is that it was a position we were really struggling with at the time. That’s the frustration for me. If the players keeping kids out are clearly poor or underperforming, then there’s nothing to lose by giving them a chance. Same was true of Field and, more recently Bostock.
We can’t just “play the kids” for the sake of it, but if we have a weak area and a kid in that position with potential, then it seems madness not to try.
That's the thing though, when Cleary might have got a chance he was injured, overweight or showing signs of being a petulant child... Was this actually true though or just employed as an excuse for him not getting a chance? I’m 0% ITK so no idea, all I can say is, when he played he looked no worse than those keeping him out and his attitude seemed fine.
RE: Reyes Cleary - CarlosCorbewrong - 01-14-2026
(01-14-2026, 01:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Tim I, Field, Cleary, O'Shea, Palmer, Taylor would all improve our squad and though you might not regret it they would be an improvement on Wildsmith, SIJ, Mepham, Taylor and Bielik
O'Shea and Palmer were sold for profit not 'let go'/swiped by the DVBs.
Wasn't Tim I released? Or is that someone else? I take your point on him though - although 'regret' is a step too far in my mind - he's good but nowhewre near the Wood/DVB level.
RE: Reyes Cleary - PatelsPlatoon - 01-14-2026
(01-14-2026, 09:07 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (01-14-2026, 01:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Tim I, Field, Cleary, O'Shea, Palmer, Taylor would all improve our squad and though you might not regret it they would be an improvement on Wildsmith, SIJ, Mepham, Taylor and Bielik
O'Shea and Palmer were sold for profit not 'let go'/swiped by the DVBs.
Wasn't Tim I released? Or is that someone else? I take your point on him though - although 'regret' is a step too far in my mind - he's good but nowhewre near the Wood/DVB level.
Who is DVB?
RE: Reyes Cleary - Lightnin - 01-14-2026
Blackburn were apparently interested in signing him from Barnsley. Barnsley said they wanted £10m, Blackburn haven’t stopped laughing yet.
(01-14-2026, 09:42 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: (01-14-2026, 09:07 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (01-14-2026, 01:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Tim I, Field, Cleary, O'Shea, Palmer, Taylor would all improve our squad and though you might not regret it they would be an improvement on Wildsmith, SIJ, Mepham, Taylor and Bielik
O'Shea and Palmer were sold for profit not 'let go'/swiped by the DVBs.
Wasn't Tim I released? Or is that someone else? I take your point on him though - although 'regret' is a step too far in my mind - he's good but nowhewre near the Wood/DVB level.
Who is DVB?
I’d imagine the V is for Villa
RE: Reyes Cleary - Tom Joad 25 - 01-14-2026
(01-14-2026, 09:07 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (01-14-2026, 01:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Tim I, Field, Cleary, O'Shea, Palmer, Taylor would all improve our squad and though you might not regret it they would be an improvement on Wildsmith, SIJ, Mepham, Taylor and Bielik
O'Shea and Palmer were sold for profit not 'let go'/swiped by the DVBs.
Wasn't Tim I released? Or is that someone else? I take your point on him though - although 'regret' is a step too far in my mind - he's good but nowhewre near the Wood/DVB level.
No. He was offered an eye watering (for an apprentice) amount of money to go to villa. They effectively gazumped us.
RE: Reyes Cleary - Jacko - 01-14-2026
(01-14-2026, 09:42 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: (01-14-2026, 09:07 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (01-14-2026, 01:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Tim I, Field, Cleary, O'Shea, Palmer, Taylor would all improve our squad and though you might not regret it they would be an improvement on Wildsmith, SIJ, Mepham, Taylor and Bielik
O'Shea and Palmer were sold for profit not 'let go'/swiped by the DVBs.
Wasn't Tim I released? Or is that someone else? I take your point on him though - although 'regret' is a step too far in my mind - he's good but nowhewre near the Wood/DVB level.
Who is DVB?
In this instance, Morgan Rogers (who is/was an Albion fan).
RE: Reyes Cleary - GunsOfNavarone - 01-14-2026
(01-14-2026, 11:23 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: (01-14-2026, 09:07 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (01-14-2026, 01:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Tim I, Field, Cleary, O'Shea, Palmer, Taylor would all improve our squad and though you might not regret it they would be an improvement on Wildsmith, SIJ, Mepham, Taylor and Bielik
O'Shea and Palmer were sold for profit not 'let go'/swiped by the DVBs.
Wasn't Tim I released? Or is that someone else? I take your point on him though - although 'regret' is a step too far in my mind - he's good but nowhewre near the Wood/DVB level.
No. He was offered an eye watering (for an apprentice) amount of money to go to villa. They effectively gazumped us.
Correct. Cunts.
|