WBAUnofficial
The Steve Bruce Defence - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The Steve Bruce Defence (/showthread.php?tid=39920)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: The Steve Bruce Defence - Lurker#3 - 01-03-2026

(01-02-2026, 09:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The squad isn’t the bleeding same as it was two or three seasons ago and neither is the league. Making comparisons with then and now is pointless navel gazing. We have weakened the squad in line with lowering the wage bill and selling our best young players. I’m sure with another manager we could be doing better but until next season I don’t even think we know the extent of investment the club can or are prepared to pump into the squad to make it a genuine promotion contender.

This is sadly what happens to most teams who miss promotion whilst wasting the advantage of parachute payments and or over spending (we did both Wink ). Fans didn’t need to be Nostradamus to work out this might be where we end up. We have had both Wolves and Blues right on our doorstep as examples of where things can go after the money runs out or can’t be spent. Whilst Mason is getting hammered, I think the problems are far broader and difficult to navigate for some to accept. Just one more manager and it’ll be ok, just one, two, three more transfer windows and the squad will be promotion candidates.  Unless we invest in the squad, and the club put together a better backroom/football dept asap then we will be having similar arguments for the next five seasons bobbling around in the Championship at best.

We shall see, Mason leaving might make the squad perform better, I imagine it will but to what degree I don’t know. This season was always going to be messy and frankly I’m not seeing a long term plan transpiring if we continually looking to replace managers and selling our best players every season.

Good post for the post part that Dekka. 

However, your ingrained bias when talking about 'the project' also veers slightly towards TSBD as it's diluting Masons poor performance. Not that any concerns about said project shouldn't be explored. But they are completely independent of Masons inability to manage a game football.


RE: The Steve Bruce Defence - Jack Halford - 01-03-2026

I understand where you are coming from Derek but this squad should be doing far better.
Watford have lost their parachute payments were struggling and have appointed a decent manager and look at them now.
Preston have spent less nearly went down two seasons ago and are in the mix so are Millwall. Having a decent coach helps a lot.

Our manager is too stubborn to utilise the squad properly. I also don’t think the players were fit enough after pre-season which led to a lot of the late goals we conceded.

We are in a right mess and the longer we leave acting the less time someone else will have to put it right. The only positive is that Leicester are devoid of confidence…… but I’m sure we will be charitable.


RE: The Steve Bruce Defence - Tom Joad 25 - 01-03-2026

(01-02-2026, 09:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The squad isn’t the bleeding same as it was two or three seasons ago and neither is the league. Making comparisons with then and now is pointless navel gazing. We have weakened the squad in line with lowering the wage bill and selling our best young players. I’m sure with another manager we could be doing better but until next season I don’t even think we know the extent of investment the club can or are prepared to pump into the squad to make it a genuine promotion contender.

This is sadly what happens to most teams who miss promotion whilst wasting the advantage of parachute payments and or over spending (we did both Wink ). Fans didn’t need to be Nostradamus to work out this might be where we end up. We have had both Wolves and Blues right on our doorstep as examples of where things can go after the money runs out or can’t be spent. Whilst Mason is getting hammered, I think the problems are far broader and difficult to navigate for some to accept. Just one more manager and it’ll be ok, just one, two, three more transfer windows and the squad will be promotion candidates.  Unless we invest in the squad, and the club put together a better backroom/football dept asap then we will be having similar arguments for the next five seasons bobbling around in the Championship at best.

We shall see, Mason leaving might make the squad perform better, I imagine it will but to what degree I don’t know. This season was always going to be messy and frankly I’m not seeing a long term plan transpiring if we continually looking to replace managers and selling our best players every season.

I understand your point Derek, but this squad doesn't have to be 17th and rudderless.  It's much of a self inflicted wound. Switching back the keepers would have us comfortably mid table, introducing an extra forward may have turned games heading for 0 points into 1 point. I fully agree when you say spending on a manager should have been top priority but we are where we are, and we could easily be 5 or 6 places higher.


RE: The Steve Bruce Defence - Derek Hardballs - 01-03-2026

To clarify I’m not bothered if Mason goes. I thought the appointment was wrong in the first place.


RE: The Steve Bruce Defence - Jacko - 01-03-2026

(01-02-2026, 09:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The squad isn’t the bleeding same as it was two or three seasons ago and neither is the league. Making comparisons with then and now is pointless navel gazing. We have weakened the squad in line with lowering the wage bill and selling our best young players. I’m sure with another manager we could be doing better but until next season I don’t even think we know the extent of investment the club can or are prepared to pump into the squad to make it a genuine promotion contender.

This is sadly what happens to most teams who miss promotion whilst wasting the advantage of parachute payments and or over spending (we did both Wink ). Fans didn’t need to be Nostradamus to work out this might be where we end up. We have had both Wolves and Blues right on our doorstep as examples of where things can go after the money runs out or can’t be spent. Whilst Mason is getting hammered, I think the problems are far broader and difficult to navigate for some to accept. Just one more manager and it’ll be ok, just one, two, three more transfer windows and the squad will be promotion candidates.  Unless we invest in the squad, and the club put together a better backroom/football dept asap then we will be having similar arguments for the next five seasons bobbling around in the Championship at best.

We shall see, Mason leaving might make the squad perform better, I imagine it will but to what degree I don’t know. This season was always going to be messy and frankly I’m not seeing a long term plan transpiring if we continually looking to replace managers and selling our best players every season.

The SBD isn't about comparing squads historically. It's not a comparison at all.

It's merely the act of blaming everything but the manager, using phrases like, 'anyone would take this lot down', 'no one would do any better than ...', 'another manager would only have us a few points better off', 'we wouldn't be challenging with another manager'.

The Steve Bruce defence has even been used within this thread.


RE: The Steve Bruce Defence - halifax_baggie - 01-03-2026

(01-03-2026, 07:46 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-02-2026, 09:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The squad isn’t the bleeding same as it was two or three seasons ago and neither is the league. Making comparisons with then and now is pointless navel gazing. We have weakened the squad in line with lowering the wage bill and selling our best young players. I’m sure with another manager we could be doing better but until next season I don’t even think we know the extent of investment the club can or are prepared to pump into the squad to make it a genuine promotion contender.

This is sadly what happens to most teams who miss promotion whilst wasting the advantage of parachute payments and or over spending (we did both Wink ). Fans didn’t need to be Nostradamus to work out this might be where we end up. We have had both Wolves and Blues right on our doorstep as examples of where things can go after the money runs out or can’t be spent. Whilst Mason is getting hammered, I think the problems are far broader and difficult to navigate for some to accept. Just one more manager and it’ll be ok, just one, two, three more transfer windows and the squad will be promotion candidates.  Unless we invest in the squad, and the club put together a better backroom/football dept asap then we will be having similar arguments for the next five seasons bobbling around in the Championship at best.

We shall see, Mason leaving might make the squad perform better, I imagine it will but to what degree I don’t know. This season was always going to be messy and frankly I’m not seeing a long term plan transpiring if we continually looking to replace managers and selling our best players every season.

Good post for the post part that Dekka. 

However, your ingrained bias when talking about 'the project' also veers slightly towards TSBD as it's diluting Masons poor performance. Not that any concerns about said project shouldn't be explored. But they are completely independent of Masons inability to manage a game football.

Dekka, you are at least cognisant and analytical in your summary, unlike the short sighted and biased who see no further than the next 2 or 3 games and cannot remember the previous catastrophe under our Chinese ownership and previous old school managers
good Luck keep posting common sense


RE: The Steve Bruce Defence - CA Baggie - 01-03-2026

If anyone wants to see what changing managers can do, good and bad, then stain your eyes by looking at the Old Firm.

5th to 15th in this league has very little difference in squad quality. It’s more about their use and a bit of luck with decisions & injuries.