WBAUnofficial
Message from MR Nestor - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Message from MR Nestor (/showthread.php?tid=39795)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Message from MR Nestor - Josh1873 - 12-23-2025

I think this is a case of 'I've seen criticism of myself on SM, and I'm going to put our a lengthy statement to defend myself' rather than being transparent or updating fans.

Most reasonable fans understand our financial plight has our hands tied, somewhat. Did we really need such a lengthy statement dressed up in the name of an update?

I'd rather nothing was said and you go about your job, tbh.

FWIW I don't think there's anything wrong with the statement - it's very detailed and interesting, I just worry about the motivation of releasing it from Nestor - that's the point I'm labouring to make.


RE: Message from MR Nestor - Tom Joad 25 - 12-23-2025

(12-23-2025, 06:44 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(12-23-2025, 06:39 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Nice to see us keeping up the transparent communication, but that was the most empty update so far.

It felt like a filler statement.

Let's see what happens in January, because I think it's a big window.

Personally I thought it was pretty comprehensive and laid out we still have challenges but also provided updates on some new key positions.

What more did you expect?

Agree. The appointment to some key positions next year is surely a good thing. There's also a reality check that Bilkul have only been in control for the one full year. A reminder that they have made a start on what was an almost impossible job. That loss of over £37m in just one year is some challenge. 
On the field I'm hoping Mason can get it together.  I also have the frustrations we all share at the oft mentioned team selections/subs and cannot in all confidence argue otherwise.  That said I'm still fairly sanguine about the whole situation.  The real challenge will come if we begin to see more empty seats, that is something no board of directors can ignore. All that said, I'm always solid behind the team on matchday and Boxing day will be no different.


RE: Message from MR Nestor - richbaggie - 12-23-2025

(12-23-2025, 07:03 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote:
(12-23-2025, 06:03 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: There’s a few posters who are a bit of a broken record going on time and time again putting the boot in on Mason.
I hope this statement helps take some heat off him. I’ve been underwhelmed but always expected it could be a wobbly old season based on the rebalance of the finances.
I’m sorry for the more impatient fans who no excuses will ever be enough- not even a financial apocalypse averted.
It’s not saying there hasn’t been poor decisions but this is a major reset and we just have to hope these lot running the club are the real deal.

I take it you mean me as I am one of the posters that moans on about Mason not being
Good enough as over the last few weeks I have made it know that I don’t
Think he is good enough to lead our team.

I understand that he is a young coach learning his trade but to me he is
Consistently making the same mistakes on the one occasion he threw
His rule book away by making substitutions at halftime the team suddenly
Burst into life and won the game convincingly.
Since then he has reverted back to type.
His stubbornness by not giving Dike or Bany any game is beyond stupid.
He comes across to me as being quite boring and this is being reflected
In our style of play if this is a major reset we are in danger of getting
Relegated

From Rich’s point of view I know he is on a couple of the Albion
Fans committee’s and while the new owners are doing a good job
Steadying the financial side of things they should not be exempt
From some criticism regarding the playing side of things.

Sorry chaps but that’s my view.M

My position on the Fan Advisory Board wouldn't stop me voicing criticism and have done regarding aspects of RMs management.


RE: Message from MR Nestor - ElbowGrease73 - 12-23-2025

(12-23-2025, 03:32 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: The message reads no money being spent in January and Mason is staying

Pretty much how I interpreted it too Hughie.

I'd rather this season was over now, so we could approach next season with a bit of optimism.

I think midtable is the best we can hope for this season, as we seem incapable if putting a run of results together. Saturday was our best away performance for a while, but we still failed to get a result.

I really want Mason to succeed, but not sure he's learning or making better decisions as the season progresses. 

I guess we're playing the long term game on both the financial and managerial situation. Hopefully this time next year we'll all think it's gone well.


RE: Message from MR Nestor - man in the corner shop - 12-23-2025

I am Nestor's biggest critic. He's in the last chance saloon with me. But I'm with him on giving Mason more time and his rationale for saying so.
Can't say I'm enjoying it and I don't think Mason is wising up fast enough. I don't think he is as clueless as AFI. But those of you that say that Mason will never have it may well be right. I don't think he is either clever enough or ruthless enough. But I'd still give him more time.


RE: Message from MR Nestor - HawkingsHalfpint - 12-23-2025

It all reads very much how I expected it to, albeit with more commas and longer sentences than were particularly necessary. A ‘managing expectation’ overload promising very little else indeed, although it does usefully highlight the shit that we were in. Nonetheless, just like the Labour Party, they can’t blame the last lot forever, and there will be more than a few bookmarking this statement; particularly with regard to that (very much trumpeted) 2026/27 season. At least he didn’t say 2027/28 - that would have really pissed me off.

Time will indeed tell, and I hope that - should it indeed transpire that as good a weekday coach as he may be, Ryan Mason in fact is not a good matchday manager - that that patience he so keenly appeals for is not indefinite. It certainly wasn’t for Mowbray, and by that yardstick I don’t see why it should be with Mason, if the outlook becomes bleak. For now the jury is still (just about) out but he is really clinging on, and if that wondrous 2026/27 comes around and we’re still bang average then he will only be jeopardising his own position even further by not acting accordingly. For all of Peace’s faults, more often than not he didn’t hesitate for too long in correcting the mistakes that he made.


RE: Message from MR Nestor - BertieTheBaggie - 12-23-2025

(12-23-2025, 08:17 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: It all reads very much how I expected it to, albeit with more commas and longer sentences than were particularly necessary. A ‘managing expectation’ overload promising very little else indeed, although it does usefully highlight the shit that we were in. Nonetheless, just like the Labour Party, they can’t blame the last lot forever, and there will be more than a few bookmarking this statement; particularly with regard to that (very much trumpeted) 2026/27 season. At least he didn’t say 2027/28 - that would have really pissed me off.

Time will indeed tell, and I hope that - should it indeed transpire that as good a weekday coach as he may be, Ryan Mason in fact is not a good matchday manager - that that patience he so keenly appeals for is not indefinite. It certainly wasn’t  for Mowbray, and by that yardstick I don’t see why it should be with Mason, if the outlook becomes bleak. For now the jury is still (just about) out but he is really clinging on, and if that wondrous 2026/27 comes around and we’re still bang average then he will only be jeopardising his own position even further by not acting accordingly. For all of Peace’s faults, more often than not he didn’t hesitate for too long in correcting the mistakes that he made.
They can’t blame the last lot forever line kind of says all about your mindset rather than the state of the club. 
They inherited a financial mess like the club hadn’t seen in its history. 
We’ve sold our best prospect in ages, Fellows, to keep ourselves from getting hammers on FFP. We then sold the high earners like Furlong and had to sell our best keeper as well.
We’re shopping in Farmfoods in the football world. 
This was pretty clearly going to be the case. 
They can’t blame the last lot forever but at the moment less than 2 years in after inheriting Lai’sshambles they’ve got a fair old bit of goodwill still in the bank by level headed fans. 
A middle of the road nothing season will be ok.


RE: Message from MR Nestor - richbaggie - 12-23-2025

It's really surprised me how little is being made of the club looking for a TD. For me, thats a really big development.


RE: Message from MR Nestor - tHEgLASSdOORS - 12-23-2025

I suppose it’s hard to get too excited when it’s a way off, we don’t know who it is, there’s no impact yet and we are where we are on the pitch.

It’s good to see the bricks going into place gradually and an awareness of what’s lacking


RE: Message from MR Nestor - HawkingsHalfpint - 12-23-2025

(12-23-2025, 08:58 PM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote:
(12-23-2025, 08:17 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: It all reads very much how I expected it to, albeit with more commas and longer sentences than were particularly necessary. A ‘managing expectation’ overload promising very little else indeed, although it does usefully highlight the shit that we were in. Nonetheless, just like the Labour Party, they can’t blame the last lot forever, and there will be more than a few bookmarking this statement; particularly with regard to that (very much trumpeted) 2026/27 season. At least he didn’t say 2027/28 - that would have really pissed me off.

Time will indeed tell, and I hope that - should it indeed transpire that as good a weekday coach as he may be, Ryan Mason in fact is not a good matchday manager - that that patience he so keenly appeals for is not indefinite. It certainly wasn’t  for Mowbray, and by that yardstick I don’t see why it should be with Mason, if the outlook becomes bleak. For now the jury is still (just about) out but he is really clinging on, and if that wondrous 2026/27 comes around and we’re still bang average then he will only be jeopardising his own position even further by not acting accordingly. For all of Peace’s faults, more often than not he didn’t hesitate for too long in correcting the mistakes that he made.
They can’t blame the last lot forever line kind of says all about your mindset rather than the state of the club. 
They inherited a financial mess like the club hadn’t seen in its history. 
We’ve sold our best prospect in ages, Fellows, to keep ourselves from getting hammers on FFP. We then sold the high earners like Furlong and had to sell our best keeper as well.
We’re shopping in Farmfoods in the football world. 
This was pretty clearly going to be the case. 
They can’t blame the last lot forever but at the moment less than 2 years in after inheriting Lai’sshambles they’ve got a fair old bit of goodwill still in the bank by level headed fans. 
A middle of the road nothing season will be ok.

Erm, hence my mindset also acknowledging ‘the shit that we were in’?

In fact, if you look at the context of the post in its entirety, rather than just focussing upon one sentence, you wouldn’t see me at all disagreeing that 2026/27 is the point from which (financially at least) it is fair to judge. Just to be clear I fully appreciate not only the catastrophic mess Lai left us in, but that - even if Patel and co had a magic wand to instantly fix it all - they wouldn’t yet be allowed to wave it. 

All I’m saying is that from that point it will be fair to see how their strategy is going, and that after one bad managerial appointment (and another struggling) it is bound to happen. 

Meanwhile, if you want to have a bash at someone anti the new regime, you haven’t got to look that far about this place to find a target for that. Generally I’m not anti at all - it’s still far too early to say whether or not they will indeed make good custodians. The jury is still very much out on Nestor, but so far we’ve no reason to suspect that they’re anywhere near as bad as the prior incumbents.

The only other point is that they ‘inherited’ what I would very much hope that they’d already appraised via their own due diligence. Most of us knew we were a mess - it’s inconceivable to think that they didn’t also. Of course financial constraints are as applicable as they are understandable until that’s fixed. For now.