WBAUnofficial
Mowbray - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Mowbray (/showthread.php?tid=39324)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Mowbray - Ted Maul - 11-13-2025

(11-13-2025, 01:52 PM)MrBater Wrote: Thing is, you can't directly compare one years squad with another... Because all the other teams are different too.. the last few Champ years I think have been getting weaker and weaker..

Mowbrays side or Dave's side would likely walk it, but could we even have either side now? Probably not. Just because our squad now isn't as strong as back then you have to factor in who their opposition are too... And I reckon most tope ten teams in Mowbrays year would probably do very well in the champ in the last 3 years ..

As a whole the Championship is stronger than it was 17 years ago due to the amount of parachute money that has trickled down into it. It just so happens our position is weaker as we don't have any.


RE: Mowbray - HawkingsHalfpint - 11-13-2025

Thanks, Dekka

IMO, TM succeeded with us purely because of the squad. It could afford to raise revenues yet still retain a strong nucleus, which was (mostly, but not entirely) well reinvested. That, and of course a very solid spine and the magnificent adaptability of players such as Greening, Clement and the emergence of future, similarly adaptable reliability players like Brunt and Morrison.

If TM were a true great, he’d have enjoyed a far better career in his post-Celtic days, opposed to bouncing around like a slightly younger Bruce, with little more of note than a relatively decent 12 or 13-week stint at Blues to point at.


RE: Mowbray - Derek Hardballs - 11-13-2025

(11-13-2025, 01:57 PM)KRO Wrote:
(11-13-2025, 01:40 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-13-2025, 01:32 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: The 2007-08 squad was absolutely brilliant. It was full of gifted, talented players, who most importantly had balls. When you look back at the likes of Keily, Robinson, Clement, Greening, Gera, Bednar, Phillips, Miller, Tex, Mozza, Brunt… even the more average players like Barnett, Howfkens, Beattie, Do One had plenty of license to chip in. I’m not sure anyone’s granny would necessarily have gotten anyone up (other than Wayne Rooney) but the stage was set. Credit to TM for winning what was there to be won, but it must be said it was an easy promotion with quality like that. Especially in comparison to the others around that era.

But despite the quality, the warning of how short-lived it was to become was the cup semi-final, which if anything was a sneak preview of the season that would follow. A shit load of beautiful, tippy tappy precision passing with utterly no end product. Granted, the injury James inflicted upon Miller, the shocking decision not to give Phillips a two-year deal (and instead allowing the sealcunts off their obligations by accepting that wanker Luke Isaac Hunt Moore as his replacement), Bednar’s extra curricular etc. didn’t help, but Mowbray was well and truly found out the year that followed. Although it did indeed result in silverware, I truly believe that the squad at that time flattered him.

And it is absolutely true that the season before the promotion one was an abject failure. Whilst the quality was comparable, there was still too much experience and ability in that side not to go up.

Some fond memories under naughties TM? Absolutely, yes. But a true managerial great? Not for me.

Excellent summary of the reality of that era HH.

FAO KRO you may have watched us from afar but the above is reality not a handful of games for Blues.
Again I’m not basing his managerial capabilities on his 3 months at Blues.
And you say that’s reality because he agrees with SOME of what you think. The majority disagree with you. Lots of those players excelled due to the style of play and being bought by Mowbray. So credit should be given there. But won’t be. Over his career he’s got most teams punching above where they should be and without splashing loads of cash. You say he’s average, yet your words paint him in a far worse light. His career suggests he’s better than average imo. And comfortably

Just because we have a hardcore of fervent Mowbray disciples within our supporter base doesn’t mean they are right. The promotion team was always flawed, it played far too open and without defensive discipline or shape, it meant we got up with one of the lowest points totals for promotion from the Championship. I suspect that under another manager promotion would have yielded more points. The season after our tippy tappy play brought plaudits whilst the opposition took the points. 

This isn’t hindsight and there were people like me who said we couldn’t play that way once promoted as we were defensively weak as team. The main reason we went up is our owner had created an environment where we would be amongst if not the favourite for promotion at the time, this wasn’t a miracle, we weren’t punching above our weight, if anything we were flat track bullies. 

TM’s an average Championship manager which is why he managed Blues!


RE: Mowbray - MrBater - 11-13-2025

(11-13-2025, 02:08 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-13-2025, 01:52 PM)MrBater Wrote: Thing is, you can't directly compare one years squad with another... Because all the other teams are different too.. the last few Champ years I think have been getting weaker and weaker..

Mowbrays side or Dave's side would likely walk it, but could we even have either side now? Probably not. Just because our squad now isn't as strong as back then you have to factor in who their opposition are too... And I reckon most tope ten teams in Mowbrays year would probably do very well in the champ in the last 3 years ..

As a whole the Championship is stronger than it was 17 years ago due to the amount of parachute money that has trickled down into it. It just so happens our position is weaker as we don't have any.

Most teams in IT don't have any! I think it's a much more even and weaker league than it's ever been.


RE: Mowbray - tHEgLASSdOORS - 11-13-2025

(11-13-2025, 02:11 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Thanks, Dekka

IMO, TM succeeded with us purely because of the squad. It could afford to raise revenues yet still retain a strong nucleus, which was (mostly, but not entirely) well reinvested. That, and of course a very solid spine and the magnificent adaptability of players such as Greening, Clement and the emergence of future, similarly adaptable reliability players like Brunt and Morrison.

If TM were a true great, he’d have enjoyed a far better career in his post-Celtic days, opposed to bouncing around like a slightly younger Bruce, with little more of note than a relatively decent 12 or 13-week stint at Blues to point at.

Correct


RE: Mowbray - Josh1873 - 11-13-2025

It's worth acknowledging the fact we had a big clear out after the PO defeat. We pretty much built a whole new squad! To oversee that and win the league is a good achievement, I believe. Talking of that PO final season, NobSor really struggled with the squad and was rightly sacked. Whilst TM also failed to get a very good squad promoted that season, he very nearly did, and gave us the memorable 4 out 5 Dingle wins. 

I'm really not sure what the point of this debate is, if I'm honest. Mowbray wasn't a great manager back then. He had his faults, he was stubborn, and definitely made mistakes & had weaknesses. But we had a fantastic season, winning silverware and had a memorable cup run. Neither of those achievements were special in terms of expectations. It wasn't some Megson-esque 2002 miracle, but they were very enjoyable nonetheless. 

I couldn't care less whether he achieved something he should have done, given the resources. It was one of my favourite seasons in 30ish years supporting this club, and a period that will live with me for the rest of my life. That feeling when Brunt clattered home the equaliser that promoted us v Saints. Special. Seeing us lift a trophy away at QPR. Special. Getting within touching distance of an FA Cup final. Heartbreaking. He gave us memories I will cherish and look back on with fondness.

I understand the stance of not rating TM, there's some fair reasoning behind it. But I also don't understand the reluctance to accept 2007/8 season as brilliant. You can be critical of TM, but still acknowledge what a wonderful season it was. The two aren't exclusive. 

I can't recall whether injuries were a factor or whether it was classic TM stubborness but if he had Mulumbu and Dorrans available all season in the PL relegation season, who knows? I seem to recall us making a bit of a fist of staying up, unless I'm misremembering! Points wise it wasn't close, but I feel like we gave it a good go with a late run when Fortune and Menseguez, in particular, hit a real run of form. 

In short, I don't think the PL relegation was the meek surrendering that it is being made out to be. Be critical, yes. He wasn't great first time around but he wasn't bad. Far from it. Give the guy some credit for giving us a fair amount of good times and memories.


RE: Mowbray - Squid - 11-13-2025

(11-13-2025, 01:57 PM)KRO Wrote:
(11-13-2025, 01:40 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-13-2025, 01:32 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: The 2007-08 squad was absolutely brilliant. It was full of gifted, talented players, who most importantly had balls. When you look back at the likes of Keily, Robinson, Clement, Greening, Gera, Bednar, Phillips, Miller, Tex, Mozza, Brunt… even the more average players like Barnett, Howfkens, Beattie, Do One had plenty of license to chip in. I’m not sure anyone’s granny would necessarily have gotten anyone up (other than Wayne Rooney) but the stage was set. Credit to TM for winning what was there to be won, but it must be said it was an easy promotion with quality like that. Especially in comparison to the others around that era.

But despite the quality, the warning of how short-lived it was to become was the cup semi-final, which if anything was a sneak preview of the season that would follow. A shit load of beautiful, tippy tappy precision passing with utterly no end product. Granted, the injury James inflicted upon Miller, the shocking decision not to give Phillips a two-year deal (and instead allowing the sealcunts off their obligations by accepting that wanker Luke Isaac Hunt Moore as his replacement), Bednar’s extra curricular etc. didn’t help, but Mowbray was well and truly found out the year that followed. Although it did indeed result in silverware, I truly believe that the squad at that time flattered him.

And it is absolutely true that the season before the promotion one was an abject failure. Whilst the quality was comparable, there was still too much experience and ability in that side not to go up.

Some fond memories under naughties TM? Absolutely, yes. But a true managerial great? Not for me.

Excellent summary of the reality of that era HH.

FAO KRO you may have watched us from afar but the above is reality not a handful of games for Blues.
Again I’m not basing his managerial capabilities on his 3 months at Blues.
And you say that’s reality because he agrees with SOME of what you think. The majority disagree with you. Lots of those players excelled due to the style of play and being bought by Mowbray. So credit should be given there. But won’t be. Over his career he’s got most teams punching above where they should be and without splashing loads of cash. You say he’s average, yet your words paint him in a far worse light. His career suggests he’s better than average imo. And comfortably

Hmm. If you want to know how fans of another team managed by Mowbray think, the following is a worthwhile read:

https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/showthread.php?tid=36636


RE: Mowbray - PatelsPlatoon - 11-13-2025

Wow 5 pages on a manager who has left us. It really feels like an international break.


RE: Mowbray - Merkinagogo - 11-13-2025

(11-13-2025, 04:30 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: Wow 5 pages on a manager who has left us. It really feels like an international break.

People get bored. 

By the end of the weekend we'll have the Ashman thread


RE: Mowbray - Bob Fossil - 11-13-2025

Once Pulis established his anti-football survival blueprint he was finished as a Championship manager. You don’t get promoted with draws. He tried and failed a couple of times if memory serves me well. Boro may even have been involved?
CC also had this issue, to a point, no pun intended.
Mowbray was a disaster here but has it in his locker. If the players relate to him and he gets on a run, Boro will continue to be a force. If not, he’ll be gone before the end of the season.