![]() |
|
The Top 50 Albums of all time - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: The Top 50 Albums of all time (/showthread.php?tid=39154) |
RE: The Top 50 Albums of all time - HawkingsHalfpint - 10-29-2025 (10-29-2025, 08:46 PM)Squid Wrote: That is a terribly predictable list. Nothing truly left field or surprising whatsoever and quite a few choices that just feel like ticking off a genre box. For example, choosing To Pimp a Butterfly over 3 Feet High and Rising seems to be more dictated by the current popularity of the artist than the quality of the album. Trans Europe Express fair enough, but choosing anything by Daft Punk while ignoring Orbital, The Chemical Brothers or Prodigy would suggest that he has ears of cloth. I'd argue that Odelay by Beck and Debut by Björk deserve a place there. Odelay is indeed a masterpiece, and of all the Orbital releases In Sides would definitely be among my top 50. But then, people I know would probably go for the Orange one or Snivelisation ahead of that. Who is really to say. But herein lies the subjectiveness of so many of these ‘Top 100/50/whatever’-type opinions; they are just that. Both acts are examples of music I wouldn’t expect (most of) the generation above/below ours to listen to (let alone appreciate), in the same way I don’t appreciate as much music of their genres. In fact, notwithstanding the odd intergenerational classic enjoyed by most if-not all (Rumours being a good example), I find such lists little more than a way of saying ‘look at my playlist’. All a matter of taste, really. RE: The Top 50 Albums of all time - Duffers - 10-29-2025 (10-29-2025, 08:46 PM)Squid Wrote: That is a terribly predictable list. Nothing truly left field or surprising whatsoever and quite a few choices that just feel like ticking off a genre box. For example, choosing To Pimp a Butterfly over 3 Feet High and Rising seems to be more dictated by the current popularity of the artist than the quality of the album. Trans Europe Express fair enough, but choosing anything by Daft Punk while ignoring Orbital, The Chemical Brothers or Prodigy would suggest that he has ears of cloth. I'd argue that Odelay by Beck and Debut by Björk deserve a place there. Agreed, everyone knows Good Kid Maad City is better. RE: The Top 50 Albums of all time - chasetownbaggie - 10-30-2025 I like seeing lists like this but take them with a pinch of salt. There's no way the reviewer has heard every album ever made for a start, but it's just onions. Lists compiled from choices of many people rather than one can probably make more sense. Interesting that having been an avid reader of NME and other music weeklies from late 80s to early noughties, where they'd do lists like this regularly, some of the ones that regularly topped their polls don't make this list e.g. Stone Roses, Love and Public Enemy Re: this list, I've listened to only about 15 of them (and I probably own about 400 albums, I'm guessing and heard more via Spotify). I agree with comments that Beatles wouldn't be #1, as influential as they are and In Utero over Nevermind. I'd put any one of 3 other Radiohead albums ahead of OK Computer. Dark Side Of The Moon is dull. Miseducation of Lauryn Hill - nah. And I've just never got The Clash. Off the top of my head, in my top 50, I'd definitely have Giant Steps by Boo Radleys and In The Heart Of Town by Gallon Drunk and Rings Around The World by SFA and The Last Broadcast by Doves. RE: The Top 50 Albums of all time - petty sniper - 10-30-2025 Ocean rain by Echo and the Bunnymen is a timeless masterpiece and would always be my number one RE: The Top 50 Albums of all time - CarlosCorbewrong - 10-30-2025 Dexys? RE: The Top 50 Albums of all time - tHEgLASSdOORS - 10-30-2025 No Doggystyle, no New Forms, no Original Pirate Material Another wasted mouse click, what a load of rack RE: The Top 50 Albums of all time - Duffers - 10-30-2025 (10-30-2025, 07:19 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I like seeing lists like this but take them with a pinch of salt. There's no way the reviewer has heard every album ever made for a start, but it's just onions. Lists compiled from choices of many people rather than one can probably make more sense. Interesting that having been an avid reader of NME and other music weeklies from late 80s to early noughties, where they'd do lists like this regularly, some of the ones that regularly topped their polls don't make this list e.g. Stone Roses, Love and Public Enemy Same, I enjoy reading them but treat them more as conversation starters than anything more serious. It's all subjective anyway, if every person on this dump was asked to name their top ten albums you wouldn't get two identical lists. RE: The Top 50 Albums of all time - DemonicBaggie - 10-30-2025 No such thing as ‘Greatest Ever’ or ‘Top’, just ‘My favourites’. Entirely subjective. RE: The Top 50 Albums of all time - Duffers - 10-30-2025 My top ten (not in order): Arcade Fire - Funeral Pulp - Different Class Kendrick Lamar - Good Kid Maad City Nirvana - In Utero Soulwax - Any Minute Now Radiohead - OK Computer The National - High Violet LCD Soundsystem - Sound of Silver Stone Roses - Stone Roses Lana Del Rey - Norman Fucking Rockwell RE: The Top 50 Albums of all time - Tokyo Baggie - 10-30-2025 Favorite off the top of my head. Would probably change tomorrow! No order: Velevet Underground and Nico Smashing Pumpkins - Siamese Dream Orbital - Snivilization Eat Static - Implant A Tribe Called Quest - The Low End Theory Dandy Warhols - Come Down Roni Size & Reprazent- New Forms The Horrors - Primary Colors Eddy Current Suppresion Ring - Eddy Current Suppresion Ring QOTSA - Songs for the Deaf (just pips Lullabies) |