![]() |
|
Post Window Thoughts - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Post Window Thoughts (/showthread.php?tid=38579) |
RE: Post Window Thoughts - richbaggie - 09-03-2025 Another thought that occurred to me when thinking about recruitment. Nestor has received all the plaudits about the improvement made with recruitment over the last 12 months. Ian Pearce never gets any praise, despite him being in charge of recruitment, scouting and Strategic planning. Do people think its nestor doing all this? Why doesn't Pearce get any recognition do you think? RE: Post Window Thoughts - SW4Baggie - 09-03-2025 (09-03-2025, 09:17 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Another thought that occurred to me when thinking about recruitment. Because Pearce was here when our recruitment was utter shit - we don't know whether he was responsible or even involved during that period (plenty of murmurs about he and his team being sidelined whilst Gourmet and Bruce signed their mates) - but ultimately he was part of the team that brought in so many underwhelming wastes of money that contributed to the PSR mess we find ourselves in. Nestor has also been the very public face of our new recruitment approach, he made it clear the system was broken and needed rebuilding so it's hard to believe Pearce would have done something similar had he not been constrained by Bruce and co. We will never know - the fact Nestor and co kept Pearce on suggests he adds some value but I'm not sure he's worthy of any huge credit? RE: Post Window Thoughts - ChamonixBaggie - 09-03-2025 (09-03-2025, 09:17 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Another thought that occurred to me when thinking about recruitment. Presumably because the improvement has come about since Nestor/Bilkul arrived. Pearce was around during a phase of shambolic recruitment and while he may be doing better work now under better guidance, it's not him that brought about the change. RE: Post Window Thoughts - Bob Fossil - 09-03-2025 (09-03-2025, 09:17 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Another thought that occurred to me when thinking about recruitment.If any of the latest lot turn out shit, he'll get credit for them
RE: Post Window Thoughts - richbaggie - 09-03-2025 Pearce was very much hamstrung under Lai. Recruitment budgets were slashed. What Nestor has done is reverse that which has allowed Pearce to scout wider and with better s technology. It's Pearce that is choosing the players though, not Nestor. Nestor has no football knowledge as such. For me, Nestor/Bilkul get credit for investing in that area again and better strategic planning and Pearce gets credit for identifying the players to fit that strategy. RE: Post Window Thoughts - Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025 Pearce suffers the same misfortune as Mowatt, Furlong, Townsend, Livermore and Bartley. All get/have got unduly criticised for being part of a collective failure at the club rather than actually being directly responsible for it. RE: Post Window Thoughts - Derek Hardballs - 09-03-2025 Isn’t it prudent to judge our recruitment at the end of the season? Currently we are doing well but that form tapered off badly last season and could quite easily this season. Football isn’t judged on paper and shouldn’t be judged over a handful of games, actually not even a handful currently. I’m old enough to remember when it’s been declared that we’ve done ‘great business’ ‘excellent window’ and in reality we were average or worse than the season before. RE: Post Window Thoughts - Ted Maul - 09-03-2025 (09-03-2025, 12:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Isn’t it prudent to judge our recruitment at the end of the season? Currently we are doing well but that form tapered off badly last season and could quite easily this season. Football isn’t judged on paper and shouldn’t be judged over a handful of games, actually not even a handful currently. This is a discussion forum Dekka, would defeat the object if we just posted our thoughts once a year at the end of each season. RE: Post Window Thoughts - richbaggie - 09-03-2025 (09-03-2025, 12:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Isn’t it prudent to judge our recruitment at the end of the season? Currently we are doing well but that form tapered off badly last season and could quite easily this season. Football isn’t judged on paper and shouldn’t be judged over a handful of games, actually not even a handful currently. Bilkul have been here 20 months, you can have an opinion on how we have gone about things since then. Wider net, younger profile, better character. It's pretty clear we are in a much better place with the strategy and approach to recruitment. RE: Post Window Thoughts - Derek Hardballs - 09-03-2025 (09-03-2025, 12:14 PM)richbaggie Wrote:(09-03-2025, 12:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Isn’t it prudent to judge our recruitment at the end of the season? Currently we are doing well but that form tapered off badly last season and could quite easily this season. Football isn’t judged on paper and shouldn’t be judged over a handful of games, actually not even a handful currently. Well their managerial recruitment last season was appalling Far too soon to judge this seasons but the signs look promising. The question is what is success for us as a club? Consolidation, hope for the play/offs and working towards operating within the PSR rules is I imagine what the owners would deem success. On that score we are doing ok potentially. I can’t say we are doing any better than that currently as it’s too early to say. If we are in the playoff this season I would deem that a very successful season, if we are bobbling around in midtable as we were last year by the end it will be understandable but two or three more seasons without troubling the promotion spots and the same recruitment strategy will look like managed decline. In summary it’s looking better than previously, but let’s be honest the previous owners had driven the club into the ground so we are coming from a relatively low base. It’s looking far better than it did, and we seem to be building much firmer foundations but I still think it’s going to take at least until the end of this season to really see where our new recruitment policy can take us. |