WBAUnofficial
Fellows - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Fellows (/showthread.php?tid=38487)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34


RE: Fellows - Even Flow 2.0 - 08-28-2025

I said we are getting probably double what I would have expected for Furlong and now potentially selling Fellows for half of what I'd expect. Don't think Fellows is a 20m player but that's the kind of money being thrown around now.


RE: Fellows - rsbaggy2 - 08-28-2025

Right hand side of team cleaned out in a matter of hours. Angry


RE: Fellows - Josh1873 - 08-28-2025

@Jacko - Fellows is obviously a better player than Grant. That's not what I said, though.

@Dumbo - £10mill does seem light. Let's see what's confirmed first before criticising the club.


RE: Fellows - CIM - 08-28-2025

I can't believe we are selling Fellows for 4x less than Ipswich sold Omari Hutchinson. Wrexham paid £10m for the bang average Broadhead FFS.


RE: Fellows - Ted Maul - 08-28-2025

When quoting the fees received for Dibling, Hutchinson and Fernandes people would do well to remember that they put up numbers in the PL last season to earn those moves - Hutchinson and Dibling are both younger too. Fellows has never played in the PL, nor has he ever played for a team in this division that has looked capable of really pushing the top two.

He's a throwback winger, not many clubs play with wide players like that anymore. He's not a cutting in off the wing goal threat, his record backs that up. It's telling that there was no queue of clubs at our door, there was no bidding war. If the reported £8-10m with add-ons is true, I wont defend it as it's low, but it's not THAT much too low.

£15m coming off the season he's just had would have been fair, given his deficiencies and what I think is a pretty limited scope to really go on and make himself a consistent top flight winger.


RE: Fellows - Josh1873 - 08-28-2025

(08-28-2025, 11:38 AM)Even Flow 2.0 Wrote: Don't think Fellows is a 20m player but that's the kind of money being thrown around now.

That's how I feel, if I'm honest. I think he's a good talent and will have a great career. But I don't sit at the Hawthorns and think 'he's gonna be a star' like I do with Price. 

£10 mill is light - £15mill feels about right to me. Ultimately there are people involved with both clubs who will have all sorts of data and analytics that come to a value conclusion. Let's see what the final value turns out to be. If Saints have agreed to pay £10mill and we've agreed to accept it, there must be a good reason for it. 

As far as I'm aware with PSR we don't need to sell, do we? Our situation isn't as desperate as it was. Fellows isn't demanding to leave, so you have to think WBA wouldn't accept what they perceive to be a ridiculously low offer - they (if the reports are true) obviously believe £10mill is fair and believe they can use those funds to further strengthen the squad.

Edit - I agree with Ted in the post above. £10mill is low, but I don't think it's as low or derogatory or stupid or whatever as people are making out.


RE: Fellows - Mouse - 08-28-2025

Something is being hidden here, either from our side or Southampton's side. I've seen different things (ok not reputable) stating £8m+£2 and even £7m+£2 and also seen a few that suggest there is a 25% sell on clause.

Ultimately, we don't know and we won't know for a while as it'll be "undisclosed" i'd imagine.

However, I think the club have done enough in recent months to earn a bit of trust here. Disapointing if the figure is low, however perhaps we've got the opportunity to get someone else in and need to act quickly.

Perhaps I am being naive.


RE: Fellows - Cheshire East Baggie - 08-28-2025

(08-28-2025, 11:31 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Am I the only fan that's not overly disappointed about this transfer? I like Fellows, and he's obviously a good talent, but I also feel he goes missing more often than people dare mention.

I hate the term 'one trick pony', that's not strictly true, but he does have the run down the right, step over and chip to back post trick which so often works to our benefit, I do wonder how he'd get on in the Prem, against better defenders, and maybe that's why his value is perceived to be low from other clubs. 

He's not versatile, really. He can't play as a striker, or you wouldn't want him at full back. He's a right winger and he's great at that. But you won't get much else from him. 

It's sad to see him go, and he'll be a loss, but I also believe he's replaceable.

Ideally I'd like all our best home-grown players to stay and play 300+ games for us. But that's not how the game works these days.

Has Fellows developed rapidly and become a devastating attacking force for us? Not really, he isn't our only threat, despite his excellent stats. Are Premier League clubs offering big bucks for him? Apparently not. Does it make sense to move him on now for a decentish fee, rather than wait to see if he goes up in value on the back of another strong season? Maybe it does.

I'm not going into meltdown over the size of the fee, there are too many factors we fans don't know when it comes to the money. As for replacing him, can't Grant or Johnston play down the right? Could Styles play down the left if we had another LB? If we ever get Bany fit (as well as Maja) we'll have plenty of options for a 10.

Above all, I feel this window will have been positive. Furlong is the last of the clique that saw off several coaches from 2019 onwards. A complete changeout of the defence was long overdue, for too long the weaker players stayed and the better ones were sold. Plenty of cause for optimism, even if we're playing the Lardy Men from Stoke next.


RE: Fellows - CA Baggie - 08-28-2025

He'll need replacing immediately, we cannot go with Wallace.

For context, we paid £15m for Karlan Grant in 2020. It's not like transfer fees have gone through the roof in that time.


RE: Fellows - Duffers - 08-28-2025

(08-28-2025, 11:47 AM)Acker Bilks Clarinet Wrote:
(08-28-2025, 11:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: When quoting the fees received for Dibling, Hutchinson and Fernandes people would do well to remember that they put up numbers in the PL last season to earn those moves - Hutchinson and Dibling are both younger too. Fellows has never played in the PL, nor has he ever played for a team in this division that has looked capable of really pushing the top two.

He's a throwback winger, not many clubs play with wide players like that anymore. He's not a cutting in off the wing goal threat, his record backs that up. It's telling that there was no queue of clubs at our door, there was no bidding war. If the reported £8-10m with add-ons is true, I wont defend it as it's low, but it's not THAT much too low.

£15m coming off the season he's just had would have been fair, given his deficiencies and what I think is a pretty limited scope to really go on and make himself a consistent top flight winger.

This will go down as a terrible move for the club. Fellows will be in the England squad by the end of the year.

He’s got promise but this is a pretty daft statement.

Welcome new poster by the way.