WBAUnofficial
How does this work? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: How does this work? (/showthread.php?tid=37639)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11


RE: How does this work? - Protheroe - 05-12-2025

Amongst all the usual Proth pile-on, not one single comment on the issue of substance. Plus ca change de la classe du cordon.


RE: How does this work? - Jacko - 05-12-2025

Sir Kier has started his lurch towards Enoch Powell I see...


RE: How does this work? - baggy1 - 05-12-2025

Starts with condescending new terminology that he picked up in the Times and then criticises everyone else for not finding a solution the problem that has been with us since the 90s.

(05-12-2025, 12:20 PM)Jacko Wrote: Sir Kier has started his lurch towards Enoch Powell I see...

He can expect your vote then next time I presume


RE: How does this work? - Derek Hardballs - 05-12-2025

(05-12-2025, 09:05 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-12-2025, 08:02 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Hmm, the grown up answer doesn’t make any sense…

Who are these British people queuing up to take care jobs? Still waiting for an answer
If you raise the pay for these jobs how are people going to pay? Tax payer, and families…
Are Labour going to cap profits on private companies who exploit both the receiver of care and the carers? What do something to actually help solve the problem? Nah!
Does anyone want a carer who has been forced into the job by the government? Not really, no
How does this solve the real issue people have with illegal immigration on boats, planes and trucks? It doesn’t and people aren’t stupid, contrary to the condescending statements Labour officials and supporters trot out

When will Labour and their fervent centrist supporters learn, you will never out Reform, Reform. You have lost those votes, if you ever really had them, they aren’t coming back no matter how unconvincingly Yvette Cooper and Smarmer pretend they are suddenly tough on immigration.

Give your own narrative of hope, challenge the narrative of Reform, look like you’re on the side of the public, not just ‘working people’ stop alienating millions of people on the left and right with disingenuous policies that aren’t joined up and solve absolutely nothing. What do Labour actually stand for?

There was a time some on here used to scoff at the unrealistic aims of getting thousands of Brits to take on these roles, what’s changed? Nothing, it’s just pandering to voters you’ve long since alienated.

I don't disagree with you Dekka, I'm just highlighting the discrepancy between you arguing against foreign workers undercutting UK workers last week and keen to get the workers in this week.

(05-12-2025, 07:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-12-2025, 07:35 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And I can imagine the headlines and the reform party line going forward "Labour think immigration isn't a problem' and 'Reform is the only party to stop the boats'

You and the brexiteer class allowed Farage to sow the seed of the knotweed we have today because it suited your end goal. I don't remember the 'truth' being spouted by Johnson, Gove et al at the time conveniently.

I take offence at the suggestion that I've ever been anti (legal) immigration. 

Instead of worrying about legal migration, Labour *only* needs to deal with irregular migration - the boats. I doubt there are many in the country who really care about migration through legal routes. Far less if they were actually educated about the benefits of it.

The *only* migration problem in the UK is the very visible perception of invasion by "fighting age men" arriving illegally on boats.

I'm listening to Starmer now, talking about "taking back control" - we will clamp down on the immigration we need, and fail yet again on the boats. You just watch.

(05-12-2025, 07:45 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-12-2025, 07:39 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I don't believe the truth has altered in a couple of decades. We are already short of skilled workers, tradesmen and care workers. This shortage will become ever more acute as our population ages. Personally I don't have an issue with legal migration from anywhere in the world (and never have).

And yet you still saw Brexit as the solution

The solution to what? 

I would have happily retained free movement into the UK from the EU as part of a liberal Brexit.

Take offence all you like I haven't accused you of that, I've accused you of standing by whilst the 'useful idiot' that is Farage sewed the seeds that would allow Brexit to happen. Without his poisonous rhetoric about the 'boats' and 'controlling our borders' you'd never have got anywhere near a majority. I don't recall the great Leave campaign 'truth' at the time. It was a deafening 'as long as we win, we can deal with that later'.

I don’t recall being anti-immigration. Particularly when there are no credible or affordable alternatives. I’m sure most care companies would prefer to employ people from their local communities but currently there are no real solutions from Labour just more Reform rhetoric to fill those positions. 

Yet again there has been a Reform/Tory dog whistle policy made without any impact study being produced. What will be the effect on care for those that need it? Will it be reduced, become more expensive? Will Labour cap profits if companies try and pass the cost onto the person or local authority that needs the care? 

Labour have no balls, they are allowing other parties to steel the initiative and are blundering from one ill thought out policy to another. 

If you asked a ‘working family’ if they would prefer no care for their elderly father or someone from Zimbabwe to care for them, what do you think the answer is going to be? Labour are obsessed with getting people working, where once family members could afford to care for their relatives and now they can’t and rely on care companies, add to this with the disability and sickness cuts this is a recipe for complete social care collapse. 

… and for what? Trying to get votes from people who will vote Reform? It’s not going to happen. Who the pluck is advising Labour?


RE: How does this work? - Jacko - 05-12-2025

(05-12-2025, 12:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Starts with condescending new terminology that he picked up in the Times and then criticises everyone else for not finding a solution the problem that has been with us since the 90s.

(05-12-2025, 12:20 PM)Jacko Wrote: Sir Kier has started his lurch towards Enoch Powell I see...

He can expect your vote then next time I presume

Bazinga!!

When its difficult to defend the insults come out. Come on, straighten up that red rosette, dry your eyes and give it your best shot Champ.


RE: How does this work? - baggy1 - 05-12-2025

(05-12-2025, 12:41 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(05-12-2025, 12:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Starts with condescending new terminology that he picked up in the Times and then criticises everyone else for not finding a solution the problem that has been with us since the 90s.

(05-12-2025, 12:20 PM)Jacko Wrote: Sir Kier has started his lurch towards Enoch Powell I see...

He can expect your vote then next time I presume

Bazinga!!

When its difficult to defend the insults come out. Come on,  straighten up that red rosette, dry your eyes and give it your best shot Champ.

Can't say my best shot is needed in this case - you are a dyed in the wool anti-immigration party voter, this policy should be right up your street.

(05-12-2025, 12:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-12-2025, 09:05 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I don't disagree with you Dekka, I'm just highlighting the discrepancy between you arguing against foreign workers undercutting UK workers last week and keen to get the workers in this week.

I don’t recall being anti-immigration. Particularly when there are no credible or affordable alternatives. I’m sure most care companies would prefer to employ people from their local communities but currently there are no real solutions from Labour just more Reform rhetoric to fill those positions. 

Yet again there has been a Reform/Tory dog whistle policy made without any impact study being produced. What will be the effect on care for those that need it? Will it be reduced, become more expensive? Will Labour cap profits if companies try and pass the cost onto the person or local authority that needs the care? 

Labour have no balls, they are allowing other parties to steel the initiative and are blundering from one ill thought out policy to another. 

If you asked a ‘working family’ if they would prefer no care for their elderly father or someone from Zimbabwe to care for them, what do you think the answer is going to be? Labour are obsessed with getting people working, where once family members could afford to care for their relatives and now they can’t and rely on care companies, add to this with the disability and sickness cuts this is a recipe for complete social care collapse. 

… and for what? Trying to get votes from people who will vote Reform? It’s not going to happen. Who the pluck is advising Labour?

Last week you were literally complaining about Indians coming over without having to pay double taxation and taking jobs from UK workers. Those Indians coming with investment from Indian companies that is - is that a different type of anti-immigration to the one you want to talk about today?

Anyway back to the paper - having looked through it I can see the reasoning behind the announcement. That being to take the wind out of the sails of Farage and Badenock who are on the back foot with it. If they manage to reduce immigration then it blunts the threat of Reform. And I don't think they are looking for the votes of reform types, they are simply looking to stop them being so motivated to get out and vote.

There are a lot of 'ifs' in the paper though. The tightening of social care visa's has it's merits in that the current abuse of that system to get into the country needs to be addressed and have the ability to apply for citizenship after 5 years which is now 10. It would root out those that see a way in via a skill that they don't intend to pursue. However without the Fair Pay Agreement in place for Social Care it has a massive hole. We do need to get away from the 'anybody will do' approach to caring in the UK to one of a skilled vocation but we need that FPA sorted soon and there are no indications that is being published soon.

I do wonder why the PM has announced this now especially seeing as the FPA has not been put in place yet but I'm wondering is it simply politicking based on the timing of the war in Ukraine. If that does stabilise over the next few months there will possibly be an exodus of, up to, the 250k Ukrainians which would make his numbers look good and he could say 'told you so' without actually having done too much.

As the argument has, rightly, shifted to the social care sector and the shortages there, what I will say is the current arrangement isn't working clearly. That is partly down to the type of overseas worker that is being attracted and their reasoning. The turnover of staff is running at 33% pa I think I read which does indicate the social care route is being abused as is stated. Making that ability to apply for citizenship harder (10 instead of 5 years) may be the right approach to rectify some of that. If, again big if, they can get the FPA and an appropriate training in place, whilst giving the provider less easy options, then it might work better than the current broken system.

B1 prepares himself for accusations of defence simply because I am not going all chicken licken on this.


RE: How does this work? - Protheroe - 05-12-2025

So essentially it is merely a cynical political move and hang the consequences. Glad we're clear on that.


RE: How does this work? - baggy1 - 05-12-2025

(05-12-2025, 02:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote: So essentially it is merely a cynical political move and hang the consequences. Glad we're clear on that.

What consequences are you talking about? The number of care workers that come into the country and stop in that sector after they have achieved citizenship resulting in the 33% turnover?

The lack of incentive for companies to train UK workers into a sector that can get cheap labour from abroad that don't stay (see above)?

(05-12-2025, 10:57 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Amongst all the usual Proth pile-on, not one single comment on the issue of substance. Plus ca change de la classe du cordon.

Followed by the usual Proth misquoting and cherrypicking comments out of context and the wider post.

"Why won't anyone take me seriously"


RE: How does this work? - Borin' Baggie - 05-12-2025

I'd have more sympathy in your defence of the carer caps if there was a plan to actually address the issues of local authority spending on social care and the huge constraints put on the NHS by a lack of adequate social care provisions to release patients into, but this government have kicked that into the long grass.

Who's paying for the British care workers to be trained? Who's paying for more of the NHS budget to be spent on trying to cover gaps in social care? What's the actual plan here?

Same with wanting to build, what's the point in planning reform if there's not enough labour to build the things you've planned?


RE: How does this work? - baggy1 - 05-12-2025

(05-12-2025, 02:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'd have more sympathy in your defence of the carer caps if there was a plan to actually address the issues of local authority spending on social care and the huge constraints put on the NHS by a lack of adequate social care provisions to release patients into, but this government have kicked that into the long grass.

Agree with that BB, I'm not certain that today's announcement is much more than a mission statement. I think this is aimed at solving one problem, social care seen as an easy route to citizenship with no intention of staying in he sector, and not the bigger one of social care.