WBAUnofficial
Two signings that maybe defined our season - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Two signings that maybe defined our season (/showthread.php?tid=37530)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Two signings that maybe defined our season - Derek Hardballs - 05-02-2025

(05-02-2025, 05:57 PM)1952 Wrote: Appointing a manager is just a lottery, a lot of luck is needed. The are solid reasons behind the god awful appointments we made. In hindsight yes they were terrible but apart from the perennial doom mongers the normal majority had hope. Hindsight is brilliant but sadly is after the event. Those that bitch and moan about appointments will probably be correct most of the time as most managers fail to live up to expectations. I do wonder if the worst bitchers and moans ever attend games. Good luck to those in charge getting lucky. We could do with some.

I usually support managers I rate heck I have defended Megson, RDM, Hodgson and Pulis to the hilt even mistakenly Bruce to a certain extent mainly because he wasn’t Val. I’m not sure your description really fits, I just didn’t want TM as I thought it was a mistake. However I agree it’s not an exact science.

I want the Plymouth manager but that may be a mistake… I do have a season ticket Wink


RE: Two signings that maybe defined our season - Gzbaggy - 05-03-2025

Its not a lottery at all, it is a risk but there are certain things you look at to reduce that risk
- age , preferably under 40
-number of previous clubs, avoid anybody who has had more than 5/6
-is a move to WBA a move down, if so avoid
-motivation- are we their best/only chance of getting into the Premier League and are
they young enough to be motivated
-how many of their mates do they want to bring in, be wary if it is family

Hodgson is the exception, but we were a Premier League team then


RE: Two signings that maybe defined our season - baggie_ray - 05-03-2025

Hodgson wanted to be England manager so he needed to be in work and doing (relatively) well to even be in the running. He was definitely motivated in that respect.


RE: Two signings that maybe defined our season - Derek Hardballs - 05-03-2025

(05-03-2025, 01:10 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Its not a lottery at all, it is a risk but there are certain things you look at to reduce that risk
- age , preferably under 40
-number of previous clubs, avoid anybody who has had more than 5/6
-is a move to WBA a move down, if so avoid
-motivation- are we their best/only chance of getting into the Premier League and are
they young enough to be motivated
-how many of their mates do they want to bring in, be wary if it is family

Hodgson is the exception, but we were a Premier League team then

How many managers are under 40? You can mitigate for risk but every managerial appointment is a gamble. There isn’t a tried and tested formula, because if there were every club would be doing exactly what you said and seeing success.


RE: Two signings that maybe defined our season - Johnnykayeengland - 05-03-2025

(05-03-2025, 11:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-03-2025, 01:10 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Its not a lottery at all, it is a risk but there are certain things you look at to reduce that risk
- age , preferably under 40
-number of previous clubs, avoid anybody who has had more than 5/6
-is a move to WBA a move down, if so avoid
-motivation- are we their best/only chance of getting into the Premier League and are
they young enough to be motivated
-how many of their mates do they want to bring in, be wary if it is family

Hodgson is the exception, but we were a Premier League team then

How many managers are under 40? You can mitigate for risk but every managerial appointment is a gamble. There isn’t a tried and tested formula, because if there were every club would be doing exactly what you said and seeing success.
... and there'd still be winners and losers!


RE: Two signings that maybe defined our season - 1952 - 05-03-2025

(05-02-2025, 06:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-02-2025, 05:57 PM)1952 Wrote: Appointing a manager is just a lottery, a lot of luck is needed. The are solid reasons behind the god awful appointments we made. In hindsight yes they were terrible but apart from the perennial doom mongers the normal majority had hope. Hindsight is brilliant but sadly is after the event. Those that bitch and moan about appointments will probably be correct most of the time as most managers fail to live up to expectations. I do wonder if the worst bitchers and moans ever attend games. Good luck to those in charge getting lucky. We could do with some.

I usually support managers I rate heck I have defended Megson, RDM, Hodgson and Pulis to the hilt even mistakenly Bruce to a certain extent mainly because he wasn’t Val. I’m not sure your description really fits, I just didn’t want TM as I thought it was a mistake. However I agree it’s not an exact science.

I want the Plymouth manager but that may be a mistake… I do have a season ticket Wink

I'd take the Plymouth manager too. I've always supported the manager even if I didn't want him, at least to a point where it's he's not doing it for us.