WBAUnofficial
Worst appointment ever? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Worst appointment ever? (/showthread.php?tid=37394)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: Worst appointment ever? - Vinebaggie - 04-21-2025

Reading this Fred and wondering has any other football club in the history of the world appointed so many shit managers?


RE: Worst appointment ever? - CA Baggie - 04-21-2025

Gould was given the bird before

he was even appointed, no hindsight there and relegated us to the third tier. Clearly was, way worse than anything else before or since.

I don’t have any hatred for TM, unlike someone like Pardew, just frustration that it didn’t work. TM isn’t going to micro manage and this bunch of players slack off at the slightest opportunity and TM was naive (self indulgent) enough to think he could trust them a little.

How bad a footballer do you have to be to forget how to pass the ball to your own player? Or forget to mark a forward on the edge of your 6 yard box. These players are the reason that cups of coffee say “contents may be hot” on the side.

Brian Little I thought would do a decent job, make no mistake he was taking us down.

Denis Smith - that was an appointment that everyone knew was wrong, but again a decent bloke who just couldn’t handle the size of the job.

At least we didn’t ever actually appoint John Rudge, despite several links. That would have failed too.

Pepe Mel, AFI, Robson, Wylie, Allen v2, Giles v2 and Saunders were all viewed with scepticism and all failed to some degree.


RE: Worst appointment ever? - Boinger - 04-21-2025

I’d say out of all of them , your assessment of Trump as a cunt is your most accurate. The rest fairly accurate ?


RE: Worst appointment ever? - Gzbaggy - 04-22-2025

(04-21-2025, 10:37 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Gould was given the bird before

he was even appointed, no hindsight there and relegated us to the third tier. Clearly was, way worse than anything else before or since.

I don’t have any hatred for TM, unlike someone like Pardew, just frustration that it didn’t work.  TM isn’t going to micro manage and this bunch of players slack off at the slightest opportunity and TM was naive (self indulgent) enough to think he could trust them a little.

How bad a footballer do you have to be to forget how to pass the ball to your own player? Or forget to mark a forward on the edge of your 6 yard box.  These players are the reason that cups of coffee say “contents may be hot” on the side.

Brian Little I thought would do a decent job, make no mistake he was taking us down.

Denis Smith - that was an appointment that everyone knew was wrong, but again a decent bloke who just couldn’t handle the size of the job.

At least we didn’t ever actually appoint John Rudge, despite several links. That would have failed too.

Pepe Mel, AFI, Robson, Wylie, Allen v2, Giles v2 and Saunders were all viewed with scepticism and all failed to some degree.

John Rudge did an excellent job at Port Vale for many years


RE: Worst appointment ever? - Squid - 04-22-2025

(04-21-2025, 10:31 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Reading this Fred and wondering has any other football club in the history of the world appointed so many shit managers?

Stoke employ good managers and make them very bad. Possibly that's worse.


RE: Worst appointment ever? - petty sniper - 04-22-2025

I cannot believe that no one has mentioned Pullis. He brought players from 'the agents he knew and liked to work with' for the benefit of T Pullis and left us with a squad including James Chester and Ollie Burke who he had payed fortunes for. He then downed tools and engineered himself the sack as he needed to pay some legal bills and avaoided the relegation on his CV. In keeping us up for a couple of fucking miserable years he dismantled all scouting and within a few years we were signing the managers neigbour


RE: Worst appointment ever? - Derek Hardballs - 04-22-2025

(04-22-2025, 07:35 AM)petty sniper Wrote: I cannot believe that no one has mentioned Pullis.  He brought players from 'the agents he knew and liked to work with' for the benefit of T Pullis and left us with a squad including James Chester and Ollie Burke who he had payed fortunes for.  He then downed tools and engineered himself the sack as he needed to pay some legal bills and avaoided the relegation on his CV.  In keeping us up for a couple of fucking miserable years he dismantled all scouting and within a few years we were signing the managers neigbour

Miserable years finishing midtable in the Prem having beaten top six teams, yes how miserable I long for days like yesterday and Coventry. Btw the reason Pulis came in was because the clubs brilliant system and scouting had failed, Blanco, Samaras, Davidson, Gamboa, Ideye Brown were brought in after the club allowed half the squad to leave in one Summer. We ended up with these players because of our scouting system and those employed in it, I appreciate this isn’t what many want to acknowledge but they are the facts. Pulis should have left at the end of the season before he did but let’s not rewrite history, he was brought in because the clubs brilliant system was failing not because it was succeeding.


RE: Worst appointment ever? - Peachy - 04-22-2025

(04-21-2025, 04:49 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(04-21-2025, 04:44 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(04-21-2025, 04:38 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Relative to resources this is on a par with Bruce.  Little wasn’t this fucking bad

I know Bruce turned out bad Manc and his failure probably could have been foreseen. But I was willing to be optimistic - naively as it turned out - and give him a chance based on his promotions to the Prem.

With Mowbray I was fucking gutted to be honest. No optimism at all. I couldn't have foreseen him being this shit though. I agree he has turned out as badly, maybe worse, than Bruce.

I thought SB would keep us in the playoffs - and be a good antidote after Val.  I was wrong although I did want him gone in the summer

I thought TM was a downgrade but I wasn’t expecting fucking relegation form. Useless twat needs sacking tonight

Me too Manc. I actually thought it made a bit on sense given he knew the club and could settle quickly. What I hadn't factored in was just how transformational he would be in his style of play. I'd hoped that he would make just a few minor tweaks.

In hindsight it was a monumental fuck up which cost us dearly.

Back to the drawing board ...


RE: Worst appointment ever? - Jacko - 04-22-2025

Without the benefit of hindsight you'd be hard pressed to find a worse appointment and reaction to said appointment than AFI.


RE: Worst appointment ever? - Lurker#3 - 04-22-2025

For me it is close to being the worst appointment in my time supporting us.

Most head coach changes happen as it's already gone, and/or is going to shit.

ToMo came into a really stable, well functioning set up. Was then backed in the window and given a much improved tool kit. And the deterioration in our performances and results was shocking.

Bruce and Mowbray are one and the same unfortunately on this occasion.