WBAUnofficial
Mowbray - Public Opinion Poll - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Mowbray - Public Opinion Poll (/showthread.php?tid=37230)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: Mowbray - Public Opinion Poll - Lurker#3 - 04-10-2025

(04-10-2025, 05:24 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Being unsentimental:

Why would you appoint someone who’s just come through a serious illness, one that few recover from, especially considering the emotional toll it must have taken on him and his family? 
Managing the club surely comes second. Given that, how could Mowbray possibly have had the energy or been at the level of championship knowledge required? 
And even if you set that aside, after an intense coach like CC, whose style is all about focus and control, why go for someone as laid back as Mowbray? It’s too much of a contrast.
In any case you don't go back. 
Isn't it obvious that the players haven't bought into it? As has been pointed out these lot specialise in getting rid of managers.
This situation is so Albion. Those of us who listened to Goldberg's podcast after the game could sense the frustration, Adrian was practically in tears.
I genuinely question the judgment of those who made the appointment. I just hope they have the courage to admit the mistake and let him go.

Just out of interest, who are "these lot" and who have they "got rid of"? 

This squad is completely different to the one that argument was levelled at.


RE: Mowbray - Public Opinion Poll - man in the corner shop - 04-10-2025

"I genuinely question the judgment of those who made the appointment."

100% this.

No good blaming Mowbray for being Mowbray and doing what Mowbray does. He is a poor manager. Questions need to be asked of those who appointed him.


RE: Mowbray - Public Opinion Poll - Pontificator - 04-10-2025

(04-10-2025, 05:31 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(04-10-2025, 05:24 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Being unsentimental:

Why would you appoint someone who’s just come through a serious illness, one that few recover from, especially considering the emotional toll it must have taken on him and his family? 
Managing the club surely comes second. Given that, how could Mowbray possibly have had the energy or been at the level of championship knowledge required? 
And even if you set that aside, after an intense coach like CC, whose style is all about focus and control, why go for someone as laid back as Mowbray? It’s too much of a contrast.
In any case you don't go back. 
Isn't it obvious that the players haven't bought into it? As has been pointed out these lot specialise in getting rid of managers.
This situation is so Albion. Those of us who listened to Goldberg's podcast after the game could sense the frustration, Adrian was practically in tears.
I genuinely question the judgment of those who made the appointment. I just hope they have the courage to admit the mistake and let him go.

Just out of interest, who are "these lot" and who have they "got rid of"? 

This squad is completely different to the one that argument was levelled at.

Over the last ten years we average about one manager a year


RE: Mowbray - Public Opinion Poll - Remi_Moses - 04-10-2025

I don't think anyone is anti Tony Mowbray.
IMHO it's we all want success for the club, but we don't believe he can deliver it.
Most were prepared to give him a chance and we did. Unfortunately for him and us it hasn't worked.
We know need to move on. I know people will shout he needs more time. The next question is what suggests he will make us better / stronger in the future. Well the facts are in the results world we are now worse off then before he came.
My conclusion he needs to move on and a n other manager needs to take up the challenge.


RE: Mowbray - Public Opinion Poll - fuzzbox - 04-10-2025

I would have voted for give him more time if I believed there was anything in the performances that displayed any potential for improvement if given more time. I just don't see anything. 

I worry that we will just blame it all on a lack of Maja


RE: Mowbray - Public Opinion Poll - Lurker#3 - 04-10-2025

(04-10-2025, 06:23 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Over the last ten years we average about one manager a year

That's a different thing all together. Who are "these lot" and who did they "get rid of"? In my time following Albion the only managers I can think of that the players almost "downed tools" for are Mel and Val. 

In fact I think it shines a light on how poorly run the club has been for much of the last 10 years, which is highlighted in the consistent down turn on fortunes until CC was hired.


RE: Mowbray - Public Opinion Poll - ElbowGrease1973 II - 04-10-2025

(04-09-2025, 08:27 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Not now, no point, we made that mistake with Moore and ended up with Shan for the play offs.
If we win 4 from 5 then he will have clicked and should stay. If not he should go at the end of the season.

Yes, agree Bob. If the next 5 games are similar to the last 3, it's an easy decision to make.

If I were the owner, I'd be massively concerned that just when we need to hit top form, we hit our worse form all season. That's sadly on the Manager.


RE: Mowbray - Public Opinion Poll - Bob Fossil - 04-10-2025

(04-10-2025, 05:24 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Being unsentimental:

Why would you appoint someone who’s just come through a serious illness, one that few recover from, especially considering the emotional toll it must have taken on him and his family? 
Managing the club surely comes second. Given that, how could Mowbray possibly have had the energy or been at the level of championship knowledge required? 
And even if you set that aside, after an intense coach like CC, whose style is all about focus and control, why go for someone as laid back as Mowbray? It’s too much of a contrast.
In any case you don't go back. 
Isn't it obvious that the players haven't bought into it? As has been pointed out these lot specialise in getting rid of managers.
This situation is so Albion. Those of us who listened to Goldberg's podcast after the game could sense the frustration, Adrian was practically in tears.
I genuinely question the judgment of those who made the appointment. I just hope they have the courage to admit the mistake and let him go.

That's a really fair point mate, means we, technically, appointed Mark Venus as "head" coach with TM as a public figurehead / technical advisor. TM is clearly not the head coach he was before that horrible fucking disease got hold of him.
If Venus had applied on his own, however, he wouldn't have got past the East Stand burger van so it does appear to have been an ill thought out, sentimental decision, triggered by the Wicky debacle.


RE: Mowbray - Public Opinion Poll - richbaggie - 04-10-2025

TM wasn't a knee jerk reaction after Wicky let us down. TM was sounded out very early doors and was very much on our radar. At the time, he was still awaiting all clear as I under it and couldn't commit.


RE: Mowbray - Public Opinion Poll - Bob Fossil - 04-10-2025

(04-10-2025, 08:08 AM)richbaggie Wrote: TM wasn't a knee jerk reaction after Wicky let us down. TM was sounded out very early doors and was very much on our radar. At the time, he was still awaiting all clear as I under it and couldn't commit.

Then those making the decision have to take responsibility. And, will probably be more inclined to persist past this season.