![]() |
|
Well done Mark Carney - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Well done Mark Carney (/showthread.php?tid=36901) |
RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-19-2025 (03-19-2025, 09:50 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: How can you possibly interpret a graph that ends at 2019 as being the result COVID and the invasion of Ukraine? The chart you linked has data to Q4 2024. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-19-2025 (03-19-2025, 10:34 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(03-19-2025, 09:50 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: How can you possibly interpret a graph that ends at 2019 as being the result COVID and the invasion of Ukraine? Click that link on post number 29 on this thread, scroll down to chart 4.8. I've downloaded it and attached it onto this post if that's too difficult for you. It goes to 2019. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-19-2025 Oh, OK. More estimates. Are we still trusting BoE / OBR estimates / projections then? Loaded with whatever other assumptions they've made? I suppose it makes for a good theoretical argument but it doesn't really get us anywhere. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-19-2025 I'm not on about the estimate, I'm on about the blue line which indicates the actual business investment between 2012 and 2019. The one where it goes flat in 2016 just after the Brexit vote indicating an impact on business confidence to invest, otherwise it would show growth. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-19-2025 I know what you're on about. The chart you linked to shows a return to trend. So if your argument is the hiatus between 2016-2019 led to a flatlining of investment then you are correct. However following Brexit Day (and Covid & Ukraine) investment has returned to trend. What this suggests is businesses sat on their hands whilst politicians failed in their duty between 2016-19. That's hardly surprising. What it also suggests is that Carney's interest rate reduction and bond buying made no difference to investment outcomes, but further embedded asset price inflation (which is hardly up for debate is it?) RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-19-2025 No, what it indicates is that it would have started to decline if not for an intervention designed to sure up business investment. You're ignoring the cause and effect, things don't happen in isolation. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-19-2025 (03-19-2025, 04:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, what it indicates is that it would have started to decline if not for an intervention designed to sure up business investment. You're ignoring the cause and effect, things don't happen in isolation. What it indicates was that it flatlined - which is understandable. The rest is conjecture on your part. Investment returned to trend with much higher interest rates. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-19-2025 (03-19-2025, 07:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(03-19-2025, 04:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, what it indicates is that it would have started to decline if not for an intervention designed to sure up business investment. You're ignoring the cause and effect, things don't happen in isolation. No, it indicates that if not for the intervention it would have dropped as a result of the business uncertainty, that was the point of the intervention. This isn't up for debate. The rest of your post is just copium, it hasn't returned to anywhere near a rate high enough to compensate for the flatlined period but that's besides the point because you're trying to steer this away on a tangent as you usually do, which is about why the BoE intervened in August 2016 - business investment flatlined. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-20-2025 (03-19-2025, 08:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, it indicates that if not for the intervention it would have dropped as a result of the business uncertainty, that was the point of the intervention. This isn't up for debate. I'm sorry, that is perfectly up for debate. The intervention, like the one at the beginning of Covid was wholly unnecessary. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-20-2025 (03-20-2025, 11:54 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(03-19-2025, 08:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, it indicates that if not for the intervention it would have dropped as a result of the business uncertainty, that was the point of the intervention. This isn't up for debate. Are you incapable of understanding the concept of cause and effect or something? Do you think the people who went around fixing the Y2K bugs were wasting their time because nothing bad happened? Do you not understand why it was more important to examine the areas of aircraft returning from bombing raids in WWII that weren't full of bullet holes? This really isn't up for debate, they intervened to stop investment collapsing to prevent a feedback loop from happening and the result of the intervention was that investment stayed flat which is the result they were trying to achieve as further intervention would have spiked inflation higher. Much the same as if they'd not intervened at the start of COVID then the health care would have been overwhelmed with resources unable to be applied effectively due to needing to manage a higher volume of cases, especially seeing as we had people who were too stupid and completely incapable to apply basic common sense to not want to put on a mask unless they were told to and mixing around at Cheltenham with 70k other people when they knew there was a global pandemic caused by an unknown virus. |