WBAUnofficial
Bartley. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Bartley. (/showthread.php?tid=322)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: Bartley. - Cheshire East Baggie - 02-07-2019

A surprising number of apologists for Bartley on here. He is a little slow on the turn and is prone to errors. Amazing to try and pass the blame for their first goal onto Dawson - "He should have covered it" - Jonny Evans would have stood with his hands on his hips, shaking his head in disbelief before shouting foul abuse at Bartley for his error. And no-one would have suggested he could have stopped it.

I just get the impression that Bartley isn't an easy player to be alongside. Like Darren Purse without the nice nature. But don't worry, Big Dave is in no doubt who his best centre-back pair are. Also worth a mention that Tosin was routinely out of position, first half and second. Got away with a couple of offsides that might have been close. His pace and poise on the ball cover his positioning errors most of the time. Could he be the next Rio Ferdinand?

It worried me a little that the back three idea even got an airing last night. Other changes were available if JRod was to be rested. Jones obviously hopes to win this one in the end. But Dawson was never the best choice for man in the middle, Hegs is far and away our best in that position. And changing them at 90 minutes was worthy of an England Cricket team practice match. A plan which back-fired badly.


RE: Bartley. - tiptontown - 02-07-2019

(02-07-2019, 05:48 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: A surprising number of apologists for Bartley on here. He is a little slow on the turn and is prone to errors. Amazing to try and pass the blame for their first goal onto Dawson - "He should have covered it" - Jonny Evans would have stood with his hands on his hips, shaking his head in disbelief before shouting foul abuse at Bartley for his error. And no-one would have suggested he could have stopped it.

I just get the impression that Bartley isn't an easy player to be alongside. Like Darren Purse without the nice nature. But don't worry, Big Dave is in no doubt who his best centre-back pair are. Also worth a mention that Tosin was routinely out of position, first half and second. Got away with a couple of offsides that might have been close. His pace and poise on the ball cover his positioning errors most of the time. Could he be the next Rio Ferdinand?

It worried me a little that the back three idea even got an airing last night. Other changes were available if JRod was to be rested. Jones obviously hopes to win this one in the end. But Dawson was never the best choice for man in the middle, Hegs is far and away our best in that position. And changing them at 90 minutes was worthy of an England Cricket team practice match. A plan which back-fired badly.

Chesh, I actually like Dawson and in general he has been a good player for us, but come on, I'm still not sure what he was trying do there. Bartley did appear to mis-control it, but it did look at first like a simple clean up job by Dawson, but for some reason he just left it. 
Not sure if he wasn't aware that the Brighton player was so close or what and when he relised, it was too late?

Having said that I still think Hegazi and Dawson are the best pairing without doubt.


RE: Bartley. - Sliced - 02-07-2019

(02-07-2019, 05:48 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: A surprising number of apologists for Bartley on here. He is a little slow on the turn and is prone to errors. Amazing to try and pass the blame for their first goal onto Dawson - "He should have covered it" - Jonny Evans would have stood with his hands on his hips, shaking his head in disbelief before shouting foul abuse at Bartley for his error. And no-one would have suggested he could have stopped it.

I just get the impression that Bartley isn't an easy player to be alongside. Like Darren Purse without the nice nature. But don't worry, Big Dave is in no doubt who his best centre-back pair are. Also worth a mention that Tosin was routinely out of position, first half and second. Got away with a couple of offsides that might have been close. His pace and poise on the ball cover his positioning errors most of the time. Could he be the next Rio Ferdinand?

It worried me a little that the back three idea even got an airing last night. Other changes were available if JRod was to be rested. Jones obviously hopes to win this one in the end. But Dawson was never the best choice for man in the middle, Hegs is far and away our best in that position. And changing them at 90 minutes was worthy of an England Cricket team practice match. A plan which back-fired badly.

Are these the same as the former McAuley apologists, or Evans apologists that you used to refer to? I can only assume at this point that Craig Dawson is your son because you defend him to the death. If only Dawson had shown your level of commitment to defending yesterday we may have won! There's no doubt Dawson is a better defender than Bartley. Absolutely no one here is suggesting otherwise but both Dawson and Bartley were to blame for the goal. Dawson was asleep


RE: Bartley. - Birdman1811 - 02-07-2019

Sorry but Dawson was equally culpable for that goal.

Saying otherwise is completely moronic.


RE: Bartley. - TETLEY74 - 02-07-2019

Still think Bartley is a poor defender but as said Dawson should have moped that up easily seems to be making an increase number of mistakes of late, is he turning into Billy Big bollocks?


RE: Bartley. - Duffers - 02-07-2019

(02-07-2019, 07:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Sorry but Dawson was equally culpable for that goal.

Saying otherwise is completely moronic.

Come on, this is Chesh. Dawson can do no wrong in his eyes.


RE: Bartley. - Cunninghamismagic - 02-07-2019

(02-07-2019, 08:09 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Still think Bartley is a poor defender but as said Dawson should have moped that up easily seems to be making an increase number of mistakes of late, is he turning into Billy Big bollocks?

Dawson looks much better beside Hegazi. Likewise Hegazi beside Dawson.


RE: Bartley. - Remi_Moses - 02-07-2019

Fact :- none of the center half's played well last night. If that's the best they can do - it's time to dump them. Glenn Murray made them look like what they are. And Bartley - buying a CH who couldn't get in the Swansea team that were relegated was a gamble and it hasn't paid off.


RE: Bartley. - Bruntsmagicwand - 02-08-2019

So the only CB to come out with any credit is Tosin


RE: Bartley. - KratosBaggie - 02-08-2019

I should be surprised that some folk actually rate Bartley, but ultimately I'm not.