WBAUnofficial
Ref complaint - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ref complaint (/showthread.php?tid=31416)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Ref complaint - SuperBob2002 - 10-08-2023

Went to Yeltz v Bromsgrove yesterday, to a man Blues, Dingles and Seals were laughing at what a shitshow the decision was.

I'm not sure what KRO is doing here, I think he's better than a WUM, but I'm genuinely at a loss as to why he believes it's a pen. Anyway, Blues fully deserved the win, I've no complaints in that regard. I just believe the "pen" was a farce, like 99% of the people who watched the game.


RE: Ref complaint - KRO - 10-08-2023

I’ve not actually said anywhere I thought it was a pen. I’ve shown something that helps understand why he gave it.
And I’m not sure we deserved the win. Apart from scoring more which some use to decide who deserves to win. You played as well as we did at Preston and lost and we didn’t deserve to lose there. You were good and controlled in possession even though we sat back a little more second half and were seemingly happy for you to have the ball and deal with crosses into the box. Which we did pretty well bar the Furlong chance. Weirdly you and Plymouth have been the best sides we’ve played at home and we’ve won both.


RE: Ref complaint - Huggybear - 10-08-2023

If you slow everything down it looks worse than what it is and that is just one of the numerous problems with VAR.Any hands on a player now can look like a push and with no common sense being used for the handball then it’s a toss of a coin if it’s going to be given as a penalty.
As for the incident the other night ,I actually thought the ref had pointed for a goal kick and the reaction from the Blues fans told you everything,they first moaned because he hadn’t given a corner and then it took them another 30 seconds to realise he had pointed to the penalty spot.Here is where VAR should be used,just for a penalty check.The VAR for offside needs to be scrapped unless you can get an instant decision.I guess what I’m saying is that we have to move away from fans celebrating a goal and then waiting minutes to see if it’s going to count.The game should be about supporters at the game and what’s happened in the Premier League has took the experience and spontaneous reaction away from scoring a goal.


RE: Ref complaint - DemonicBaggie - 10-08-2023

(10-08-2023, 07:16 AM)KRO Wrote: I’ve not actually said anywhere I thought it was a pen. I’ve shown something that helps understand why he gave it.
And I’m not sure we deserved the win. Apart from scoring more which some use to decide who deserves to win. You played as well as we did at Preston and lost and we didn’t deserve to lose there. You were good and controlled in possession even though we sat back a little more second half and were seemingly happy for you to have the ball and deal with crosses into the box. Which we did pretty well bar the Furlong chance. Weirdly you and Plymouth have been the best sides we’ve played at home and we’ve won both.

Very fair post, KRO, and reflects how I saw the game. Gardner's free kick was superb, otherwise I felt we were hard done to not to take a point from a game where we dictated much if the tempo. Certainly not a game where we were abysmal against you like last season, we did some terrific passing during build up play but umlike Blues failed to caputalise on chances when they fell our way. The ridiculous penalty obviously cost us and Swift's injury sums up our current luck on that front- it probably pisses me off more than the defeat.


RE: Ref complaint - Leicesterbaggie - 10-08-2023

TBH I didn’t even think their third goal was merited as I didn’t think it was a free kick. Again the referee was behind the play and from his angle of viewing there was no infringement. Clever play by Hogan but in my view not a free kick and ref bought it. Good free kick when taken though. We played well, good controlled football but you can’t win most games without a truly recognised striker (Preston was an exception) What is also frustrating is that that is the first time Blues have come from behind to win a game in about 30+ games. Yet again you can rely on West Brom to help teams end long unwanted runs.