![]() |
|
Culture wars - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Culture wars (/showthread.php?tid=30697) |
RE: Culture wars - Protheroe - 08-03-2023 Don't be obtuse, you know exactly that the receipts refer to producing wells. I don't agree with BB's assertion that this will be "instead of" rather than "as well as" investment in renewables. Nor does the past 20 years experience of Labour & Tory governments. Nor will the several governments to come despite the clear blue water the Tories are cynically looking to create for 2024. Nor have I never suggested that UK oil will be sold on anything but a global market, but crippling the future of an industry that provides products we'll need for decades and provides quality employment to over a quarter of a million people is the kind of short-termist industrial vandalism you consistently moan about in other industries. Again you seem incapable of separating the practicality of the issues from the Party announcing it. I wonder what your response will be when the Labour Party inevitably changes its stance on this (it will) when the reality of government dawns on them? The fact is we will need gas for decades to come - not just for home heating but for a huge variety of industrial processes. If CCS can be made to work at scale there's also potential for blue hydrogen. (08-03-2023, 09:44 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And what's your solution to that? Culling old people? With comments like that I simply don't believe you have the first idea of the crisis hurtling towards health and social care. RE: Culture wars - baggy1 - 08-03-2023 I'm not being obtuse, I simply don't see the benefit of issuing new licences at this point in time. It makes no sense at all, you appear to want to be obtuse by referring to existing revenues rather than the benefits of the new licences (in fact the very definition of being obtuse by widening the discussion). The government flowering it up by announcing it is protecting UK fuel prices which is clearly bullshit, and tying it into the ULEZ discussion is madness. If there was a coherent message coming out from government that wasn't so stop start it would make sense but this bunch of morons are flapping with the wind to make up long term strategy (that will be disbanded as soon as no-one is looking). RE: Culture wars - Protheroe - 08-03-2023 (08-03-2023, 11:12 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm not being obtuse, I simply don't see the benefit of issuing new licences at this point in time. It makes no sense at all, you appear to want to be obtuse by referring to existing revenues rather than the benefits of the new licences (in fact the very definition of being obtuse by widening the discussion). OK, we disagree. I do see the benefit in issuing new licences. Labour will too, in time. The rest is, as you say bullshit. RE: Culture wars - Borin' Baggie - 08-03-2023 (08-03-2023, 11:00 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Don't be obtuse, you know exactly that the receipts refer to producing wells. First of, I do recognise the scale of the demographic crisis and it's effect on resources. Hence why I don't want to exacerbate them with additional chronic issues that multiplicity the effect of health and social care acting as drag. Because, quite frankly, I'm fed up of the steaming economic shit that's been left on my door by your generation and the boomers that we have to now clean up. And I find your refusal to accept any inconveniences, no matter how small, to yourself in order to reduce the scale of the issue - such as driving less when it's perfectly practical to walk - infuriating. Secondly, how much has us relying on gas for electricity generation cost us Vs going for nuclear in the 1980s? Both to the Exchequer and, currently, people's pockets from the energy crisis? It takes, on average, nearly 3 decades for new licenses to yield output - that money would be better spent elsewhere. I'm not going to argue rescinding current licences but fact is that this addiction to gas screwed us in the 1980s and I refuse to repeat those mistakes now because the Tories are pandering to deluded fuckwits that think everything is fine and the gas lobby. And in terms of economics, the cheaper long term option. Just look at the LCOEs of gas turbines right now. And, I'm sorry, but we've not gone with all the "easy wins", as just on energy markets alone everything is still tied to the gas price, and there's a moratorium on wind and solar for some stupid reason. As for the "last 20 years of government", compare the scale of change when the energy department was controlled by the Lib Dems Vs the subsequent 8 years. The Tories have been fucking useless on energy policy and if not for those 5 years where Lib Dem policy bailed them out we'd be fucked. And the 7 years previous were shocking as well, aside from Brown's government scrambling to identify new nuclear RE: Culture wars - baggy1 - 08-03-2023 The fact is that there is no benefit to this apart from the Tories need to get some votes from somewhere to avoid annihilation. They've done all the red meat possible on immigration and now are going for the global warming sceptic vote. What next, removing duty on cheap cider to win the alcoholic lobby group vote? RE: Culture wars - Borin' Baggie - 08-03-2023 (08-03-2023, 12:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The fact is that there is no benefit to this apart from the Tories need to get some votes from somewhere to avoid annihilation. They've done all the red meat possible on immigration and now are going for the global warming sceptic vote. What next, removing duty on cheap cider to win the alcoholic lobby group vote? Well they've just absolutely fucked over small, "proper" cider makers in favour of the likes of Thatcher's. And their refusal to reform business rates is certainly helping big businesses over most SMEs RE: Culture wars - Protheroe - 08-03-2023 (08-03-2023, 11:31 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: First of, I do recognise the scale of the demographic crisis and it's effect on resources. Hence why I don't want to exacerbate them with additional chronic issues that multiplicity the effect of health and social care acting as drag. Because, quite frankly, I'm fed up of the steaming economic shit that's been left on my door by your generation and the boomers that we have to now clean up. And I find your refusal to accept any inconveniences, no matter how small, to yourself in order to reduce the scale of the issue - such as driving less when it's perfectly practical to walk - infuriating. So much anger. Having been brought up myself with a father who was ordered on strike more than he was at work, no family car for years on end, no colour telly until Argentina 78, which promptly went back to Granada TV Rentals until Espana 82, sink comp education and no foreign holiday until I paid for one myself at the age of 23 you can stick your sanctimony about my generation right up you arse pal. Don't talk to me about "small inconveniencies" I walked everywhere or got the bus because I had no choice. Adopting the guise of Captain Hindsight you're compounding the failures of the past (with which I broadly agree) and projecting new ones into the future with your pathetic ideological purity. The conceit that we won't need oil and gas for decades to come is breathtaking - precisely because we'll need both to help us transition the future. And lets not forget that until relatively recently the Lib Dems had been anti nuclear power in policy terms for decades and that twat Clegg kicked development into the long grass because there was no electoral advantage to it. A more mealy-mouthed paragraph you'd be hard pressed to find in the Coalition Agreement: "Liberal Democrats have long opposed any new nuclear construction. Conservatives, by contrast, are committed to allowing the replacement of existing nuclear power stations provided that they are subject to the normal planning process for major projects (under a new National Planning Statement), and also provided that they receive no public subsidy. We have agreed a process that will allow Liberal Democrats to maintain their opposition to nuclear power while permitting the government to bring forward the national planning statement for ratification by Parliament so that nuclear construction becomes possible." RE: Culture wars - Borin' Baggie - 08-03-2023 (08-03-2023, 12:35 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(08-03-2023, 11:31 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: First of, I do recognise the scale of the demographic crisis and it's effect on resources. Hence why I don't want to exacerbate them with additional chronic issues that multiplicity the effect of health and social care acting as drag. Because, quite frankly, I'm fed up of the steaming economic shit that's been left on my door by your generation and the boomers that we have to now clean up. And I find your refusal to accept any inconveniences, no matter how small, to yourself in order to reduce the scale of the issue - such as driving less when it's perfectly practical to walk - infuriating. Think I'll refute your "woe is me, my generation had it tougher" crap with this, both on incomes and housing. And now we're being lumbered with dealing with the fallout of climate change and the demographic crises because your generation and that before it went scorched earth and refused to take any responsibility for the issues you were causing. I'm sorry if that upsets you, but that's the fact. Your kids will be dealing with more and more of the fallout if less is done now, that is the point. You crying about minor inconveniences (and they are minor) because you don't want to deal with the looming and costly shitshow is, frankly pathetic, as is your blasé attitude to accepting that it will cost more to deal with it long term the less we do now. I don't give a fuck about when you had a colour TV, how old were you when you got a mortgage for a house? What's your projected retirement age? Because I'm pretty confident that you weren't heading towards 40 for the former nor were you looking at your early 70s for the latter despite being in the fortunate position of being better off than your peers and able to put money in to cover that. But no, it's perfectly fair for me to pay more taxes than necessary later in my life because people won't do the bare minimum today. But it's ok that I can't afford a house on more than the median household income, I'm getting paid less in real terms than previous generations doing the same job and there's a good chance I won't have any time to retire because at least I can watch Disney Plus and eat avocados, right? That certainly makes up for it. And it isn't hindsight, warning not to repeat the mistakes of the past is not hindsight. I'm not saying what we should have done in the past, I'm saying what we should do now and over the next decade. What's pissing me off is people like you refusing to want to do what's needed now, and you'll scream that it's hindsight in a decades time when we say what we should have done up to 2030 much as you're doing now because the people who said we needed to electrify and move away from gas in the 1980s were ignored. How could I possibly be "Captain Hindsight" when I'm on about the next 27 years, are you living in 2050 or something? As for nuclear, I don't give a shit what Clegg said. Ed Davey and Chris Huhne have empirically better records on nuclear than any energy secretary before them since the 1960s and since then. If not for the Tories Sizewell B would have been sorted in 2016, the Tories you voted and campaigned for blocked signing off on Hinkley Point C for THREE YEARS and then proceeded to waste another four re-evaluating how new nuclear is funded instead of just copying the funding framework for Sizewell B, and for what? Blair and Thatcher were both "pro-nuclear" in rhetoric yet failed to bring forward nuclear plans because words are meaningless. When the biggest "anti-nuclear" party have the best record on it in government your have a problem. RE: Culture wars - Protheroe - 08-03-2023 I don't think you could ever accuse me of ignoring intergenerational unfairness unless you've completely ignored all my posts on housing for a couple of decades, and it's precisely one of the points I'm making. YOU are going to be loaded with the costs of net zero before you've made a life for yourself. That's the reality of the situation. I'm not surprised you're so angry. I also think you're inviting scorn on a grand scale by blaming previous generations. I hope you actually meant previous generations of politicians. I'm curious as to what you think I'm refusing to do now? And then we can discuss why it would be either rational or effective in climate or cash terms to alter my behaviour. RE: Culture wars - Borin' Baggie - 08-03-2023 (08-03-2023, 03:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I don't think you could ever accuse me of ignoring intergenerational unfairness unless you've completely ignored all my posts on housing for a couple of decades, and it's precisely one of the points I'm making. I'm blaming previous generations as a collective, because it's as a collective that the blame lies. Politicians are part of that but anthropogenic climate change has been known for over a century, lobbyists and bad faith actors and people acting like because they won't be around to face the consequences have all amplified the problems. Thatcher called it out in the mid-1980s as an existential threat. This was largely ignored until 1992, and barely acted on until the mid-2000s (when modelling for a 5K increase was produced). To this day we, as in the UK, are still pissing around with electrification of transport (specifically, rail, not cars) and heating on top of banning wind farms and solar farms because of pandering to the gas lobby and NIMBY voting Tories (or NIMBY voting Greens in my council area and in Suffolk). We're reading and hearing all this stupid shit from the government, I've had junior ministers with zero background in engineering or science tell me them like I've not read up about them before and considered their practicalities or, in some cases, modelled them - see carbon capture, hydrogen and SMR reactors - while staring at me like I've explained quantum thermodynamics when I explain why doing basic shit like the benefits of electrification, why wind turbines have a low OpEx, capacity constraints of hydrogen production of electrolysis and how it's better off being used for green steel or ammonia production, why the private sector can't be bothered to invested in CCS and why AGR reactors are more efficient than experimental SMR reactors. The delays we have by sticking our fingers in our ears and burying our heads into the sand to pretend we're doing alright has only amplified the costs associated and, the fact is, that will continue to happen burdening future generations with more issues the more we kick the can down the road. This government and that techbro pillock in Number 10 deciding to pander to people by treating climate change like a culture war issue and focusing on polling trends in line with Tory voter demographics is pathetic, pushing back new building regs is pathetic. And you know what? A lot of those mitigation measures align with reaching net zero (expanded grid capacity, electrification and heat pumps can provide capacity and the technology to also deliver air conditioning, which might be important if the frequency of August last year starts to ramp up, and it being powered by renewables is a lot better and a lot more secure than gas). How much better off would we have been if Exxon Mobil didn't suppress data they were obtaining independently and instead started the process of reducing carbon back in the early 1970s? How much cheaper would it have been? That multiplication factor still applies today, the more we do now the less it costs in the future. Do you know how much shit I have read from the likes of the CPS and IEA (the "liberal" thinktank, not the International Energy Agency) that is then parroted by the government despite being broken? Too much. As for dealing with the costs, I'm fully aware my generation will pay for reaching net zero but the point is that we're paying for both reaching it and the fallout of the previous generations, and the more we do now the less your kids will end up needing to pay and their kids will end up needing to pay. The carbon in the atmosphere hasn't all been put up there over the last 20 years, it's a multigenerational. I look at the data for it as part of my job, I read journal, trade magazine and newspaper articles on it as part of my job. It is depressing, and it is urgent. We're now at the point where I'm reading about feedback cycles coming in (e.g. the effects of permafrost melting releasing methane) and hoping that the recent issues in the Atlantic Ocean and Antarctic are a blip rather than the start of a trend moving into a feedback system (how much money is it going to take to fix those problems should they arise?). That is going to accelerate the reduction in the standards of living. As in, less access to what we have considered as basic commodities since the turn of the 20th century like coffee beans, or cocoa beans, or vanilla. I'm also realistic in knowing oil and gas (mainly oil) won't go to zero but the fact is UK O+G production doesn't do anything to address the overall market price volatility and those new licences will take nearly 3 decades (as is the average timeline) to output new production and they take money out that could be invested elsewhere and will provide better returns on energy security and decarbonisation. As for you, you are being blasé about it. Talking about the "costs" of it, yes it will cost money but it will cost less the more we do now because it won't be as last minute and we shouldn't go with mild inconveniences like driving less (not ban driving) which barely impact the quality of life but make a huge impact on UK emission totals (24% is from transport, most of that is passenger journeys and you don't need to drive everywhere as too many people do). There's stuff we could have done 40-50 years ago but the best time to plant a tree etc etc and saying that I'm being "Captain Hindsight" makes zero sense because I'm not complaining about the past just to complain, I'm pointing out that we should not make the same mistakes of the past. One single Lib Dem policy during the coalition, the energy market liberalisation reform, has had a huge effect on decarbonising grid input. We need more of that and less of delaying new building regs, playing stupid games over hydrogen boilers, moratorium on renewables and wasting years to sign off new AGR reactors. We should be lifting the moratorium on new onshore wind and photovoltaic farms, we should be planning out community heat schemes for London, Birmingham, Manchester and Glasgow, we should be overruling planning legislation on pylons and high voltage cables, we should be reforming CAP to move towards subsidies only going to unused land etc etc as soon as possible instead of just kicking the can down the road, we should be pushing the markets to more aggressively invest in tidal and geothermal schemes in Wales and the South West over O+G. But no, we're about to build a brand new railway between Oxford and Cambridge that isn't electrified, because that's a brilliant bit of foresight isn't it? And I'm not being a doomer, I'm being a realist. There are positives, the IEA (International Energy Agency) keep doing an IFS on their solar installed capacity projections and revising upwards due to pessimistic projections, we've revised down the projected warming from 5K at the start of the century to 2.5K now, per capita carbon liabilities in the West are trending downwards, countries like India and China are rapidly installing renewables (can do better but they're not all in the shit, they are both experiencing higher incidence rates of storms) but there is still so much easy shit we can do and treating climate change as either an economic drag or pandering to the loonies who don't believe in it or don't want us to believe in it doesn't help. |