RE: Brexit has failed… - Derek Hardballs - 05-19-2023
(05-19-2023, 11:20 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-19-2023, 09:54 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (05-19-2023, 09:24 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-19-2023, 08:59 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Incremental change over 40yrs and agreed/amended via successive U.K. governments is not the same as just leaving without any coherent and set out plan. What a ludicrous comparison.
Incremental change, never directly submitted to public vote in the UK. Where change was directly submitted to public vote in other countries it was variously rejected, until the government gave the people the opportunity to give correct answer in a second referendum - or just ignore them completely.
You simply can't grasp the concept that someone with a deep desire for democracy and the primacy of the best form of advancement possible - the nation state - might think differently from you, can you?
I know you and probably several other internationalists on here loathe the very concept of the nation state, and Britain in particular.
Dear deary me. The fact remains that if a democratically elected government under the scrutinity of a democratically elected parliament makes a decision, it does not have to be submitted for approval by a plebiscite. It is a sovereign decision made by said government the basis of rule making in the UK. And of course electors have a vote every time there is a GE. Past governments have integrated EU law into UK law and the idea that it is not kosher is daft. It was a deeply unconservative thing to do to campaign to leave the EU after 50 years, but then you were never a Conservative were you? The other side of the coin to the mad narrow minded Corbyn socialists, who after all had the same crank view as you.
I don't know why posters on here are prepared to give you the time of day you are absolutely fucking crackers
Fundamental alterations to nations' relationships with the EU have often been put to the test via a referendum. Perhaps if our previous governments had done so then there may have been a democratic mandate for Maastricht or Lisbon, and there may have been the space for a proper public debate about the democratic powers we had or would have to cede to the EU.
Democracy means accepting the the result placed before you, even if you don't like it. Not even being asked about either of those Treaties is fundamentally undemocratic.
In your opinion it's absolutely crackers to believe that people ought to have a say about how their nation is governed. I'm afraid I don't agree.
(05-19-2023, 10:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-19-2023, 09:24 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-19-2023, 08:59 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Incremental change over 40yrs and agreed/amended via successive U.K. governments is not the same as just leaving without any coherent and set out plan. What a ludicrous comparison.
Incremental change, never directly submitted to public vote in the UK. Where change was directly submitted to public vote in other countries it was variously rejected, until the government gave the people the opportunity to give correct answer in a second referendum - or just ignore them completely.
You simply can't grasp the concept that someone with a deep desire for democracy and the primacy of the best form of advancement possible - the nation state - might think differently from you, can you?
I know you and probably several other internationalists on here loathe the very concept of the nation state, and Britain in particular.
This just reads like a response you’d get from Farage.
Good to know you hadn’t got a clue what you were campaigning and voting for.
You've merely confirmed everything I've just posted. Well done. You've never spent a moment considering a world view other than your own in your whole life have you?
Answer the question what was YOUR BREXiT PLAN cut the faux Farage replies and childish culture war nonsense that would not have been out of place at the NAT C conference last week.
RE: Brexit has failed… - Protheroe - 05-19-2023
Christ on a bike. You never actually read anything do you?
I get that pluralism is a foreign country to you Derek, but you don't have to confirm your ignorance in every post you make. You appear to have the most bitter and narrowest world view of anyone I've ever conversed with, including plenty of Kippers.
RE: Brexit has failed… - Derek Hardballs - 05-19-2023
(05-19-2023, 01:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Christ on a bike. You never actually read anything do you?
I get that pluralism is a foreign country to you Derek, but you don't have to confirm your ignorance in every post you make. You appear to have the most bitter and narrowest world view of anyone I've ever conversed with, including plenty of Kippers.
What was your plan beyond leaving? That’s the question numerous posters have asked you. Stop trying to change the question/tell me what the question was like a two-bit Jenrick.
RE: Brexit has failed… - Protheroe - 05-19-2023
I've made plenty of posts on that in past. Use the search function.
RE: Brexit has failed… - Derek Hardballs - 05-19-2023
(05-19-2023, 03:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I've made plenty of posts on that in past. Use the search function.
Bullet points will do
RE: Brexit has failed… - Cheshire East Baggie - 05-20-2023
So what it comes down to is "people wanted it, so that's OK". The democracy cop-out for anyone (and that's everyone) who can't give a rational explanation of the benefits of Brexit.
It's all very well wanting to be somewhere different. What you have to do is get there. That's the minor point which no-one on the Leave side even considered.
As it happens, Geoff Norcott was on The News Quiz last night on R4. He said "if Suella Braverman is really a leadership candidate, then they've gone a long way down the talent pool. I think they're going to have to take some time out to reflect". Shortly after the Brexit referendum, the Guardian suggested that Brexit would destroy the Conservative Party. Right wing comedians and journalists turning on them is a clear sign that it's happening. Of course it's done a lot of damage to Britain along the way, but there you go.
RE: Brexit has failed… - Pontificator - 05-20-2023
(05-19-2023, 12:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-19-2023, 11:20 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-19-2023, 09:54 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (05-19-2023, 09:24 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-19-2023, 08:59 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Incremental change over 40yrs and agreed/amended via successive U.K. governments is not the same as just leaving without any coherent and set out plan. What a ludicrous comparison.
Incremental change, never directly submitted to public vote in the UK. Where change was directly submitted to public vote in other countries it was variously rejected, until the government gave the people the opportunity to give correct answer in a second referendum - or just ignore them completely.
You simply can't grasp the concept that someone with a deep desire for democracy and the primacy of the best form of advancement possible - the nation state - might think differently from you, can you?
I know you and probably several other internationalists on here loathe the very concept of the nation state, and Britain in particular.
Dear deary me. The fact remains that if a democratically elected government under the scrutinity of a democratically elected parliament makes a decision, it does not have to be submitted for approval by a plebiscite. It is a sovereign decision made by said government the basis of rule making in the UK. And of course electors have a vote every time there is a GE. Past governments have integrated EU law into UK law and the idea that it is not kosher is daft. It was a deeply unconservative thing to do to campaign to leave the EU after 50 years, but then you were never a Conservative were you? The other side of the coin to the mad narrow minded Corbyn socialists, who after all had the same crank view as you.
I don't know why posters on here are prepared to give you the time of day you are absolutely fucking crackers
Fundamental alterations to nations' relationships with the EU have often been put to the test via a referendum. Perhaps if our previous governments had done so then there may have been a democratic mandate for Maastricht or Lisbon, and there may have been the space for a proper public debate about the democratic powers we had or would have to cede to the EU.
Democracy means accepting the the result placed before you, even if you don't like it. Not even being asked about either of those Treaties is fundamentally undemocratic.
In your opinion it's absolutely crackers to believe that people ought to have a say about how their nation is governed. I'm afraid I don't agree.
(05-19-2023, 10:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-19-2023, 09:24 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-19-2023, 08:59 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Incremental change over 40yrs and agreed/amended via successive U.K. governments is not the same as just leaving without any coherent and set out plan. What a ludicrous comparison.
Incremental change, never directly submitted to public vote in the UK. Where change was directly submitted to public vote in other countries it was variously rejected, until the government gave the people the opportunity to give correct answer in a second referendum - or just ignore them completely.
You simply can't grasp the concept that someone with a deep desire for democracy and the primacy of the best form of advancement possible - the nation state - might think differently from you, can you?
I know you and probably several other internationalists on here loathe the very concept of the nation state, and Britain in particular.
This just reads like a response you’d get from Farage.
Good to know you hadn’t got a clue what you were campaigning and voting for.
You've merely confirmed everything I've just posted. Well done. You've never spent a moment considering a world view other than your own in your whole life have you?
Answer the question what was YOUR BREXiT PLAN cut the faux Farage replies and childish culture war nonsense that would not have been out of place at the NAT C conference last week.
"Democracy means accepting the the result placed before you, even if you don't like it. Not even being asked about either of those Treaties is fundamentally undemocratic"
Just because you and your crank assosciates say so? The Maastricht Treaty was signed by John Major the democractically elected leader of the Tory party and a democtratically elected MP and Prime Minister. He had every right to sign the treaty on the UKs behalf after a democraticall elected parliamiant scrutinesd and ratified it. He was re-elected democratically as leader of the Conservative Party when he resigned because of the bastard cranks. I mean just how much democracy do you want? Then when you get your crank fucking democracy, you fuck it up and refuse to accept the reponsibility
RE: Brexit has failed… - CaptainFantastico - 05-20-2023
It was all about ego, that’s the truth of it. That’s why no apology can be arrived at. It doesn’t fit with the origins.
RE: Brexit has failed… - hudds - 05-22-2023
The UK wine producers (ie grape growers who vinify) are livid about this doublespeak:
https://www.thedrinksbusiness.com/2023/05/scrapping-eu-law-could-create-180m-boost-for-uk-wine-industry/
It helps the Aussies, though. As UK winemaker has just posted on the GBWine email posts:
"Making a premium quality product that competes in a global market such as English Quality Sparkling Wine requires significant financial investment and time. Any attempts to reduce that competitiveness in the global market such as diminishing the product when comparing it against a market leader, in this case Champagne, by allowing other grape varietals to be included in its production should be resisted. A key element of the consumer appeal of English Quality Sparkling Wine is that it is made from the same grape varietals as Champagne but is made by English winemakers and therefore commands a similar price to Champagne in the market place.
I do not therefore accept that increasing the number of grape varietals for PDO/PDI English Quality Sparkling Wine can be seen in anyway as a positive step forward. In this case the EU rules actually make sense and have kept ‘Champagne’ where it is in the market."
RE: Brexit has failed… - Borin' Baggie - 05-22-2023
Given climate change is likely to make the South East and South West of England much more like the central French winegrowing regions in terms of climate this seems very shortsighted.
|