WBAUnofficial
Erling Haaland - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Erling Haaland (/showthread.php?tid=29861)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Erling Haaland - AnelkasBeard - 05-04-2023

I think Spandau is so blinded by his hatred of modern football (which is completely justified, and I do agree with), that he can't acknowledge that Haaland is still a cut above anything City have had before, and is probably the best striker in the world currently. He also probably would be if he played for any of the top 4/5 clubs in each league in Europe.


RE: Erling Haaland - Spandaubaggie - 05-04-2023

(05-04-2023, 09:20 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:18 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:14 AM)Duffers Wrote: 29 goals in 27 games for RB Salzburg
86 goals in 89 games for Dortmund
51 goals in 45 games for City
21 goals in 23 games for Norway

He was incredible well before he signed for City.

No no Duffers. Football was better back in't day, and Haaland is only good because he plays in a billion pound team.

Technically it only cost £895 million to assemble their current squad....

We've had inflation though due to factors including increased fuel prices. I wonder who is making the money from the fuel! Oh!!
Win win.


RE: Erling Haaland - Sliced - 05-04-2023

He’s 22 and his off the ball movement is the best in the world. Off the ball movement is generally something that improves with age and experience. Obviously his finishing is ridiculous too. Scarily, he’s probably only going to get better


RE: Erling Haaland - Spandaubaggie - 05-04-2023

(05-04-2023, 09:22 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I think Spandau is so blinded by his hatred of modern football (which is completely justified, and I do agree with), that he can't acknowledge that Haaland is still a cut above anything City have had before, and it probably the best striker in the world currently. He also probably would be if he played for any of the top 4/5 clubs in each league in Europe.

Right from the get go I've said Haaland is phenomenal, but I like to critically think about this.

There are only a handful of teams in Europe capable of giving City a game now. Equally this lack of competitiveness is in most European leagues.
It creates the conditions for people like Haaland to get even better.

I think as Albion fans we owe it to our club to highlight the farce of it all otherwise we are rolling over and having our bellies tickled by the bullshit around the Prem.

(05-04-2023, 09:21 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:17 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:14 AM)Duffers Wrote: 29 goals in 27 games for RB Salzburg
86 goals in 89 games for Dortmund
51 goals in 45 games for City
21 goals in 23 games for Norway

He was incredible well before he signed for City.

And no one has said otherwise. He just wouldn't look so good if football was less uneven.

Norway hardly have a billion pound system built around him and he scores for fun for them.

Dortmund are probably as close to your own "put him at Arsenal and see what he does" argument as you can get and he scored pretty much a goal a game for them.

He's a generational talent and was acknowledged as such well before he signed for City.
How did Norway get on at the World Cup?


RE: Erling Haaland - Duffers - 05-04-2023

(05-04-2023, 09:28 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:22 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I think Spandau is so blinded by his hatred of modern football (which is completely justified, and I do agree with), that he can't acknowledge that Haaland is still a cut above anything City have had before, and it probably the best striker in the world currently. He also probably would be if he played for any of the top 4/5 clubs in each league in Europe.

Right from the get go I've said Haaland is phenomenal, but I like to critically think about this.

There are only a handful of teams in Europe capable of giving City a game now. Equally this lack of competitiveness is in most European leagues.
It creates the conditions for people like Haaland to get even better.

I think as Albion fans we owe it to our club to highlight the farce of it all otherwise we are rolling over and having our bellies tickled by the bullshit around the Prem.

(05-04-2023, 09:21 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:17 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:14 AM)Duffers Wrote: 29 goals in 27 games for RB Salzburg
86 goals in 89 games for Dortmund
51 goals in 45 games for City
21 goals in 23 games for Norway

He was incredible well before he signed for City.

And no one has said otherwise. He just wouldn't look so good if football was less uneven.

Norway hardly have a billion pound system built around him and he scores for fun for them.

Dortmund are probably as close to your own "put him at Arsenal and see what he does" argument as you can get and he scored pretty much a goal a game for them.

He's a generational talent and was acknowledged as such well before he signed for City.
How did Norway get on at the World Cup?

They weren't there because they aren't very good. Yet despite not being very good Haaland still scores a lot of goals for them.

I don't think this strengthens your point.


RE: Erling Haaland - SW4Baggie - 05-04-2023

(05-04-2023, 09:12 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:06 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:53 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:42 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:38 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Ok, 20 years ago he was 2. I don't even think he would have got one goal.

Point is it's all about questioning the achievement of this record, whilst acknowledging the talent. We as Albion fans have seen the Prem boat sail off and we couldn't even hope to be competitive against Man City's reserves. So fawning over Haaland whilst not doing a shade more critical thinking about the environment that has had created this seems to be a shade simplistic.

As I've said further up though City have had elite players before and the environment you mention has existed for a while. Yet nobody in that environment has achieved what Haaland has this season.

It's not "fawning" to acknowledge that he's simply a different class to what has come before him.

And I have. Look at the very start of the thread- I think he is going to be one of the greatest of all time. He is phenomenal, but he is also in a team that has world stars galore around him. 
His record though surely isn't as impressive as Dixie Dean's on for want of a better term was in a time when those muddy pitches saw teams on a level playing field.
It's not just the quality of his co-stars either, it's the quality of the opposition.
Frank Bruno would have been the greatest champion of all time if he'd only fought lightweiights. That's the equivalent for me, it's such an uneven playing field that it's a bit embarrassing to laud any record attained by these clubs.

Thank the lord for you on this Bob.

It's like lauding Westlife as one of the greatest modern bands of all time.

By my calculations they must be nearly twice as good as Oasis as they had 14 number ones and Oasis only 8.

Surely you can't argue with the facts!

You know selecting circumstantial opinions from people who agree with you isn’t facts?

Haaland has scored 35 goals in 31 games in a City team with 87 goals 
Dean scored 60 in 42 in an Everton side that scored 102

Based on the above, one could argue that Everton’s style, or perhaps the tactics of football over 100 years ago better suited Dean given he was responsible for almost 60% of their goals, vs Haaland being about 40%

A quick look at the 1927/28 season’s top goal scorers shows TWENTY players in that division managed 20  or more goals. Dean scored almost double the next highest scorer with 35, suggesting that individual players scored more goals back then, but looking at 3-4 seasons either side of Dean’s record breaking season, generally the top scorers hit between 35-40 suggesting his season really was an emphatic performance.

Whilst Dean did consistently score goals for Everton for nearly 10 years, he didn’t get anywhere near 60 again, and his number reverted to the 30-40 amounts the top strikers in the league tended to hit. Suggesting 1927/28 was a purple patch.

Looking at other PL strikers this season, there’s a similar gap of about 30% between Haaland’s numbers and the next ranked striker to what Dean managed suggesting Haaland and he were about level for this season vs the 1927/28 one.

Moving forward, I expect Haaland will get better as the years go by, and will end the comparisons, but both were clearly very good strikers and it’s not really worth trying to say who is better as it’s ultimately impossible.

And let’s drop the “could he do it in a team like Burnley” nonsense, he could.


RE: Erling Haaland - Duffers - 05-04-2023

"Could he do it at Burnley" is a stupid argument anyway. It's the same reason Mbappe doesn't play for Bournemouth or you don't see Bellingham strutting around Sunderland. They're elite players, they play at elite clubs.

Yes they have opportunities, financial backing, team mates and care lesser players can only dream of but with that comes greater scrutiny, pressure and expectation to perform to perform at an elite level every single week.

Haaland had a quiet debut for City in the Charity Shield and people were genuinely questioning whether he'd succeed at City, that's the sort of scrutiny elite players face.


RE: Erling Haaland - AnelkasBeard - 05-04-2023

(05-04-2023, 09:28 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:22 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I think Spandau is so blinded by his hatred of modern football (which is completely justified, and I do agree with), that he can't acknowledge that Haaland is still a cut above anything City have had before, and it probably the best striker in the world currently. He also probably would be if he played for any of the top 4/5 clubs in each league in Europe.

Right from the get go I've said Haaland is phenomenal, but I like to critically think about this.

There are only a handful of teams in Europe capable of giving City a game now. Equally this lack of competitiveness is in most European leagues.
It creates the conditions for people like Haaland to get even better.

I think as Albion fans we owe it to our club to highlight the farce of it all otherwise we are rolling over and having our bellies tickled by the bullshit around the Prem.

(05-04-2023, 09:21 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:17 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:14 AM)Duffers Wrote: 29 goals in 27 games for RB Salzburg
86 goals in 89 games for Dortmund
51 goals in 45 games for City
21 goals in 23 games for Norway

He was incredible well before he signed for City.

And no one has said otherwise. He just wouldn't look so good if football was less uneven.

Norway hardly have a billion pound system built around him and he scores for fun for them.

Dortmund are probably as close to your own "put him at Arsenal and see what he does" argument as you can get and he scored pretty much a goal a game for them.

He's a generational talent and was acknowledged as such well before he signed for City.
How did Norway get on at the World Cup?

You're contradicting yourself in the same post. In response to me, saying Haaland is so good because no-one can give City a game, yet in response to Duffers, you're saying Norway aren't good because they didn't make the World Cup. So he scores goals for a top team, and an average team then?


RE: Erling Haaland - MrFizz - 05-04-2023

The guy is a Cyborg from another galaxy. If you cut him in half he'd bleed lubricant and you'd get an electric shock.


RE: Erling Haaland - Spandaubaggie - 05-04-2023

(05-04-2023, 09:34 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:12 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:06 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:53 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:42 AM)Duffers Wrote: As I've said further up though City have had elite players before and the environment you mention has existed for a while. Yet nobody in that environment has achieved what Haaland has this season.

It's not "fawning" to acknowledge that he's simply a different class to what has come before him.

And I have. Look at the very start of the thread- I think he is going to be one of the greatest of all time. He is phenomenal, but he is also in a team that has world stars galore around him. 
His record though surely isn't as impressive as Dixie Dean's on for want of a better term was in a time when those muddy pitches saw teams on a level playing field.
It's not just the quality of his co-stars either, it's the quality of the opposition.
Frank Bruno would have been the greatest champion of all time if he'd only fought lightweiights. That's the equivalent for me, it's such an uneven playing field that it's a bit embarrassing to laud any record attained by these clubs.

Thank the lord for you on this Bob.

It's like lauding Westlife as one of the greatest modern bands of all time.

By my calculations they must be nearly twice as good as Oasis as they had 14 number ones and Oasis only 8.

Surely you can't argue with the facts!

You know selecting circumstantial opinions from people who agree with you isn’t facts?

Haaland has scored 35 goals in 31 games in a City team with 87 goals 
Dean scored 60 in 42 in an Everton side that scored 102

Based on the above, one could argue that Everton’s style, or perhaps the tactics of football over 100 years ago better suited Dean given he was responsible for almost 60% of their goals, vs Haaland being about 40%

A quick look at the 1927/28 season’s top goal scorers shows TWENTY players in that division managed 20  or more goals. Dean scored almost double the next highest scorer with 35, suggesting that individual players scored more goals back then, but looking at 3-4 seasons either side of Dean’s record breaking season, generally the top scorers hit between 35-40 suggesting his season really was an emphatic performance.

Whilst Dean did consistently score goals for Everton for nearly 10 years, he didn’t get anywhere near 60 again, and his number reverted to the 30-40 amounts the top strikers in the league tended to hit. Suggesting 1927/28 was a purple patch.

Looking at other PL strikers this season, there’s a similar gap of about 30% between Haaland’s numbers and the next ranked striker to what Dean managed suggesting Haaland and he were about level for this season vs the 1927/28 one.

Moving forward, I expect Haaland will get better as the years go by, and will end the comparisons, but both were clearly very good strikers and it’s not really worth trying to say who is better as it’s ultimately impossible.

And let’s drop the “could he do it in a team like Burnley” nonsense, he could.

Take a minute to read through this thread. You will see no one saying he couldn't do it in a team like Burnley or anything remotely like that.

It's a conundrum comparisons as you can't compare different eras, yet you have to compare as without comparison it is unintelligent to take what is as read and instead understand why someone is now so good.

Simply Haaland has been acknowledged by all on this thread as an incredible talent. However, it has morphed slightly into a dig at modern day football where the modern day game allows the stronger teams to have more of the money, which leads to better players, which leads to domination of the ball, which leads to more of the chances, which leads to more goals, which has all lead to a chasm.

It is a chasm that means Haaland looks even better than he is and adds to the cult of celebrity surrounding the game now.

For those of us old enough to recall per prem days of course the game wasn't as advanced due to poorer pitches, players not knowing about how to maximise their strengths through training and diet. However, it was great when Albion, Ipswich, Forest, Watford could actually have a fair contest v other teams. I think we all still enjoyed the competitiveness rather than the procession where we know who will win.

Football now is brilliant due to better pitches and fitness, but only when the teams are matched. Haaland will no doubt score many more next season against clubs with a fraction of the resources of city. 

I'm happy enough to admit the sour taste of the bullshit of the Prem hype(modern leagues at the top levels being monopolised by a few), does detract from his achievement for me.

I hope we see him at the Hawthorns at some point so generations can say they were there. He will be talked about in 40 years the way we over 50s talk about Maradona and it's possibly the first time the best footballer on the planet has been in England.

He'd walk the Ballon Dor if Messi hadn't won the World Cup.