![]() |
|
Comparative Healthcare - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Comparative Healthcare (/showthread.php?tid=27445) |
RE: Comparative Healthcare - Borin' Baggie - 11-03-2022 (11-03-2022, 02:43 PM)Protheroe Wrote: There is an inherent conflict between the best outcome for the individual and "ensuring value for the taxpayer". As a patient I care for only one end of that transaction. Unfortunately the way the NHS is structured (especially the way it is funded) is far too skewed toward the needs of the producer and the rationing of healthcare. The same way Norway, Denmark, Sweden and Finland deal with it? The same way we dealt with it in circa 2005? I literally wrote up a list of areas for improvement and I started this thread going on about preventative healthcare (not helped by having an overweight smoker who thinks antibiotics are a magic bullet in the DfH, the very antithesis of preventative care). The thing you are not acknowledging, and I have no idea why you're not acknowledging it because I thought I made it pretty obvious, is that even with countries like Germany which use statutory healthcare contributions most of the healthcare funding still comes in from the general taxation pool and not the Gesetzliche Krankenkasse (and both those are revenues for the German Treasury). The funding model is objectively not the issue with the NHS. RE: Comparative Healthcare - Protheroe - 11-03-2022 (11-03-2022, 03:11 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The funding model is objectively not the issue with the NHS. It is an interesting belief that individual behaviour in respect of preventable healthcare issues and the inability of the same individual to discern the cost of those issues to them personally are unrelated. You simply believe opportunity cost would not affect individual and societal behaviour. I do. Just as it does in any other transaction for personal services. You could even provide incentives to alter behaviour. RE: Comparative Healthcare - Borin' Baggie - 11-03-2022 For God's sakes, it is an objective fact that changing the funding model will not affect any of the prevalent issues with the NHS affecting healthcare outcomes. You can talk about hypothetical "behavioural changes" but the fact is that the funding model does not directly or indirectly affect that whatsoever. Changing to a Bismark model system doesn't hire more healthcare personnel, it doesn't open up more A&E wards and it doesn't change the fact that healthcare decisions will still be made by the same body that it is currently and that the political pressure will still be made by the same House of Commons and House of Lords. What is also an objective fact is that you can fix those issues with a Beveridge model system in place, as shown by what the NHS was 17 years ago and what healthcare looks like in the Nordic countries. Quite frankly, I'm a bit disturbed that someone who champions value for the taxpayer would support risking billions of taxpayer pounds on something that doesn't offer any direct or indirect changes to healthcare outcomes, on purely the hope that it changes the behaviour of the electorate to challenge the same politicians that aren't fixing the issues currently that are known about at the moment and, in a lot of cases, don't want to fix the issues. RE: Comparative Healthcare - Derek Hardballs - 11-06-2022 It almost looks deliberate… RE: Comparative Healthcare - Protheroe - 11-07-2022 You can blame your Lockdowns for that, and the wholesale refusal of GP practices to offer anything resembling a service since. Bravo. RE: Comparative Healthcare - Ournextstriker - 11-07-2022 (11-07-2022, 09:05 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You can blame your Lockdowns for that, and the wholesale refusal of GP practices to offer anything resembling a service since. Bravo. No lockdowns in those other countries then? RE: Comparative Healthcare - baggy1 - 11-07-2022 I don’t recall the great lockdown of 2017 and 18, memory must be playing up. RE: Comparative Healthcare - Derek Hardballs - 11-07-2022 (11-07-2022, 09:05 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You can blame your Lockdowns for that, and the wholesale refusal of GP practices to offer anything resembling a service since. Bravo. Proth, what absolute drivel. RE: Comparative Healthcare - Shabby Russian - 11-07-2022 Good lively debate on this thread. I don't agree with Proth about his fixation with the way in which the NHS is funded. But there are some difficult discussions about how some people use the NHS. My observations is that people use the service for too many trivial reasons, with GP surgeries and AandE in particular struggling because there are having to deal with people who don't need to be there. The point BB makes about the NHS trying to implement more preventative health strategies is spot on. Mental Health is one area I am aware that is being targeted in this way. Also feel that in education more provision should be made for general health and first aid education. So many of us our ignorant about what we need to do in a health situation. In my family our first port of call if a medical situation arises is my mother in law, who was a nurse. A chat with her can often negate the need to seek professional medical assistance. RE: Comparative Healthcare - Protheroe - 11-07-2022 (11-07-2022, 09:42 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I don’t recall the great lockdown of 2017 and 18, memory must be playing up. You can do an online course about statistical trends you know. What was the trend prior to Lockdown? |