RE: Karlan grant - Tom Joad - 10-29-2022
Shabby Russian Wrote:I'm going to play a combination of an old contrarian and devil's advocate.
Yes as a centre forward he is clearly not good enough, particularly for a side that play with 2 wide men who put crosses into the box.
He needs balls to be played for him to run onto..something we seem incapable of doing. Even today Diangana had the opportunity to play a simple ball to put him in, but couldn't do it. The final ball leaves a lot to be desired.
And even if Grant was good in the air, I'm not sure what difference it would make, we are really poor at getting bodies into the box. It is easy for defenders to mark Grant aerially, even easier as he has very little support.
We really need Dike to get fit and be good.
If not we will need to change we play..sitting deep and counter attack. All true, but as we are we can't afford a ghost in the shirt.
RE: Karlan grant - CA Baggie - 10-29-2022
He’s a fraud and currently stealing living.
It’s true he’s not a centre forward, but he could at least try. He uses his energy making half hearted attempts to chase balls or jumps for headers, but never wins the ball, never gets there. Doesn’t put himself anywhere getting tackled, in case it hurt him.
My impression of him is that he’s a cunt. He appears to be everything that is wrong with modern players who earn more than their ability deserves and he’s making the most of it. I can imagine him in sunglasses behind the VIP rope of some seedy nightclub, pointing at which wannabe wag can be allowed through as he has a bottle of champagne on ice.
The centre forward position is at the very heart of all our problems this season. The ball just never sticks up there. I think it’s the second goal that starts from him losing the ball, sure there’s a lot of piss-poor defending thereafter but if he did the basics then we can all move up the pitch as a team.
He’s a one trick pony, said this last season. This year we don’t have the forward for him to play off to perform his one trick.
He’s a fraud and we not shot ASAP and will just have to take the hit on the chin and replace him with a bunch of PL youth loans whilst we get over the financial disaster his signature has been.
RE: Karlan grant - Faggits_n_Payse - 10-29-2022
(10-29-2022, 05:09 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: He’s a fraud and currently stealing living.
It’s true he’s not a centre forward, but he could at least try. He uses his energy making half hearted attempts to chase balls or jumps for headers, but never wins the ball, never gets there. Doesn’t put himself anywhere getting tackled, in case it hurt him.
My impression of him is that he’s a cunt. He appears to be everything that is wrong with modern players who earn more than their ability deserves and he’s making the most of it. I can imagine him in sunglasses behind the VIP rope of some seedy nightclub, pointing at which wannabe wag can be allowed through as he has a bottle of champagne on ice.
The centre forward position is at the very heart of all our problems this season. The ball just never sticks up there. I think it’s the second goal that starts from him losing the ball, sure there’s a lot of piss-poor defending thereafter but if he did the basics then we can all move up the pitch as a team.
He’s a one trick pony, said this last season. This year we don’t have the forward for him to play off to perform his one trick.
He’s a fraud and we not shot ASAP and will just have to take the hit on the chin and replace him with a bunch of PL youth loans whilst we get over the financial disaster his signature has been.
Thank you for making me laugh the comment about the nightclub !
RE: Karlan grant - Brandywell - 10-29-2022
Whatever he is, he's the only one in the squad who can score goals regularly. So you better hope he starts playing in his favoured position soon or we are going down
BTA like Carroll tries hard but you can't rely on him to score often, how he missed both of those chances today
Wallace and Swift will chip in with a couple, Grady hasn't and won't
RE: Karlan grant - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-29-2022
(10-29-2022, 05:09 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: He’s a fraud and currently stealing living.
It’s true he’s not a centre forward, but he could at least try. He uses his energy making half hearted attempts to chase balls or jumps for headers, but never wins the ball, never gets there. Doesn’t put himself anywhere getting tackled, in case it hurt him.
My impression of him is that he’s a cunt. He appears to be everything that is wrong with modern players who earn more than their ability deserves and he’s making the most of it. I can imagine him in sunglasses behind the VIP rope of some seedy nightclub, pointing at which wannabe wag can be allowed through as he has a bottle of champagne on ice.
The centre forward position is at the very heart of all our problems this season. The ball just never sticks up there. I think it’s the second goal that starts from him losing the ball, sure there’s a lot of piss-poor defending thereafter but if he did the basics then we can all move up the pitch as a team.
He’s a one trick pony, said this last season. This year we don’t have the forward for him to play off to perform his one trick.
He’s a fraud and we not shot ASAP and will just have to take the hit on the chin and replace him with a bunch of PL youth loans whilst we get over the financial disaster his signature has been.
I'll be retired by then
RE: Karlan grant - HugeHons - 10-29-2022
(10-29-2022, 05:14 PM)Faggits_n_Payse Wrote: (10-29-2022, 05:09 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: He’s a fraud and currently stealing living.
It’s true he’s not a centre forward, but he could at least try. He uses his energy making half hearted attempts to chase balls or jumps for headers, but never wins the ball, never gets there. Doesn’t put himself anywhere getting tackled, in case it hurt him.
My impression of him is that he’s a cunt. He appears to be everything that is wrong with modern players who earn more than their ability deserves and he’s making the most of it. I can imagine him in sunglasses behind the VIP rope of some seedy nightclub, pointing at which wannabe wag can be allowed through as he has a bottle of champagne on ice.
The centre forward position is at the very heart of all our problems this season. The ball just never sticks up there. I think it’s the second goal that starts from him losing the ball, sure there’s a lot of piss-poor defending thereafter but if he did the basics then we can all move up the pitch as a team.
He’s a one trick pony, said this last season. This year we don’t have the forward for him to play off to perform his one trick.
He’s a fraud and we not shot ASAP and will just have to take the hit on the chin and replace him with a bunch of PL youth loans whilst we get over the financial disaster his signature has been.
Thank you for making me laugh the comment about the nightclub !
Same
RE: Karlan grant - CA Baggie - 10-29-2022
(10-29-2022, 05:48 PM)HugeHons Wrote: (10-29-2022, 05:14 PM)Faggits_n_Payse Wrote: (10-29-2022, 05:09 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: He’s a fraud and currently stealing living.
It’s true he’s not a centre forward, but he could at least try. He uses his energy making half hearted attempts to chase balls or jumps for headers, but never wins the ball, never gets there. Doesn’t put himself anywhere getting tackled, in case it hurt him.
My impression of him is that he’s a cunt. He appears to be everything that is wrong with modern players who earn more than their ability deserves and he’s making the most of it. I can imagine him in sunglasses behind the VIP rope of some seedy nightclub, pointing at which wannabe wag can be allowed through as he has a bottle of champagne on ice.
The centre forward position is at the very heart of all our problems this season. The ball just never sticks up there. I think it’s the second goal that starts from him losing the ball, sure there’s a lot of piss-poor defending thereafter but if he did the basics then we can all move up the pitch as a team.
He’s a one trick pony, said this last season. This year we don’t have the forward for him to play off to perform his one trick.
He’s a fraud and we not shot ASAP and will just have to take the hit on the chin and replace him with a bunch of PL youth loans whilst we get over the financial disaster his signature has been.
Thank you for making me laugh the comment about the nightclub !
Same 
You’re welcome. His ability is more ‘spoons than even Goldsmiths night club.
Quicker he’s gone the better.
RE: Karlan grant - mickeypearce - 10-29-2022
(10-29-2022, 05:52 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (10-29-2022, 05:48 PM)HugeHons Wrote: (10-29-2022, 05:14 PM)Faggits_n_Payse Wrote: (10-29-2022, 05:09 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: He’s a fraud and currently stealing living.
It’s true he’s not a centre forward, but he could at least try. He uses his energy making half hearted attempts to chase balls or jumps for headers, but never wins the ball, never gets there. Doesn’t put himself anywhere getting tackled, in case it hurt him.
My impression of him is that he’s a cunt. He appears to be everything that is wrong with modern players who earn more than their ability deserves and he’s making the most of it. I can imagine him in sunglasses behind the VIP rope of some seedy nightclub, pointing at which wannabe wag can be allowed through as he has a bottle of champagne on ice.
The centre forward position is at the very heart of all our problems this season. The ball just never sticks up there. I think it’s the second goal that starts from him losing the ball, sure there’s a lot of piss-poor defending thereafter but if he did the basics then we can all move up the pitch as a team.
He’s a one trick pony, said this last season. This year we don’t have the forward for him to play off to perform his one trick.
He’s a fraud and we not shot ASAP and will just have to take the hit on the chin and replace him with a bunch of PL youth loans whilst we get over the financial disaster his signature has been.
Thank you for making me laugh the comment about the nightclub !
Same 
You’re welcome. His ability is more ‘spoons than even Goldsmiths night club.
Quicker he’s gone the better.
This made me laugh out loud before i even got to the nightclub bit.
RE: Karlan grant - Hopalong - 10-29-2022
(10-29-2022, 05:09 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: He’s a fraud and currently stealing living.
It’s true he’s not a centre forward, but he could at least try. He uses his energy making half hearted attempts to chase balls or jumps for headers, but never wins the ball, never gets there. Doesn’t put himself anywhere getting tackled, in case it hurt him.
My impression of him is that he’s a cunt. He appears to be everything that is wrong with modern players who earn more than their ability deserves and he’s making the most of it. I can imagine him in sunglasses behind the VIP rope of some seedy nightclub, pointing at which wannabe wag can be allowed through as he has a bottle of champagne on ice.
The centre forward position is at the very heart of all our problems this season. The ball just never sticks up there. I think it’s the second goal that starts from him losing the ball, sure there’s a lot of piss-poor defending thereafter but if he did the basics then we can all move up the pitch as a team.
He’s a one trick pony, said this last season. This year we don’t have the forward for him to play off to perform his one trick.
He’s a fraud and we not shot ASAP and will just have to take the hit on the chin and replace him with a bunch of PL youth loans whilst we get over the financial disaster his signature has been.
He gets paid what we agreed in his contract on the basis of the 48 goals he'd scored as a then 22 yr old. Young english strikers who score goals cost a lot of money. Brewster was £23m if I recall and has scored 4 goals, lol (and crocked today again). McBurnie £17.5m - 14 in 101 apps.
He's not an out an out no 9 but he can play the role, most effectively when we're counter-attacking and he can run past defenders but as has been mentioned he rarely gets through balls to run onto (but think Cov away particularly) and he's not going to out-muscle two big centre-backs with his back to goal. It's a shame Dike got injured as he would probably have got quite a few goals this season playing alongside him.
He's at his most effective playing on the left of a three (your one trick pony description) so it's something of a puzzle why Bilic persisted in insisting we sign him when he didn't fit what we needed at the time which was a big robust no 9 target man like Diagne. It took Sam 5 minutes to work that one out. Bilic also signed Diangana and Robinson so we ended up with three left sided attackers/wingers (I won't bother mentioning Grosicki ) and no number 9!
I think it's unfair to call him a fraud but if that's your opinion. I can think of others at the club who that description may more aptly apply to, without mentioning names.
His goals earned us 27 of our 67 points last season (not including assists). He's unlikely to do that this season due to a lack of a target man but he may yet hit it off with Dike if he ever gets fit.
RE: Karlan grant - Faggits_n_Payse - 10-29-2022
(10-29-2022, 05:52 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (10-29-2022, 05:48 PM)HugeHons Wrote: (10-29-2022, 05:14 PM)Faggits_n_Payse Wrote: (10-29-2022, 05:09 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: He’s a fraud and currently stealing living.
It’s true he’s not a centre forward, but he could at least try. He uses his energy making half hearted attempts to chase balls or jumps for headers, but never wins the ball, never gets there. Doesn’t put himself anywhere getting tackled, in case it hurt him.
My impression of him is that he’s a cunt. He appears to be everything that is wrong with modern players who earn more than their ability deserves and he’s making the most of it. I can imagine him in sunglasses behind the VIP rope of some seedy nightclub, pointing at which wannabe wag can be allowed through as he has a bottle of champagne on ice.
The centre forward position is at the very heart of all our problems this season. The ball just never sticks up there. I think it’s the second goal that starts from him losing the ball, sure there’s a lot of piss-poor defending thereafter but if he did the basics then we can all move up the pitch as a team.
He’s a one trick pony, said this last season. This year we don’t have the forward for him to play off to perform his one trick.
He’s a fraud and we not shot ASAP and will just have to take the hit on the chin and replace him with a bunch of PL youth loans whilst we get over the financial disaster his signature has been.
Thank you for making me laugh the comment about the nightclub !
Same 
You’re welcome. His ability is more ‘spoons than even Goldsmiths night club.
Quicker he’s gone the better.
He wouldnt have got into goldsmiths or queens for that matter , 42nd street maybe but at a push.
|