WBAUnofficial
Ratings……. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings……. (/showthread.php?tid=27396)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Ratings……. - Calgary_Baggie - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 12:05 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Palmer - 4 - Marginally better than Button but could’ve done better

Townsend - 0 - Shite. Their first goal was his third cock up of the match and it was only 11 minutes in.

Pieters - 3 - looks like an elderly full back trying to have a go at centre half, because that’s what he is.

O'Shea - 2 - Awful. Think he’s going to be a league 1 player, sadly with us

Furlong - 0 - Main contribution was aimlessly lobbing throw ins at Sheffield United players. Actually turned his back on their bloke for the second in a show of cowardice that should’ve seen him hooked immediately

Livermore - 0 - Just keep paying him but fuck him off immediately. Shit.

TGH - 5 - at least gives a toss.

Phillips - 3 - Embarrassing for all concerned

Grady - 4 - no end product.

Wallace - 4 - Dragged down to the level of the dross around him

Grant - 0 - The bloke is a coward and a disgrace. An insult to the shirt.

Molumby - 5 - At least tried

Swift - 4 - See Molumby

Reach - 4 - Should probably replace Townsend on Tuesday, that’s how bad this squad is.

BTA - 4 - Run about a bit. Better than Grant by the fact he actually moved.

Carlos- At least we didn’t jam a result and he’s got to see the shit he’s inherited.

Players are pretty much spot on.

I thought Corberan's team selection  was awful today given that he's seen every game we've played.


RE: Ratings……. - Remi_Moses - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 01:11 AM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 12:05 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Palmer - 4 - Marginally better than Button but could’ve done better

Townsend - 0 - Shite. Their first goal was his third cock up of the match and it was only 11 minutes in.

Pieters - 3 - looks like an elderly full back trying to have a go at centre half, because that’s what he is.

O'Shea - 2 - Awful. Think he’s going to be a league 1 player, sadly with us

Furlong - 0 - Main contribution was aimlessly lobbing throw ins at Sheffield United players. Actually turned his back on their bloke for the second in a show of cowardice that should’ve seen him hooked immediately

Livermore - 0 - Just keep paying him but fuck him off immediately. Shit.

TGH - 5 - at least gives a toss.

Phillips - 3 - Embarrassing for all concerned

Grady - 4 - no end product.

Wallace - 4 - Dragged down to the level of the dross around him

Grant - 0 - The bloke is a coward and a disgrace. An insult to the shirt.

Molumby - 5 - At least tried

Swift - 4 - See Molumby

Reach - 4 - Should probably replace Townsend on Tuesday, that’s how bad this squad is.

BTA - 4 - Run about a bit. Better than Grant by the fact he actually moved.

Carlos- At least we didn’t jam a result and he’s got to see the shit he’s inherited.

Players are pretty much spot on.

I thought Corberan's team selection  was awful today given that he's seen every game we've played.

Looking back that was a comment that left him wide open.
Is he not to bright or to honest. Time will tell.


RE: Ratings……. - Huggybear - 10-30-2022

Unfortunately some fans have given there scores on a player before he’s kicked a ball.We all know Phillips was finished a couple of years back but yesterday he was one of our better performers.


RE: Ratings……. - TTM2 - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 06:52 AM)Huggybear Wrote: Unfortunately some fans have given there scores on a player before he’s kicked a ball.We all know Phillips was finished a couple of years back but yesterday he was one of our better performers.

Don’t agree. 

He now toddles off with the ball knowing he’s not quick enough to beat his marker so either runs into the man or just stands there not knowing what to do with it. He then moves inside to get his breath back.

Him and Jake simply can’t move and slow things down awfully.


RE: Ratings……. - Huggybear - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 07:48 AM)TTM2 Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 06:52 AM)Huggybear Wrote: Unfortunately some fans have given there scores on a player before he’s kicked a ball.We all know Phillips was finished a couple of years back but yesterday he was one of our better performers.

Don’t agree. 

He now toddles off with the ball knowing he’s not quick enough to beat his marker so either runs into the man or just stands there not knowing what to do with it. He then moves inside to get his breath back.

Him and Jake simply can’t move and slow things down awfully.

I agree with you ,but yesterday he was still one of our better players which doesn’t say a lot about the rest of the players.


RE: Ratings……. - B68Baggy - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 05:49 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 01:11 AM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 12:05 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Palmer - 4 - Marginally better than Button but could’ve done better

Townsend - 0 - Shite. Their first goal was his third cock up of the match and it was only 11 minutes in.

Pieters - 3 - looks like an elderly full back trying to have a go at centre half, because that’s what he is.

O'Shea - 2 - Awful. Think he’s going to be a league 1 player, sadly with us

Furlong - 0 - Main contribution was aimlessly lobbing throw ins at Sheffield United players. Actually turned his back on their bloke for the second in a show of cowardice that should’ve seen him hooked immediately

Livermore - 0 - Just keep paying him but fuck him off immediately. Shit.

TGH - 5 - at least gives a toss.

Phillips - 3 - Embarrassing for all concerned

Grady - 4 - no end product.

Wallace - 4 - Dragged down to the level of the dross around him

Grant - 0 - The bloke is a coward and a disgrace. An insult to the shirt.

Molumby - 5 - At least tried

Swift - 4 - See Molumby

Reach - 4 - Should probably replace Townsend on Tuesday, that’s how bad this squad is.

BTA - 4 - Run about a bit. Better than Grant by the fact he actually moved.

Carlos- At least we didn’t jam a result and he’s got to see the shit he’s inherited.

Players are pretty much spot on.

I thought Corberan's team selection  was awful today given that he's seen every game we've played.

Looking back that was a comment that left him wide open.
Is he not to bright or to honest. Time will tell.

Every manager comes in thinking they can get a tune out of these players, who up until about 5 games ago the majority of fans still thought was a top six squad.

I still think Allardyce was a terrible appointment but he got the reality pretty quickly and changed it as soon as the loan market allowed.  Grant, Grady, Jake etc all disappeared.  CC needs to be brave enough to do the same.


RE: Ratings……. - Tom Joad - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 05:49 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 01:11 AM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 12:05 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Palmer - 4 - Marginally better than Button but could’ve done better

Townsend - 0 - Shite. Their first goal was his third cock up of the match and it was only 11 minutes in.

Pieters - 3 - looks like an elderly full back trying to have a go at centre half, because that’s what he is.

O'Shea - 2 - Awful. Think he’s going to be a league 1 player, sadly with us

Furlong - 0 - Main contribution was aimlessly lobbing throw ins at Sheffield United players. Actually turned his back on their bloke for the second in a show of cowardice that should’ve seen him hooked immediately

Livermore - 0 - Just keep paying him but fuck him off immediately. Shit.

TGH - 5 - at least gives a toss.

Phillips - 3 - Embarrassing for all concerned

Grady - 4 - no end product.

Wallace - 4 - Dragged down to the level of the dross around him

Grant - 0 - The bloke is a coward and a disgrace. An insult to the shirt.

Molumby - 5 - At least tried

Swift - 4 - See Molumby

Reach - 4 - Should probably replace Townsend on Tuesday, that’s how bad this squad is.

BTA - 4 - Run about a bit. Better than Grant by the fact he actually moved.

Carlos- At least we didn’t jam a result and he’s got to see the shit he’s inherited.

Players are pretty much spot on.

I thought Corberan's team selection  was awful today given that he's seen every game we've played.

Looking back that was a comment that left him wide open.
Is he not to bright or to honest. Time will tell.
It's perfectly understandably CC went with those that have featured the most. He spent the whole game shuffling them and instructing them to see who will buy in. After the world cup I guess we will see a very different side, those that cant/won't follow the plan won't play. IMO.


RE: Ratings……. - wba13 - 10-30-2022

For all those moaning about his team selection yesterday, well what was he supposed to do, play the under 23’s. You will see a change in personnel and positions very quickly as he showed yesterday. We were better when Livermore and Townsend were hooked. Yesterday was a learning curve for Corberan I think you will see a different side on Tuesday and a totally different side after word cup. There will be changes again in transfer window. Instead of moaning I agree with Tom Joad so let’s wait and see some need a reality check moaning after 3 days in the job.


RE: Ratings……. - Ted Maul - 10-30-2022

Few very harsh comments on the manager. What is he supposed to do? He's had three days to talk about some of his ideas and he can't get them between Wednesday and Saturday. He did what every manager would/should do and pick the most experienced side he could.

Phillips again coming in for some very harsh stick. If we're not going to use BTA from the start then he's very much our best centre forward. Dike will make a huge difference.

Diangana tried but faded badly, again a lack of fitness.

Some particularly harsh marks for the subs, all of whom I thought positively impacted the game. Molumby in particularly allowing TGH more time on the ball to start picking some passes. A nod to Adam Reach as well who should now be starting at left back in place of Townsend.


RE: Ratings……. - Squid - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 09:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Few very harsh comments on the manager. What is he supposed to do? He's had three days to talk about some of his ideas and he can't get them between Wednesday and Saturday. He did what every manager would/should do and pick the most experienced side he could.

Phillips again coming in for some very harsh stick. If we're not going to use BTA from the start then he's very much our best centre forward. Dike will make a huge difference.

Diangana tried but faded badly, again a lack of fitness.

Some particularly harsh marks for the subs, all of whom I thought positively impacted the game. Molumby in particularly allowing TGH more time on the ball to start picking some passes. A nod to Adam Reach as well who should now be starting at left back in place of Townsend.

CC needs to know what he's working with, so I have no argument with the team select. The subs improved us, especially Molumby. I'll never understand why Reach comes in for so much stick either.