WBAUnofficial
The manager not backed - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The manager not backed (/showthread.php?tid=2682)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: The manager not backed - backsidebaggie - 03-10-2019

(03-10-2019, 03:13 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I am sure in financial terms Moore has had good backing.

But I would question the strategy of keeping the squad together.

For those who obviously fell asleep for the whole of the 2017-18 season, we finished bottom of the premiership and for significant spells of time the attitude of the players was atrocious. This time last season we lost consecutive matches against Southampton (twice), Huddersfield, Watford, Burnley, Bournemouth, not to mention the Barcelona debacle,

You really do have to question  why keeping that squad together was so imperative.

Norwich who had a mediocre season last year kept faith with their manager, they also sold their best player in James Maddison, some of the proceeds of which they re-invested in players.

I can't help thinking that it would have been better for us to sell some of our so called  premiership players and re-invest it .The only flaw in this plan was our recent record in player recruitment.

After the window closed in August last season, it struck me how few goal scorers we had in the squad and this season when the window closed it struck me how few players we had in the 21-27 age group.

Keeping the squad together was seen as imperative as in most similar cases, its given a club the best chance of going back up.

We can all pick holes in bits of the squad and say it could be better, but that's the same everywhere.

You could be right that we'd have been better selling some and re-investing, we'll never know. But BD wanted to keep them as far as we know.


RE: The manager not backed - Remi_Moses - 03-10-2019

(03-10-2019, 02:55 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: This debate rolls on, and I can't quite believe some of the things I'm reading. Moore has been backed by keeping most of a high salary squad after relegation. Since when has that equated to 'not backed'?

Newcastle have been relegated twice in the last ten years and both times kept most of their squad and come back (Nolan, Barton, Gutierez, and many other I can't be arsed to name). Keeping these players was seen as the manager being backed wth a squad to come back up by fans, media, and the manager at the time (Hughton, Benitez). Both times they got back up and were expected to.

West Ham were relegated a few years back and again kept a good proportion of high wage players, like us and Newcastle, and again were expected to come back up, and they did.

We were relegated under Mowbray and kept most of the high earners again (some for one year like Koumas/Kamara, and some for two like Gera/Olsson), but again with a higher wage bill than most of the division. We were expected to come back up, this was seen as the manager being backed, and RDM did it.

How in gods name keeping most of the squad together can suddenly be seen as "not backed" in Big Dave's case I have no idea! Do you really think he wasnt happy with having Gibbs, Dawson, Jrod, Livermore etc? Fucking hell how can this suddenly be classsed as not backing a manager? Keeping a squad together after relegation has always been seen, almost unanimously at Allbion and other clubs, as backing the manager with the tools to get back up.

To bring the dingles in as a comparison, who seem to have won the ownership lottery last season (plus dodgy Mendes) and lost 60M in bringing in a ridiculously talented squad for that division, is barmy. Nuno was backed through the fucking roof to get back up. Big dave maybe less so, but still a reasonable comparison to us in the past, and West Ham/Newcastle as similar in the last few years.

I really don't think Big Dave seemed to want us to sell JRod/Dawson/Gibbs etc, so keeping them IS backing him.

And thank god we did, as BD blew god knows what on Bartley (awful signing). God knows what he might have spent had he had 30M to spend after selling Jrod and Dawson, if we'd gone down that route.

The fact is we can always find parts of the squad where we can say Big Dave didn't have it perfect, but fucking hell when does a manager have it perfect anywhere (bar maybe Wolves last season). This is a similar situation to Albion, West Ham and Newcastle in the past, where pretty much unanimously fans saw that as backing the manager to get back up. That's why Big Sam was happy to be in the champ with West Ham, and Benitez was happy in the champ at Newcastle. Keeping a squad of high earners and "proven" prem players can not be seen as not backing the manager in this division. Its ridiculous.

Now I know we can say some of these players are over rated and aren't as good as many think, but BD didn't seem to want to sell them, praises them to the hilt, and they're still better than most in the champ.

Some mention Stoke kept their best players too and have been worse. That's exactly whey Rowett got the sack even quicker than BD! Rowett was backed as well by keeping their squad together.

I'm at a loss as to why anyone would suddenly think in this case that keeping a high earning squad with many players seen as prem players can not be backing a manager. In every similar case at Albion in the past, and at similar clubs like I mentioned above, it's been seen as backing the manager, so I don't know why so many think Big Dave had some kind of short straw and has been hung out to dry or whatever. Absolute nonsense.
Yes we did keep several good players who got us relegated, but we also sold a few and left big gaps in the team.
Remember last years team were not good enough, all I have been saying is the players who left were not replaced with better quality players and if we had signed a Barnes / Holgate / Dack we would be top of the league. Well that's my opinion. If people on here think that's nonsense so be it.
Most people expected a team rebuild not an immediate attempt at auto-promotion tbh. If Auto-promotion was the objective from the outset we should have replaced the players who left with better quality hungry younger players. I can't understand as to why anybody would think this is nonsense. Anyway again this is why I believe Darren was left well short to achieve the clubs objective.


RE: The manager not backed - WorcBaggie - 03-10-2019

(03-10-2019, 03:26 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 02:55 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: This debate rolls on, and I can't quite believe some of the things I'm reading. Moore has been backed by keeping most of a high salary squad after relegation. Since when has that equated to 'not backed'?

Newcastle have been relegated twice in the last ten years and both times kept most of their squad and come back (Nolan, Barton, Gutierez, and many other I can't be arsed to name). Keeping these players was seen as the manager being backed wth a squad to come back up by fans, media, and the manager at the time (Hughton, Benitez). Both times they got back up and were expected to.

West Ham were relegated a few years back and again kept a good proportion of high wage players, like us and Newcastle, and again were expected to come back up, and they did.

We were relegated under Mowbray and kept most of the high earners again (some for one year like Koumas/Kamara, and some for two like Gera/Olsson), but again with a higher wage bill than most of the division. We were expected to come back up, this was seen as the manager being backed, and RDM did it.

How in gods name keeping most of the squad together can suddenly be seen as "not backed" in Big Dave's case I have no idea! Do you really think he wasnt happy with having Gibbs, Dawson, Jrod, Livermore etc? Fucking hell how can this suddenly be classsed as not backing a manager? Keeping a squad together after relegation has always been seen, almost unanimously at Allbion and other clubs, as backing the manager with the tools to get back up.

To bring the dingles in as a comparison, who seem to have won the ownership lottery last season (plus dodgy Mendes) and lost 60M in bringing in a ridiculously talented squad for that division, is barmy. Nuno was backed through the fucking roof to get back up. Big dave maybe less so, but still a reasonable comparison to us in the past, and West Ham/Newcastle as similar in the last few years.

I really don't think Big Dave seemed to want us to sell JRod/Dawson/Gibbs etc, so keeping them IS backing him.

And thank god we did, as BD blew god knows what on Bartley (awful signing). God knows what he might have spent had he had 30M to spend after selling Jrod and Dawson, if we'd gone down that route.

The fact is we can always find parts of the squad where we can say Big Dave didn't have it perfect, but fucking hell when does a manager have it perfect anywhere (bar maybe Wolves last season). This is a similar situation to Albion, West Ham and Newcastle in the past, where pretty much unanimously fans saw that as backing the manager to get back up. That's why Big Sam was happy to be in the champ with West Ham, and Benitez was happy in the champ at Newcastle. Keeping a squad of high earners and "proven" prem players can not be seen as not backing the manager in this division. Its ridiculous.

Now I know we can say some of these players are over rated and aren't as good as many think, but BD didn't seem to want to sell them, praises them to the hilt, and they're still better than most in the champ.

Some mention Stoke kept their best players too and have been worse. That's exactly whey Rowett got the sack even quicker than BD! Rowett was backed as well by keeping their squad together.

I'm at a loss as to why anyone would suddenly think in this case that keeping a high earning squad with many players seen as prem players can not be backing a manager. In every similar case at Albion in the past, and at similar clubs like I mentioned above, it's been seen as backing the manager, so I don't know why so many think Big Dave had some kind of short straw and has been hung out to dry or whatever. Absolute nonsense.
Yes we did keep several good players who got us relegated, but we also sold a few and left big gaps in the team.
Remember last years team were not good enough, all I have been saying is the players who left were not replaced with better quality players and if we had signed a Barnes / Holgate / Dack we would be top of the league. Well that's my opinion. If people on here think that's nonsense so be it.
Most people expected a team rebuild not an immediate attempt at auto-promotion tbh. If Auto-promotion was the objective from the outset we should have replaced the players who left with better quality hungry younger players. I can't understand as to why anybody would think this is nonsense. Anyway again this is why I believe Darren was left well short to achieve the clubs objective.

Why do you keep saying things like this? Replace Evans, Foster, Rondon etc with better quality. How the fecking hell can a championship side do that.


RE: The manager not backed - Jack Halford - 03-10-2019

(03-10-2019, 03:13 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 02:55 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: This debate rolls on, and I can't quite believe some of the things I'm reading. Moore has been backed by keeping most of a high salary squad after relegation. Since when has that equated to 'not backed'?

Newcastle have been relegated twice in the last ten years and both times kept most of their squad and come back (Nolan, Barton, Gutierez, and many other I can't be arsed to name). Keeping these players was seen as the manager being backed wth a squad to come back up by fans, media, and the manager at the time (Hughton, Benitez). Both times they got back up and were expected to.

West Ham were relegated a few years back and again kept a good proportion of high wage players, like us and Newcastle, and again were expected to come back up, and they did.

We were relegated under Mowbray and kept most of the high earners again (some for one year like Koumas/Kamara, and some for two like Gera/Olsson), but again with a higher wage bill than most of the division. We were expected to come back up, this was seen as the manager being backed, and RDM did it.

How in gods name keeping most of the squad together can suddenly be seen as "not backed" in Big Dave's case I have no idea! Do you really think he wasnt happy with having Gibbs, Dawson, Jrod, Livermore etc? Fucking hell how can this suddenly be classsed as not backing a manager? Keeping a squad together after relegation has always been seen, almost unanimously at Allbion and other clubs, as backing the manager with the tools to get back up.

To bring the dingles in as a comparison, who seem to have won the ownership lottery last season (plus dodgy Mendes) and lost 60M in bringing in a ridiculously talented squad for that division, is barmy. Nuno was backed through the fucking roof to get back up. Big dave maybe less so, but still a reasonable comparison to us in the past, and West Ham/Newcastle as similar in the last few years.

I really don't think Big Dave seemed to want us to sell JRod/Dawson/Gibbs etc, so keeping them IS backing him.

And thank god we did, as BD blew god knows what on Bartley (awful signing). God knows what he might have spent had he had 30M to spend after selling Jrod and Dawson, if we'd gone down that route.

The fact is we can always find parts of the squad where we can say Big Dave didn't have it perfect, but fucking hell when does a manager have it perfect anywhere (bar maybe Wolves last season). This is a similar situation to Albion, West Ham and Newcastle in the past, where pretty much unanimously fans saw that as backing the manager to get back up. That's why Big Sam was happy to be in the champ with West Ham, and Benitez was happy in the champ at Newcastle. Keeping a squad of high earners and "proven" prem players can not be seen as not backing the manager in this division. Its ridiculous.

Now I know we can say some of these players are over rated and aren't as good as many think, but BD didn't seem to want to sell them, praises them to the hilt, and they're still better than most in the champ.

Some mention Stoke kept their best players too and have been worse. That's exactly whey Rowett got the sack even quicker than BD! Rowett was backed as well by keeping their squad together.

I'm at a loss as to why anyone would suddenly think in this case that keeping a high earning squad with many players seen as prem players can not be backing a manager. In every similar case at Albion in the past, and at similar clubs like I mentioned above, it's been seen as backing the manager, so I don't know why so many think Big Dave had some kind of short straw and has been hung out to dry or whatever. Absolute nonsense.


Fucking brilliant!!! Absolutely on the money.

By premier league standards we had a small squad last year and let’s face it an ageing shit squad.

Never in the years of Mowbray, RDM did we sell the spine of the team and then two players on deadline day (Charlie and Nyom) and not replace them properly.

The issue is that our recruitment policy has been flawed over a number of years now with the short term fox of staying in the Premier League rather than recruiting younger talented players.

The lack of 21-27 players in the squad (who we own is a scandal and really bad management). It akin to a business employing loads of apprentices and a lot of 70 year olds with very few personnel in the middle. 

Of those players who stayed it appeared that only bids were received for J-Rod and I’m sure that had the right bid come in he would have gone.

It does make you wonder how much control BD had over transfers and how much he was told only on a free.

With FFP it’s become harder for the relegated teams to go back up. With the size of our ground we have limited our turnover and for any extra cash rely on our owner.

I can see the arguments for BD staying and going but we are getting that reputation as a club now and we really do need a period of stability.


RE: The manager not backed - backsidebaggie - 03-10-2019

(03-10-2019, 03:26 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 02:55 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: This debate rolls on, and I can't quite believe some of the things I'm reading. Moore has been backed by keeping most of a high salary squad after relegation. Since when has that equated to 'not backed'?

Newcastle have been relegated twice in the last ten years and both times kept most of their squad and come back (Nolan, Barton, Gutierez, and many other I can't be arsed to name). Keeping these players was seen as the manager being backed wth a squad to come back up by fans, media, and the manager at the time (Hughton, Benitez). Both times they got back up and were expected to.

West Ham were relegated a few years back and again kept a good proportion of high wage players, like us and Newcastle, and again were expected to come back up, and they did.

We were relegated under Mowbray and kept most of the high earners again (some for one year like Koumas/Kamara, and some for two like Gera/Olsson), but again with a higher wage bill than most of the division. We were expected to come back up, this was seen as the manager being backed, and RDM did it.

How in gods name keeping most of the squad together can suddenly be seen as "not backed" in Big Dave's case I have no idea! Do you really think he wasnt happy with having Gibbs, Dawson, Jrod, Livermore etc? Fucking hell how can this suddenly be classsed as not backing a manager? Keeping a squad together after relegation has always been seen, almost unanimously at Allbion and other clubs, as backing the manager with the tools to get back up.

To bring the dingles in as a comparison, who seem to have won the ownership lottery last season (plus dodgy Mendes) and lost 60M in bringing in a ridiculously talented squad for that division, is barmy. Nuno was backed through the fucking roof to get back up. Big dave maybe less so, but still a reasonable comparison to us in the past, and West Ham/Newcastle as similar in the last few years.

I really don't think Big Dave seemed to want us to sell JRod/Dawson/Gibbs etc, so keeping them IS backing him.

And thank god we did, as BD blew god knows what on Bartley (awful signing). God knows what he might have spent had he had 30M to spend after selling Jrod and Dawson, if we'd gone down that route.

The fact is we can always find parts of the squad where we can say Big Dave didn't have it perfect, but fucking hell when does a manager have it perfect anywhere (bar maybe Wolves last season). This is a similar situation to Albion, West Ham and Newcastle in the past, where pretty much unanimously fans saw that as backing the manager to get back up. That's why Big Sam was happy to be in the champ with West Ham, and Benitez was happy in the champ at Newcastle. Keeping a squad of high earners and "proven" prem players can not be seen as not backing the manager in this division. Its ridiculous.

Now I know we can say some of these players are over rated and aren't as good as many think, but BD didn't seem to want to sell them, praises them to the hilt, and they're still better than most in the champ.

Some mention Stoke kept their best players too and have been worse. That's exactly whey Rowett got the sack even quicker than BD! Rowett was backed as well by keeping their squad together.

I'm at a loss as to why anyone would suddenly think in this case that keeping a high earning squad with many players seen as prem players can not be backing a manager. In every similar case at Albion in the past, and at similar clubs like I mentioned above, it's been seen as backing the manager, so I don't know why so many think Big Dave had some kind of short straw and has been hung out to dry or whatever. Absolute nonsense.
Yes we did keep several good players who got us relegated, but we also sold a few and left big gaps in the team.
Remember last years team were not good enough, all I have been saying is the players who left were not replaced with better quality players and if we had signed a Barnes / Holgate / Dack we would be top of the league. Well that's my opinion. If people on here think that's nonsense so be it.
Most people expected a team rebuild not an immediate attempt at auto-promotion tbh. If Auto-promotion was the objective from the outset we should have replaced the players who left with better quality hungry younger players. I can't understand as to why anybody would think this is nonsense. Anyway again this is why I believe Darren was left well short to achieve the clubs objective.

And every time a club in a similar situation with that sort of wage bill has been relegated, they haven't been good enough, but the squad were still good enough to come back (us in the past, Newcastle, West Ham).

As for most people expected a rebuild, not an immediate return, I have to disagree completely. Most expected an attempt at an immediate return, and the club certainly did (which is all that matters in terms of why BD has had the sack), like in the similar situations I've described. He had easily enough tools, like RDM did, and Megson the second time we went up. It was BD's lack of tactical nous that did for him, and insistanece on playing out from the back despite it killing us every other week.


RE: The manager not backed - Derek Hardballs - 03-10-2019

(03-10-2019, 03:26 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 02:55 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: This debate rolls on, and I can't quite believe some of the things I'm reading. Moore has been backed by keeping most of a high salary squad after relegation. Since when has that equated to 'not backed'?

Newcastle have been relegated twice in the last ten years and both times kept most of their squad and come back (Nolan, Barton, Gutierez, and many other I can't be arsed to name). Keeping these players was seen as the manager being backed wth a squad to come back up by fans, media, and the manager at the time (Hughton, Benitez). Both times they got back up and were expected to.

West Ham were relegated a few years back and again kept a good proportion of high wage players, like us and Newcastle, and again were expected to come back up, and they did.

We were relegated under Mowbray and kept most of the high earners again (some for one year like Koumas/Kamara, and some for two like Gera/Olsson), but again with a higher wage bill than most of the division. We were expected to come back up, this was seen as the manager being backed, and RDM did it.

How in gods name keeping most of the squad together can suddenly be seen as "not backed" in Big Dave's case I have no idea! Do you really think he wasnt happy with having Gibbs, Dawson, Jrod, Livermore etc? Fucking hell how can this suddenly be classsed as not backing a manager? Keeping a squad together after relegation has always been seen, almost unanimously at Allbion and other clubs, as backing the manager with the tools to get back up.

To bring the dingles in as a comparison, who seem to have won the ownership lottery last season (plus dodgy Mendes) and lost 60M in bringing in a ridiculously talented squad for that division, is barmy. Nuno was backed through the fucking roof to get back up. Big dave maybe less so, but still a reasonable comparison to us in the past, and West Ham/Newcastle as similar in the last few years.

I really don't think Big Dave seemed to want us to sell JRod/Dawson/Gibbs etc, so keeping them IS backing him.

And thank god we did, as BD blew god knows what on Bartley (awful signing). God knows what he might have spent had he had 30M to spend after selling Jrod and Dawson, if we'd gone down that route.

The fact is we can always find parts of the squad where we can say Big Dave didn't have it perfect, but fucking hell when does a manager have it perfect anywhere (bar maybe Wolves last season). This is a similar situation to Albion, West Ham and Newcastle in the past, where pretty much unanimously fans saw that as backing the manager to get back up. That's why Big Sam was happy to be in the champ with West Ham, and Benitez was happy in the champ at Newcastle. Keeping a squad of high earners and "proven" prem players can not be seen as not backing the manager in this division. Its ridiculous.

Now I know we can say some of these players are over rated and aren't as good as many think, but BD didn't seem to want to sell them, praises them to the hilt, and they're still better than most in the champ.

Some mention Stoke kept their best players too and have been worse. That's exactly whey Rowett got the sack even quicker than BD! Rowett was backed as well by keeping their squad together.

I'm at a loss as to why anyone would suddenly think in this case that keeping a high earning squad with many players seen as prem players can not be backing a manager. In every similar case at Albion in the past, and at similar clubs like I mentioned above, it's been seen as backing the manager, so I don't know why so many think Big Dave had some kind of short straw and has been hung out to dry or whatever. Absolute nonsense.
Yes we did keep several good players who got us relegated, but we also sold a few and left big gaps in the team.
Remember last years team were not good enough, all I have been saying is the players who left were not replaced with better quality players and if we had signed a Barnes / Holgate / Dack we would be top of the league. Well that's my opinion. If people on here think that's nonsense so be it.
Most people expected a team rebuild not an immediate attempt at auto-promotion tbh. If Auto-promotion was the objective from the outset we should have replaced the players who left with better quality hungry younger players. I can't understand as to why anybody would think this is nonsense. Anyway again this is why I believe Darren was left well short to achieve the clubs objective.


Better quality players than what we could afford in the Prem? 

Better quality than Rondon, Evans, Foster etc? 

Buying players such as Barnes and Holgate whose clubs don’t want to sell them and have no need to? 

We already have one of the top three wage bills in the Championship the idea we can just throw millions more than everyone else at promition and that constitutes giving the manager a fair chance of promotion is nonsense.


RE: The manager not backed - Shabby Russian - 03-10-2019

(03-10-2019, 03:22 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:13 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I am sure in financial terms Moore has had good backing.

But I would question the strategy of keeping the squad together.

For those who obviously fell asleep for the whole of the 2017-18 season, we finished bottom of the premiership and for significant spells of time the attitude of the players was atrocious. This time last season we lost consecutive matches against Southampton (twice), Huddersfield, Watford, Burnley, Bournemouth, not to mention the Barcelona debacle,

You really do have to question  why keeping that squad together was so imperative.

Norwich who had a mediocre season last year kept faith with their manager, they also sold their best player in James Maddison, some of the proceeds of which they re-invested in players.

I can't help thinking that it would have been better for us to sell some of our so called  premiership players and re-invest it .The only flaw in this plan was our recent record in player recruitment.

After the window closed in August last season, it struck me how few goal scorers we had in the squad and this season when the window closed it struck me how few players we had in the 21-27 age group.

Keeping the squad together was seen as imperative as in most similar cases, its given a club the best chance of going back up.

We can all pick holes in bits of the squad and say it could be better, but that's the same everywhere.

You could be right that we'd have been better selling some and re-investing, we'll never know. But BD wanted to keep them as far as we know.

Although of the last 30 teams who have been relegated only 9 have come back at the first time of asking.

It depends on the squad you have, the last time we were relegated, we had a lot of players who had experience of being promoted under Mowbray, and a good nucleus of younger players in their early to mid 20s, Brunt, Morrison, Dorrans, Mulumbu.

Our previous relegation to that we had a squad of players who when relegated basically gave up after January - it wasn't called the Great Surrender for nothing. Needless to say they didn't attain promotion the next season. It was only when that squad was broke up and a new one assembled from the proceeds of player sales, that we got promotion.

In my view the squad that got relegated last season resembled far more the great surrender squad, than the one that got relegated under Mowbray.


RE: The manager not backed - backsidebaggie - 03-10-2019

(03-10-2019, 03:29 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:26 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 02:55 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: This debate rolls on, and I can't quite believe some of the things I'm reading. Moore has been backed by keeping most of a high salary squad after relegation. Since when has that equated to 'not backed'?

Newcastle have been relegated twice in the last ten years and both times kept most of their squad and come back (Nolan, Barton, Gutierez, and many other I can't be arsed to name). Keeping these players was seen as the manager being backed wth a squad to come back up by fans, media, and the manager at the time (Hughton, Benitez). Both times they got back up and were expected to.

West Ham were relegated a few years back and again kept a good proportion of high wage players, like us and Newcastle, and again were expected to come back up, and they did.

We were relegated under Mowbray and kept most of the high earners again (some for one year like Koumas/Kamara, and some for two like Gera/Olsson), but again with a higher wage bill than most of the division. We were expected to come back up, this was seen as the manager being backed, and RDM did it.

How in gods name keeping most of the squad together can suddenly be seen as "not backed" in Big Dave's case I have no idea! Do you really think he wasnt happy with having Gibbs, Dawson, Jrod, Livermore etc? Fucking hell how can this suddenly be classsed as not backing a manager? Keeping a squad together after relegation has always been seen, almost unanimously at Allbion and other clubs, as backing the manager with the tools to get back up.

To bring the dingles in as a comparison, who seem to have won the ownership lottery last season (plus dodgy Mendes) and lost 60M in bringing in a ridiculously talented squad for that division, is barmy. Nuno was backed through the fucking roof to get back up. Big dave maybe less so, but still a reasonable comparison to us in the past, and West Ham/Newcastle as similar in the last few years.

I really don't think Big Dave seemed to want us to sell JRod/Dawson/Gibbs etc, so keeping them IS backing him.

And thank god we did, as BD blew god knows what on Bartley (awful signing). God knows what he might have spent had he had 30M to spend after selling Jrod and Dawson, if we'd gone down that route.

The fact is we can always find parts of the squad where we can say Big Dave didn't have it perfect, but fucking hell when does a manager have it perfect anywhere (bar maybe Wolves last season). This is a similar situation to Albion, West Ham and Newcastle in the past, where pretty much unanimously fans saw that as backing the manager to get back up. That's why Big Sam was happy to be in the champ with West Ham, and Benitez was happy in the champ at Newcastle. Keeping a squad of high earners and "proven" prem players can not be seen as not backing the manager in this division. Its ridiculous.

Now I know we can say some of these players are over rated and aren't as good as many think, but BD didn't seem to want to sell them, praises them to the hilt, and they're still better than most in the champ.

Some mention Stoke kept their best players too and have been worse. That's exactly whey Rowett got the sack even quicker than BD! Rowett was backed as well by keeping their squad together.

I'm at a loss as to why anyone would suddenly think in this case that keeping a high earning squad with many players seen as prem players can not be backing a manager. In every similar case at Albion in the past, and at similar clubs like I mentioned above, it's been seen as backing the manager, so I don't know why so many think Big Dave had some kind of short straw and has been hung out to dry or whatever. Absolute nonsense.
Yes we did keep several good players who got us relegated, but we also sold a few and left big gaps in the team.
Remember last years team were not good enough, all I have been saying is the players who left were not replaced with better quality players and if we had signed a Barnes / Holgate / Dack we would be top of the league. Well that's my opinion. If people on here think that's nonsense so be it.
Most people expected a team rebuild not an immediate attempt at auto-promotion tbh. If Auto-promotion was the objective from the outset we should have replaced the players who left with better quality hungry younger players. I can't understand as to why anybody would think this is nonsense. Anyway again this is why I believe Darren was left well short to achieve the clubs objective.

Why do you keep saying things like this? Replace Evans, Foster, Rondon etc with better quality. How the fecking hell can a championship side do that.

Exactly. Gayle for Rondon is fine. SJ for Foster is fine. Upping the quality after going down isn't realistic.

(03-10-2019, 03:36 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:22 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:13 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I am sure in financial terms Moore has had good backing.

But I would question the strategy of keeping the squad together.

For those who obviously fell asleep for the whole of the 2017-18 season, we finished bottom of the premiership and for significant spells of time the attitude of the players was atrocious. This time last season we lost consecutive matches against Southampton (twice), Huddersfield, Watford, Burnley, Bournemouth, not to mention the Barcelona debacle,

You really do have to question  why keeping that squad together was so imperative.

Norwich who had a mediocre season last year kept faith with their manager, they also sold their best player in James Maddison, some of the proceeds of which they re-invested in players.

I can't help thinking that it would have been better for us to sell some of our so called  premiership players and re-invest it .The only flaw in this plan was our recent record in player recruitment.

After the window closed in August last season, it struck me how few goal scorers we had in the squad and this season when the window closed it struck me how few players we had in the 21-27 age group.

Keeping the squad together was seen as imperative as in most similar cases, its given a club the best chance of going back up.

We can all pick holes in bits of the squad and say it could be better, but that's the same everywhere.

You could be right that we'd have been better selling some and re-investing, we'll never know. But BD wanted to keep them as far as we know.

Although of the last 30 teams who have been relegated only 9 have come back at the first time of asking.

It depends on the squad you have, the last time we were relegated, we had a lot of players who had experience of being promoted under Mowbray, and a good nucleus of younger players in their early to mid 20s, Brunt, Morrison, Dorrans, Mulumbu.

Our previous relegation to that we had a squad of players who when relegated basically gave up after January - it wasn't called the Great Surrender for nothing. Needless to say they didn't attain promotion the next season. It was only when that squad was broke up and a new one assembled from the proceeds of player sales, that we got promotion.

In my view the squad that got relegated last season resembled far more the great surrender squad, than the one that got relegated under Mowbray.

That's because most don't keep their squad together! That's exactly the point. The ones who did generally do come back, and if they don't, the manager gets the boot!


RE: The manager not backed - WorcBaggie - 03-10-2019

(03-10-2019, 03:36 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:22 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:13 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I am sure in financial terms Moore has had good backing.

But I would question the strategy of keeping the squad together.

For those who obviously fell asleep for the whole of the 2017-18 season, we finished bottom of the premiership and for significant spells of time the attitude of the players was atrocious. This time last season we lost consecutive matches against Southampton (twice), Huddersfield, Watford, Burnley, Bournemouth, not to mention the Barcelona debacle,

You really do have to question  why keeping that squad together was so imperative.

Norwich who had a mediocre season last year kept faith with their manager, they also sold their best player in James Maddison, some of the proceeds of which they re-invested in players.

I can't help thinking that it would have been better for us to sell some of our so called  premiership players and re-invest it .The only flaw in this plan was our recent record in player recruitment.

After the window closed in August last season, it struck me how few goal scorers we had in the squad and this season when the window closed it struck me how few players we had in the 21-27 age group.

Keeping the squad together was seen as imperative as in most similar cases, its given a club the best chance of going back up.

We can all pick holes in bits of the squad and say it could be better, but that's the same everywhere.

You could be right that we'd have been better selling some and re-investing, we'll never know. But BD wanted to keep them as far as we know.

Although of the last 30 teams who have been relegated only 9 have come back at the first time of asking.

It depends on the squad you have, the last time we were relegated, we had a lot of players who had experience of being promoted under Mowbray, and a good nucleus of younger players in their early to mid 20s, Brunt, Morrison, Dorrans, Mulumbu.

Our previous relegation to that we had a squad of players who when relegated basically gave up after January - it wasn't called the Great Surrender for nothing. Needless to say they didn't attain promotion the next season. It was only when that squad was broke up and a new one assembled from the proceeds of player sales, that we got promotion.

In my view the squad that got relegated last season resembled far more the great surrender squad, than the one that got relegated under Mowbray.

Your last sentence makes some sense BUT then who made the decision to keep the likes of Dawson, JRod etc and to give Livermore a contract extension? If it was Moore then it really negates your argument as they are obviously players he wanted and who he felt would get us promoted.


RE: The manager not backed - backsidebaggie - 03-10-2019

(03-10-2019, 03:42 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:36 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:22 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2019, 03:13 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I am sure in financial terms Moore has had good backing.

But I would question the strategy of keeping the squad together.

For those who obviously fell asleep for the whole of the 2017-18 season, we finished bottom of the premiership and for significant spells of time the attitude of the players was atrocious. This time last season we lost consecutive matches against Southampton (twice), Huddersfield, Watford, Burnley, Bournemouth, not to mention the Barcelona debacle,

You really do have to question  why keeping that squad together was so imperative.

Norwich who had a mediocre season last year kept faith with their manager, they also sold their best player in James Maddison, some of the proceeds of which they re-invested in players.

I can't help thinking that it would have been better for us to sell some of our so called  premiership players and re-invest it .The only flaw in this plan was our recent record in player recruitment.

After the window closed in August last season, it struck me how few goal scorers we had in the squad and this season when the window closed it struck me how few players we had in the 21-27 age group.

Keeping the squad together was seen as imperative as in most similar cases, its given a club the best chance of going back up.

We can all pick holes in bits of the squad and say it could be better, but that's the same everywhere.

You could be right that we'd have been better selling some and re-investing, we'll never know. But BD wanted to keep them as far as we know.

Although of the last 30 teams who have been relegated only 9 have come back at the first time of asking.

It depends on the squad you have, the last time we were relegated, we had a lot of players who had experience of being promoted under Mowbray, and a good nucleus of younger players in their early to mid 20s, Brunt, Morrison, Dorrans, Mulumbu.

Our previous relegation to that we had a squad of players who when relegated basically gave up after January - it wasn't called the Great Surrender for nothing. Needless to say they didn't attain promotion the next season. It was only when that squad was broke up and a new one assembled from the proceeds of player sales, that we got promotion.

In my view the squad that got relegated last season resembled far more the great surrender squad, than the one that got relegated under Mowbray.

Your last sentence makes some sense BUT then who made the decision to keep the likes of Dawson, JRod etc and to give Livermore a contract extension? If it was Moore then it really negates your argument as they are obviously players he wanted and who he felt would get us promoted.

Exactly, BD wanted to keep them. And this squad has better players than some of the shit in the great surrender.