WBAUnofficial
Palmer - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Palmer (/showthread.php?tid=26618)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Palmer - EastMidsBaggie - 09-15-2022

As said, Palmer must be a poor keeper if he’s behind Button.


RE: Palmer - Everything Zin - 09-15-2022

If Palmer's no better than Button, he needs to find a new career.


RE: Palmer - Hopalong - 09-15-2022

(09-15-2022, 04:19 AM)Banbury Baggie Wrote: Can't we sign Ben Foster and play him instead.....

He's just announced his retirement after hearing of our interest.....

(09-15-2022, 06:04 AM)BaggieBaggieBromBrom Wrote: Not to say I told you so but I told you so. Been saying for weeks and weeks that Button is absolute garbage.

Could you post the posts...

(09-15-2022, 07:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 07:13 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'm not convinced by Button.

But how many of the goals conceded did he have a reasonable chance of saving.

Don't tell Derek, but it might be worth looking at our xg for goals conceded. If we are letting in significantly more than our xg then it points to a potential problem with the goalkeeper.

We do seem susceptible to the counter attack, which will leave a goalkeeper exposed.

And we have conceded some goals of quality. The second last night was of the highest quality.

We're susceptible to the counter attack because we attack without any plan or direction. Their second goal last night was not the highest quality, it was three simple passes that ripped us apart because we're the most poorly coached and disorganised side in the division. It's the sort of goal a pub team concedes, credit where it's due he finished it well. All of the above stems from the manager.

If Button wasn't keeping out a lad who'd come through our youth system the stick wouldn't be half as bad. Why are we so reluctant to give one of our own a go, how can it be worse? If nothing else I would expect fans to be more patient with Palmer. Button is already finished here.

I think we're susceptible to the counter attack due to players not involved in the attack being in the right zones and marking opposition players who are not involved in defending.  Plus we have absolutely no pace at the back. 

Button has no defence in front of him!   I'll have to do an analysis of every goal conceded before making a judgement.


Right;

Boro - no chance

Watford - no chance - wonder goal - can argue shouldn't have been so far off his line but....

Blackburn - 1st, had he been central rather than slightly to his left and stepped out slightly he may have got his fingertips to it but right in the corner - 2nd - well positioned but Gallagher's shot had pace and was right in the corner, I would say difficult to blame him

Hull - Button made two brilliant saves 1st half at 0-0. No chance with either goal

Hudds - no chance for either

Wigan - no chance

Burnley - gave away the pen, bit unlucky as he got his boot to it.

Blues - 1st - was positioned too far to the left - 2nd - no chance - 3rd - debatable but on balance Hogan did the unexpected.

Overall - you could question his positioning for Blackburn's first and whether he got down quick enough for the 2nd. Again, against Blues positioning for the 1st wasn't central and he got a bit mugged for the 3rd.

In his defence as there isn't one our defending this season has been truly appalling.

Hopefully our league position might wake some of these lackadaisical players to the fact that we're not just going to turn up and turn these teams over like they seem to think.

So for me, he keeps his position at Norwich. But Bartley has to be dropped.


RE: Palmer - Woodman scoreboard - 09-16-2022

Hudds away he got beat at the near post AGAIN


RE: Palmer - Ted Maul - 09-16-2022

(09-15-2022, 09:47 PM)Hopalong Wrote: I think we're susceptible to the counter attack due to players not involved in the attack being in the right zones and marking opposition players who are not involved in defending.  Plus we have absolutely no pace at the back. 

Button has no defence in front of him!   I'll have to do an analysis of every goal conceded before making a judgement.


Right;

Boro - no chance

Watford - no chance - wonder goal - can argue shouldn't have been so far off his line but....

Blackburn - 1st, had he been central rather than slightly to his left and stepped out slightly he may have got his fingertips to it but right in the corner - 2nd - well positioned but Gallagher's shot had pace and was right in the corner, I would say difficult to blame him

Hull - Button made two brilliant saves 1st half at 0-0. No chance with either goal

Hudds - no chance for either

Wigan - no chance

Burnley - gave away the pen, bit unlucky as he got his boot to it.

Blues - 1st - was positioned too far to the left - 2nd - no chance - 3rd - debatable but on balance Hogan did the unexpected.

Overall - you could question his positioning for Blackburn's first and whether he got down quick enough for the 2nd. Again, against Blues positioning for the 1st wasn't central and he got a bit mugged for the 3rd.

In his defence as there isn't one our defending this season has been truly appalling.

Hopefully our league position might wake some of these lackadaisical players to the fact that we're not just going to turn up and turn these teams over like they seem to think.

So for me, he keeps his position at Norwich. But Bartley has to be dropped.

Our structure in defence is non-existent, however he is currently conceding 50% of the shots on target he faces. I think I'm agreeing with you in that he is far from the worst culprit, hence my comment that if he wasn't keeping an academy graduate out of the team then people wouldn't be so strong in calling for him to be dropped. In a time where a manager might be looking to generate some positivity, throwing a homegrown kid into the team is a way to do it. Plus we're pretty much in the bottom three, how much worse can it be with Palmer in goal?


RE: Palmer - Psalm23 - 09-16-2022

I think we're so susceptible to the counter attack due to the head coach, & his staff being fucking clueless.  
The same reason that most of our set pieces, either fail to clear the first defender, or end up going for a throw in.
I'd love to know WTF they do in training all week.


RE: Palmer - Woodman scoreboard - 09-16-2022

Some players ned to take responsibility and think for themselves .


RE: Palmer - HawkingsHalfpint - 09-16-2022

(09-16-2022, 07:23 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Some players ned to take responsibility and think for themselves .

True, but to some of them thinking appears a challenge.


RE: Palmer - Baggie in Valley - 09-16-2022

(09-15-2022, 09:47 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 04:19 AM)Banbury Baggie Wrote: Can't we sign Ben Foster and play him instead.....

He's just announced his retirement after hearing of our interest.....

(09-15-2022, 06:04 AM)BaggieBaggieBromBrom Wrote: Not to say I told you so but I told you so. Been saying for weeks and weeks that Button is absolute garbage.

Could you post the posts...

(09-15-2022, 07:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 07:13 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'm not convinced by Button.

But how many of the goals conceded did he have a reasonable chance of saving.

Don't tell Derek, but it might be worth looking at our xg for goals conceded. If we are letting in significantly more than our xg then it points to a potential problem with the goalkeeper.

We do seem susceptible to the counter attack, which will leave a goalkeeper exposed.

And we have conceded some goals of quality. The second last night was of the highest quality.

We're susceptible to the counter attack because we attack without any plan or direction. Their second goal last night was not the highest quality, it was three simple passes that ripped us apart because we're the most poorly coached and disorganised side in the division. It's the sort of goal a pub team concedes, credit where it's due he finished it well. All of the above stems from the manager.

If Button wasn't keeping out a lad who'd come through our youth system the stick wouldn't be half as bad. Why are we so reluctant to give one of our own a go, how can it be worse? If nothing else I would expect fans to be more patient with Palmer. Button is already finished here.

I think we're susceptible to the counter attack due to players not involved in the attack being in the right zones and marking opposition players who are not involved in defending.  Plus we have absolutely no pace at the back. 

Button has no defence in front of him!   I'll have to do an analysis of every goal conceded before making a judgement.


Right;

Boro - no chance

Watford - no chance - wonder goal - can argue shouldn't have been so far off his line but....

Blackburn - 1st, had he been central rather than slightly to his left and stepped out slightly he may have got his fingertips to it but right in the corner - 2nd - well positioned but Gallagher's shot had pace and was right in the corner, I would say difficult to blame him

Hull - Button made two brilliant saves 1st half at 0-0. No chance with either goal

Hudds - no chance for either

Wigan - no chance

Burnley - gave away the pen, bit unlucky as he got his boot to it. 

Blues - 1st - was positioned too far to the left  -  2nd - no chance  - 3rd - debatable but on balance Hogan did the unexpected.

Overall - you could question his positioning for Blackburn's first and whether he got down quick enough for the 2nd.  Again,  against Blues positioning for the 1st wasn't central and he got a bit mugged for the 3rd.

In his defence as there isn't one our defending this season has been truly appalling.

Hopefully our league position might wake some of these lackadaisical players to the fact that we're not just going to turn up and turn these teams over like they seem to think.

So for me, he keeps his position at Norwich.  But Bartley has to be dropped.

Hi Mrs Button,

The difference between Button and top keepers (Foster, Hoult in his pomp etc ) is that they can save the 'no chance' shots and are worth 10/12 points a season.

Button can't do that which is why he's by and large been a #2 keeper during his career.

Regards,

BIV


RE: Palmer - wbamitch - 09-16-2022

I don't think he's made any huge clangers, apart from maybe the third Blues goal, but there's been a fair few a decent GK would've saved. He isn't going to win us points like Bachmann did in the Watford match. Pretty much every shot at him has gone in and you can't make excuses for that