RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Lurker#3 - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 11:16 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (08-01-2022, 11:02 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: For those who think the thread is ridiculous, I do apologise. However, asking a question to gauge fans thoughts at the start of a season isn't too stupid if you ask me. Especially as there were many people who didn't want him either originally or after the end of last season.
I feel the club has recruited well in Swift, Wallace and Okay, no arguments there. But first game of the season all the same issues that irked me since December last season, were there for us all to see. I know its the old argument, but I always look at more than just results, and will continue to do so. Second half there were signs of the team we can be. But its my opinion that they played like that in spite of not because of the manager.
However, it's good to see he's got some backing, and many have confidence in his management. I hope to be proven wrong and I will humbly consume a slice of the proverbial pie if he turns it around and gets us firing.
Despite it being in the press that the players said it was Bruce's half-time talk and tweaks that changed things?
https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/football/west-bromwich-albion/2022/08/01/steve-bruce-delivers-west-brom-home-truths/
https://twitter.com/WBA/status/1553772726334234630?t=D5PFT0Hk7xCuDCyj8CTTvA&s=19
So he had to make tactical changes away from what he decided to start with, his preferred middling approach, square lines, low to middle block, solid pros etc etc. This is my exact frustration and its been the case for 8 months, how many times has that boring, predicable, nothing approach have to fail?
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Brentbaggie - 08-01-2022
Why don't we have a poll for every single player. I'd love to read that one.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - MrFizz - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 11:33 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (08-01-2022, 11:16 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (08-01-2022, 11:02 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: For those who think the thread is ridiculous, I do apologise. However, asking a question to gauge fans thoughts at the start of a season isn't too stupid if you ask me. Especially as there were many people who didn't want him either originally or after the end of last season.
I feel the club has recruited well in Swift, Wallace and Okay, no arguments there. But first game of the season all the same issues that irked me since December last season, were there for us all to see. I know its the old argument, but I always look at more than just results, and will continue to do so. Second half there were signs of the team we can be. But its my opinion that they played like that in spite of not because of the manager.
However, it's good to see he's got some backing, and many have confidence in his management. I hope to be proven wrong and I will humbly consume a slice of the proverbial pie if he turns it around and gets us firing.
Despite it being in the press that the players said it was Bruce's half-time talk and tweaks that changed things?
https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/football/west-bromwich-albion/2022/08/01/steve-bruce-delivers-west-brom-home-truths/
https://twitter.com/WBA/status/1553772726334234630?t=D5PFT0Hk7xCuDCyj8CTTvA&s=19
So he had to make tactical changes away from what he decided to start with, his preferred middling approach, square lines, low to middle block, solid pros etc etc. This is my exact frustration and its been the case for 8 months, how many times has that boring, predicable, nothing approach have to fail?
Unfortunately he doesn't have a crystal ball to work out who the oppo will play, how they will play and the intensity of said play. If only he did. At least he changed things a bit.
Preferred tactics not quite working away from home in the first game of the season against good opposition. Hardly a crime. Tweak things, get a result. Its what managers do.
One game into the season. I really do fuckin despair.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Lurker#3 - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 12:02 PM)MrFizz Wrote: (08-01-2022, 11:33 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (08-01-2022, 11:16 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (08-01-2022, 11:02 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: For those who think the thread is ridiculous, I do apologise. However, asking a question to gauge fans thoughts at the start of a season isn't too stupid if you ask me. Especially as there were many people who didn't want him either originally or after the end of last season.
I feel the club has recruited well in Swift, Wallace and Okay, no arguments there. But first game of the season all the same issues that irked me since December last season, were there for us all to see. I know its the old argument, but I always look at more than just results, and will continue to do so. Second half there were signs of the team we can be. But its my opinion that they played like that in spite of not because of the manager.
However, it's good to see he's got some backing, and many have confidence in his management. I hope to be proven wrong and I will humbly consume a slice of the proverbial pie if he turns it around and gets us firing.
Despite it being in the press that the players said it was Bruce's half-time talk and tweaks that changed things?
https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/football/west-bromwich-albion/2022/08/01/steve-bruce-delivers-west-brom-home-truths/
https://twitter.com/WBA/status/1553772726334234630?t=D5PFT0Hk7xCuDCyj8CTTvA&s=19
So he had to make tactical changes away from what he decided to start with, his preferred middling approach, square lines, low to middle block, solid pros etc etc. This is my exact frustration and its been the case for 8 months, how many times has that boring, predicable, nothing approach have to fail?
Unfortunately he doesn't have a crystal ball to work out who the oppo will play, how they will play and the intensity of said play. If only he did. At least he changed things a bit.
Preferred tactics not quite working away from home in the first game of the season against good opposition. Hardly a crime. Tweak things, get a result. Its what managers do.
One game into the season. I really do fuckin despair.
My opinion is that his preferred tactics are shite and boring, and that's made me despair for 8 months let alone one game! But if he does finally have some sort of epiphany and change his longstanding approach, I will be team Brucey!
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - coxy134 - 08-01-2022
My concern that in football terms he is a bit long in the tooth.
Still have to give him some time though.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Derek Hardballs - 08-01-2022
Hysterical nonsense again from the same posters who overreacted about the team sheet on the first day of the season ffs!
Val ball left the squad in position it could only really play one way. It was formulaic drivel, football designed exclusively around stats with zero creativity. Players were going backwards in terms of performance under his management. As were results and it’s disingenuous to suggest we were 5th when he left, when we all know the trajectory of our results and pts tally meant we were going down the table rather than up. The same people who disagree with this point would have happily seen Irvine remain as coach because we weren’t in the relegation zone when he was sacked I presume?
Bruce tried to change things too quickly arguably given the formulaic approach the players had drilled into them. It didn’t work but by the end of the season there were signs that things were improving. To say he’s got a handful of games is harsh but understandable if the same posters had shown anywhere near such harshness towards Val. I’m old enough to remember the same posters saying Val deserved three / four transfer windows and it was going to be a two, three, four year ‘project’.
Hawks is right if Bruce was Esteban Brucio and spoke about his philosophy and his project this ludicrous poll wouldn’t even have been posted.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Lurker#3 - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Hysterical nonsense again from the same posters who overreacted about the team sheet on the first day of the season ffs!
Val ball left the squad in position it could only really play one way. It was formulaic drivel, football designed exclusively around stats with zero creativity. Players were going backwards in terms of performance under his management. As were results and it’s disingenuous to suggest we were 5th when he left, when we all know the trajectory of our results and pts tally meant we were going down the table rather than up. The same people who disagree with this point would have happily seen Irvine remain as coach because we weren’t in the relegation zone when he was sacked I presume?
Bruce tried to change things too quickly arguably given the formulaic approach the players had drilled into them. It didn’t work but by the end of the season there were signs that things were improving. To say he’s got a handful of games is harsh but understandable if the same posters had shown anywhere near such harshness towards Val. I’m old enough to remember the same posters saying Val deserved three / four transfer windows and it was going to be a two, three, four year ‘project’.
Hawks is right if Bruce was Esteban Brucio and spoke about his philosophy and his project this ludicrous poll wouldn’t even have been posted.
I'll put you down as "option 3" then Dekka 
Or should I add a forth - "Still Val's fault"
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Duffers - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Hysterical nonsense again from the same posters who overreacted about the team sheet on the first day of the season ffs!
Val ball left the squad in position it could only really play one way. It was formulaic drivel, football designed exclusively around stats with zero creativity. Players were going backwards in terms of performance under his management. As were results and it’s disingenuous to suggest we were 5th when he left, when we all know the trajectory of our results and pts tally meant we were going down the table rather than up. The same people who disagree with this point would have happily seen Irvine remain as coach because we weren’t in the relegation zone when he was sacked I presume?
Bruce tried to change things too quickly arguably given the formulaic approach the players had drilled into them. It didn’t work but by the end of the season there were signs that things were improving. To say he’s got a handful of games is harsh but understandable if the same posters had shown anywhere near such harshness towards Val. I’m old enough to remember the same posters saying Val deserved three / four transfer windows and it was going to be a two, three, four year ‘project’.
Hawks is right if Bruce was Esteban Brucio and spoke about his philosophy and his project this ludicrous poll wouldn’t even have been posted.
Bruce was brought in with the key requirement to arrest that slide though. Something he failed abjectly at.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - Big Daddy Cool - 08-01-2022
You can't criticise Bruce for the first half performance but say he had nothing to with the second half response. That's just showing you have an agenda.
RE: Your view on Bruce-y: The Poll - MrFizz - 08-01-2022
(08-01-2022, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Hawks is right if Bruce was Esteban Brucio and spoke about his philosophy and his project this ludicrous poll wouldn’t even have been posted.
Don't forget the obligatory MS Surface Tablet surgically attached to their coaches left hand, the slicked back hair, neatly trimmed beard and bleached gnashers. Thats a modern, progressive football manager.
|