RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - Squid - 05-12-2022
(05-12-2022, 10:33 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-12-2022, 09:48 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (05-12-2022, 09:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-12-2022, 07:07 AM)Peachy Wrote: I seem to remember reading that we might get up to £2m for Irreongbunam if he hits certain targets. I might be totally wrong on that though.
So almost a year of Grant - great 
There's no doubt he had a difficult season in the Prem, but was never going to be able to lead the line and score goals consistently, not his forte. He was then bombed by Allardyce for half a season.
He scored 18 in 44 this season - missed 3 pens and countless other chances.
He scored 19 in 43 in 2019/20 in a struggling Huddersfield side.
And where would we have finished this season without Grant's goals? Around 18/19th probably.
So we are paying £2.5m a yr for a striker (for the next 4 yrs unless we sell) who scores between 18-20 a season. Sounds reasonably good value to me.
How much did Austin cost the two seasons he was here in fee and wages? About £8m? Zohore?
That's just like saying how many goals would we have let in if we didn't have a keeper between the sticks, isn't it? If we hadn't spent the money on him and had a better CF then we may have had Diangana playing left wing where he's played his best football etc, etc.
The number of excuses people will make for that pea-hearted player. He hides as soon as he gets kicked.
Grant has scored us a stack of goals, won plenty of games for us and people still bleat.
RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - SW4Baggie - 05-12-2022
(05-12-2022, 09:48 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (05-12-2022, 09:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-12-2022, 07:07 AM)Peachy Wrote: I seem to remember reading that we might get up to £2m for Irreongbunam if he hits certain targets. I might be totally wrong on that though.
So almost a year of Grant - great  There's no doubt he had a difficult season in the Prem, but was never going to be able to lead the line and score goals consistently, not his forte. He was then bombed by Allardyce for half a season.
He scored 18 in 44 this season - missed 3 pens and countless other chances.
He scored 19 in 43 in 2019/20 in a struggling Huddersfield side.
And where would we have finished this season without Grant's goals? Around 18/19th probably.
So we are paying £2.5m a yr for a striker (for the next 4 yrs unless we sell) who scores between 18-20 a season. Sounds reasonably good value to me.
How much did Austin cost the two seasons he was here in fee and wages? About £8m? Zohore?
Joel Piroe scored 22 goals and cost around £1m
Andy Wiemann scored 22 goals and I think Bristol got him on a free
Adebajo scored 16 goals and cost pennies...
The point is that we have struggled to find value in the market when purchasing players, and we've failed to extract value on players exiting the club.
"Bombed out" by Allardyce is harsh... Fat Sam replaced him as he wasn't good enough, in the same way Livermore and Sawyers were replaced. They were hardly training alone, they just weren't selected as they weren't good enough and we improved at least in performances when they didn't play.
I've nothing against Grant, I think he works hard and has a decent attitude if I'm honest. He's found parts of this season tough, but he tries hard and has a given us a decent return in goals, but to suggest anything other than we massively overpaid for him, and he shows all of the weaknesses of our recent acquisiton strategy is just plain wrong.
RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - Fido - 05-12-2022
(05-12-2022, 10:53 AM)Squid Wrote: (05-12-2022, 10:33 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-12-2022, 09:48 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (05-12-2022, 09:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-12-2022, 07:07 AM)Peachy Wrote: I seem to remember reading that we might get up to £2m for Irreongbunam if he hits certain targets. I might be totally wrong on that though.
So almost a year of Grant - great 
There's no doubt he had a difficult season in the Prem, but was never going to be able to lead the line and score goals consistently, not his forte. He was then bombed by Allardyce for half a season.
He scored 18 in 44 this season - missed 3 pens and countless other chances.
He scored 19 in 43 in 2019/20 in a struggling Huddersfield side.
And where would we have finished this season without Grant's goals? Around 18/19th probably.
So we are paying £2.5m a yr for a striker (for the next 4 yrs unless we sell) who scores between 18-20 a season. Sounds reasonably good value to me.
How much did Austin cost the two seasons he was here in fee and wages? About £8m? Zohore?
That's just like saying how many goals would we have let in if we didn't have a keeper between the sticks, isn't it? If we hadn't spent the money on him and had a better CF then we may have had Diangana playing left wing where he's played his best football etc, etc.
The number of excuses people will make for that pea-hearted player. He hides as soon as he gets kicked.
Grant has scored us a stack of goals, won plenty of games for us and people still bleat.
Doesn't disagree completely with regards to Diangana but it was more another "what of" example than anything else.
I tend to veer more towards SW4's point of view though in that better value could have been found elsewhere which, in turn, provides us with a chance to buy another player in another position who may have contributed more. There is always a tendency to watch forward players more than defenders and from what I've witnessed he doesn't often provide a strong first line of defence, rarely holds it up for long and quite often is in positions where other players cannot find him. Of course, you can counter that with the number of goals scored but there must be alternatives out there than do a bit more of the other stuff as well. Being a forward is not just about scoring yourself but also holding good positions for your team and contributing to the midfield chipping in with a few as well.
RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - wbamitch - 05-12-2022
(05-12-2022, 09:48 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (05-12-2022, 09:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-12-2022, 07:07 AM)Peachy Wrote: I seem to remember reading that we might get up to £2m for Irreongbunam if he hits certain targets. I might be totally wrong on that though.
So almost a year of Grant - great 
There's no doubt he had a difficult season in the Prem, but was never going to be able to lead the line and score goals consistently, not his forte. He was then bombed by Allardyce for half a season.
He scored 18 in 44 this season - missed 3 pens and countless other chances.
He scored 19 in 43 in 2019/20 in a struggling Huddersfield side.
And where would we have finished this season without Grant's goals? Around 18/19th probably.
So we are paying £2.5m a yr for a striker (for the next 4 yrs unless we sell) who scores between 18-20 a season. Sounds reasonably good value to me.
How much did Austin cost the two seasons he was here in fee and wages? About £8m? Zohore?
You could also spin it that he's been the striker in two struggling championship sides. Huddersfield seem to be doing OK now he's gone. Grant's not the main problem but his lack of attributes apart from finishing chances definitely holds us back at times.
RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - Dial M for Mick - 05-12-2022
(05-12-2022, 02:46 PM)wbamitch Wrote: (05-12-2022, 09:48 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (05-12-2022, 09:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-12-2022, 07:07 AM)Peachy Wrote: I seem to remember reading that we might get up to £2m for Irreongbunam if he hits certain targets. I might be totally wrong on that though.
So almost a year of Grant - great 
There's no doubt he had a difficult season in the Prem, but was never going to be able to lead the line and score goals consistently, not his forte. He was then bombed by Allardyce for half a season.
He scored 18 in 44 this season - missed 3 pens and countless other chances.
He scored 19 in 43 in 2019/20 in a struggling Huddersfield side.
And where would we have finished this season without Grant's goals? Around 18/19th probably.
So we are paying £2.5m a yr for a striker (for the next 4 yrs unless we sell) who scores between 18-20 a season. Sounds reasonably good value to me.
How much did Austin cost the two seasons he was here in fee and wages? About £8m? Zohore?
You could also spin it that he's been the striker in two struggling championship sides. Huddersfield seem to be doing OK now he's gone. Grant's not the main problem but his lack of attributes apart from finishing chances definitely holds us back at times.
You could spin it that way if Huddersfield hadn’t finished 20th last season after they sold him. I suppose he’s to blame for them struggling when he wasn’t even there as well.
RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - wbamitch - 05-12-2022
(05-12-2022, 03:45 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: (05-12-2022, 02:46 PM)wbamitch Wrote: (05-12-2022, 09:48 AM)Hopalong Wrote: (05-12-2022, 09:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-12-2022, 07:07 AM)Peachy Wrote: I seem to remember reading that we might get up to £2m for Irreongbunam if he hits certain targets. I might be totally wrong on that though.
So almost a year of Grant - great 
There's no doubt he had a difficult season in the Prem, but was never going to be able to lead the line and score goals consistently, not his forte. He was then bombed by Allardyce for half a season.
He scored 18 in 44 this season - missed 3 pens and countless other chances.
He scored 19 in 43 in 2019/20 in a struggling Huddersfield side.
And where would we have finished this season without Grant's goals? Around 18/19th probably.
So we are paying £2.5m a yr for a striker (for the next 4 yrs unless we sell) who scores between 18-20 a season. Sounds reasonably good value to me.
How much did Austin cost the two seasons he was here in fee and wages? About £8m? Zohore?
You could also spin it that he's been the striker in two struggling championship sides. Huddersfield seem to be doing OK now he's gone. Grant's not the main problem but his lack of attributes apart from finishing chances definitely holds us back at times.
You could spin it that way if Huddersfield hadn’t finished 20th last season after they sold him. I suppose he’s to blame for them struggling when he wasn’t even there as well.
I did say he's not the main problem but you decided to ignore that part. Huddersfield fans weren't bothered in the slightest when he left and certainly wouldn't have him back now. He's a limited player who has a decent goal return but I personally wouldn't be bothered if we moved him on. IMO you need more from your wide forwards who can score but contribute in other ways which Grant can't. If goals/assists are all that matters then we shouldn't have a problem with Robinson either who contributed to 16 goals in 1000 less minutes.
RE: Reyes Cleary and Owen Windsor - Tom Joad - 05-12-2022
wbamitch Wrote:Dial M for Mick Wrote:wbamitch Wrote:Hopalong Wrote:SW4Baggie Wrote:So almost a year of Grant - great 
There's no doubt he had a difficult season in the Prem, but was never going to be able to lead the line and score goals consistently, not his forte. He was then bombed by Allardyce for half a season.
He scored 18 in 44 this season - missed 3 pens and countless other chances.
He scored 19 in 43 in 2019/20 in a struggling Huddersfield side.
And where would we have finished this season without Grant's goals? Around 18/19th probably.
So we are paying £2.5m a yr for a striker (for the next 4 yrs unless we sell) who scores between 18-20 a season. Sounds reasonably good value to me.
How much did Austin cost the two seasons he was here in fee and wages? About £8m? Zohore?
You could also spin it that he's been the striker in two struggling championship sides. Huddersfield seem to be doing OK now he's gone. Grant's not the main problem but his lack of attributes apart from finishing chances definitely holds us back at times.
You could spin it that way if Huddersfield hadn’t finished 20th last season after they sold him. I suppose he’s to blame for them struggling when he wasn’t even there as well.
I did say he's not the main problem but you decided to ignore that part. Huddersfield fans weren't bothered in the slightest when he left and certainly wouldn't have him back now. He's a limited player who has a decent goal return but I personally wouldn't be bothered if we moved him on. IMO you need more from your wide forwards who can score but contribute in other ways which Grant can't. If goals/assists are all that matters then we shouldn't have a problem with Robinson either who contributed to 16 goals in 1000 less minutes. I will always have a problem with Robinson. He is probably the ,most talented forward at the club yet has no heart, ihas the backbone of a jellyfish, hides when the going is tough and then does all that gesturing to get the crowd going at corners. First out the door for me. He doesn't seem to last under any manager, there's a reason for that.
|