RE: The Magic of the FA Cup - Shabby Russian - 04-18-2022
The FA Cup is a diminished competition, primarily for two reasons.
1 Introduction of the Premier League. The financial consequence of relegation has reduced many a premier league club and manager to a quivering jelly afraid of its own shadow. I remember the olden days when clubs would rest players in league games to protect them for an important cup game, not the other way round.
2 The introduction of the Champions League, which has led to a reduction in the domestic timetable. Gone are the midweek replays played under floodlights, that could in theory just never get resolved.
Anyone who was at The Hawthorns for the replay against Man Utd would understand how great these occasions could be.
RE: The Magic of the FA Cup - Hopalong - 04-18-2022
(04-17-2022, 07:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Liverpool v Chelsea…
It’s the unpredictability I think that makes it so special!
At least those two will give the competition the respect it deserves.
RE: The Magic of the FA Cup - Derek Hardballs - 04-18-2022
(04-18-2022, 01:08 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: (04-18-2022, 12:47 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-18-2022, 12:34 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: (04-18-2022, 12:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-18-2022, 12:04 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: I love a bit of extreme ironing on the YouTube me.
Again, I don't really see what you can have unhappiness about.
Shirley and logically, the team with the best players are going to go far in the competition and potentially win it.
On their day, Watford, Palace or God forbid Villa could have won their finals.
What do you expect the FA to say or implement to the bigger clubs when facing opposition such as Luton or Shrewsbury? "You need to have 6 or 7 U18 or U23 in your starting lineup?"
What killed the cup competitions for the "magic of the cup" so you put it, is giving the winner automatic access to the European competitions, and that is down to the FA in the way they allocate entrants based on domestic competitions. I could go on and on about hence why UEFA created the conference league to add more teams and spread the wealth, but I won't.
The point is, the bigger teams are always going to win aren't they.
Look at this from the 1980's, consistently Man Utd, Liverpool, Everton, Spurs and Arsenal - again the bigger teams of that era:
https://pop-culture-scrapbook.fandom.com/wiki/FA_Cup_finals_(1980-1989)
You're barking up a shitpipe Derek.
I’m not barking up any tree or whatever a shitpipe is. The cup for decades has been won by top six clubs mainly. There is very little magic to the cup it’s relentlessly predictable. The difference now compared to the 80-90s is top six clubs can field kids for two or three rounds and still get to finals because no one cares about the competition until the quarter finals anymore.
Again, your point holds no relevance and you've just contradicted yourself.
Consistently, the bigger clubs (of whichever era) have won the FA Cup irrespective of whether they field kids or not.
I suppose "the magic of the cup" you keep referring to is media generated, or considered mentioning when a smaller club is going on a good run, or a one off like Wimbledon or Wigan.
And, to potentially apply your logic, the bigger teams should field their strongest first choice eleven vs Hartlepool? Is that gentlemanly?
I disagree with your other statement also, I think all teams down to grass roots on the park love the FA Cup, because it's a tournament where anything can happen on the day.
Seems to me your just pissed off at modern football and don't really have an argument anyway.
Seems to me that you’re trying to extrapolate an argument from a shitpipe based on me posting ‘the magic of the cup’.
Ours and many more clubs attendances in the early rounds of the cup suggest the FA Cup has become an opportunity to play weakened teams and kids in half empty stadiums.
I'm not extrapolating an argument Derek, I put it to you and merely commenting on, what is it that you expect when the bigger teams are predominately in the FA Cup final, when they are currently and or historically, considered the bigger teams.
You, back tracked and went off on tangents, and I put to you that you did not have a point on the FA Cup matter and that you're just pissed off at football.
I didn’t backtrack on anything or go off at tangents. The cup is predictable and has become less relevant as a competition.
RE: The Magic of the FA Cup - Cheshire East Baggie - 04-18-2022
(04-18-2022, 12:27 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote: Mr vertical Wrote:Borin' Baggie Wrote:HLS Wrote:What robbery was there? We were second best that day for sure and despite some excellent performances in previous rounds we didn't look at all like scoring against Portsmouth.
Being robbed is more like getting a nonsense red card and nonsense pen given against you in a play off semi.
Their goal shouldn't have stood as there was a blatant handball in the build up.
This was my memory also.
Correct.
Absolutely.
RE: The Magic of the FA Cup - Johnnykayeengland - 04-18-2022
"The point is, the bigger teams are always going to win aren't they."
No
The "magic of the cup" theme comes from the time when upsets were possible. The bigger clubs are certainly going to win the League. But upsets were regular and exciting. And a mid table team was usually going to win. There was no Top 6 of course.
And 3rd round day was great because here was a brand new competition you might go far in.
A competition we excelled in, which was as big as the league.
But that was then...
RE: The Magic of the FA Cup - hudds - 04-18-2022
(04-18-2022, 01:08 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: (04-18-2022, 12:47 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-18-2022, 12:34 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: (04-18-2022, 12:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-18-2022, 12:04 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: I love a bit of extreme ironing on the YouTube me.
Again, I don't really see what you can have unhappiness about.
Shirley and logically, the team with the best players are going to go far in the competition and potentially win it.
On their day, Watford, Palace or God forbid Villa could have won their finals.
What do you expect the FA to say or implement to the bigger clubs when facing opposition such as Luton or Shrewsbury? "You need to have 6 or 7 U18 or U23 in your starting lineup?"
What killed the cup competitions for the "magic of the cup" so you put it, is giving the winner automatic access to the European competitions, and that is down to the FA in the way they allocate entrants based on domestic competitions. I could go on and on about hence why UEFA created the conference league to add more teams and spread the wealth, but I won't.
The point is, the bigger teams are always going to win aren't they.
Look at this from the 1980's, consistently Man Utd, Liverpool, Everton, Spurs and Arsenal - again the bigger teams of that era:
https://pop-culture-scrapbook.fandom.com/wiki/FA_Cup_finals_(1980-1989)
You're barking up a shitpipe Derek.
I’m not barking up any tree or whatever a shitpipe is. The cup for decades has been won by top six clubs mainly. There is very little magic to the cup it’s relentlessly predictable. The difference now compared to the 80-90s is top six clubs can field kids for two or three rounds and still get to finals because no one cares about the competition until the quarter finals anymore.
Again, your point holds no relevance and you've just contradicted yourself.
Consistently, the bigger clubs (of whichever era) have won the FA Cup irrespective of whether they field kids or not.
I suppose "the magic of the cup" you keep referring to is media generated, or considered mentioning when a smaller club is going on a good run, or a one off like Wimbledon or Wigan.
And, to potentially apply your logic, the bigger teams should field their strongest first choice eleven vs Hartlepool? Is that gentlemanly?
I disagree with your other statement also, I think all teams down to grass roots on the park love the FA Cup, because it's a tournament where anything can happen on the day.
Seems to me your just pissed off at modern football and don't really have an argument anyway.
Seems to me that you’re trying to extrapolate an argument from a shitpipe based on me posting ‘the magic of the cup’.
Ours and many more clubs attendances in the early rounds of the cup suggest the FA Cup has become an opportunity to play weakened teams and kids in half empty stadiums.
I'm not extrapolating an argument Derek, I put it to you and merely commenting on, what is it that you expect when the bigger teams are predominately in the FA Cup final, when they are currently and or historically, considered the bigger teams.
You, back tracked and went off on tangents, and I put to you that you did not have a point on the FA Cup matter and that you're just pissed off at football.
H'mmm. There appear to be two users sharing the Sausage and Egg Baton log-in.
RE: The Magic of the FA Cup - Hopalong - 04-19-2022
(04-18-2022, 02:12 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (04-18-2022, 12:27 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote: Mr vertical Wrote:Borin' Baggie Wrote:HLS Wrote:What robbery was there? We were second best that day for sure and despite some excellent performances in previous rounds we didn't look at all like scoring against Portsmouth.
Being robbed is more like getting a nonsense red card and nonsense pen given against you in a play off semi.
Their goal shouldn't have stood as there was a blatant handball in the build up.
This was my memory also.
Correct.
Absolutely.
Baros cheated us out of at least the opportunity of extra-time/penalties. Closest we'll probably ever get to a 6th win.
|