RE: Our Top 2 Squad - Noibla - 02-10-2022
(02-10-2022, 12:26 AM)Dumbo Wrote: We’ve gone from Periera in the number 10, to Adam fucking Reach. From Connor Gallagher and Ainsley Maitland Niles in the middle to Alex fucking Mowatt. Is it any surprise we are where we fucking are…
Mowatt is looking more and more like a free transfer from Barnsley every game……Oh
RE: Our Top 2 Squad - wbamitch - 02-10-2022
Since when did money spent guarantee success anyway? Barely anyone in the league spent big on players, and if they did it wasn’t much. I bet our cheap nasty free transfers our manager was ‘forced’ to sign are on higher wages than most in this division. A lot of our successful signings at this level have been frees, cheap deals and loans. DM got Holgate, Gayle and Barnes on loan, Bilic got Pereira, Grady & Krovinovic on loan all of whom had a big impact. Nobody held him at gun point and said you must sign Hugil and Reach, he just didn’t really know what he was doing.
RE: Our Top 2 Squad - Derek Hardballs - 02-10-2022
The rather large elephant in the room is this, we can’t compare squads from other years. This season is unique as is any other and with the financial problems caused by Covid every squad bar Fulham are weaker than in many previous seasons with gaps and deficiencies in key areas. That does not mean we are weaker than any of the front runners it means we are being managed badly and failing to get the best out of the players.
If I’m wrong and this side is worse than Blackburn, Forest, etc then the short lived glee of getting one up on me and others will be very short lived, when it becomes apparent we won’t have any resources to produce a better squad next season and beyond. For all the talk of systems and scouting networks, the underlying advantage we had was TV money in the Championship, it gave us an advantage and still does this season and perhaps to a lesser extent next but after that I can’t see anything but struggle.
Last observation two three of the loudest voices saying we have a poor squad slated Bilic for not getting the best out of it in the Prem and despite the fact it was obvious we had a promotion capable squad and not a Prem squad when the season kicked off. Now you can’t argue a manager has little or no influence on results this season due to the quality of the squad but previously say the manager(s) including Allardyce should be competing with clearly far better squads than ours week in week out at a level far higher than the Championship.
The league table is tight because there are no stand out squads in this division, the fact we are languishing outside the play-offs is down to bad management nothing more.
RE: Our Top 2 Squad - MassDebater - 02-10-2022
(02-09-2022, 11:29 PM)Sliced Wrote: (02-09-2022, 10:46 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Blackburn £1.22m
Blackpool £1.15m
Bournemouth £9m
Bristol £1.44m
Coventry £1.08m
Fulham £19.80m
Hull £720k
Boro £11.3m
Forest £3.1m
P'boro £4.74m
PNE £1.26m
QPR £1.67m
Stoke £4.19m
Swansea £4.9m
WBA £7.77m
So, we've spent the 4th highest amount this season. Which puts paid to the he had no money to spend malarkey. Yes it was on one player...but hey, 22 other clubs have spent less (9 spent nothing) .
5 who spent less than us are currently above us.
6 out of the 7 above us, never came down from the Prem last year. (which would usually suggest that their squad would be weaker to start with)
2 of the teams above us have spent nothing. If you add Forest, QPR and Blackburn's combined spend with those 2 clubs then that is 5 clubs above us combined who have spent less than we have.
But hey don't let FACTS *(this now means that this is magically absolute truth) get in the way of making out we did as good as others in the transfer market.
How much did we spend in the summer? 0 was it?
How much income did we have in the summer? 17 million was it?
I wonder why our 7m pound signing hasn’t made the impact before Christmas. Bizarre
“Puts paid to the amount spent argument”, yeah if you conveniently ignore the fact that we spent zero until January, sold our best player and still have the second lowest net spend in the league.
Our squad is clearly much better than we’re doing. Adam Reach would walk into any squad in the league as an attacking central midfielder and its also the reason why 33 year old Andy Carroll has been our best player since he arrived.
Look at who those who did spend money a. already had, and b. bought, then come back whining about not spending anything. WE COULD have bought someone, but Six obviously wanted Dike and he wasn't available, so Six waited and let us fester. Anyway he's gone and that will be my last post about him and what a fucking mess he has left us in.
RE: Our Top 2 Squad - Shabby Russian - 02-10-2022
(02-10-2022, 04:51 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (02-10-2022, 12:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: There are players in this squad who during their career have played very well in the Championship and who have played in higher divisions; however too many of this squad are reliant on reputation alone now. Add into that we have some powerful voices in the dressing room who have been at the squad through our prolonged period of decline, offering very little.
On current form this squad has one Premier League quality player - Johnstone - and he leaves on a free in 4 months.
Bartley, Phillips, Livermore ought to be standing out at this level, but they’ve achieved as much as they are likely to in the game and know this contract will be their last big payday, and neither of them have shown any mental strength since signing.
Robinson, Townsend, Mowatt, Ajayi, Furlong, Reach, Button - all decent 6/10 championship players. Could arguably hold their own for a few games in the PL, but unlikely to ever get a move to beyond this level. With the exception of Mowatt, all have had a crack at the PL and probably know promotion will only result in being sold to a Champ side or warming the bench. Are mid-20s and have very little to prove.
O’Shea, Grady (and Dike at Barnsley) have the ability to play top flight football and have time on their side. All have been blighted with injury problems this season so haven’t had the impact we need.
Grant, Molumby, Clark, Kipré all have something to prove still. Unfortunately in Clark, the most promising of the 4 isn’t ours. Currently they’re Championship players and although they have some commitment to developing and improving, they’re likely to only ever be upper end Champ players, which is what we need now - and even on form they are not good enough to lift this sorry bunch.
Carroll - 33 and a crock, but currently our best player as he is combining ability and effort… but he has a 6 month deal and will get a better offer based on our current performance.
On paper, we have a squad that should be doing better, but that’s on paper. Breaking it down we have very few players with much reason to push on. Most are on the best contract they’re likely to receive, and those that are on an upward trajectory aren’t really good enough. Val’s stubbornness was not helping, but let’s not pretend everything can be fixed by getting rid of him. We have a rotten squad that’s being paid very handsomely based on past glories, and captained by a man who is onto his 7th manager having led us through a period of characterless regression.
That my friend is the post of the week/season absolutely spot on Sw4.
While I don't agree with all the individual points and not sure I agree with the lack of motivation, overall this post post is getting to the heart of the problem
To sun up we have a squad of players who were very good at this level in the past, some who have been ok at championship, but no more than that. A small number who hint at being very good and one player who is currently very good but will leave for nothing in the summer.
RE: Our Top 2 Squad - Duffers - 02-10-2022
(02-10-2022, 12:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: There are players in this squad who during their career have played very well in the Championship and who have played in higher divisions; however too many of this squad are reliant on reputation alone now. Add into that we have some powerful voices in the dressing room who have been at the squad through our prolonged period of decline, offering very little.
On current form this squad has one Premier League quality player - Johnstone - and he leaves on a free in 4 months.
Bartley, Phillips, Livermore ought to be standing out at this level, but they’ve achieved as much as they are likely to in the game and know this contract will be their last big payday, and neither of them have shown any mental strength since signing.
Robinson, Townsend, Mowatt, Ajayi, Furlong, Reach, Button - all decent 6/10 championship players. Could arguably hold their own for a few games in the PL, but unlikely to ever get a move to beyond this level. With the exception of Mowatt, all have had a crack at the PL and probably know promotion will only result in being sold to a Champ side or warming the bench. Are mid-20s and have very little to prove.
O’Shea, Grady (and Dike at Barnsley) have the ability to play top flight football and have time on their side. All have been blighted with injury problems this season so haven’t had the impact we need.
Grant, Molumby, Clark, Kipré all have something to prove still. Unfortunately in Clark, the most promising of the 4 isn’t ours. Currently they’re Championship players and although they have some commitment to developing and improving, they’re likely to only ever be upper end Champ players, which is what we need now - and even on form they are not good enough to lift this sorry bunch.
Carroll - 33 and a crock, but currently our best player as he is combining ability and effort… but he has a 6 month deal and will get a better offer based on our current performance.
On paper, we have a squad that should be doing better, but that’s on paper. Breaking it down we have very few players with much reason to push on. Most are on the best contract they’re likely to receive, and those that are on an upward trajectory aren’t really good enough. Val’s stubbornness was not helping, but let’s not pretend everything can be fixed by getting rid of him. We have a rotten squad that’s being paid very handsomely based on past glories, and captained by a man who is onto his 7th manager having led us through a period of characterless regression.
This is a great post.
RE: Our Top 2 Squad - SW4Baggie - 02-10-2022
(02-10-2022, 08:13 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (02-10-2022, 04:51 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (02-10-2022, 12:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: There are players in this squad who during their career have played very well in the Championship and who have played in higher divisions; however too many of this squad are reliant on reputation alone now. Add into that we have some powerful voices in the dressing room who have been at the squad through our prolonged period of decline, offering very little.
On current form this squad has one Premier League quality player - Johnstone - and he leaves on a free in 4 months.
Bartley, Phillips, Livermore ought to be standing out at this level, but they’ve achieved as much as they are likely to in the game and know this contract will be their last big payday, and neither of them have shown any mental strength since signing.
Robinson, Townsend, Mowatt, Ajayi, Furlong, Reach, Button - all decent 6/10 championship players. Could arguably hold their own for a few games in the PL, but unlikely to ever get a move to beyond this level. With the exception of Mowatt, all have had a crack at the PL and probably know promotion will only result in being sold to a Champ side or warming the bench. Are mid-20s and have very little to prove.
O’Shea, Grady (and Dike at Barnsley) have the ability to play top flight football and have time on their side. All have been blighted with injury problems this season so haven’t had the impact we need.
Grant, Molumby, Clark, Kipré all have something to prove still. Unfortunately in Clark, the most promising of the 4 isn’t ours. Currently they’re Championship players and although they have some commitment to developing and improving, they’re likely to only ever be upper end Champ players, which is what we need now - and even on form they are not good enough to lift this sorry bunch.
Carroll - 33 and a crock, but currently our best player as he is combining ability and effort… but he has a 6 month deal and will get a better offer based on our current performance.
On paper, we have a squad that should be doing better, but that’s on paper. Breaking it down we have very few players with much reason to push on. Most are on the best contract they’re likely to receive, and those that are on an upward trajectory aren’t really good enough. Val’s stubbornness was not helping, but let’s not pretend everything can be fixed by getting rid of him. We have a rotten squad that’s being paid very handsomely based on past glories, and captained by a man who is onto his 7th manager having led us through a period of characterless regression.
That my friend is the post of the week/season absolutely spot on Sw4.
While I don't agree with all the individual points and not sure I agree with the lack of motivation, overall this post post is getting to the heart of the problem
To sun up we have a squad of players who were very good at this level in the past, some who have been ok at championship, but no more than that. A small number who hint at being very good and one player who is currently very good but will leave for nothing in the summer.
I don’t really remember writing this post - in true Minstrel fashion I was full of oysters and cava last night
I may have made some wild assumptions on motivations of individuals, but ultimately what I’m trying to say is that whilst we have the resources to be highly competitive, those resources are being wasted on expensive players that for the most part are well past their best, we’re never as good as we believed they were, or have physical/mental blocks preventing them from performing with any degree of regularity.
Whilst I take Derek’s point about “who has a better squad than us” - I reckon if we were to look to sell our players vs squads like Forest and Blackburn, I reckon they’d raise more than us. Just because we’ve spent a lot, and continue to spend a lot on this group of players doesn’t mean they’re necessarily worth it.
RE: Our Top 2 Squad - Shabby Russian - 02-10-2022
(02-10-2022, 08:34 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (02-10-2022, 08:13 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (02-10-2022, 04:51 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (02-10-2022, 12:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: There are players in this squad who during their career have played very well in the Championship and who have played in higher divisions; however too many of this squad are reliant on reputation alone now. Add into that we have some powerful voices in the dressing room who have been at the squad through our prolonged period of decline, offering very little.
On current form this squad has one Premier League quality player - Johnstone - and he leaves on a free in 4 months.
Bartley, Phillips, Livermore ought to be standing out at this level, but they’ve achieved as much as they are likely to in the game and know this contract will be their last big payday, and neither of them have shown any mental strength since signing.
Robinson, Townsend, Mowatt, Ajayi, Furlong, Reach, Button - all decent 6/10 championship players. Could arguably hold their own for a few games in the PL, but unlikely to ever get a move to beyond this level. With the exception of Mowatt, all have had a crack at the PL and probably know promotion will only result in being sold to a Champ side or warming the bench. Are mid-20s and have very little to prove.
O’Shea, Grady (and Dike at Barnsley) have the ability to play top flight football and have time on their side. All have been blighted with injury problems this season so haven’t had the impact we need.
Grant, Molumby, Clark, Kipré all have something to prove still. Unfortunately in Clark, the most promising of the 4 isn’t ours. Currently they’re Championship players and although they have some commitment to developing and improving, they’re likely to only ever be upper end Champ players, which is what we need now - and even on form they are not good enough to lift this sorry bunch.
Carroll - 33 and a crock, but currently our best player as he is combining ability and effort… but he has a 6 month deal and will get a better offer based on our current performance.
On paper, we have a squad that should be doing better, but that’s on paper. Breaking it down we have very few players with much reason to push on. Most are on the best contract they’re likely to receive, and those that are on an upward trajectory aren’t really good enough. Val’s stubbornness was not helping, but let’s not pretend everything can be fixed by getting rid of him. We have a rotten squad that’s being paid very handsomely based on past glories, and captained by a man who is onto his 7th manager having led us through a period of characterless regression.
That my friend is the post of the week/season absolutely spot on Sw4.
While I don't agree with all the individual points and not sure I agree with the lack of motivation, overall this post post is getting to the heart of the problem
To sun up we have a squad of players who were very good at this level in the past, some who have been ok at championship, but no more than that. A small number who hint at being very good and one player who is currently very good but will leave for nothing in the summer.
I don’t really remember writing this post - in true Minstrel fashion I was full of oysters and cava last night
I may have made some wild assumptions on motivations of individuals, but ultimately what I’m trying to say is that whilst we have the resources to be highly competitive, those resources are being wasted on expensive players that for the most part are well past their best, we’re never as good as we believed they were, or have physical/mental blocks preventing them from performing with any degree of regularity.
Whilst I take Derek’s point about “who has a better squad than us” - I reckon if we were to look to sell our players vs squads like Forest and Blackburn, I reckon they’d raise more than us. Just because we’ve spent a lot, and continue to spend a lot on this group of players doesn’t mean they’re necessarily worth it.
Last paragraph bang on the money.
I do agree with DH more than I disagree, but on this issue I don't . I can only assume he thinks the players we have will be the best because our resources st this level suggest we should have the best.
RE: Our Top 2 Squad - Mickyfudge - 02-10-2022
I think this season is a write off now ,hopefully dyke will we improve us ,then I think it needs a major clear out in the summer it’s obvious that a lot of these players have neither the ability or the heart that’s needed ,we are paying the price for some very poor recruitment
RE: Our Top 2 Squad - Sliced - 02-10-2022
Presumably it’s based on the fact that we were PL last season. That team was one of the most out of its depth Prem teams in history despite being supplemented in the midfield with genuine PL quality players and having the whole reason we were in the Prem in the first place Pereira.
The team we have at the moment is the one that was nowhere near being competitive in the Prem despite having the assistance of a few PL quality players in midfield. Sheff United weren’t competitive in the Prem either but they haven’t lost half of their first team from last year and, specifically, the best outfield players in their first team.
|