WBAUnofficial
Preston - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Preston (/showthread.php?tid=23655)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Preston - Derek Hardballs - 01-23-2022

(01-23-2022, 10:12 PM)Sliced Wrote: Derek, you know I think you’re a good poster, but you must be the only football fan Im aware of who seems to think that there are no statistics that can provide any information about how a game played out. I know of people who think that some statistics don’t mean much, but to say that all statistics are uninformative is bizarre.

I don’t think stats are useless. I do think there is far too much emphasis on them. Take these XG stats what great insight have given us that hasn’t been mentioned on here?


RE: Preston - SW4Baggie - 01-23-2022

(01-23-2022, 10:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 10:12 PM)Sliced Wrote: Derek, you know I think you’re a good poster, but you must be the only football fan Im aware of who seems to think that there are no statistics that can provide any information about how a game played out. I know of people who think that some statistics don’t mean much, but to say that all statistics are uninformative is bizarre.

I don’t think stats are useless. I do think there is far too much emphasis on them. Take these XG stats what great insight have given us that hasn’t been mentioned on here?

You’re an intelligent bloke Derek, but I think you’re being a little harsh on footballing metrics.

The purpose of these stats is not to give us great insight, it’s to make a very subjective field more objective. The purpose of xG is to evaluate effectiveness against the norm, not to tell us anything that can’t be seen by watching a match, it’s merely to try and allow comparison between several different players, playing in wildly differing circumstances. 

Looking at individual games on xG result is tongue in cheek, it’s not useful, but the trend of over/under performance and who’s great the gap is does tell us a lot about our inefficiency… far more so than some bloke in the Brummie Road claiming we’re shit. 

xG/xA/xT and all their derivatives allow us to understand how much poorer than other teams we are, and potentially isolate players that would improve us…I mean all these stats haven’t really hurt Brentford have they…


RE: Preston - Sliced - 01-23-2022

(01-23-2022, 10:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 10:12 PM)Sliced Wrote: Derek, you know I think you’re a good poster, but you must be the only football fan Im aware of who seems to think that there are no statistics that can provide any information about how a game played out. I know of people who think that some statistics don’t mean much, but to say that all statistics are uninformative is bizarre.

I don’t think stats are useless. I do think there is far too much emphasis on them. Take these XG stats what great insight have given us that hasn’t been mentioned on here?

I read on here yesterday that we had no good chances to score until the 78th minute.

That's the view of someone who is wrong and provably wrong by looking at the XG stats.

If you, as a subjective individual, see a game in a different way to someone else which happens literally every single game then why is your opinion more valid than theirs? XG is an imperfect metric, but it is a way of assessing the quality of chances that each team had. It isn't the be all and end all but "I can see it with my own eyes" is an overrated metric too given that no one can ever agree on the most fundamental things in a game


RE: Preston - WorcsWBA - 01-23-2022

As stats and data are irrelevant, then all the clubs employing analysts must clearly be wasting their time, money and effort! Big Grin


RE: Preston - baggie_ray - 01-23-2022

(01-23-2022, 11:29 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: As stats and data are irrelevant, then all the clubs employing analysts must clearly be wasting their time, money and effort! Big Grin

The clubs have been mis-sold the need for analysts. There'll be a glut of claims through the courts when they realise.


RE: Preston - Derek Hardballs - 01-24-2022

Lads it’s been fun Wink

Stats have their place, I just wanted to argue the case about their overuse and in some cases misuse. I don’t think they are as useful as some do but there is clearly a place for them. Just remember the only real stats that counts are the final score and the league total.


RE: Preston - Ted Maul - 01-24-2022

(01-23-2022, 11:14 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 10:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 10:12 PM)Sliced Wrote: Derek, you know I think you’re a good poster, but you must be the only football fan Im aware of who seems to think that there are no statistics that can provide any information about how a game played out. I know of people who think that some statistics don’t mean much, but to say that all statistics are uninformative is bizarre.

I don’t think stats are useless. I do think there is far too much emphasis on them. Take these XG stats what great insight have given us that hasn’t been mentioned on here?

I read on here yesterday that we had no good chances to score until the 78th minute.

That's the view of someone who is wrong and provably wrong by looking at the XG stats.

If you, as a subjective individual, see a game in a different way to someone else which happens literally every single game then why is your opinion more valid than theirs? XG is an imperfect metric, but it is a way of assessing the quality of chances that each team had. It isn't the be all and end all but "I can see it with my own eyes" is an overrated metric too given that no one can ever agree on the most fundamental things in a game

Another good post on the use of stats.

They've only been used (and used well) to prove the Val haters wrong. 

If folks are going to throw way statements about us not creating chances then they should take their medicine when proved wrong through the use of data and statistics.


RE: Preston - Malcolm Tucker - 01-24-2022

A final word on xG…

Only Fulham (58) have a higher xG than ours (50) this season. They’ve outperformed theirs by 15 goals, whilst we’ve ended up with 16 goals fewer than xG models suggest we should have. Fulham have Mitrovic up top, whilst we’ve had to put up with Hugill or a winger playing there.

Yes, the only stats that actually count are actual goals scored and conceded however comparisons between Val and Puliscunt are quite clearly utterly ridiculous.


RE: Preston - Derek Hardballs - 01-24-2022

(01-24-2022, 07:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 11:14 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 10:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 10:12 PM)Sliced Wrote: Derek, you know I think you’re a good poster, but you must be the only football fan Im aware of who seems to think that there are no statistics that can provide any information about how a game played out. I know of people who think that some statistics don’t mean much, but to say that all statistics are uninformative is bizarre.

I don’t think stats are useless. I do think there is far too much emphasis on them. Take these XG stats what great insight have given us that hasn’t been mentioned on here?

I read on here yesterday that we had no good chances to score until the 78th minute.

That's the view of someone who is wrong and provably wrong by looking at the XG stats.

If you, as a subjective individual, see a game in a different way to someone else which happens literally every single game then why is your opinion more valid than theirs? XG is an imperfect metric, but it is a way of assessing the quality of chances that each team had. It isn't the be all and end all but "I can see it with my own eyes" is an overrated metric too given that no one can ever agree on the most fundamental things in a game

Another good post on the use of stats.

They've only been used (and used well) to prove the Val haters wrong. 

If folks are going to throw way statements about us not creating chances then they should take their medicine when proved wrong through the use of data and statistics.

What stats have disproved what I have observed just watching the games and stated on here? 

What part of my stat free assessment over the last few weeks isn’t true?

We put poor crosses into the box
We have been very poor from set pieces
We have created poor quality chances but a lot of them
We haven’t scored enough goals
We don’t get enough players from midfield into the box to get on the end of crosses be they good, bad or indifferent
We have been playing in front of the opposition as they sit deep and we need more guile to break them down

I’m not a Val hater, frankly I couldn’t careless about any manager. I have however been critical of our tactics, results and performances this season. 

A few years ago possession stats were thrown about as proof we had played poorly under Pulis during the time when we finished in the top ten, they were used positively when we were relegated under Mowbray and now they could be used to say how well we played because we had the ball for the majority of the games we have played recently. The reality is, in most of those games the opposition didn’t really want to have the ball and were more than happy to catch us on the break. 

It’s a tool, it has its place but the argument that stats are more objective is a tad misleading because it’s humans that interpret and use them.

(01-24-2022, 08:48 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: A final word on xG…

Only Fulham (58) have a higher xG than ours (50) this season. They’ve outperformed theirs by 15 goals, whilst we’ve ended up with 16 goals fewer than xG models suggest we should have. Fulham have Mitrovic up top, whilst we’ve had to put up with Hugill or a winger playing there.

Yes, the only stats that actually count are actual goals scored and conceded however comparisons between Val and Puliscunt are quite clearly utterly ridiculous.

This is true, Pulis has achieved far more than Val has currently. I bet the XG figures were shite though.