WBAUnofficial
First post in a while…. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: First post in a while…. (/showthread.php?tid=23360)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: First post in a while…. - SW4Baggie - 01-03-2022

The biggest mistake IMO is Val’s underestimation of how defensive teams would play against us. It was naivety in the extreme to expect opposition sides to approach a team expected to win most games as they would one which was expected to lose most games. This lack of experience from Val, and those that appointed him resulted in the one dimensional squad additions and glaring weaknesses in our team.

However, we are trying to find a balance, and Val has been flexible in some of his approach whilst not wanting to veer too far from the principles that have brought him success previously. Whilst it’s not pretty, had refs not been inept, had Hugill not been shit and had Robinson been more clinical we would be comfortably in the automatic race.


RE: First post in a while…. - Pragmatist - 01-03-2022

It’s a bit misleading that the majority of the squad have seen off several managers. When Bilic was appointed in January 2019 I think only Johnstone, Bartley, Phillips, Livermore and Townsend were already here, and some of those only arrived in summer 2018.

It is more of an indictment of how many managers we have hired and fired in such a short period. There’s a board in the Richardson Suite entrance listing our managers and I think it showed we’ve had 9 in 10 years. Therein lies quite a problem - how on earth do we build any sort of identity of playing style and develop a squad to play that way if we are changing managers so often? Make a careful appointment decision and properly back the manager to deliver his plan.


RE: First post in a while…. - Crossbar11 - 01-03-2022

Not at all one for quick sackings but this bloke was a bad fit from day one , I don't blame VI as this is what he does .I look above him for appointing a manager using spreadsheets . What a mess .


RE: First post in a while…. - Squid - 01-04-2022

(01-03-2022, 10:37 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: It’s a bit misleading that the majority of the squad have seen off several managers. When Bilic was appointed in January 2019 I think only Johnstone, Bartley, Phillips, Livermore and Townsend were already here, and some of those only arrived in summer 2018.

It is more of an indictment of how many managers we have hired and fired in such a short period. There’s a board in the Richardson Suite entrance listing our managers and I think it showed we’ve had 9 in 10 years. Therein lies quite a problem - how on earth do we build any sort of identity of playing style and develop a squad to play that way if we are changing managers so often? Make a careful appointment decision and properly back the manager to deliver his plan.

Since Steve Clarke was sacked in 2013, which is now the best part of 10 years ago, we've essentially been swinging between PL survival mode and seeking promotion from the Championship mode. There has been barely any planning beyond the next transfer window.

It's not a sustainable way to run a football club long term and for all that we're self-sustaining with minimal debt, we've wasted a lot of money along the way. Luckily, many football clubs are run in an even more clueless manner, or we would find ourselves even further down the pecking order then we already are.

There are no football brains at the club, no grand planner and there hasn't been for a long time and it shows. The legacy of Nick Hammond - debt and relegation. The legacy of Luke Dowling spending too much money on the wrong players and major disruption to the academy.* For all that people look longingly at Chris Wilder, Steve Gibson will keep him on a tight leash. Wilder and Dowling would have been like kids in a sweet shop and I dread to think of some of the transfer business they would have done.

For all the wages we've paid to Hammond and Dowling, it's a damning indictment that our best recent transfer window was the one run by Big Dave and his phone book.

Where do we go from here? It's interesting but not surprising to hear about unhappiness at other clubs. The game has changed, not for the better, and except for a few golden clubs, football has become a grind for many fans. All something like VAR has produced is a new way to screw over smaller clubs for the benefit of the big teams.

*Albeit I think Richard Stevens is an excellent hire.


RE: First post in a while…. - coxy134 - 01-04-2022

(01-04-2022, 12:03 AM)Squid Wrote:
(01-03-2022, 10:37 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: It’s a bit misleading that the majority of the squad have seen off several managers.  When Bilic was appointed in January 2019 I think only Johnstone, Bartley, Phillips, Livermore and Townsend were already here, and some of those only arrived in summer 2018. 

It is more of an indictment of how many managers we have hired and fired in such a short period.  There’s a board in the Richardson Suite entrance listing our managers and I think it showed we’ve had 9 in 10 years.  Therein lies quite a problem - how on earth do we build any sort of identity of playing style and develop a squad to play that way if we are changing managers so often?  Make a careful appointment decision and properly back the manager to deliver his plan.

Since Steve Clarke was sacked in 2013, which is now the best part of 10 years ago, we've essentially been swinging between PL survival mode and seeking promotion from the Championship mode. There has been barely any planning beyond the next transfer window.

It's not a sustainable way to run a football club long term and for all that we're self-sustaining with minimal debt, we've wasted a lot of money along the way. Luckily, many football clubs are run in an even more clueless manner, or we would find ourselves even further down the pecking order then we already are.

There are no football brains at the club, no grand planner and there hasn't been for a long time and it shows. The legacy of Nick Hammond - debt and relegation. The legacy of Luke Dowling spending too much money on the wrong players and major disruption to the academy.* For all that people look longingly at Chris Wilder, Steve Gibson will keep him on a tight leash. Wilder and Dowling would have been like kids in a sweet shop and I dread to think of some of the transfer business they would have done.

For all the wages we've paid to Hammond and Dowling, it's a damning indictment that our best recent transfer window was the one run by Big Dave and his phone book.

Where do we go from here? It's interesting but not surprising to hear about unhappiness at other clubs. The game has changed, not for the better, and except for a few golden clubs, football has become a grind for many fans. All something like VAR has produced is a new way to screw over smaller clubs for the benefit of the big teams.

*Albeit I think Richard Stevens is an excellent hire.
Have to agree with all of that. I am backing VI at the moment but Saturday did get me a little worried. TGH and Fellows on the same side? It was obvious we were going to be weak, but does Diangana and Furlong offer us anymore at the moment?
Not sure if we can say the players are playing for the manager or they are simply not up to their best? Or is it just frustration and confindence?


RE: First post in a while…. - MassDebater - 01-04-2022

(01-03-2022, 04:04 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Normally with you Ronnie.

Not so much this one, though I have concerns.

Don't think it was possible to have a fan base not edgy at the moment. My Fulham supporting mate is saying how horrendous their fans are at the moment too, every goal conceded is a disaster, every loss or draw a reason to sack the manager. Just seems the way of everyone at the moment. I've seen man City fans calling for Pep to go....

I've said before, Vals basic principles I agree with heavily, my criticism will be that his lowered these to try to get us better in possession, but in doing so has weakened what he wanted us to do. This is partly borne from us having a squad totally ill-suited to his style, which begs the question, without a massive rebuild, why hire him?

Because Lai didn't want Wilder and so went for someone who had been getting plaudits for doing a great job with no money at a small club with no expectations. It's not like Lai and Ken (is he even still here?) have a clue how to run a football club is it? If they did there'd never have been a 4 year contract.


RE: First post in a while…. - Ted Maul - 01-04-2022

(01-03-2022, 03:56 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: I want VI gone. 

Sh** to watch.
Create very little (don’t give me that expected goals stat!).
Formation doesn’t suit what we have in squad.
Points tally is way off what it should be. 
We’re one dimensional. 
Crowds dropping - yes covid to blame for some but others are voting with feet. 
Home crowd more disillusioned than in a long time. 
Away crowd (which I love!) is turning.
Discipline gone to pot! Starts with the manager and he was a disgrace yesterday. 

25 games in and it’s been horrific this season. 

I don’t know what the answer is, that’s not my job, but I’ve had enough of VI. 

Up the baggies!

Stopped reading after you made a statement and then went on to disregard the facts that prove you wrong.


RE: First post in a while…. - ferencpuskas - 01-04-2022

(01-03-2022, 03:56 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: I want VI gone. 

Sh** to watch.
Create very little (don’t give me that expected goals stat!).
Formation doesn’t suit what we have in squad.
Points tally is way off what it should be. 
We’re one dimensional. 
Crowds dropping - yes covid to blame for some but others are voting with feet. 
Home crowd more disillusioned than in a long time. 
Away crowd (which I love!) is turning.
Discipline gone to pot! Starts with the manager and he was a disgrace yesterday. 

25 games in and it’s been horrific this season. 

I don’t know what the answer is, that’s not my job, but I’ve had enough of VI. 

Up the baggies!

Nice to see you back Ronnie ode pal, and another voice from the wilderness, talking sense. Perhaps enlightment will eventually dawn on a few more although don't hold yer breath .


RE: First post in a while…. - Birdman1811 - 01-04-2022

Nobody is giving Val a free ride.

I'm one of his most vocal supporters yet I've given criticism. Same as I've criticised every manager, even those I liked. I detest the sack the manager culture in football.

I see massive holes in our squad, which line up well with the issues we see during games. Therefore I find it hard to pin it all on the manager.

I said before he was appointed, our purist fans, the ones who dribble on about some mythical 'West Brom' way, will always hate it. But that's utterly irrelevant, it's a results business, right now he isn't getting them with consistency. One big hole has been plugged, so I'd expect to see an improvement.


RE: First post in a while…. - Tom Joad - 01-04-2022

Squid Wrote:
Pragmatist Wrote:It’s a bit misleading that the majority of the squad have seen off several managers.  When Bilic was appointed in January 2019 I think only Johnstone, Bartley, Phillips, Livermore and Townsend were already here, and some of those only arrived in summer 2018. 

It is more of an indictment of how many managers we have hired and fired in such a short period.  There’s a board in the Richardson Suite entrance listing our managers and I think it showed we’ve had 9 in 10 years.  Therein lies quite a problem - how on earth do we build any sort of identity of playing style and develop a squad to play that way if we are changing managers so often?  Make a careful appointment decision and properly back the manager to deliver his plan.

Since Steve Clarke was sacked in 2013, which is now the best part of 10 years ago, we've essentially been swinging between PL survival mode and seeking promotion from the Championship mode. There has been barely any planning beyond the next transfer window.

It's not a sustainable way to run a football club long term and for all that we're self-sustaining with minimal debt, we've wasted a lot of money along the way. Luckily, many football clubs are run in an even more clueless manner, or we would find ourselves even further down the pecking order then we already are.

There are no football brains at the club, no grand planner and there hasn't been for a long time and it shows. The legacy of Nick Hammond - debt and relegation. The legacy of Luke Dowling spending too much money on the wrong players and major disruption to the academy.* For all that people look longingly at Chris Wilder, Steve Gibson will keep him on a tight leash. Wilder and Dowling would have been like kids in a sweet shop and I dread to think of some of the transfer business they would have done.

For all the wages we've paid to Hammond and Dowling, it's a damning indictment that our best recent transfer window was the one run by Big Dave and his phone book.

Where do we go from here? It's interesting but not surprising to hear about unhappiness at other clubs. The game has changed, not for the better, and except for a few golden clubs, football has become a grind for many fans. All something like VAR has produced is a new way to screw over smaller clubs for the benefit of the big teams.

*Albeit I think Richard Stevens is an excellent hire.
Bang on, Squid. It's important to remember nearly ALL football fans are unhappy and the ones that aren't are only temporarily pleased. Expectations are way beyond anything that can be fulfilled in a game where there are only a few trophies available. We do ok considering we are self funding but unfortunately there are no plaudits for this, and that in itself is probably the biggest problem in the game.