RE: After 65 years of supporting.... - Birdman1811 - 10-16-2021
Worth noting too.
I didn't find last night boring, it was a fantastic tactical battle with some excellent defending on display (I did mention I prefer defending to attacking, it's far more tactically in depth.) So not all find it boring. I loved Italian football when a team scoring 2 gaols a game was free scoring....
RE: After 65 years of supporting.... - MassDebater - 10-16-2021
(10-16-2021, 03:16 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I ahve no issue with you sharing your opinion at all MD, as said, I disagree but see whaere you're coming from, but hyperbole like it being worse than the 90's is inexcusable. Honestly, it's a good thing I really loved football because fuck it was shit back then. There were times I thought my school team played better than West Brom, and several times I thought we could give them a game, we were dire, literally relying on one or two players who we were lucky to have to get us something, Taylor/Hunt/Sneekes/Hughes...
It just felt different back then, the fans seemed more accepting as long as the players tried. it felt more like a family band on the terraces (some night games it was barely even a large family!)
Maybe our expectations are now higher, I mean how much did our first eleven in 1993 earn per week compared to say Grady nowadays? The whole game below the early premiership was a totally different thing. I remember in those days having a loss completely ruin my weekends, even though it happened so often! Maybe I just cared more back then? Maybe it just meant more to me on a personal level then it does this season, I think if the continued boring dross continues that I may well stop going again. Maybe it is all down to a personal thing I am far more detached from it than I ever felt in the 90s?
I think it was Spandau who started that has football had its day thread, and maybe I'm approaching that level?
RE: After 65 years of supporting.... - Loanee - 10-16-2021
There were games under Pulis where we’d have no shots on goal.
In every game, apart from Stoke, we’ve dominated the opposition and have double figures of shots.
ARE YOU NOT ENTERTAINED?!
RE: After 65 years of supporting.... - Derek Hardballs - 10-16-2021
(10-16-2021, 03:13 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-16-2021, 03:03 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I didn't go last night and couldn't bring myself to watch it. My dad phoned me at the end, and he was annoyed with the pile of crap he'd watched. I said, let me guess; we lumped it forward, rushed at it, and there was no end product and it was boring. He said exactly. I replied, it's like bad parks football, hoof and chase, and that the fact i didn't watch it and described it pretty accurately shows how crap it is.
He actually said he thought it was the worst he'd ever seen, I said come on we had Pulis, which he agreed was worse. He's been a fan since the 1950s, he thinks it's an utter shambles and utterly boring to watch. We both agreed that getting promoted with this side, manager and 'way of playing' could see us doing worse than Derby did.
Some of us need more than just winning, which I know is an unpopular view on here. Six has his work cut out and needs to provide more than flukey wins.
They aren’t flukey wins and what were you and your Dad doing in the 90s? It couldn’t have been watching us getting thrashed by the likes of Stockport and Crewe or embarrassing ourselves against Halifax and Woking etc. I respect the fact you don’t like the style of play but not the hyperbole.
Indeed.
I get as I said, that football purists are not going to like it, those that love possession, delicate passing and creative flair throughout the midfield are not going to like this at all. And that's fine, so long as they accept that so long as we're getting results the manager is doing the job he is paid to do. It's a results based business, if you need entertainment, may I suggest wrestling or the cinema?
I see no evidence to say why we'd fail in the prem because of how we play. With current personnel, yes, but until I see who we sign I won't make any predictions on that count, in fact, considering most prem teams prefer to hold possession and play out from the back, would suit us more than the Champ where teams want rid of it far more quickly. So as said, I'll make predictions and worry / get excited about that when and if we get there!
But anyone saying this is worse than under Buckley, Little, Pardew... I'm sorry, football isn't the sport for you or you're just whining because it's not the style you like, and that is sad. I didn't whine about Bilic's teams holding on to the ball too long while results were good, which I hated as much as some hate this. Because, results were good.
As I've stated many times, maybe it's age (could be similar with Ferenc and others too?), we just want more from the match, but obviously only you and the win is all that matters brigade are the only ones who are allowed to watch the game, because obviously only your opinion counts.
I'm all for giving credit where it is due and did so when we played Sheff Utd and Cardiff off the park (and 70 minutes v Luton), but that also means when we play shyte then I'll say that too. If you recall I said against Bournemouth that this style is easily countered, by just not holding onto the ball, I wish I had been wrong, but that'll be me watching something else that gave me that obvious knowledge.
Moore and Bilic showed that you can play decent / entertaining football and get results. Fulham and Bournemouth also seem to be having no issues doing it either.
For me, Six is a few bad results away from being lumped in with Pulis and that would be sad and unfair on him. I see what he is trying to do, and it can work and provide some excitement, sadly he just seems to not be aware that the opposition are allowed to change how they usually play to counter it. Which is a kind of compliment to Six and the team, but it's getting very boring and getting even more boring saying exactly the same things even when we eke out a win.
I've not felt like I missed out on not going to a match since Pulis was here, when I could just check the results and know I'd not missed anything, Six is currently heading in that direction for me. At the moment it's purely results football, i.e. just check and hope we won after its over without needing to watch it to annoy yourself. I've seen glimpses to know we can play better, but we just seem to fall into the same no ideas so hoof it trap when the opposition set up to counter us.
(10-16-2021, 03:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:59 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-16-2021, 02:45 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I didn't go last night and couldn't bring myself to watch it. My dad phoned me at the end, and he was annoyed with the pile of crap he'd watched. I said, let me guess; we lumped it forward, rushed at it, and there was no end product and it was boring. He said exactly. I replied, it's like bad parks football, hoof and chase, and that the fact i didn't watch it and described it pretty accurately shows how crap it is.
He actually said he thought it was the worst he'd ever seen, I said come on we had Pulis, which he agreed was worse. He's been a fan since the 1950s, he thinks it's an utter shambles and utterly boring to watch. We both agreed that getting promoted with this side, manager and 'way of playing' could see us doing worse than Derby did.
Some of us need more than just winning, which I know is an unpopular view on here. Six has his work cut out and needs to provide more than flukey wins.
They aren’t flukey wins and what were you and your Dad doing in the 90s? It couldn’t have been watching us getting thrashed by the likes of Stockport and Crewe or embarrassing ourselves against Halifax and Woking etc.
We were there. Whilst it was shyte back then, it never ever felt boring. Most of the stuff served up by Six has been boring, interspersed with a few bits of excitement. I'd say there's been about 30% of games this season that I've enjoyed. Football was a different beast back in the 90s, and I always enjoyed going even when we were utter shyte, maybe it's an age thing and the realisation that promotion is only good for the club's finances. I'm long past the winning is all that counts mentality, as what will that actually get us?
I've not felt this disconnected from enjoying the games since Pulis, who completely stopped me going for a good while. Last night I cheered when I heard we'd scored, but since it was 75 minutes in and I'd checked the stats at half time, I just knew it was another load of turgid crap. When you don't even need to watch it to know it's bad, then something is not right.
The 90s were embarrassing and our gates for run of the mill games back this up. My old school struggled to give tickets away for free. The 90s ingeneral were great fun though 
See it's weird, I only ever felt embarrassed vs Woking, the rest I was always proud. Our gates were low, but my dad and I virtually never missed a single game. These days I'm more likely to not bust a gut to go, god knows how Cornish does it.
I came away from games angry and embarrassed many, many times. We had pockets of hope via the odd player and manager as Birdie said but I was so close to giving up on the club the season Megson saved us. It was cringeworthy shite. I remember one game against Port Vale, freezing cold, misty, three quarters of the ground empty drawing 1-1 (I think) and the only entertainment was a middle aged out of shape streaker. It was absolutely piss poor. I can remember my Dad saying if it makes you this angry / miserable then why do we bother going? He made a very good point.
The fans that went weren’t that tolerant, protests, boo’s, three quarter empty stadiums were normal.
RE: After 65 years of supporting.... - Birdman1811 - 10-16-2021
(10-16-2021, 03:23 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-16-2021, 03:16 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I ahve no issue with you sharing your opinion at all MD, as said, I disagree but see whaere you're coming from, but hyperbole like it being worse than the 90's is inexcusable. Honestly, it's a good thing I really loved football because fuck it was shit back then. There were times I thought my school team played better than West Brom, and several times I thought we could give them a game, we were dire, literally relying on one or two players who we were lucky to have to get us something, Taylor/Hunt/Sneekes/Hughes...
It just felt different back then, the fans seemed more accepting as long as the players tried. it felt more like a family band on the terraces (some night games it was barely even a large family!)
Maybe our expectations are now higher, I mean how much did our first eleven in 1993 earn per week compared to say Grady nowadays? The whole game below the early premiership was a totally different thing. I remember in those days having a loss completely ruin my weekends, even though it happened so often! Maybe I just cared more back then? Maybe it just meant more to me on a personal level then it does this season, I think if the continued boring dross continues that I may well stop going again. Maybe it is all down to a personal thing I am far more detached from it than I ever felt in the 90s?
I think it was Spandau who started that has football had its day thread, and maybe I'm approaching that level?
I think that's more the issue MD, and that's fine. I struggle with a lot of modern football, for those who saw the old days where it was competetive, the atmosphere was different, less obnoxious media around it... It must seem a very different time, and not better that's for sure.
RE: After 65 years of supporting.... - MassDebater - 10-16-2021
(10-16-2021, 03:18 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: But I said NEED entertainment for a reason, it's absolutely fine to want it, and I get that totally. But needing it for you to like the manager when he's getting results, is to me, non sensical.
I'm one of those who is happy and proud of a valiant and well played loss than a turgid grindy result against (on paper) lower quality opposition. It was different in the Prem when we were the lower quality and so had to grind it out and cling on. I enjoyed what Woy did massively for example.
I guess that's one of the things annoying me this year, the likes of Blues were borderline out of business and yet we struggled against them, ditto (even more nearly out of business) Derby... No, I do not expect to sweep all sides aside, but right now we are struggling against teams who should be/ are lower half. that's my greatest concern, Six just does not seem to have a clue about countering their non-playing.
(10-16-2021, 03:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I came away from games angry and embarrassed many, many times. We had pockets of hope via the odd player and manager as Birdie said but I was so close to giving up on the club the season Megson saved us. It was cringeworthy shite. I remember one game against Port Vale, freezing cold, misty, three quarters of the ground empty drawing 1-1 (I think) and the only entertainment was a middle aged out of shape streaker. It was absolutely piss poor. I can remember my Dad saying if it makes you this angry / miserable then why do we bother going? He made a very good point.
The fans that went weren’t that tolerant, protests, boo’s, three quarter empty stadiums were normal.
Oh believe me the amount of times I came home and would have kicked a cat had we had one was high.
I'm well aware of how empty the grounds were, but that was football coming out of the violent 80s, football that was no longer in vogue and certainly not trendy. Back then if you told people you went to matches they expected you to be in some nazi group of skinhead boot boy gang or something. it was a very different game, and looking back I guess the Premiership did actually save a lot of clubs from going bump?
Protest wise, I recall the glass doors, the guy ripping up his season ticket on the pitch. Calls for the board to be fucked off or the manager to be sacked. Was there a sit in? I also remember a lot of gallows humour. Unlike you, at no point did I ever want to not go! Maybe I am a closet masochist?!
For me it was buying a house during the first Prem season that stopped me going after it. I still fondly remember the 6-0 (owen hat-trick) match from that season, which is a weird thing to have find memories about!
However this season we are top or thereabouts and people are booing because of how shyte it has been to watch (I have not booed), so it's clear that it can't just be old farts yearning for long gone, possibly never existing, days.
RE: After 65 years of supporting.... - Birdman1811 - 10-16-2021
(10-16-2021, 03:27 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-16-2021, 03:18 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: But I said NEED entertainment for a reason, it's absolutely fine to want it, and I get that totally. But needing it for you to like the manager when he's getting results, is to me, non sensical.
I'm one of those who is happy and proud of a valiant and well played loss than a turgid grindy result against (on paper) lower quality opposition. It was different in the Prem when we were the lower quality and so had to grind it out and cling on. I enjoyed what Woy did massively for example.
I guess that's one of the things annoying me this year, the likes of Blues were borderline out of business and yet we struggled against them, ditto (even more nearly out of business) Derby... No, I do not expect to sweep all sides aside, but right now we are struggling against teams who should be/ are lower half. that's my greatest concern, Six just does not seem to have a clue about countering their non-playing.
But that was often a complaint aimed at Roy on here, grinding results out against teams we expected to beat. Not from me, I loved the guy, turned us into an actual Premiership team.
I don't think it's a case of not knowing how to counter it, as much as we don't have the personnel to. We have a decent squad, don't get me wrong, but there is a lack of creativity and goal threat, however we play, no players similar to Pereira, Grady not even half what he was at his peak. I've asked a few times, how else, bearing in mind the key tenets Val wants, and got him the job, shall we play.
So with these as givens, how would anyone change things?
We must be direct, the team have now been drilled into being so, getting the ball into the final third quickly. Suddenly asking players to slow the tempo, keep the ball won't work, we'll lose possession even more arguably, in more dangerous areas. Maybe we should have kept Sawyers around so we can do this if required.
The opposition must have no time on the ball, due to our high line, it is important the opposition don't get time to pick passes through and over the defence, they need to be rushed so they make mistakes, over and under hit passes.
With them as the team 'philosophy', what the pre-season and weekly training is geared towards, with current personnel, what do people suggest, I'm genuinely interested, because I've struggled to come up with much different that would clearly change things.
RE: After 65 years of supporting.... - MassDebater - 10-16-2021
(10-16-2021, 03:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (10-16-2021, 03:23 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-16-2021, 03:16 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I ahve no issue with you sharing your opinion at all MD, as said, I disagree but see whaere you're coming from, but hyperbole like it being worse than the 90's is inexcusable. Honestly, it's a good thing I really loved football because fuck it was shit back then. There were times I thought my school team played better than West Brom, and several times I thought we could give them a game, we were dire, literally relying on one or two players who we were lucky to have to get us something, Taylor/Hunt/Sneekes/Hughes...
It just felt different back then, the fans seemed more accepting as long as the players tried. it felt more like a family band on the terraces (some night games it was barely even a large family!)
Maybe our expectations are now higher, I mean how much did our first eleven in 1993 earn per week compared to say Grady nowadays? The whole game below the early premiership was a totally different thing. I remember in those days having a loss completely ruin my weekends, even though it happened so often! Maybe I just cared more back then? Maybe it just meant more to me on a personal level then it does this season, I think if the continued boring dross continues that I may well stop going again. Maybe it is all down to a personal thing I am far more detached from it than I ever felt in the 90s?
I think it was Spandau who started that has football had its day thread, and maybe I'm approaching that level?
I think that's more the issue MD, and that's fine. I struggle with a lot of modern football, for those who saw the old days where it was competetive, the atmosphere was different, less obnoxious media around it... It must seem a very different time, and not better that's for sure.
Maybe also, from my point of view, after not going for many years for one reason and another and then getting hooked back on the drug and Big Dave coming in and making it feel more like it used to, as well as it being enjoyable football, then Slav spoiling me with his first half of the season (I too was annoyed at times by some of what he dished up). This season feels like the fans are detached again and it doesn't feel like we are part of it again. Even some of Six's interviews have hinted that he's not a fan of our fans and that he doesn't seem to care what a lot of them think, it just feels like another kick in the nads.
(10-16-2021, 03:37 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (10-16-2021, 03:27 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-16-2021, 03:18 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: But I said NEED entertainment for a reason, it's absolutely fine to want it, and I get that totally. But needing it for you to like the manager when he's getting results, is to me, non sensical.
I'm one of those who is happy and proud of a valiant and well played loss than a turgid grindy result against (on paper) lower quality opposition. It was different in the Prem when we were the lower quality and so had to grind it out and cling on. I enjoyed what Woy did massively for example.
I guess that's one of the things annoying me this year, the likes of Blues were borderline out of business and yet we struggled against them, ditto (even more nearly out of business) Derby... No, I do not expect to sweep all sides aside, but right now we are struggling against teams who should be/ are lower half. that's my greatest concern, Six just does not seem to have a clue about countering their non-playing.
But that was often a complaint aimed at Roy on here, grinding results out against teams we expected to beat. Not from me, I loved the guy, turned us into an actual Premiership team.
I don't think it's a case of not knowing how to counter it, as much as we don't have the personnel to. We have a decent squad, don't get me wrong, but there is a lack of creativity and goal threat, however we play, no players similar to Pereira, Grady not even half what he was at his peak. I've asked a few times, how else, bearing in mind the key tenets Val wants, and got him the job, shall we play.
So with these as givens, how would anyone change things?
We must be direct, the team have now been drilled into being so, getting the ball into the final third quickly. Suddenly asking players to slow the tempo, keep the ball won't work, we'll lose possession even more arguably, in more dangerous areas. Maybe we should have kept Sawyers around so we can do this if required.
The opposition must have no time on the ball, due to our high line, it is important the opposition don't get time to pick passes through and over the defence, they need to be rushed so they make mistakes, over and under hit passes.
With them as the team 'philosophy', what the pre-season and weekly training is geared towards, with current personnel, what do people suggest, I'm genuinely interested, because I've struggled to come up with much different that would clearly change things.
I thought Roy was one of our best ever managers that I've seen, I'd have given my arm for him to come back instead of Six.
I get where you are coming from with the 'with the players we have' point, however as with Six's tactics it's easily countered with, we have the team we have because of Six. He got players in to try and play his version of football. Our best player in over a decade was sold on the cheap, because he wouldn't fit into Six's way. Grady is a shadow of what we know he can be, is it because he's lost it or because he struggles with Six's way? Six laid out his plans, got the players in that he wanted, didn't think we needed a big number 9, his choice. It's all his choices.
I said the other week the sides that seem to most easily stop us are the ones who played Barnsley last year, so maybe they kind of know how rigid Six is? We definitely are missing Dara and a fully fit Grady, but we seem to be having more injuries this year than I can remember in many a long year. Which is probably down to Six's way.
How we tried playing against Cardiff is what I want to see more of, we passed it around, with purpose, instead of just lumping it up. So Six can change it, but seems to not want to.
Anyway I'm off out, been nice discussing things with you gents. Have a good rest of your weekend.
RE: After 65 years of supporting.... - Squid - 10-16-2021
(10-16-2021, 03:38 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-16-2021, 03:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (10-16-2021, 03:23 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-16-2021, 03:16 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I ahve no issue with you sharing your opinion at all MD, as said, I disagree but see whaere you're coming from, but hyperbole like it being worse than the 90's is inexcusable. Honestly, it's a good thing I really loved football because fuck it was shit back then. There were times I thought my school team played better than West Brom, and several times I thought we could give them a game, we were dire, literally relying on one or two players who we were lucky to have to get us something, Taylor/Hunt/Sneekes/Hughes...
It just felt different back then, the fans seemed more accepting as long as the players tried. it felt more like a family band on the terraces (some night games it was barely even a large family!)
Maybe our expectations are now higher, I mean how much did our first eleven in 1993 earn per week compared to say Grady nowadays? The whole game below the early premiership was a totally different thing. I remember in those days having a loss completely ruin my weekends, even though it happened so often! Maybe I just cared more back then? Maybe it just meant more to me on a personal level then it does this season, I think if the continued boring dross continues that I may well stop going again. Maybe it is all down to a personal thing I am far more detached from it than I ever felt in the 90s?
I think it was Spandau who started that has football had its day thread, and maybe I'm approaching that level?
I think that's more the issue MD, and that's fine. I struggle with a lot of modern football, for those who saw the old days where it was competetive, the atmosphere was different, less obnoxious media around it... It must seem a very different time, and not better that's for sure.
Maybe also, from my point of view, after not going for many years for one reason and another and then getting hooked back on the drug and Big Dave coming in and making it feel more like it used to, as well as it being enjoyable football, then Slav spoiling me with his first half of the season (I too was annoyed at times by some of what he dished up). This season feels like the fans are detached again and it doesn't feel like we are part of it again. Even some of Six's interviews have hinted that he's not a fan of our fans and that he doesn't seem to care what a lot of them think, it just feels like another kick in the nads.
(10-16-2021, 03:37 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (10-16-2021, 03:27 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-16-2021, 03:18 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: But I said NEED entertainment for a reason, it's absolutely fine to want it, and I get that totally. But needing it for you to like the manager when he's getting results, is to me, non sensical.
I'm one of those who is happy and proud of a valiant and well played loss than a turgid grindy result against (on paper) lower quality opposition. It was different in the Prem when we were the lower quality and so had to grind it out and cling on. I enjoyed what Woy did massively for example.
I guess that's one of the things annoying me this year, the likes of Blues were borderline out of business and yet we struggled against them, ditto (even more nearly out of business) Derby... No, I do not expect to sweep all sides aside, but right now we are struggling against teams who should be/ are lower half. that's my greatest concern, Six just does not seem to have a clue about countering their non-playing.
But that was often a complaint aimed at Roy on here, grinding results out against teams we expected to beat. Not from me, I loved the guy, turned us into an actual Premiership team.
I don't think it's a case of not knowing how to counter it, as much as we don't have the personnel to. We have a decent squad, don't get me wrong, but there is a lack of creativity and goal threat, however we play, no players similar to Pereira, Grady not even half what he was at his peak. I've asked a few times, how else, bearing in mind the key tenets Val wants, and got him the job, shall we play.
So with these as givens, how would anyone change things?
We must be direct, the team have now been drilled into being so, getting the ball into the final third quickly. Suddenly asking players to slow the tempo, keep the ball won't work, we'll lose possession even more arguably, in more dangerous areas. Maybe we should have kept Sawyers around so we can do this if required.
The opposition must have no time on the ball, due to our high line, it is important the opposition don't get time to pick passes through and over the defence, they need to be rushed so they make mistakes, over and under hit passes.
With them as the team 'philosophy', what the pre-season and weekly training is geared towards, with current personnel, what do people suggest, I'm genuinely interested, because I've struggled to come up with much different that would clearly change things.
I thought Roy was one of our best ever managers that I've seen, I'd have given my arm for him to come back instead of Six.
I get where you are coming from with the 'with the players we have' point, however as with Six's tactics it's easily countered with, we have the team we have because of Six. He got players in to try and play his version of football. Our best player in over a decade was sold on the cheap, because he wouldn't fit into Six's way. Grady is a shadow of what we know he can be, is it because he's lost it or because he struggles with Six's way? Six laid out his plans, got the players in that he wanted, didn't think we needed a big number 9, his choice. It's all his choices.
I said the other week the sides that seem to most easily stop us are the ones who played Barnsley last year, so maybe they kind of know how rigid Six is? We definitely are missing Dara and a fully fit Grady, but we seem to be having more injuries this year than I can remember in many a long year. Which is probably down to Six's way.
How we tried playing against Cardiff is what I want to see more of, we passed it around, with purpose, instead of just lumping it up. So Six can change it, but seems to not want to.
Anyway I'm off out, been nice discussing things with you gents. Have a good rest of your weekend.
1) The club were trying to sell Pereira in January. Pereira was absolutely desperate to leave, whoever the manager was. The price he was sold at has been debated endlessly, so I'll not dig that up again, but cannot be blamed on VI.
2) O'Shea broke his ankle in a horror tackle while playing for Ireland. Not sure how that is VI's fault. Clarke is injury-prone. Grady's hamstrings are from an injury which predates VI. Mowatt just seems like bad luck.
Some people seem to be actively casting about for excuses not to like VI and it's starting to make me feel rather uncomfortable.
RE: After 65 years of supporting.... - Birdman1811 - 10-16-2021
I think Val wanted a better No 9 btw, just none that were available in our, pathetic, budget.
I said before O'Shea is a big miss, not just defensively, he is surprisingly good at picking the right pass, and aiming headers into our players to pick up, also knows when to come forward and when to sit back, this style seems tailor made for him, losing him is a big problem imo.
|