WBAUnofficial
Reyes Cleary - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Reyes Cleary (/showthread.php?tid=21649)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Reyes Cleary - baggiebuckster - 11-11-2021

Saw him last Friday come on for 20 mins ago Wolves Under 23's. Even in that short period you could tell he had potential if a little raw. Looked a really powerful player who was always looking to make something happen.


RE: Reyes Cleary - Lillwall's left foot - 11-11-2021

(11-11-2021, 07:58 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 07:40 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 12:41 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Right after he scored another 2 for the U18's Saturday, just see this one ending badly unfortunately

Cuzer

I agree Cuz. 

Ready or not i just wonder, given our lack of quality number 9 options, if we don't make him a really decent contract offer and put him on the bench and get him involved. 

He might not sign it but at least we've got it in writing. Also giving him minutes will hopefully bump up his fee should he be poached. We did it with Izzy Brown when he was 16. 

Like I've said before if the best option off the bench is fucking Hugill then I really don't see any reason not to give the kid a shot. Not like he can be worse. He's bang in form at 18 and 23 level. We risk losing him anyway so I cant see we have much to lose and we can make more money out of the shite situation that are the bollocks EPP compensation rules.

Completely agree Peachy.

If these German clubs are interested , it's not because they plan to bury him in their youth system fir a couple of years.

Can see no downside to him being on the bench, and more importantly given some minutes. What is the worst that can happen.

One thing that consistently baffles fans is the reluctance of managers in general to try out the kids when experienced pros appear to be unfit, out of form or just out of their depth.    I get that career trajectories tell us that most players to.come through the academy arn't champ plus level but i do think it's the "What have we got to lose" bit that fans struggle with.  

From his recent presser Val made it clear he wants to bring the kids through, that's why all the teams are instructed to play with the same core strategy so they know their roles if called upon.  And tbf we have seen that allready with the debut for GH.  The difference being that he had obviously been monitored and coached into readiness, wheras by all accounts Cleary is raw and very unready so it would be more a case of throw him in and see what happens.

I was pleased to see Val addressing the fact that something needs to change regarding the loss of our youngsters, it will be interesting to see if that change comes soon enough for this new crop.


RE: Reyes Cleary - Cuzer - 11-11-2021

As I said in my earlier post, it’s against our policy to differentiate with youth contract offers, or has been up until now, hopefully we put the right deal on the table for him

Cuzer


RE: Reyes Cleary - GunsOfNavarone - 11-11-2021

(11-11-2021, 07:58 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 07:40 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 12:41 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Right after he scored another 2 for the U18's Saturday, just see this one ending badly unfortunately

Cuzer

I agree Cuz. 

Ready or not i just wonder, given our lack of quality number 9 options, if we don't make him a really decent contract offer and put him on the bench and get him involved. 

He might not sign it but at least we've got it in writing. Also giving him minutes will hopefully bump up his fee should he be poached. We did it with Izzy Brown when he was 16. 

Like I've said before if the best option off the bench is fucking Hugill then I really don't see any reason not to give the kid a shot. Not like he can be worse. He's bang in form at 18 and 23 level. We risk losing him anyway so I cant see we have much to lose and we can make more money out of the shite situation that are the bollocks EPP compensation rules.

Completely agree Peachy.

If these German clubs are interested , it's not because they plan to bury him in their youth system fir a couple of years.

Can see no downside to him being on the bench, and more importantly given some minutes. What is the worst that can happen.

Re bold text.

I suppose he could refuse the offer of featuring on the bench or having a run out so future compensation stays as low as possible. If this were to happen it would set an example for others to follow.

For the record I am not suggesting for one moment that Reyes Cleary or his 'representatives' would stoop so low as to stiff the Albion/look out for his 'best financial interests' moving forward.......


RE: Reyes Cleary - Pragmatist - 11-11-2021

(11-11-2021, 08:41 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 07:58 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 07:40 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 12:41 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Right after he scored another 2 for the U18's Saturday, just see this one ending badly unfortunately

Cuzer

I agree Cuz. 

Ready or not i just wonder, given our lack of quality number 9 options, if we don't make him a really decent contract offer and put him on the bench and get him involved. 

He might not sign it but at least we've got it in writing. Also giving him minutes will hopefully bump up his fee should he be poached. We did it with Izzy Brown when he was 16. 

Like I've said before if the best option off the bench is fucking Hugill then I really don't see any reason not to give the kid a shot. Not like he can be worse. He's bang in form at 18 and 23 level. We risk losing him anyway so I cant see we have much to lose and we can make more money out of the shite situation that are the bollocks EPP compensation rules.

Completely agree Peachy.

If these German clubs are interested , it's not because they plan to bury him in their youth system fir a couple of years.

Can see no downside to him being on the bench, and more importantly given some minutes. What is the worst that can happen.

Re bold text.

I suppose he could refuse the offer of featuring on the bench or having a run out so future compensation stays as low as possible. If this were to happen it would set an example for others to follow.

For the record I am not suggesting for one moment that Reyes Cleary or his 'representatives' would stoop so low as to stiff the Albion/look out for his 'best financial interests' moving forward.......

If he moves outside of England, even to Scotland, the compensation is fixed at a paltry sum regardless of any first team involvement.  It is only if he moves within England that a tribunal will take other factors account and I’ve lost all faith in that after Ferguson. 

We need to take a punt and offer the better youngsters 3-year deals at the right time.  By the time we think about it the scouts from elsewhere have already tapped up these kids and told them not to sign a deal with us. 

We simply have got to up our game re how we deal with our top Academy youngsters.  We will win some and lose some, but a few winners can transform the club.


RE: Reyes Cleary - Lillwall's left foot - 11-11-2021

(11-11-2021, 08:57 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 08:41 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 07:58 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 07:40 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 12:41 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Right after he scored another 2 for the U18's Saturday, just see this one ending badly unfortunately

Cuzer

I agree Cuz. 

Ready or not i just wonder, given our lack of quality number 9 options, if we don't make him a really decent contract offer and put him on the bench and get him involved. 

He might not sign it but at least we've got it in writing. Also giving him minutes will hopefully bump up his fee should he be poached. We did it with Izzy Brown when he was 16. 

Like I've said before if the best option off the bench is fucking Hugill then I really don't see any reason not to give the kid a shot. Not like he can be worse. He's bang in form at 18 and 23 level. We risk losing him anyway so I cant see we have much to lose and we can make more money out of the shite situation that are the bollocks EPP compensation rules.

Completely agree Peachy.

If these German clubs are interested , it's not because they plan to bury him in their youth system fir a couple of years.

Can see no downside to him being on the bench, and more importantly given some minutes. What is the worst that can happen.

Re bold text.

I suppose he could refuse the offer of featuring on the bench or having a run out so future compensation stays as low as possible. If this were to happen it would set an example for others to follow.

For the record I am not suggesting for one moment that Reyes Cleary or his 'representatives' would stoop so low as to stiff the Albion/look out for his 'best financial interests' moving forward.......

If he moves outside of England, even to Scotland, the compensation is fixed at a paltry sum regardless of any first team involvement.  It is only if he moves within England that a tribunal will take other factors account and I’ve lost all faith in that after Ferguson. 

We need to take a punt and offer the better youngsters 3-year deals at the right time.  By the time we think about it the scouts from elsewhere have already tapped up these kids and told them not to sign a deal with us. 

We simply have got to up our game re how we deal with our top Academy youngsters.  We will win some and lose some, but a few winners can transform the club.

This.  We need to gamble a bit more in the hope of hitting the occasional jackpot.


RE: Reyes Cleary - GunsOfNavarone - 11-11-2021

(11-11-2021, 08:57 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 08:41 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 07:58 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 07:40 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(11-11-2021, 12:41 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Right after he scored another 2 for the U18's Saturday, just see this one ending badly unfortunately

Cuzer

I agree Cuz. 

Ready or not i just wonder, given our lack of quality number 9 options, if we don't make him a really decent contract offer and put him on the bench and get him involved. 

He might not sign it but at least we've got it in writing. Also giving him minutes will hopefully bump up his fee should he be poached. We did it with Izzy Brown when he was 16. 

Like I've said before if the best option off the bench is fucking Hugill then I really don't see any reason not to give the kid a shot. Not like he can be worse. He's bang in form at 18 and 23 level. We risk losing him anyway so I cant see we have much to lose and we can make more money out of the shite situation that are the bollocks EPP compensation rules.

Completely agree Peachy.

If these German clubs are interested , it's not because they plan to bury him in their youth system fir a couple of years.

Can see no downside to him being on the bench, and more importantly given some minutes. What is the worst that can happen.

Re bold text.

I suppose he could refuse the offer of featuring on the bench or having a run out so future compensation stays as low as possible. If this were to happen it would set an example for others to follow.

For the record I am not suggesting for one moment that Reyes Cleary or his 'representatives' would stoop so low as to stiff the Albion/look out for his 'best financial interests' moving forward.......

If he moves outside of England, even to Scotland, the compensation is fixed at a paltry sum regardless of any first team involvement.  It is only if he moves within England that a tribunal will take other factors account and I’ve lost all faith in that after Ferguson. 

We need to take a punt and offer the better youngsters 3-year deals at the right time.  By the time we think about it the scouts from elsewhere have already tapped up these kids and told them not to sign a deal with us. 

We simply have got to up our game re how we deal with our top Academy youngsters.  We will win some and lose some, but a few winners can transform the club.

I know about the differences between foreign and domestic compensation. I was suggesting it as a worst case scenario in relation to the example it could set for others should they wish to remain based in England.

Completely agree with everything you say regarding contract offers with a couple of caveats. Players within such age ranges are as likely (at least) to drop off a cliff developmentally as they are to go all the way.

To the best of my knowledge we simply don't have the financial means to be offering lucrative three year contracts to numerous academy players. The only way this happens is to trim the first team squad further to finance youth while providing a clearer pathway. 

On the face of it that's great. But what happens when you've further weakened the first team squad and their younger replacements simply can't hack it? The way things are going ownership and finance wise we're coming to a time when we're going to have to find out.


RE: Reyes Cleary - MrFizz - 11-11-2021

The Great Yoof Conundrum.

Everyone loves to see 'one of our own' break through and do well, but how do you identify those that can, and when do you put them in?

I've always thought it less risky to blood youngsters in forward positions as mistakes are less costly. Putting in an 18yr old CH could cost you dearly as a mistake can easily lead you to lose a goal.

I would have no issue with someone like Cleary being on the bench. Why not throw on a kid with 15mins left if the established pro's aren't getting it done? I remember a raw young man called Hughes coming on in just that fashion......


RE: Reyes Cleary - rsbaggy2 - 11-11-2021

(11-11-2021, 09:37 AM)MrFizz Wrote: The Great Yoof Conundrum.

Everyone loves to see 'one of our own' break through and do well, but how do you identify those that can, and when do you put them in?

I've always thought it less risky to blood youngsters in forward positions as mistakes are less costly. Putting in an 18yr old CH could cost you dearly as a mistake can easily lead you to lose a goal.

I would have no issue with someone like Cleary being on the bench. Why not throw on a kid with 15mins left if the established pro's aren't getting it done? I remember a raw young man called Hughes coming on in just that fashion......

Regis is the one that comes to my mind.


RE: Reyes Cleary - Squid - 11-11-2021

Adding to the conundrum is that getting a contract might go completely to some player's heads. Look at Harper.