WBAUnofficial
Dike - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Dike (/showthread.php?tid=20831)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Dike - SW4Baggie - 08-26-2021

(08-26-2021, 02:46 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-26-2021, 02:05 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-26-2021, 01:36 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-26-2021, 12:50 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-26-2021, 12:32 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I have massive concerns over our recruitment, trust me. Sadly until ownership changes, we won't see a change. Dowling, who I defended way too much tbh, having seen what's been left after his watch really fucked us up.

Left in terms of players or in terms of finances? 

The issue with assessing the likes of Dowling is that a certain clique of fan (who seem to actively despise the club anyway) never had anything good to say about him, but then unless Ashworth returned, it's unlikely they'd say anything good about anyone in that role.

Both.

If the Chinese owners get one thing right this summer, sacking him was it.

Still a bit vague there as to what Dowling got wrong. Transfer-wise he had hits and misses like anyone. Finances-wise it all seems a bit murky any way. At least he didn't do anything ludicrously stupid like sign Oli Burke for £15 million or sign players without flexdown (like fans were clamouring for us to do for Troy Deeney(.

I would agree that he completely seemed to lose his head over getting the next manager and couldn't see past Wilder and should have really known a lot sooner that Wilder wasn't going to be approved by Lai.

The more I think about the catastrophe that was last summer, when we threw any chance of survival down the drain, the happier I am for anyone involved to no longer be at the club. However, had Dowling done the correct thing and sacked Bilic that summer there would have been absolute fan meltdown, so it's a tricky situation all around.

Obviously last summer was just a cluster fuck, both Bilic and Dowling to blame. 

Dowling left nothing that could be classed as a legacy, apart from killing off a good generation of academy players. Money invested in players will probably never be recouped and we significantly overpaid on too many purchases. His illegal idea about selling Pereira helped to lead to this summers cheap selling of our best asset.

There is very little he did good here, and arguably was yet another hammer blow to what was good at the club.

We are pretty much back to before Mowbray turned up on the road to where we ended up. Long way away.

I dont want to defend LD as he certainly made mistakes but I think you may be attributing decisions to him that were well above his pay grade there Birdie.

Absolutely no incentive for LD to facilitate the MP deal without encouragement from above, and regardless of the chances LD made in the academy the team there would have upped and gone to Villa… The seals  pretty much tripled their salary, hugely increased their budget and have invested in a massive new state of the art academy facility… the LD mess gave them a nice story to cover the fact they joined the local cash cow and then stole our best players.


RE: Dike - Birdman1811 - 08-26-2021

(08-26-2021, 03:29 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-26-2021, 02:46 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-26-2021, 02:05 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-26-2021, 01:36 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-26-2021, 12:50 PM)Squid Wrote: Left in terms of players or in terms of finances? 

The issue with assessing the likes of Dowling is that a certain clique of fan (who seem to actively despise the club anyway) never had anything good to say about him, but then unless Ashworth returned, it's unlikely they'd say anything good about anyone in that role.

Both.

If the Chinese owners get one thing right this summer, sacking him was it.

Still a bit vague there as to what Dowling got wrong. Transfer-wise he had hits and misses like anyone. Finances-wise it all seems a bit murky any way. At least he didn't do anything ludicrously stupid like sign Oli Burke for £15 million or sign players without flexdown (like fans were clamouring for us to do for Troy Deeney(.

I would agree that he completely seemed to lose his head over getting the next manager and couldn't see past Wilder and should have really known a lot sooner that Wilder wasn't going to be approved by Lai.

The more I think about the catastrophe that was last summer, when we threw any chance of survival down the drain, the happier I am for anyone involved to no longer be at the club. However, had Dowling done the correct thing and sacked Bilic that summer there would have been absolute fan meltdown, so it's a tricky situation all around.

Obviously last summer was just a cluster fuck, both Bilic and Dowling to blame. 

Dowling left nothing that could be classed as a legacy, apart from killing off a good generation of academy players. Money invested in players will probably never be recouped and we significantly overpaid on too many purchases. His illegal idea about selling Pereira helped to lead to this summers cheap selling of our best asset.

There is very little he did good here, and arguably was yet another hammer blow to what was good at the club.

We are pretty much back to before Mowbray turned up on the road to where we ended up. Long way away.

I appreciate the detailed response, but there still doesn't seem to be that much substance to it.

Point by point:

1)Dowling left nothing that could be classed as a legacy

Hard to leave any legacy when we barely plan beyond the current season

2) apart from killing off a good generation of academy players

How? Which players? The likes of Harper and Edwards were given opportunities and didn't take them. If this is about the academy staff crying about their ill-treatment while they pocket their massive salary increases at the hands of our biggest rival then I've got even less patience for it.  Richard Stevens has got an excellent record and most academies would be delighted to have him.

3) Money invested in players will probably never be recouped and we significantly overpaid on too many purchases.

I can think of three where we overpaid, four if you include Austin, which I don't as he did what he was supposed to do and helped us towards promotion. Zohore, Grant and arguably Diangana, although everyone thought that was a great deal at the time and he still might come good for us. Furlong, Ajayi and Sawyers were all pretty reasonably. £1.5 in particular for Ajayi was a steal.

No worries, let me explain further.

1. Dowling was the one who set the short term policy, yes budgetary constraints were part of the reason, but he absolutely loves loans rather than purchases, that hurt us.

2. Thankfully yes, the Academy is in good hands again, however we lost some good players and staff due to Dowlings pig headedness, not what he did, but his attitude to people was very poor. Friends of the Terry's, enough said 

3. I'd also agree Austin was fine, Grant, Zohore and Grady though, overpaid. I can understand Grady, a mistake anyone in that situation could make. But Zohore was only due to shared agents. No one at the club thought signing him was a good idea, yet Dowling just did it. Grant was a Bilic driven transfer yes, but Dowling could gave just said no. Hopefully he can kick on though, not any issue with the player himself.

Overall, as said, not an impressive time here for him. Not helped by current ownership either mind you.