![]() |
|
Pensions - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Pensions (/showthread.php?tid=20749) |
RE: Pensions - Birdman1811 - 09-08-2021 (09-08-2021, 09:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Of course there are exceptions at either end of the financial scale but to argue that those retiring now or recently haven’t had it far easier than the generations after them is defensive nonsense. Relatively secure jobs, clearer career ladders, decent work pensions, affordable housing, decent jobs not dependant on gaining a degree. What have those younger than them have now? Insecure jobs in many sectors, no real career ladders in many sectors, non existent pension schemes offered by many employers, affordable housing paha! Saddled with debt for gaining a degree and working hard at school. You can now add the idiotic decision to leave the EU to the list of the older generations saddling the younger generations with a decisions they don’t support and are not to their advantage. Well I agree with you. And it's exactly what my parents, both in my 60's say too. They still vote Tory, but while saying they've fucked everything up.... RE: Pensions - Fido - 09-08-2021 (09-08-2021, 09:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Of course there are exceptions at either end of the financial scale but to argue that those retiring now or recently haven’t had it far easier than the generations after them is defensive nonsense. Relatively secure jobs, clearer career ladders, decent work pensions, affordable housing, decent jobs not dependant on gaining a degree. What have those younger than them have now? Insecure jobs in many sectors, no real career ladders in many sectors, non existent pension schemes offered by many employers, affordable housing paha! Saddled with debt for gaining a degree and working hard at school. You can now add the idiotic decision to leave the EU to the list of the older generations saddling the younger generations with a decisions they don’t support and are not to their advantage. Agree with the first paragraph but lo and behold you've thrown in a wee jab at Brexit which is completely redundant (quelle surprise). Remember this "more privileged" group were those that voted to enter the EEC in the first place. Means testing would not be easy by any means and, of course, in no way perfect. But there has to be some kind of progressive "taxation" element if we are looking to care for all when some are far more able to pay and some not at all. But the gears do need to be put in motion quickly so we try and combat this from when people first start to earn otherwise we'll constantly be chasing our tails. RE: Pensions - Birdman1811 - 09-08-2021 All benefits should be means tested, my Dad always says its dumb how he now has free prescriptions while earning more than me still for example, just because he's over 65. State pension should be only for those without suitable provision or assets to fund retirement. RE: Pensions - Fido - 09-08-2021 (09-08-2021, 09:51 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: All benefits should be means tested, my Dad always says its dumb how he now has free prescriptions while earning more than me still for example, just because he's over 65. Agree but that should be a gradual goal for future generations; we're far, far away from that at the moment financially. RE: Pensions - Tom Joad - 09-08-2021 Again there are arguments based on false assumptions. As I said, not one of my contemporaries went to university. Most started work at 15. Again, most have worked in building or similar trades where there are insecure contracts and no pensions. A working life of 50 years deserves a pension. How old are all those on here saying the older generation fucked it up by electing selfish governments? Have they not voted these last 20+ years? I've never voted tory but for me, increasing NI and tax is one of the very few sensible things this lot have ever done. Remember those nasty buggers that are coming up for retirement used to pay a much higher tax rate. They also cleared the debt from WW2. Swings and roundabouts. I see a lot of ire here and very little personal responsibility. If I wanted to be more provocative I'd add that my generation took to the streets every opportunity, campaigned against unworthy wars, apartheid, the poll tax and formed rock against racism. Never once stopping to have Deliveroo drop off a Greg's pasty nor spending time ordering stuff online from the world champion tax dodgers. Put the tax up, I say. Let's live in a more civilised society. RE: Pensions - Birdman1811 - 09-08-2021 I have no issue with tax increases when applied fairly. This one isn't, that's my issue. Actually, that's a lie, I do because the government spend money it steals so inefficiently its criminal. But if it was spent efficiently and sensibly, and collected in a progressive manner, I'm all for it. I've never voted Tory or Labour in my life I'm delighted to say, both have proven to be incapable of governing. And I vote at every opportunity, even though I'm very disillusioned with it all. It is financially impossible for me to own a house until my parents die and I get that inheritance, if its still there when that happens. With paying rent and standard living costs, on an about average salary, I can't save for a deposit, ever. My parents bought a house for a couple of grand when they got married, that's an example how the game has got so rigged against us. I've mentioned before in other threads how people now are still voting against their best interest based on soundbites and an inability to actually read and understand data. I've always been a proponent of 2 things. Wealth tax, rather than income tax, and Universal Basic Income. With that the government can step away from controlling our lives, everyone has at least a good chance of success, and employers aren't able to bully staff into accepting shit to prop up their crappy business plan. RE: Pensions - Borin' Baggie - 09-08-2021 (09-08-2021, 12:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Again there are arguments based on false assumptions. As I said, not one of my contemporaries went to university. Most started work at 15. Again, most have worked in building or similar trades where there are insecure contracts and no pensions. A working life of 50 years deserves a pension. How old are all those on here saying the older generation fucked it up by electing selfish governments? Have they not voted these last 20+ years? First point (regarding the issue of working at 15) the school leaving age was lower so kids didn't need to be in full time education until they are 18 like now (so you could actually and legally get a job full time), the population age was lower so it was easier to get a job due to roles opening up more frequently, job application processes were simpler, apprenticeships were more common as was the expectation of learning on the job and the UK was more industrialised so the variety of jobs were more open at the bottom end to lower skill work. I have worked since I was 17, I worked part time through and over the summer while I was at uni. I had 40 rejections before I got a job when I was in sixth form, I couldn't get a job over the summer I did my GCSE's despite trying and the change in environment of work essentially means that training on the job is outsourced to universities for a lot of vocational courses and even some things like engineering (programming and design engineering as two examples). The environment is completely different. Second point, where has anybody suggested scrapping the state pension? The issue is that the state pension is a benefit (this is indisputable) and unsustainable with an aging population and cuts to public spending so needs to be adjusted to be means tested as it is in other countries to ensure those at the bottom get what they need and it is scaled up while being affordable. The UK has a ridiculously high number of pensioners in both relative and absolute poverty but it also has average pensioner income (private, public and schemes) in-line with comparable EU nations (Germany, Netherlands etc.) and then there are benefits paid on top of that, not to mention concentration of wealth. That is a fundamentally broken, the middle and top end of pensioners are getting a stupidly large part of the pie. Third point, NI is the dumbest thing to raise as it is a tax that disproportionately affects low-income and middle-income workers. With this new rate hike the marginal rate for a young graduate is now 43.25% (20% income tax, 13.25% NI and 9% student loan repayments) above £27k, that jumps to 44.5% when properly applied with workers NI contribution (which is an accounting trick) and that goes up to 50.5% for people with a masters loan (that you now need to get to afford masters courses thanks to the government being dumb as shit). £27k is not enough money for the marginal rate to be that high, the UK average adult contribution is 33% for comparison, it is below the medium and mean incomes, is is more than the higher rate of income tax which applies above £50k and it's still 33.25% below that (39.25% with masters loan repayments above £21k). It is regressive, in an ideal world it would be scrapped and folded into income tax. I am happy to pay more tax to pay for the NHS and fund social care but it needs to be done in a fair way. RE: Pensions - Derek Hardballs - 09-08-2021 (09-08-2021, 12:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Again there are arguments based on false assumptions. As I said, not one of my contemporaries went to university. Most started work at 15. Again, most have worked in building or similar trades where there are insecure contracts and no pensions. A working life of 50 years deserves a pension. How old are all those on here saying the older generation fucked it up by electing selfish governments? Have they not voted these last 20+ years? The point is that increasing NI isn’t a fair way to solve the problem of social care. If you want to punish the poorest to help the richest then it’s a great solution. RE: Pensions - JOK - 09-09-2021 (09-08-2021, 09:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Of course there are exceptions at either end of the financial scale but to argue that those retiring now or recently haven’t had it far easier than the generations after them is defensive nonsense. Relatively secure jobs, clearer career ladders, decent work pensions, affordable housing, decent jobs not dependant on gaining a degree. What have those younger than them have now? Insecure jobs in many sectors, no real career ladders in many sectors, non existent pension schemes offered by many employers, affordable housing paha! Saddled with debt for gaining a degree and working hard at school. You can now add the idiotic decision to leave the EU to the list of the older generations saddling the younger generations with a decisions they don’t support and are not to their advantage. Are you really saying there are no “career ladders” in the work place now? Really? The only “decent work pensions” (and non-contributory) were in the higher echelons of the civil service, the police, the fire brigade, GPO. The vast majority didn’t have a work’s pension. The overwhelming number of “decent jobs” now, do not require a degree. Also, just remind us again, who’s government persuaded “50%” of the up-coming population to get an unnecessary degree and introduced the concept of paying for said degrees? Who then trebled them? Yep, they had, really secure jobs, from which you could be arbitrarily fired without recourse and little to no redundancy. No minimum or living wage. It is a legal requirement for all employers now to offer a pension. (Whether people take it up is another matter. When my wife was administering her company’s scheme, 5 of the 18 employers opted out) People in the 60s and 70s didn’t work hard at school then? So, no one under 55 voted for leaving the E.U.? We were ‘saddled’ with the decision to join the EEC and there was no vote, at all, to have a say! We were ‘saddled’ with the Maastricht Treaty, again, not public say! We were ‘saddled’ with the Schengen Agreement and again no public plebiscite. We were ‘saddled’ with the country engaging in illegal and needless wars. We were ‘saddled’ with foundation hospitals and school academies. I don’t think you can use the argument that the older generations were NOT ‘saddled’ with decisions that they didn’t support or were not to their advantage. Are you arguing that we should only be making decisions which are to the advantage of one demographic at the expense of another group? (Touch of your ‘Lets nick other states’ drivers to improve our lot while making theirs worse. And you say we oldies are selfish!) I know you can’t grab or understand the concept BUT try and consider that people who voted against your view re the EU were “thinking what was best for the generations after them.” You try not to get upset when called out for slagging of an entire generation and ignoring the fact that their lives were far from easy or when it’s pointed out that just because you think an idea is “idiotic” doesn’t necessarily make you right. RE: Pensions - Derek Hardballs - 09-09-2021 (09-09-2021, 07:38 AM)JOK Wrote:(09-08-2021, 09:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Of course there are exceptions at either end of the financial scale but to argue that those retiring now or recently haven’t had it far easier than the generations after them is defensive nonsense. Relatively secure jobs, clearer career ladders, decent work pensions, affordable housing, decent jobs not dependant on gaining a degree. What have those younger than them have now? Insecure jobs in many sectors, no real career ladders in many sectors, non existent pension schemes offered by many employers, affordable housing paha! Saddled with debt for gaining a degree and working hard at school. You can now add the idiotic decision to leave the EU to the list of the older generations saddling the younger generations with a decisions they don’t support and are not to their advantage. Ok…I imagine this will upset a few on here but the point is generational not on a personal / individual. Try and remember that when potentially replying. |