WBAUnofficial
Pereira future - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Pereira future (/showthread.php?tid=17451)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: Pereira future - Remi_Moses - 05-11-2021

(05-11-2021, 09:01 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 08:57 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 08:37 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 07:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: There won’t be an auction, there never is for the selling club,  the auction will be about paying Pereira and his agent.  Once a price has been agreed then the interested parties will just match it and then battle over wages.

IF he wants to we’ll have to eventually accept an offer and then the other vultures will come in with the same offer.

We should already be speaking with Pereira and telling him our position.  He can go if the right offer comes in, but it has to be right for the club whilst pointing out the valuations put on the likes of Maddison and Grealish.  And we’ve got to have a deadline, no point getting £40M at 10 mins to transfer window closing.

I’d love him to stay but in reality we’ve just got to extract the maximum value before we piss him off to the point of him demanding to go and kicking off.

(05-11-2021, 07:30 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: If we were to get £50-£55m for selling Pereira and SJ, our balance sheet looks far better to somebody negotiating to buy us from Lai.  SJ is easily replaceable with Palmer.  A new owner may also help us to invest wisely to replace Pereira.

I can't see any other way that Lai is going to be bought out. 

Hold that thought.

Lai may also stick a management charge across and nab the money as a way of recouping some of the purchase price.

He’s never going to get the c£180m back so might as well take some of it now...

That would give rise to absolutely enormous tax issues, so I doubt he’ll be doing that.

Could Dowling and BFS agree to selling SJ & Pereira and Lai walk away with the cash in an affort to lower his asking price?
Even Judas had his price?

He could pay himself money out in dividends but he’d have the living shit taxed out of him for that. 

The most tax-efficient way for him to get his money back using transfer fees would be to sell the players and then allow a takeover which taps into the clubs cash and distributable reserves to pay off the consideration of the takeover. Essentially a Burnley-style takeover, which would be downright fucking grim.

Burnley have gone into mega debt a the new owner have borrowed the cash to buy the club.
This has never worked out well, even the Glaziers at Manure costs then £70m a year in interest payments.
Guessing Burnley's will be £25m - affordable in the PL but any further investment in the squad is now limited and how the new owners
can increase the club value is to reduce the % debt is beyond my grey matter.
God forbid we ever get into such a situation.


RE: Pereira future - Squid - 05-11-2021

(05-11-2021, 09:01 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 08:57 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 08:37 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 07:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: There won’t be an auction, there never is for the selling club,  the auction will be about paying Pereira and his agent.  Once a price has been agreed then the interested parties will just match it and then battle over wages.

IF he wants to we’ll have to eventually accept an offer and then the other vultures will come in with the same offer.

We should already be speaking with Pereira and telling him our position.  He can go if the right offer comes in, but it has to be right for the club whilst pointing out the valuations put on the likes of Maddison and Grealish.  And we’ve got to have a deadline, no point getting £40M at 10 mins to transfer window closing.

I’d love him to stay but in reality we’ve just got to extract the maximum value before we piss him off to the point of him demanding to go and kicking off.

(05-11-2021, 07:30 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: If we were to get £50-£55m for selling Pereira and SJ, our balance sheet looks far better to somebody negotiating to buy us from Lai.  SJ is easily replaceable with Palmer.  A new owner may also help us to invest wisely to replace Pereira.

I can't see any other way that Lai is going to be bought out. 

Hold that thought.

Lai may also stick a management charge across and nab the money as a way of recouping some of the purchase price.

He’s never going to get the c£180m back so might as well take some of it now...

That would give rise to absolutely enormous tax issues, so I doubt he’ll be doing that.

Could Dowling and BFS agree to selling SJ & Pereira and Lai walk away with the cash in an affort to lower his asking price?
Even Judas had his price?

He could pay himself money out in dividends but he’d have the living shit taxed out of him for that. 

The most tax-efficient way for him to get his money back using transfer fees would be to sell the players and then allow a takeover which taps into the clubs cash and distributable reserves to pay off the consideration of the takeover. Essentially a Burnley-style takeover, which would be downright fucking grim.

I really fear that we will one day look back on the Lai years as good times. Getting a good owner is like finding a diamond in a slurry pit. There really aren't that many well-run clubs out there. Even those with supposedly generous owners are just great at throwing money down the drain - look at Derby, Forest and Reading for proof of that.


RE: Pereira future - wba13 - 05-11-2021

Just been watching Zaha of Palace and for me he is not as good as Pereira yet he is valued at around 40 mill and is 28. I know the transfer market will be deflated but I think we should hold out for at least 35 mill if he goes.


RE: Pereira future - CA Baggie - 05-11-2021

(05-11-2021, 08:37 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 07:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: There won’t be an auction, there never is for the selling club,  the auction will be about paying Pereira and his agent.  Once a price has been agreed then the interested parties will just match it and then battle over wages.

IF he wants to we’ll have to eventually accept an offer and then the other vultures will come in with the same offer.

We should already be speaking with Pereira and telling him our position.  He can go if the right offer comes in, but it has to be right for the club whilst pointing out the valuations put on the likes of Maddison and Grealish.  And we’ve got to have a deadline, no point getting £40M at 10 mins to transfer window closing.

I’d love him to stay but in reality we’ve just got to extract the maximum value before we piss him off to the point of him demanding to go and kicking off.

(05-11-2021, 07:30 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: If we were to get £50-£55m for selling Pereira and SJ, our balance sheet looks far better to somebody negotiating to buy us from Lai.  SJ is easily replaceable with Palmer.  A new owner may also help us to invest wisely to replace Pereira.

I can't see any other way that Lai is going to be bought out. 

Hold that thought.

Lai may also stick a management charge across and nab the money as a way of recouping some of the purchase price.

He’s never going to get the c£180m back so might as well take some of it now...

That would give rise to absolutely enormous tax issues, so I doubt he’ll be doing that.

I didn’t mean a salary, a charge from one of Palm’s companies for the time and support provided, then it would depend where the company making the management charge is based.  A profit in Panama or Belize may not attract quite so much tax.  The attitude of the Chinese government may be supportive to owners getting their money out of foreign football clubs and bringing it back to China, incentivise by “relaxing” tax on profits for owners getting out.


RE: Pereira future - Pragmatist - 05-11-2021

(05-11-2021, 08:37 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 07:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: There won’t be an auction, there never is for the selling club,  the auction will be about paying Pereira and his agent.  Once a price has been agreed then the interested parties will just match it and then battle over wages.

IF he wants to we’ll have to eventually accept an offer and then the other vultures will come in with the same offer.

We should already be speaking with Pereira and telling him our position.  He can go if the right offer comes in, but it has to be right for the club whilst pointing out the valuations put on the likes of Maddison and Grealish.  And we’ve got to have a deadline, no point getting £40M at 10 mins to transfer window closing.

I’d love him to stay but in reality we’ve just got to extract the maximum value before we piss him off to the point of him demanding to go and kicking off.

(05-11-2021, 07:30 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: If we were to get £50-£55m for selling Pereira and SJ, our balance sheet looks far better to somebody negotiating to buy us from Lai.  SJ is easily replaceable with Palmer.  A new owner may also help us to invest wisely to replace Pereira.

I can't see any other way that Lai is going to be bought out. 

Hold that thought.

Lai may also stick a management charge across and nab the money as a way of recouping some of the purchase price.

He’s never going to get the c£180m back so might as well take some of it now...

That would give rise to absolutely enormous tax issues, so I doubt he’ll be doing that.

It would also be fraudulent.  Fortunately the 12% minority shareholders have protected interests which would prevent that happening.

(05-11-2021, 08:56 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 07:30 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: If we were to get £50-£55m for selling Pereira and SJ, our balance sheet looks far better to somebody negotiating to buy us from Lai.  SJ is easily replaceable with Palmer.  A new owner may also help us to invest wisely to replace Pereira.

I can't see any other way that Lai is going to be bought out. 

Hold that thought.

Sadly leaves us open for a Burnley style takeover though Prag if we have that kinda cash on the balance sheet? 

Imagine if Lai is trying to exit Pereria and SJ will be sold to the highest cash up front bidder?

Not necessarily, but it does increase the chance of finding a buyer

(05-11-2021, 09:01 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 08:57 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 08:37 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 07:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: There won’t be an auction, there never is for the selling club,  the auction will be about paying Pereira and his agent.  Once a price has been agreed then the interested parties will just match it and then battle over wages.

IF he wants to we’ll have to eventually accept an offer and then the other vultures will come in with the same offer.

We should already be speaking with Pereira and telling him our position.  He can go if the right offer comes in, but it has to be right for the club whilst pointing out the valuations put on the likes of Maddison and Grealish.  And we’ve got to have a deadline, no point getting £40M at 10 mins to transfer window closing.

I’d love him to stay but in reality we’ve just got to extract the maximum value before we piss him off to the point of him demanding to go and kicking off.

(05-11-2021, 07:30 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: If we were to get £50-£55m for selling Pereira and SJ, our balance sheet looks far better to somebody negotiating to buy us from Lai.  SJ is easily replaceable with Palmer.  A new owner may also help us to invest wisely to replace Pereira.

I can't see any other way that Lai is going to be bought out. 

Hold that thought.

Lai may also stick a management charge across and nab the money as a way of recouping some of the purchase price.

He’s never going to get the c£180m back so might as well take some of it now...

That would give rise to absolutely enormous tax issues, so I doubt he’ll be doing that.

Could Dowling and BFS agree to selling SJ & Pereira and Lai walk away with the cash in an affort to lower his asking price?
Even Judas had his price?

He could pay himself money out in dividends but he’d have the living shit taxed out of him for that. 

The most tax-efficient way for him to get his money back using transfer fees would be to sell the players and then allow a takeover which taps into the clubs cash and distributable reserves to pay off the consideration of the takeover. Essentially a Burnley-style takeover, which would be downright fucking grim.

Can only pay dividends out of distributable reserves and there's not much of that.  Non-residents aren't taxed in the UK in dividends though. 

Agree with you though that we must avoid a Burnley-style deal at all costs.

(05-11-2021, 09:56 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 08:37 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 07:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: There won’t be an auction, there never is for the selling club,  the auction will be about paying Pereira and his agent.  Once a price has been agreed then the interested parties will just match it and then battle over wages.

IF he wants to we’ll have to eventually accept an offer and then the other vultures will come in with the same offer.

We should already be speaking with Pereira and telling him our position.  He can go if the right offer comes in, but it has to be right for the club whilst pointing out the valuations put on the likes of Maddison and Grealish.  And we’ve got to have a deadline, no point getting £40M at 10 mins to transfer window closing.

I’d love him to stay but in reality we’ve just got to extract the maximum value before we piss him off to the point of him demanding to go and kicking off.

(05-11-2021, 07:30 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: If we were to get £50-£55m for selling Pereira and SJ, our balance sheet looks far better to somebody negotiating to buy us from Lai.  SJ is easily replaceable with Palmer.  A new owner may also help us to invest wisely to replace Pereira.

I can't see any other way that Lai is going to be bought out. 

Hold that thought.

Lai may also stick a management charge across and nab the money as a way of recouping some of the purchase price.

He’s never going to get the c£180m back so might as well take some of it now...

That would give rise to absolutely enormous tax issues, so I doubt he’ll be doing that.

I didn’t mean a salary, a charge from one of Palm’s companies for the time and support provided, then it would depend where the company making the management charge is based.  A profit in Panama or Belize may not attract quite so much tax.  The attitude of the Chinese government may be supportive to owners getting their money out of foreign football clubs and bringing it back to China, incentivise by “relaxing” tax on profits for owners getting out.

You can only levy a charge or fee for bona fide services rendered.  You can't make it up. Anything else is fraud.  Might get away with it if it's only HMRC to satisfy (although unlikely), but when a fraud would cause loss to minority shareholders it's got no chance.


RE: Pereira future - Fido - 05-12-2021

(05-11-2021, 09:17 PM)wba13 Wrote: Just been watching Zaha of Palace and for me he is not as good as Pereira yet he is valued at around 40 mill and is 28. I know the transfer market will be deflated but I think we should hold out for at least 35 mill if he goes.

And similarly the stats show we create fugg all without him, I guess.


RE: Pereira future - CA Baggie - 05-12-2021

(05-11-2021, 10:10 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 08:37 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 07:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: There won’t be an auction, there never is for the selling club,  the auction will be about paying Pereira and his agent.  Once a price has been agreed then the interested parties will just match it and then battle over wages.

IF he wants to we’ll have to eventually accept an offer and then the other vultures will come in with the same offer.

We should already be speaking with Pereira and telling him our position.  He can go if the right offer comes in, but it has to be right for the club whilst pointing out the valuations put on the likes of Maddison and Grealish.  And we’ve got to have a deadline, no point getting £40M at 10 mins to transfer window closing.

I’d love him to stay but in reality we’ve just got to extract the maximum value before we piss him off to the point of him demanding to go and kicking off.

(05-11-2021, 07:30 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: If we were to get £50-£55m for selling Pereira and SJ, our balance sheet looks far better to somebody negotiating to buy us from Lai.  SJ is easily replaceable with Palmer.  A new owner may also help us to invest wisely to replace Pereira.

I can't see any other way that Lai is going to be bought out. 

Hold that thought.

Lai may also stick a management charge across and nab the money as a way of recouping some of the purchase price.

He’s never going to get the c£180m back so might as well take some of it now...

That would give rise to absolutely enormous tax issues, so I doubt he’ll be doing that.

It would also be fraudulent.  Fortunately the 12% minority shareholders have protected interests which would prevent that happening.

(05-11-2021, 08:56 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 07:30 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: If we were to get £50-£55m for selling Pereira and SJ, our balance sheet looks far better to somebody negotiating to buy us from Lai.  SJ is easily replaceable with Palmer.  A new owner may also help us to invest wisely to replace Pereira.

I can't see any other way that Lai is going to be bought out. 

Hold that thought.

Sadly leaves us open for a Burnley style takeover though Prag if we have that kinda cash on the balance sheet? 

Imagine if Lai is trying to exit Pereria and SJ will be sold to the highest cash up front bidder?

Not necessarily, but it does increase the chance of finding a buyer

(05-11-2021, 09:01 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 08:57 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 08:37 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 07:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: There won’t be an auction, there never is for the selling club,  the auction will be about paying Pereira and his agent.  Once a price has been agreed then the interested parties will just match it and then battle over wages.

IF he wants to we’ll have to eventually accept an offer and then the other vultures will come in with the same offer.

We should already be speaking with Pereira and telling him our position.  He can go if the right offer comes in, but it has to be right for the club whilst pointing out the valuations put on the likes of Maddison and Grealish.  And we’ve got to have a deadline, no point getting £40M at 10 mins to transfer window closing.

I’d love him to stay but in reality we’ve just got to extract the maximum value before we piss him off to the point of him demanding to go and kicking off.


Lai may also stick a management charge across and nab the money as a way of recouping some of the purchase price.

He’s never going to get the c£180m back so might as well take some of it now...

That would give rise to absolutely enormous tax issues, so I doubt he’ll be doing that.

Could Dowling and BFS agree to selling SJ & Pereira and Lai walk away with the cash in an affort to lower his asking price?
Even Judas had his price?

He could pay himself money out in dividends but he’d have the living shit taxed out of him for that. 

The most tax-efficient way for him to get his money back using transfer fees would be to sell the players and then allow a takeover which taps into the clubs cash and distributable reserves to pay off the consideration of the takeover. Essentially a Burnley-style takeover, which would be downright fucking grim.

Can only pay dividends out of distributable reserves and there's not much of that.  Non-residents aren't taxed in the UK in dividends though. 

Agree with you though that we must avoid a Burnley-style deal at all costs.

(05-11-2021, 09:56 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 08:37 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 07:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: There won’t be an auction, there never is for the selling club,  the auction will be about paying Pereira and his agent.  Once a price has been agreed then the interested parties will just match it and then battle over wages.

IF he wants to we’ll have to eventually accept an offer and then the other vultures will come in with the same offer.

We should already be speaking with Pereira and telling him our position.  He can go if the right offer comes in, but it has to be right for the club whilst pointing out the valuations put on the likes of Maddison and Grealish.  And we’ve got to have a deadline, no point getting £40M at 10 mins to transfer window closing.

I’d love him to stay but in reality we’ve just got to extract the maximum value before we piss him off to the point of him demanding to go and kicking off.

(05-11-2021, 07:30 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: If we were to get £50-£55m for selling Pereira and SJ, our balance sheet looks far better to somebody negotiating to buy us from Lai.  SJ is easily replaceable with Palmer.  A new owner may also help us to invest wisely to replace Pereira.

I can't see any other way that Lai is going to be bought out. 

Hold that thought.

Lai may also stick a management charge across and nab the money as a way of recouping some of the purchase price.

He’s never going to get the c£180m back so might as well take some of it now...

That would give rise to absolutely enormous tax issues, so I doubt he’ll be doing that.

I didn’t mean a salary, a charge from one of Palm’s companies for the time and support provided, then it would depend where the company making the management charge is based.  A profit in Panama or Belize may not attract quite so much tax.  The attitude of the Chinese government may be supportive to owners getting their money out of foreign football clubs and bringing it back to China, incentivise by “relaxing” tax on profits for owners getting out.

You can only levy a charge or fee for bona fide services rendered.  You can't make it up. Anything else is fraud.  Might get away with it if it's only HMRC to satisfy (although unlikely), but when a fraud would cause loss to minority shareholders it's got no chance.

Quite.  However I’m assuming Palm, to date, haven’t charged the club anything for their “time, effort, expert knowledge and experience” in running a multi-million pound company? There’s what, 4 years to charge us for now? That coupled with salaries might see enough of the money disappear for some sort of return.  

If Lai accepts we’ll be worth £30m regardless, then he needs to recoup the other £150m.  As a PL club he may get £120m (£30+90).  Therefore he really only needs to get £90M out and it might be easier than twisting again in the hope of promotion.

The minority shareholders can only really sue for their losses so a few million might shut them up.

This is obviously all hypothetical, but there’s lots of assumptions that we’ll just bounce back to the PL and that Palm/Lai will be happy with to take the gamble and keep their money tied up when they may just think “fuck it” we’ll get out what we can now in full knowledge they’ve already done at least a 1/3rd of their yuan.


RE: Pereira future - wba13 - 05-12-2021

Could Pereira go out on loan, Madeley of the Athletic states that if the right offer or the Albion aren’t willing to sell could see Pereira go out on loan for the season which could suit all parties. What we do know is this will run and run until late in the window. Can’t see this happening myself but if a loan deal could be made I’m all for it , as it would be a boost to hopefully get promotion and Pereira back.


RE: Pereira future - Fulham Fallout - 05-12-2021

The fact he didn’t sign a new, dramatically improved contract in terms of wages for just one extra year on his contract just doesn’t add up. Say he was on £25k a week and we offered him around £45k a week (as it was reported what we offered would have made him one of the top earners).

It all then went very quiet regarding his contract.


As I’ve said before, the only thing that would make sense in relation to him refusing an improved contract would be that he had a sell on value in his original contract and we tried to dramatically increase that due to his form. Why else turn down almost doubling your wages with an extra £1m per annum?

It just doesn’t add up.


RE: Pereira future - Ossian - 05-12-2021

One of the things we don't know - and this doesn't just apply to our owners - is how much they're actually worth; often the disclosed sums are just estimates of wealth.

There's an understandable assumption that any owner looking to sell will want to - at the very least - recoup their outlay, preferably with something on top. I'm wondering if that's actually the case; some of our clubs might now be owned by individuals or families who could actually kiss goodbye to fifty or a hundred million, take the hit and move on, inconceivable as that might sound. The danger then is that an owner takes the view that anybody's money will do as long as they can cut their losses and get out; it's not as if the Premier League's fit and proper/due diligence processes would fill anybody with much confidence. A club could easily pass from a no longer interested owner to one who is interested for all the wrong reasons.