RE: Indian Cooking - Baggie_Nick - 03-17-2021
(03-17-2021, 01:24 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (03-17-2021, 01:04 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-17-2021, 12:37 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I’m struggling to see what you aren’t grasping that whole spices in a curry (along with ground spices) makes the world of difference.
If you have a fennel seed, cumin seed, clove, cardamom pod / seed etc in your mouth is totally different to having all the spices ground as you don’t get the same variations in taste. A curry made with pastes or just ground spices are flat in regards the taste. No variations in taste.
This is why Asians prefer home cooked food due to the whole spices in there also.
That's bullshit.
And Asians like good tasting food like the rest of us regardless of ingredients or state of ingredients.
Adding the spices and pastes, regardless of whole or not, gives it layers of flavour. Eg adding garlic paste to the fry at the start and garlic at the end. Lime or lemon juice. A lot of restaurants use Worcestershire sauce because it adds depth. Authentic? No. Tasty? Yes.
A quick curry with a home made paste can be delicious.
Stick to your barbeque paella! 
You were quite condescending to a recipe that uses just 'powders' whilst in the past you have processed your love of Balti and BIR food which 99% of uses powders. As I said, the skill is in the cooking as raw spice, powdered or whole, is not pleasant.
Ask Asians why they prefer home cooked food to restaurant food. I think you need to start using whole spices Nick and discover how wonderful Asian food can be.
I enjoy both and I know Asians who enjoy both.
I've cooked with both methods.
I think you need to stop using sweeping generalisations! 
I made some seasoned oil the other day using cassia and tej patta amongst other spices. This will be used to fry in wet ingredients and masala powder to make a delicious curry.
There's are more than one way to skin a cat.
RE: Indian Cooking - Fulham Fallout - 03-17-2021
(03-17-2021, 01:29 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-17-2021, 01:24 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (03-17-2021, 01:04 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-17-2021, 12:37 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I’m struggling to see what you aren’t grasping that whole spices in a curry (along with ground spices) makes the world of difference.
If you have a fennel seed, cumin seed, clove, cardamom pod / seed etc in your mouth is totally different to having all the spices ground as you don’t get the same variations in taste. A curry made with pastes or just ground spices are flat in regards the taste. No variations in taste.
This is why Asians prefer home cooked food due to the whole spices in there also.
That's bullshit.
And Asians like good tasting food like the rest of us regardless of ingredients or state of ingredients.
Adding the spices and pastes, regardless of whole or not, gives it layers of flavour. Eg adding garlic paste to the fry at the start and garlic at the end. Lime or lemon juice. A lot of restaurants use Worcestershire sauce because it adds depth. Authentic? No. Tasty? Yes.
A quick curry with a home made paste can be delicious.
Stick to your barbeque paella! 
You were quite condescending to a recipe that uses just 'powders' whilst in the past you have processed your love of Balti and BIR food which 99% of uses powders. As I said, the skill is in the cooking as raw spice, powdered or whole, is not pleasant.
Ask Asians why they prefer home cooked food to restaurant food. I think you need to start using whole spices Nick and discover how wonderful Asian food can be.
I enjoy both and I know Asians who enjoy both.
I've cooked with both methods.
I think you need to stop using sweeping generalisations! 
I made some seasoned oil the other day using cassia and tej patta amongst other spices. This will be used to fry in wet ingredients and masala powder to make a delicious curry.
There's are more than one way to skin a cat.
As I said Nick, ask any Asian which they prefer and why.
A curry made with ground spices only is like turning a fruit salad in to a smoothie. FACT.
The bags of pre mixed whole spices in the Asian shops aren’t there for nothing either.
Let’s not forget you were advocating Pataks pastes recently, made in the UK and that well known country with a high Asian population, Poland.
May I suggest you give that “Stew” mix a try that I linked earlier on this thread as I guarantee there’s no way you’d make a better dish from using just ground spices. Let me know what you think after you’ve tried it.
RE: Indian Cooking - Tom Joad - 03-17-2021
(03-17-2021, 01:29 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-17-2021, 01:24 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (03-17-2021, 01:04 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-17-2021, 12:37 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I’m struggling to see what you aren’t grasping that whole spices in a curry (along with ground spices) makes the world of difference.
If you have a fennel seed, cumin seed, clove, cardamom pod / seed etc in your mouth is totally different to having all the spices ground as you don’t get the same variations in taste. A curry made with pastes or just ground spices are flat in regards the taste. No variations in taste.
This is why Asians prefer home cooked food due to the whole spices in there also.
That's bullshit.
And Asians like good tasting food like the rest of us regardless of ingredients or state of ingredients.
Adding the spices and pastes, regardless of whole or not, gives it layers of flavour. Eg adding garlic paste to the fry at the start and garlic at the end. Lime or lemon juice. A lot of restaurants use Worcestershire sauce because it adds depth. Authentic? No. Tasty? Yes.
A quick curry with a home made paste can be delicious.
Stick to your barbeque paella! 
You were quite condescending to a recipe that uses just 'powders' whilst in the past you have processed your love of Balti and BIR food which 99% of uses powders. As I said, the skill is in the cooking as raw spice, powdered or whole, is not pleasant.
Ask Asians why they prefer home cooked food to restaurant food. I think you need to start using whole spices Nick and discover how wonderful Asian food can be.
I enjoy both and I know Asians who enjoy both.
I've cooked with both methods.
I think you need to stop using sweeping generalisations! 
I made some seasoned oil the other day using cassia and tej patta amongst other spices. This will be used to fry in wet ingredients and masala powder to make a delicious curry.
There's are more than one way to skin a cat.
Then how do you cook your cat?
RE: Indian Cooking - Baggie_Nick - 03-17-2021
(03-17-2021, 01:45 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (03-17-2021, 01:29 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-17-2021, 01:24 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (03-17-2021, 01:04 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-17-2021, 12:37 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I’m struggling to see what you aren’t grasping that whole spices in a curry (along with ground spices) makes the world of difference.
If you have a fennel seed, cumin seed, clove, cardamom pod / seed etc in your mouth is totally different to having all the spices ground as you don’t get the same variations in taste. A curry made with pastes or just ground spices are flat in regards the taste. No variations in taste.
This is why Asians prefer home cooked food due to the whole spices in there also.
That's bullshit.
And Asians like good tasting food like the rest of us regardless of ingredients or state of ingredients.
Adding the spices and pastes, regardless of whole or not, gives it layers of flavour. Eg adding garlic paste to the fry at the start and garlic at the end. Lime or lemon juice. A lot of restaurants use Worcestershire sauce because it adds depth. Authentic? No. Tasty? Yes.
A quick curry with a home made paste can be delicious.
Stick to your barbeque paella! 
You were quite condescending to a recipe that uses just 'powders' whilst in the past you have processed your love of Balti and BIR food which 99% of uses powders. As I said, the skill is in the cooking as raw spice, powdered or whole, is not pleasant.
Ask Asians why they prefer home cooked food to restaurant food. I think you need to start using whole spices Nick and discover how wonderful Asian food can be.
I enjoy both and I know Asians who enjoy both.
I've cooked with both methods.
I think you need to stop using sweeping generalisations! 
I made some seasoned oil the other day using cassia and tej patta amongst other spices. This will be used to fry in wet ingredients and masala powder to make a delicious curry.
There's are more than one way to skin a cat.
As I said Nick, ask any Asian which they prefer and why.
A curry made with ground spices only is like turning a fruit salad in to a smoothie. FACT.
The bags of pre mixed whole spices in the Asian shops aren’t there for nothing either.
Let’s not forget you were advocating Pataks pastes recently, made in the UK and that well known country with a high Asian population, Poland.
May I suggest you give that “Stew” mix a try that I linked earlier on this thread as I guarantee there’s no way you’d make a better dish from using just ground spices. Let me know what you think after you’ve tried it.
I was advocating Pataks pastes as they are used widely in BIR kitchens. So the Baltis or curries that you say you enjoy in restaurants stand a good chance of containing some of these pastes. Completely irrelevant of where they are made. I didn't know they were made in Poland. No big deal. HP sauce is made in Holland these days? Still tastes good to me.
I've nothing against whole spices but I've mainly focused on BIR cuisine and that tends to use masalas. Again, because you seem to have missed the point, good masalas originate from whole spices which have been ground. Recipes for these can vary - some good, some bad. But to just write off every dish that uses powdered spices only is very blinkered and shows ignorance, in my very honest fucking opinion.
You can make very good curries using both methods.
Anyway, beans on toast for Tay tonight! 
(03-17-2021, 01:52 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (03-17-2021, 01:29 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-17-2021, 01:24 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (03-17-2021, 01:04 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (03-17-2021, 12:37 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I’m struggling to see what you aren’t grasping that whole spices in a curry (along with ground spices) makes the world of difference.
If you have a fennel seed, cumin seed, clove, cardamom pod / seed etc in your mouth is totally different to having all the spices ground as you don’t get the same variations in taste. A curry made with pastes or just ground spices are flat in regards the taste. No variations in taste.
This is why Asians prefer home cooked food due to the whole spices in there also.
That's bullshit.
And Asians like good tasting food like the rest of us regardless of ingredients or state of ingredients.
Adding the spices and pastes, regardless of whole or not, gives it layers of flavour. Eg adding garlic paste to the fry at the start and garlic at the end. Lime or lemon juice. A lot of restaurants use Worcestershire sauce because it adds depth. Authentic? No. Tasty? Yes.
A quick curry with a home made paste can be delicious.
Stick to your barbeque paella! 
You were quite condescending to a recipe that uses just 'powders' whilst in the past you have processed your love of Balti and BIR food which 99% of uses powders. As I said, the skill is in the cooking as raw spice, powdered or whole, is not pleasant.
Ask Asians why they prefer home cooked food to restaurant food. I think you need to start using whole spices Nick and discover how wonderful Asian food can be.
I enjoy both and I know Asians who enjoy both.
I've cooked with both methods.
I think you need to stop using sweeping generalisations! 
I made some seasoned oil the other day using cassia and tej patta amongst other spices. This will be used to fry in wet ingredients and masala powder to make a delicious curry.
There's are more than one way to skin a cat.
Then how do you cook your cat?
I only use whole spices for cat.
RE: Indian Cooking - Fulham Fallout - 03-17-2021
I was astounded when I saw a large tub of Pataks masala outside a restaurant on board street a few years ago: may as well go to the supermarket and buy a jar yourself and cook your own as go there.
I don’t tend to go to restaurants for Asian food as it’s nicer cooked at home. A couple of years ago I said to my lad “shall we have a curry tonight?” (As I didn’t fancy cooking) and then said we’d get a take away. My lad said, can’t we have one of yours instead, I prefer them.
My lad likes the onion chopped finely and I’d forgotten this a few weeks ago and so to get round it I decided to blitz it all with a hand blender, which of course blitzed the whole spices too. The end result, a dish that had no variations in flavour and my lad said “it’s nice, but you’ve made dishes a lot better.”
If you prefer restaurant style Asian food then fair enough, but I prefer the homestyle taste with whole spices.
RE: Indian Cooking - Cheshire East Baggie - 03-17-2021
Well this soon turned into a Mixed Culinary Arts bout didn't it?
I think FF was out of order linking Madhur Jaffrey with Vesta. She gets a bit of stick from "real" Asian chefs for being just an actress, not a trained chef, but her stuff tastes good to me. Although I'm not on board with "if you can't get coriander, you can use parsley" as referenced by another poster.
She uses whole spices extensively, but I don't get this notion that if there aren't any whole spices it's not right. We tend to buy whole spices because they keep better, then grind them if that's how we're going to use them.
And if the only way you're going to get started with cooking your own is by using a Patak's paste, then go for it.
RE: Indian Cooking - Baggie_Nick - 03-17-2021
(03-17-2021, 02:29 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I was astounded when I saw a large tub of Pataks masala outside a restaurant on board street a few years ago: may as well go to the supermarket and buy a jar yourself and cook your own as go there.
I don’t tend to go to restaurants for Asian food as it’s nicer cooked at home. A couple of years ago I said to my lad “shall we have a curry tonight?” (As I didn’t fancy cooking) and then said we’d get a take away. My lad said, can’t we have one of yours instead, I prefer them.
My lad likes the onion chopped finely and I’d forgotten this a few weeks ago and so to get round it I decided to blitz it all with a hand blender, which of course blitzed the whole spices too. The end result, a dish that had no variations in flavour and my lad said “it’s nice, but you’ve made dishes a lot better.”
If you prefer restaurant style Asian food then fair enough, but I prefer the homestyle taste with whole spices.
The Pataks paste that they buy in huge tubs is slightly different to the supermarket scaled down versions. In particular they'll use it for marinades - tikka for example. Not saying they all do of course but it's widely used.
Caramelization of onions is key. Just stewing onions and spices will be bland.
I see the beauty in both. But I certainly wouldn't write off one or the other completely as you have done. Again, the cooking process is key.
(03-17-2021, 02:39 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Well this soon turned into a Mixed Culinary Arts bout didn't it?
I think FF was out of order linking Madhur Jaffrey with Vesta. She gets a bit of stick from "real" Asian chefs for being just an actress, not a trained chef, but her stuff tastes good to me. Although I'm not on board with "if you can't get coriander, you can use parsley" as referenced by another poster.
She uses whole spices extensively, but I don't get this notion that if there aren't any whole spices it's not right. We tend to buy whole spices because they keep better, then grind them if that's how we're going to use them.
And if the only way you're going to get started with cooking your own is by using a Patak's paste, then go for it.
Amen.
Cooking should be all about taste. You like a Pot Noodle - good for you. You like a Vesta curry - good for you.
I have loads of whole spices and, like you, use them whole or grind them. Either can give gray flavour to dishes. And likewise the finished dish can be ruined by not cooking either properly.
RE: Indian Cooking - ChamonixBaggie - 03-17-2021
(03-17-2021, 02:29 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I was astounded when I saw a large tub of Pataks masala outside a restaurant on board street a few years ago: may as well go to the supermarket and buy a jar yourself and cook your own as go there.
I don’t tend to go to restaurants for Asian food as it’s nicer cooked at home. A couple of years ago I said to my lad “shall we have a curry tonight?” (As I didn’t fancy cooking) and then said we’d get a take away. My lad said, can’t we have one of yours instead, I prefer them.
My lad likes the onion chopped finely and I’d forgotten this a few weeks ago and so to get round it I decided to blitz it all with a hand blender, which of course blitzed the whole spices too. The end result, a dish that had no variations in flavour and my lad said “it’s nice, but you’ve made dishes a lot better.”
If you prefer restaurant style Asian food then fair enough, but I prefer the homestyle taste with whole spices.
Anyone who enjoys this post would probably also enjoy reddit.com/r/thathappened
RE: Indian Cooking - Fulham Fallout - 03-17-2021
Restaurants don’t have time to cook from scratch Nick as customers wouldn’t want to wait that long and certainly wouldn’t want to pay for the time it takes to prepare and cook. To get round this they use pastes and gravy.
You’re missing out on a wonderful cuisine by following the restaurant approach.
RE: Indian Cooking - Baggie_Nick - 03-17-2021
(03-17-2021, 02:47 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Restaurants don’t have time to cook from scratch Nick as customers wouldn’t want to wait that long and certainly wouldn’t want to pay for the time it takes to prepare and cook. To get round this they use pastes and gravy.
You’re missing out on a wonderful cuisine by following the restaurant approach.
I'm not missing out! I do authentic stuff (as you put it). I just really enjoy exploring BIR as well. BIR done well is superb.
There's no right or wrong it's down to personal taste. Only I wouldn't just write off one approach entirely.
|