RE: Gibbs - yeoman lai - 01-27-2021
(01-27-2021, 02:13 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (01-27-2021, 10:58 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I think Gibbs does get slightly overrated by a few because he came from Arsenal and he's a decent footballer. Defensively he's so poor at times.
This!
The discussions about Gibbs all stems from people's judgements on full backs, which in the last 20 years have followed an increasing trend not to look at their basic defending. So many fans look at full backs performances based on what they do overlapping/passing/going forward. But their main job is DEFENDING (that's not to say an overlap and good cross isn't handy - it is).
So many times in games a good full back will just "get in the way", block a cross, force a player to go backwards, push someone down a blind alley, head a ball away at the back post etc. So many fans simply don't judge them on these things, they judge them on a nice move going forwards instead.
Ridgewell was a great example. Absolutely slated from pillar to post by so many people on here, yet Hodgson (a good manager who knew how to keep the goals out) played him every week! And guess what, we finished high up the league. Ridgewell looked clumsy, not a great technical footballer - but he got in the way, he blocked, he marked, he headed it away at the back post. He did the basics of defending that hardly anyone seems to notice in full backs these days as they're too busy looking for the nice run and overlap down the wing. Its a nonsense!
And that's not to say the stuff in possession should be ignored, but the fact is its secondary to solid defending for a full back. Gibbs is technically one of our best, in nearly 4 seasons I don't think I've seen him have a bad first touch. His passing is accurate. But this is no good if you can't stop crosses, can't block, can't head it. And Gibbs is crap at those things at this level (and only ok at champ level). That's why no one has bid for him while he's been with us, simple as that.
Judge full backs on defending first and foremost. The attacking side to them is a bonus, not the most important thing.
Good post, and something I've been saying re : Gibbs since he signed (albeit not as eloquently).
RE: Gibbs - Birdman1811 - 01-27-2021
(01-27-2021, 02:13 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (01-27-2021, 10:58 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I think Gibbs does get slightly overrated by a few because he came from Arsenal and he's a decent footballer. Defensively he's so poor at times.
This!
The discussions about Gibbs all stems from people's judgements on full backs, which in the last 20 years have followed an increasing trend not to look at their basic defending. So many fans look at full backs performances based on what they do overlapping/passing/going forward. But their main job is DEFENDING (that's not to say an overlap and good cross isn't handy - it is).
So many times in games a good full back will just "get in the way", block a cross, force a player to go backwards, push someone down a blind alley, head a ball away at the back post etc. So many fans simply don't judge them on these things, they judge them on a nice move going forwards instead.
Ridgewell was a great example. Absolutely slated from pillar to post by so many people on here, yet Hodgson (a good manager who knew how to keep the goals out) played him every week! And guess what, we finished high up the league. Ridgewell looked clumsy, not a great technical footballer - but he got in the way, he blocked, he marked, he headed it away at the back post. He did the basics of defending that hardly anyone seems to notice in full backs these days as they're too busy looking for the nice run and overlap down the wing. Its a nonsense!
And that's not to say the stuff in possession should be ignored, but the fact is its secondary to solid defending for a full back. Gibbs is technically one of our best, in nearly 4 seasons I don't think I've seen him have a bad first touch. His passing is accurate. But this is no good if you can't stop crosses, can't block, can't head it. And Gibbs is crap at those things at this level (and only ok at champ level). That's why no one has bid for him while he's been with us, simple as that.
Judge full backs on defending first and foremost. The attacking side to them is a bonus, not the most important thing.
Spot on.
RE: Gibbs - MrFizz - 01-27-2021
I'd also wager that Peltier is a better defender than Furlong. Not as good a 'footballer', but i know which one i'd back to be in the correct position to block a shot/cross/head it away.
Perhaps we would concede less with two proper defensive full-backs, rather than wingers who can defend a bit.
RE: Gibbs - Johnnykayeengland - 01-27-2021
(01-27-2021, 03:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (01-27-2021, 02:13 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (01-27-2021, 10:58 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I think Gibbs does get slightly overrated by a few because he came from Arsenal and he's a decent footballer. Defensively he's so poor at times.
This!
The discussions about Gibbs all stems from people's judgements on full backs, which in the last 20 years have followed an increasing trend not to look at their basic defending. So many fans look at full backs performances based on what they do overlapping/passing/going forward. But their main job is DEFENDING (that's not to say an overlap and good cross isn't handy - it is).
So many times in games a good full back will just "get in the way", block a cross, force a player to go backwards, push someone down a blind alley, head a ball away at the back post etc. So many fans simply don't judge them on these things, they judge them on a nice move going forwards instead.
Ridgewell was a great example. Absolutely slated from pillar to post by so many people on here, yet Hodgson (a good manager who knew how to keep the goals out) played him every week! And guess what, we finished high up the league. Ridgewell looked clumsy, not a great technical footballer - but he got in the way, he blocked, he marked, he headed it away at the back post. He did the basics of defending that hardly anyone seems to notice in full backs these days as they're too busy looking for the nice run and overlap down the wing. Its a nonsense!
And that's not to say the stuff in possession should be ignored, but the fact is its secondary to solid defending for a full back. Gibbs is technically one of our best, in nearly 4 seasons I don't think I've seen him have a bad first touch. His passing is accurate. But this is no good if you can't stop crosses, can't block, can't head it. And Gibbs is crap at those things at this level (and only ok at champ level). That's why no one has bid for him while he's been with us, simple as that.
Judge full backs on defending first and foremost. The attacking side to them is a bonus, not the most important thing.
Spot on. Excellent points. A bit more thoughtful than"he's crap", so a bit wasted on some other sites I read...
RE: Gibbs - Duffers - 01-27-2021
Ridgewell got a hard time because of who he used to play for, not how good he was.
RE: Gibbs - Squid - 01-27-2021
(01-27-2021, 04:05 PM)Duffers Wrote: Ridgewell got a hard time because of who he used to play for, not how good he was.
Sounds familiar.
Excellent post by basksidebaggie, btw.
RE: Gibbs - MrFizz - 01-27-2021
(01-27-2021, 04:05 PM)Duffers Wrote: Ridgewell got a hard time because of who he used to play for, not how good he was.
And wiping his arse with £20 notes.
RE: Gibbs - backsidebaggie - 01-27-2021
(01-27-2021, 04:05 PM)Duffers Wrote: Ridgewell got a hard time because of who he used to play for, not how good he was.
Correct. And his haircut. He was a darn decent full back.
RE: Gibbs - clem4england - 01-27-2021
(01-27-2021, 02:13 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (01-27-2021, 10:58 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I think Gibbs does get slightly overrated by a few because he came from Arsenal and he's a decent footballer. Defensively he's so poor at times.
This!
The discussions about Gibbs all stems from people's judgements on full backs, which in the last 20 years have followed an increasing trend not to look at their basic defending. So many fans look at full backs performances based on what they do overlapping/passing/going forward. But their main job is DEFENDING (that's not to say an overlap and good cross isn't handy - it is).
So many times in games a good full back will just "get in the way", block a cross, force a player to go backwards, push someone down a blind alley, head a ball away at the back post etc. So many fans simply don't judge them on these things, they judge them on a nice move going forwards instead.
Ridgewell was a great example. Absolutely slated from pillar to post by so many people on here, yet Hodgson (a good manager who knew how to keep the goals out) played him every week! And guess what, we finished high up the league. Ridgewell looked clumsy, not a great technical footballer - but he got in the way, he blocked, he marked, he headed it away at the back post. He did the basics of defending that hardly anyone seems to notice in full backs these days as they're too busy looking for the nice run and overlap down the wing. Its a nonsense!
And that's not to say the stuff in possession should be ignored, but the fact is its secondary to solid defending for a full back. Gibbs is technically one of our best, in nearly 4 seasons I don't think I've seen him have a bad first touch. His passing is accurate. But this is no good if you can't stop crosses, can't block, can't head it. And Gibbs is crap at those things at this level (and only ok at champ level). That's why no one has bid for him while he's been with us, simple as that.
Judge full backs on defending first and foremost. The attacking side to them is a bonus, not the most important thing. Awesome post Backside. Absolutely nailed it. Gibbs is a fraud.
RE: Gibbs - TETLEY74 - 01-27-2021
(01-27-2021, 03:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (01-27-2021, 02:13 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (01-27-2021, 10:58 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I think Gibbs does get slightly overrated by a few because he came from Arsenal and he's a decent footballer. Defensively he's so poor at times.
This!
The discussions about Gibbs all stems from people's judgements on full backs, which in the last 20 years have followed an increasing trend not to look at their basic defending. So many fans look at full backs performances based on what they do overlapping/passing/going forward. But their main job is DEFENDING (that's not to say an overlap and good cross isn't handy - it is).
So many times in games a good full back will just "get in the way", block a cross, force a player to go backwards, push someone down a blind alley, head a ball away at the back post etc. So many fans simply don't judge them on these things, they judge them on a nice move going forwards instead.
Ridgewell was a great example. Absolutely slated from pillar to post by so many people on here, yet Hodgson (a good manager who knew how to keep the goals out) played him every week! And guess what, we finished high up the league. Ridgewell looked clumsy, not a great technical footballer - but he got in the way, he blocked, he marked, he headed it away at the back post. He did the basics of defending that hardly anyone seems to notice in full backs these days as they're too busy looking for the nice run and overlap down the wing. Its a nonsense!
And that's not to say the stuff in possession should be ignored, but the fact is its secondary to solid defending for a full back. Gibbs is technically one of our best, in nearly 4 seasons I don't think I've seen him have a bad first touch. His passing is accurate. But this is no good if you can't stop crosses, can't block, can't head it. And Gibbs is crap at those things at this level (and only ok at champ level). That's why no one has bid for him while he's been with us, simple as that.
Judge full backs on defending first and foremost. The attacking side to them is a bonus, not the most important thing.
Spot on.
The most important and fundamental job of any defender is to fuggin defend, Gibbs is poor at defending, Townsend is the better defender but dosnt catch the eye going forward so gets slated on here. I've only seen one fullback at the Albion who could both with consummate ease and that was Derek Statham.
Fwiw I think Roberto Carlos was crap at defending and lived on the reputation of THAT free kick most of his career.
|