WBAUnofficial
“Lack of Investment” - The Myth - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: “Lack of Investment” - The Myth (/showthread.php?tid=13558)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: “Lack of Investment” - The Myth - Big Daddy Cool - 11-04-2020

(11-04-2020, 07:30 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 11:04 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 09:45 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 09:43 PM)The liquidator Wrote: Look at our neighbours spending and its fucking embarrassing.

Which ones? The ones backed by wealthy Arabs or the ones bankrolled by a Chinese acquisition firm in bed with the Portuguese super agent?

What our neighbours do is irrelevant.

No it's,not, they are our rivals.

Our investment has been pathetic.

Last time we played Fulham at home we couldn't beat them.with more or less the same team.

And then we sell a first team player.

Nick, I know you love using emotive phrases like “pathetic” and “penny pinching” but I’m going to ask a simple question and I’m keen to get your response...

How could we have spent more? We have a 25k stadium that we struggle to fill, no wealthy backers and little sponsorship revenue. Where is this extra money you feel we should be spending coming from?

And this is what those who slag off the club for not spending don't seem to understand. We haven't got the money of other clubs and some of our own fans use that as a stick to beat us with. We're competing the best we can. This is why Slav's moaning because the the long term future of the club isn't his priority. His priority is his own CV. Of course, every manager is the same so I don't blame him for that. All managers want more money to spend.


RE: “Lack of Investment” - The Myth - CA Baggie - 11-04-2020

(11-04-2020, 02:14 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 09:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: Been reading a few times on here about the lack of investment in the transfer market by the owners, it’s something that gets repeated so often it becomes an accepted fact. I thought I would do a little digging to see how true it actually is...

Lai took over September 2016, so let’s look at the spend in the years building up:

(Figures courtesy of  Transfermarkt)

11/12 -  Players in: £8.2m Players out: £10m. Net Spend -£1.8m - Plus Gera and McAuley on frees.

12/13 - In: £4.5m Out: £3.3m. Net spend £1.2m - Plus Rosenberg and Yacob on frees and Lukaku loan fee & wages.

13/14 - In: £14.1m Out: £10.2m. Net spend £3.9m - Plus Anelka and Lugano on frees and Sinclair loan.

14/15 - In: £22.4m Out: £2.1m. Net spend £20.3m - Plus Lescott, Gardner, Fletcher on frees.

15/16 - In: £38.6m Out: £11.6m. Net spend £27m

16/17 - In: £34.1m Out: £24.2m. Net spend £9.9m

17/18 (Lai’s first summer window) In: £48.1m Out: £1.9m. Net spend £46.2m - Plus loans and wages for Sturridge and Gap-year Greg

18/19 (Champ) - In: £13.7m. Out: £23.9m. Net spend -£9.8m - Plus Gayle, Barnes, Tosin loan and wages.

19/20 (Champ) - In: £19.4m Out: £29.5m. Net spend -£10.2m

20/21 - In: £36.4 Out: £6.8m. Net spend £29.6m - Plus Ivanovic free and loans for Gallagher and Krov.

Conclusions:

Investment in the transfer market has not slowed down under Lai at all. Barring the two Championship seasons where we turned over an entire squad to cut costs investment has remained at the same rough level it always has. The line from the club has always been we will spend within our means and these figure demonstrate we are doing just that. This season’s slight dip in net spend could easily attributed to projected loss of revenue as a result of COVID. The money has been spent, the more pertinent question is whether it was spent well.

A further interesting quirk is that spend really jumped from 14/15 onwards, which was around the time JP first expressed keenness to sell the club.

And how much additional equity has been injected by the shareholders to purchase anything?

Cashflows are different to profits.  Hudds show a profit on Grant, but they will wait 6 years for the cash.

Too many people scream "where's the money gone, Tom" who couldn't understand cashflow vs Profit vs Net Worth if it was spoon fed to them.

Nice to know the condescending Minstrel is never far from our bored.

I'm one that believes we could have done more in the market and our owners could have helped us.

Lai could have repaid the loan he inherited from baldy - turning an asset into cash.  The cash could then have been used in the transfer market (provided the spending was in line with FFP).

Secondly, we have a contingent asset in the form of the fergie tribunal case.  This will be held as an asset and will also generate a profit.  Lai could have loaned the cash against this asset and taken the money back once the tribunal amount had been set/paid.  I'm sure the club's auditor could have been provided with enough evidence to recognise this as an asset and we could have prudently set this at £8m with a note detailing it is expected to be significantly more.

That profit and cash flow could have seen us get a couple of FBs or a holding midfielder or a forward that knows how to hold the bloody ball up top (I think this is more of an issue with Slav and his style of play tbh). 

Or we could have loaned against that contingent asset to help realise the cash much quicker.

Neither of those options would have cost Lai anything other than temporarily the ability to use the cash elsewhere, so it's not about pumping money in and spunking it aots, just about being smarter and trying to do the best for the club.

It seems the absent owner doesn't care enough to even do that or is so strapped that he can't.


RE: “Lack of Investment” - The Myth - Birdman1811 - 11-04-2020

Lai may not even be our owner anymore, and he never had money anyway.


RE: “Lack of Investment” - The Myth - Kit Kat Chunky - 11-04-2020

(11-04-2020, 02:12 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(11-04-2020, 02:14 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 09:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: Been reading a few times on here about the lack of investment in the transfer market by the owners, it’s something that gets repeated so often it becomes an accepted fact. I thought I would do a little digging to see how true it actually is...

Lai took over September 2016, so let’s look at the spend in the years building up:

(Figures courtesy of  Transfermarkt)

11/12 -  Players in: £8.2m Players out: £10m. Net Spend -£1.8m - Plus Gera and McAuley on frees.

12/13 - In: £4.5m Out: £3.3m. Net spend £1.2m - Plus Rosenberg and Yacob on frees and Lukaku loan fee & wages.

13/14 - In: £14.1m Out: £10.2m. Net spend £3.9m - Plus Anelka and Lugano on frees and Sinclair loan.

14/15 - In: £22.4m Out: £2.1m. Net spend £20.3m - Plus Lescott, Gardner, Fletcher on frees.

15/16 - In: £38.6m Out: £11.6m. Net spend £27m

16/17 - In: £34.1m Out: £24.2m. Net spend £9.9m

17/18 (Lai’s first summer window) In: £48.1m Out: £1.9m. Net spend £46.2m - Plus loans and wages for Sturridge and Gap-year Greg

18/19 (Champ) - In: £13.7m. Out: £23.9m. Net spend -£9.8m - Plus Gayle, Barnes, Tosin loan and wages.

19/20 (Champ) - In: £19.4m Out: £29.5m. Net spend -£10.2m

20/21 - In: £36.4 Out: £6.8m. Net spend £29.6m - Plus Ivanovic free and loans for Gallagher and Krov.

Conclusions:

Investment in the transfer market has not slowed down under Lai at all. Barring the two Championship seasons where we turned over an entire squad to cut costs investment has remained at the same rough level it always has. The line from the club has always been we will spend within our means and these figure demonstrate we are doing just that. This season’s slight dip in net spend could easily attributed to projected loss of revenue as a result of COVID. The money has been spent, the more pertinent question is whether it was spent well.

A further interesting quirk is that spend really jumped from 14/15 onwards, which was around the time JP first expressed keenness to sell the club.

And how much additional equity has been injected by the shareholders to purchase anything?

Cashflows are different to profits.  Hudds show a profit on Grant, but they will wait 6 years for the cash.

Too many people scream "where's the money gone, Tom" who couldn't understand cashflow vs Profit vs Net Worth if it was spoon fed to them.

Nice to know the condescending Minstrel is never far from our bored.

I'm one that believes we could have done more in the market and our owners could have helped us.

Lai could have repaid the loan he inherited from baldy - turning an asset into cash.  The cash could then have been used in the transfer market (provided the spending was in line with FFP).

Secondly, we have a contingent asset in the form of the fergie tribunal case.  This will be held as an asset and will also generate a profit.  Lai could have loaned the cash against this asset and taken the money back once the tribunal amount had been set/paid.  I'm sure the club's auditor could have been provided with enough evidence to recognise this as an asset and we could have prudently set this at £8m with a note detailing it is expected to be significantly more.

That profit and cash flow could have seen us get a couple of FBs or a holding midfielder or a forward that knows how to hold the bloody ball up top (I think this is more of an issue with Slav and his style of play tbh). 

Or we could have loaned against that contingent asset to help realise the cash much quicker.

Neither of those options would have cost Lai anything other than temporarily the ability to use the cash elsewhere, so it's not about pumping money in and spunking it aots, just about being smarter and trying to do the best for the club.

It seems the absent owner doesn't care enough to even do that or is so strapped that he can't.

Please let Minstrel retort, in the order the points were raised :-

Lai has never acknowledged he owes the money. Even if he does, your assuming he can raise the cash to repay it. We have seen no evidence to suggest he has any cash.

You say that Lai "could have loaned against the contingent asset", no he couldn't.  There is no bank in this day and age (even pre-covid) that will lend against ifs and maybes. We did borrow money against the Dawson payments, and if you go on Companies House you will see that documented to Macquarie Bank. That is a certain contract, and can be funded. 

You can't use profit to buy anything. If you go into a shop to buy something, they accept  cash, not profit.

Either of your options would have cost. The first would have cost Lai personally, assuming he has the cash, and the second option if fundable (which it isn't) the rates of interest Macquarie Bank charge are around 7% p.a.

The only asset that we could finance would be the future TV revenue. Given we are not established, the most you could borrow would be a percentage of 1 Season's parachute monies. Yes this would make a difference, but it is a massive gamble because if you are relegated, how do you fund your day to day operations without the parachute? The answer isn't by selling your players (even if that is realistically what you would do) because the club then is insolvent (is unable to meet its financial obligations as and when they fall due), and the auditors then also have to consider qualifying the accounts because the business cannot be run as a going concern.

I believe the club did the most it could with the resources available. You can argue that the monies could have been used more wisely, but I just don't see that we could have spent any more, unless Lai had invested into the club.


RE: “Lack of Investment” - The Myth - Birdman1811 - 11-04-2020

Spot on Minstrel.

The fact we had to stagger the Grant payment out so much shows how little cash there is in the club.

Diangana was probably an overly expensive mistake in the short term, but long term was possibly an excellent move.

Its hard to balance short and long term with limited cash flow.


RE: “Lack of Investment” - The Myth - backsidebaggie - 11-04-2020

Spot on Biirdy and KitKat.

I actually don't know what some fans want the club to do. I asked Nick the same last night on here and didn't get a reply. We simply haven't got a sugar daddy. That's it. If it upsets fans that much, the only option is to take up another hobby or go support a rich club.

Fans seem to think its a computer game and you can just spend what you haven't got. Literally the only option if we want to spend more is to go into debt, and that would be utter madness.


RE: “Lack of Investment” - The Myth - Baggiejacko - 11-04-2020

So let me get this straight. The club are cnuts for not selling players at the height of their value and cnuts for selling Hegazi?????


RE: “Lack of Investment” - The Myth - Remi_Moses - 11-04-2020

I'm not 100% sure, but a few things holdings us back ATM is the Pereira transfer has to be paid in full this month and the Hegazi move is loan to perm - so I doubt much of a cash boost came from that.


RE: “Lack of Investment” - The Myth - CA Baggie - 11-04-2020

(11-04-2020, 04:05 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Spot on Biirdy and KitKat.

I actually don't know what some fans want the club to do. I asked Nick the same last night on here and didn't get a reply. We simply haven't got a sugar daddy. That's it. If it upsets fans that much, the only option is to take up another hobby or go support a rich club.

Fans seem to think its a computer game and you can just spend what you haven't got. Literally the only option if we want to spend more is to go into debt, and that would be utter madness.

I think I've given a reasonable explanation of what I'd have liked the club to do.

Why are the views so extreme on this?  Take the likes of Nick out, who every knows is constantly on the wind-up,  plus a few dingles\seals, and who is actually asking for the club to get in to debt on this bored?  There's no shouting "spend the fucking money" going on.

Seems if we're not ultra prudent then we must be Pompey and nowhere in between.  If the owners cared and had any funds at all then they could do things lie the examples I supplied.  

Dowling told us we'd got a Sheff Utd type budget and they spent £71m in 19/20 we have spent less than half that, in 3 seasons we've spent (net) less than £10m on fees.  I'm fully aware of loan fees and wages etc but none of us know the true figures for these. 

I'm, not doubting we spend what we've got in a very cautious manner but there are ways to be better.  We hid behind FFP when we signed Sturridge and sold Tyler Roberts whilst the clubs that want to spend money just sponsor the club cat or something daft.


RE: “Lack of Investment” - The Myth - CA Baggie - 11-04-2020

(11-04-2020, 03:35 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-04-2020, 02:12 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(11-04-2020, 02:14 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 09:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: Been reading a few times on here about the lack of investment in the transfer market by the owners, it’s something that gets repeated so often it becomes an accepted fact. I thought I would do a little digging to see how true it actually is...

Lai took over September 2016, so let’s look at the spend in the years building up:

(Figures courtesy of  Transfermarkt)

11/12 -  Players in: £8.2m Players out: £10m. Net Spend -£1.8m - Plus Gera and McAuley on frees.

12/13 - In: £4.5m Out: £3.3m. Net spend £1.2m - Plus Rosenberg and Yacob on frees and Lukaku loan fee & wages.

13/14 - In: £14.1m Out: £10.2m. Net spend £3.9m - Plus Anelka and Lugano on frees and Sinclair loan.

14/15 - In: £22.4m Out: £2.1m. Net spend £20.3m - Plus Lescott, Gardner, Fletcher on frees.

15/16 - In: £38.6m Out: £11.6m. Net spend £27m

16/17 - In: £34.1m Out: £24.2m. Net spend £9.9m

17/18 (Lai’s first summer window) In: £48.1m Out: £1.9m. Net spend £46.2m - Plus loans and wages for Sturridge and Gap-year Greg

18/19 (Champ) - In: £13.7m. Out: £23.9m. Net spend -£9.8m - Plus Gayle, Barnes, Tosin loan and wages.

19/20 (Champ) - In: £19.4m Out: £29.5m. Net spend -£10.2m

20/21 - In: £36.4 Out: £6.8m. Net spend £29.6m - Plus Ivanovic free and loans for Gallagher and Krov.

Conclusions:

Investment in the transfer market has not slowed down under Lai at all. Barring the two Championship seasons where we turned over an entire squad to cut costs investment has remained at the same rough level it always has. The line from the club has always been we will spend within our means and these figure demonstrate we are doing just that. This season’s slight dip in net spend could easily attributed to projected loss of revenue as a result of COVID. The money has been spent, the more pertinent question is whether it was spent well.

A further interesting quirk is that spend really jumped from 14/15 onwards, which was around the time JP first expressed keenness to sell the club.

And how much additional equity has been injected by the shareholders to purchase anything?

Cashflows are different to profits.  Hudds show a profit on Grant, but they will wait 6 years for the cash.

Too many people scream "where's the money gone, Tom" who couldn't understand cashflow vs Profit vs Net Worth if it was spoon fed to them.

Nice to know the condescending Minstrel is never far from our bored.

I'm one that believes we could have done more in the market and our owners could have helped us.

Lai could have repaid the loan he inherited from baldy - turning an asset into cash.  The cash could then have been used in the transfer market (provided the spending was in line with FFP).

Secondly, we have a contingent asset in the form of the fergie tribunal case.  This will be held as an asset and will also generate a profit.  Lai could have loaned the cash against this asset and taken the money back once the tribunal amount had been set/paid.  I'm sure the club's auditor could have been provided with enough evidence to recognise this as an asset and we could have prudently set this at £8m with a note detailing it is expected to be significantly more.

That profit and cash flow could have seen us get a couple of FBs or a holding midfielder or a forward that knows how to hold the bloody ball up top (I think this is more of an issue with Slav and his style of play tbh). 

Or we could have loaned against that contingent asset to help realise the cash much quicker.

Neither of those options would have cost Lai anything other than temporarily the ability to use the cash elsewhere, so it's not about pumping money in and spunking it aots, just about being smarter and trying to do the best for the club.

It seems the absent owner doesn't care enough to even do that or is so strapped that he can't.

Please let Minstrel retort, in the order the points were raised :-

Lai has never acknowledged he owes the money. Even if he does, your assuming he can raise the cash to repay it. We have seen no evidence to suggest he has any cash.

You say that Lai "could have loaned against the contingent asset", no he couldn't.  There is no bank in this day and age (even pre-covid) that will lend against ifs and maybes. We did borrow money against the Dawson payments, and if you go on Companies House you will see that documented to Macquarie Bank. That is a certain contract, and can be funded. 

You can't use profit to buy anything. If you go into a shop to buy something, they accept  cash, not profit.

Either of your options would have cost. The first would have cost Lai personally, assuming he has the cash, and the second option if fundable (which it isn't) the rates of interest Macquarie Bank charge are around 7% p.a.

The only asset that we could finance would be the future TV revenue. Given we are not established, the most you could borrow would be a percentage of 1 Season's parachute monies. Yes this would make a difference, but it is a massive gamble because if you are relegated, how do you fund your day to day operations without the parachute? The answer isn't by selling your players (even if that is realistically what you would do) because the club then is insolvent (is unable to meet its financial obligations as and when they fall due), and the auditors then also have to consider qualifying the accounts because the business cannot be run as a going concern.

I believe the club did the most it could with the resources available. You can argue that the monies could have been used more wisely, but I just don't see that we could have spent any more, unless Lai had invested into the club.

I did caveat by saying he may not have the cash.

In both instances he "could" have put money in by A) repaying the loan and B) funding the future profit to be made on the Fergie Tribunal.

The profit is needed for FFP reasons so you absolutely do need the profit in the world of football.  Had we have loaned, via Lai, on this, then lcearly we could have done more business than we did.

I'm aware we effectively "factored" the Dawson money and that's never cheap.  My main point is that with a willing owner we didn't need to get into any external debt or spend money we hadn't got as a club, just be flexible as an owner.

I've not seen anyone ask for the Risdale scenario of loaning against future income. 

I understand the self-sufficient argument but having got to the PL and instantly greatly improved the market value of his asset then some flexibility would have been welcome, so I hold that the owners haven't done everything they could for the club.