WBAUnofficial
The blame game - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: The blame game (/showthread.php?tid=13322)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: The blame game - baggy1 - 10-21-2020

(10-21-2020, 12:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Have you read Danny Finklestien today btw? Well worth a scan.

I don't have a times subscription but the Lockdown vs Shielding being the wrong debate looks very much like something i want to read.


RE: The blame game - Borin' Baggie - 10-21-2020

(10-21-2020, 01:36 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-21-2020, 12:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Have you read Danny Finklestien today btw? Well worth a scan.

I don't have a times subscription but the Lockdown vs Shielding being the wrong debate looks very much like something i want to read.

You can make a free account with The Times and you get some free articles per week.


RE: The blame game - Protheroe - 10-21-2020

(10-21-2020, 01:36 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-21-2020, 12:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Have you read Danny Finklestien today btw? Well worth a scan.

I don't have a times subscription but the Lockdown vs Shielding being the wrong debate looks very much like something i want to read.

When she was 26 years old Annie Duke, a cognitive psychologist, National Science Foundation fellow, on the academic fast track, had a change of career. She became a professional poker player.
Starting in the basement of a bar in Billings, Montana, the original idea was to earn a little money to support a return to university teaching. The career diversion lasted 20 years, during which time she won $4 million and a World Series of Poker gold bracelet. And at the end of it she realised she hadn’t really changed track after all.
What Duke came to appreciate is that all she had been doing was practising decision-making in a new environment. This insight has led to two books, the best-selling Thinking in Bets and now How to Decide, published last week.
The core insight of Duke’s books is really quite simple. You can’t be certain of the outcome of your decisions in advance, since the result depends upon luck as well as skill. So the right test of a good decision is not whether it ends well but whether it is made in a disciplined fashion, applying good judgment given the facts you know.
A further complication is that you don’t know all the facts and will be forced to estimate many of them given the incomplete data you have. But this need not stop you making decisions.

So how can Duke’s new book help with the big decision now in front of us? Should we press on with the strategy of placing restrictions on the general population, hoping to control Covid until there is a vaccine or treatment? Or, as some suggest, move to a strategy of opening the economy while shielding the most vulnerable?
Duke describes a variety of techniques to help decision-making, but on Covid I found the most useful to be the pre mortem, an idea originally developed by Gary Klein, the decision theorist.
The pre mortem asks you to imagine that you are at a point in the future where the outcome of your decision has become clear and the outcome has been a disappointment. Then you examine how this disappointing result came about.

Let’s conduct a pre mortem on the shielding idea. How might it go wrong and what would it look like if it did?
Well, obviously it could prove impossible to shield vulnerable people. After all, many of them live with people who wouldn’t be shielding and those who live alone are often reliant on others. If this happened, the NHS may quickly be overwhelmed and large numbers of people would die, both of Covid and non-Covid illnesses, since the hospitals would be too full to deal with them.
The hope of the shielding strategy is that we would relatively rapidly achieve something close to herd immunity, but a pre mortem would imagine that not working. We may have a very high death rate for fairly limited progress on immunity.
And finally, in these circumstances the economy may not recover, despite restrictions being removed. People would stay at home to avoid the virus, knowing that if they or their relatives or friends became ill, the NHS wouldn’t be able to cope.
What though of the other idea? What would a pre mortem of the strategy of general control — the tiers or circuit-breaker policies — look like?
The most likely reasons for such a strategy to fail are twofold. One is that people don’t comply, the virus spreads anyway and the NHS is overwhelmed. The other is that people do comply but the resulting damage to the economy is so great that the restrictions kill more people than they save.
A pre mortem would imagine the government waiting for an effective vaccine, only to find that it doesn’t come. Eventually the policy of control has to be abandoned and we have made no progress towards herd immunity. Despite all the damage to the economy and social life, we are no further forward.
Using the pre mortem helped me understand three things about the correct strategy towards Covid.
The first is that the widespread confidence, including mine, that one knows which policy to support is astonishing and unjustified. The best one can do is to make a very rough attempt to estimate the probability of different outcomes. And even if one gets those right, a probability is only a probability. It doesn’t tell you how things will turn out.
My inclination is to support the policy of general restrictions over shielding because, using one of Duke’s educated guesses, I think the chance of making shielding work is very low and I think we are a long way from herd immunity.
However — and this is the second thing that struck me from the pre mortems — my position relies to some extent on payoffs and probabilities that I haven’t the information to calculate with great accuracy. How sensible the general restriction policy is depends a great deal on how likely we are to get a vaccine and I don’t think the publicly available information is sufficient to make this judgment properly.
Nor do we have much to help us on the economic calculation. What modelling has been done on the possible impacts of the strategies on the economy and, crucially, on what that means for mortality, life expectancy and quality of life? We can’t really have a sensible public debate without this being at its centre.
These are not, however, the most important lessons of the pre mortems. While I was looking for the contrasts between the two strategies to pick between them, I was missing the point. What the pre mortems show is not so much the differences between shielding and general restrictions as the similarity between them.
The point is that they are both highly likely to fail. It is highly likely that shielding won’t work, highly likely that herd immunity is far into the distance and unreliable, highly likely restrictions won’t work because compliance stops (we can see it happening now) and highly likely we won’t get a vaccine for a long time. In all cases of failure the NHS would be overwhelmed.
So alongside our national debate about which strategy works we should be having one about whether we are prepared for neither to work. Which means a debate about whether we can get our test infrastructure working and prepare the NHS for what may be about to come.
It would certainly be better to do that now than wait for a post mortem to tell us that’s what we ought to have done.


RE: The blame game - billybassett - 10-21-2020

Another person who doesn't understand clinical immunology and viral immunity in the body.


RE: The blame game - baggy1 - 10-21-2020

Thanks Proth, and all good points tbh despite Dr. Billy's  Wink pointing out of the dubious medical knowledge that wasn't really the point of the article.

It actually makes a lot of sense and, if I'm reading it correctly, the focus should be on preparing the NHS for the inevitable. It does sum up where i am because my gut feeling is to have a short lockdown to bring the numbers down so that they don't multiply exponentially, but I also feel that there is no real end game to this approach until we get a vaccine of which there is no sight of. It would probably help if the politicians stopped giving the 'it's close' and it will be 'world beating' and just gave us how long each stage will go if it all goes perfectly, honest, answer. And based on my views above I have taken a side based on figures that are predictions.

Billy appears to have all bases covered though and if he's wrong he can just blame misinformation and any further excess deaths being down to non-covid reasons which will reinforce his views he is right. 

Good article and has given me some for for though - appreciated


RE: The blame game - foreveralbion - 10-21-2020

good article.

im of the opinion that those that feel the most threat are already "sheilding" to a great extent already.

if as the author says nothing will work then i cant see why we need to push certain areas into further lockdowns.

id hope with the summer to prepare then the nhs is ready with all sorts of plans formulated if hospitalisations go way beyond normal.

i would like to see a much better breakdown of case numbers as well.

baggy1 does a good job on here with the numbers so i dont see why the government cant give us some more context at least weekly.


RE: The blame game - billybassett - 10-21-2020

(10-21-2020, 03:52 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Thanks Proth, and all good points tbh despite Dr. Billy's  Wink pointing out of the dubious medical knowledge that wasn't really the point of the article.

It actually makes a lot of sense and, if I'm reading it correctly, the focus should be on preparing the NHS for the inevitable. It does sum up where i am because my gut feeling is to have a short lockdown to bring the numbers down so that they don't multiply exponentially, but I also feel that there is no real end game to this approach until we get a vaccine of which there is no sight of. It would probably help if the politicians stopped giving the 'it's close' and it will be 'world beating' and just gave us how long each stage will go if it all goes perfectly, honest, answer. And based on my views above I have taken a side based on figures that are predictions.

Billy appears to have all bases covered though and if he's wrong he can just blame misinformation and any further excess deaths being down to non-covid reasons which will reinforce his views he is right. 

Good article and has given me some for for though - appreciated

That's very unfair in all honesty.

Bit like me holding you to account for all future deaths due to lack of other treatments and general health impacts


RE: The blame game - Derek Hardballs - 10-21-2020

(10-21-2020, 01:18 PM)The liquidator Wrote: Totally different argument and you know it his..... People have mugged the furlough scheme the thing that kept 12 million I think in money and not on the dole by the government.... These are the people who have acted selfishly that the government won't be bitten twice by doing it again and won't be ripped off again for another Billions again.... Get your anger at those selfish wankers on THIS one Derek.

Serco were fined millions for fraudulent activity at the expense of U.K. taxpayers. They have now been given millions of pounds again without any tendering. It is relevant even if you don’t want to admit it.


RE: The blame game - baggy1 - 10-21-2020

(10-21-2020, 05:16 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(10-21-2020, 03:52 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Thanks Proth, and all good points tbh despite Dr. Billy's  Wink pointing out of the dubious medical knowledge that wasn't really the point of the article.

It actually makes a lot of sense and, if I'm reading it correctly, the focus should be on preparing the NHS for the inevitable. It does sum up where i am because my gut feeling is to have a short lockdown to bring the numbers down so that they don't multiply exponentially, but I also feel that there is no real end game to this approach until we get a vaccine of which there is no sight of. It would probably help if the politicians stopped giving the 'it's close' and it will be 'world beating' and just gave us how long each stage will go if it all goes perfectly, honest, answer. And based on my views above I have taken a side based on figures that are predictions.

Billy appears to have all bases covered though and if he's wrong he can just blame misinformation and any further excess deaths being down to non-covid reasons which will reinforce his views he is right. 

Good article and has given me some for for though - appreciated

That's very unfair in all honesty.

Bit like me holding you to account for all future deaths due to lack of other treatments and general health impacts

It was a bit more tongue in cheek, but I do get frustrated with the conspiracy theory (all the figures are made up) approach that you take. The article spells out basically what is fact - we don't know what is best and are all guessing.


RE: The blame game - Jack Halford - 10-21-2020

(10-21-2020, 10:49 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I think what is emerging clearly now is that a Labour Govt would have been in a better position to deal with this crisis than a Conservative one.

Simply because they would have pursued a policy that was coherent and not dysfunctional like the present Govt.

With the growing influence that the Chancellor has , he has more than one eye on the economic impact of the covid response and the growing national debt and is taking decisions which act against the govt's attempts to curb infection rates. The treasuries policies are making it more difficult for ordinary people to adhere to lockdown restrictions .  But whilst the Chancellor's attention is drawn to the state of the economy, other in the Govt are concerned by the impact an uncontrolled covid will have on the NHS, and to the economy. In effect the Govt are trying to ride two horses travelling in different directions.

I think Labour would take a more coherent approach and provide the resources necessary to back up any restrictions to curb covid they would put in place.

You could argue that in the medium and long term this would be the wrong approach, that would be for the future to decide, but at the moment we are in danger of getting the worst of both worlds.

You are right about the Govt trying to ride two horses. There is a real balance to be made as there is not an infinite pot of money to keep throwing it around.

I work with many international corporates who are restructuring like crazy. There will come a point where the economy will have to take precedence as the fall out will be far worse than COVID.

However, Mmmm, the hindsight Labour Party...I’ve yet to see a coherent response apart from “we’ll follow the science”.