RE: 100 Great Black Britons - HawkingsHalfpint - 10-10-2020
If Howard from Halifax is on that list, I emigrate today.
RE: 100 Great Black Britons - Jack Halford - 10-10-2020
To have Kehindra Andrews on the list but not Cyrille is unbelievable.
I hope Trevor MacDonald is on the list
RE: 100 Great Black Britons - baggiebloke - 10-10-2020
(10-09-2020, 05:48 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Seems odd to me that you can be "great" if you are a current politician, no matter how shite, but you can't make it if you were a truly influential footballer. If the abysmal Diane Abbott gets kudos for being the first black female MP, why isn't Viv Anderson on there as the first black England footballer?
And it's interesting to note how much more easily "greatness" is achieved if you are a movie or TV star. So you need a really good agent to become "great" it seems.
Luckily, we just about have enough footage of Cyrille to show what he was all about on the pitch. Those lucky enough to meet him off it will feel an unusual privilege for having met or known him.
Luckily, again, we have Brendon who is just a great bloke.
Daley Thompson's omission is baffling.
I mean, what more could he have done?!!
RE: 100 Great Black Britons - Cheshire East Baggie - 10-10-2020
(10-10-2020, 08:58 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: (10-09-2020, 05:48 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Seems odd to me that you can be "great" if you are a current politician, no matter how shite, but you can't make it if you were a truly influential footballer. If the abysmal Diane Abbott gets kudos for being the first black female MP, why isn't Viv Anderson on there as the first black England footballer?
And it's interesting to note how much more easily "greatness" is achieved if you are a movie or TV star. So you need a really good agent to become "great" it seems.
Luckily, we just about have enough footage of Cyrille to show what he was all about on the pitch. Those lucky enough to meet him off it will feel an unusual privilege for having met or known him.
Luckily, again, we have Brendon who is just a great bloke.
Daley Thompson's omission is baffling.
I mean, what more could he have done?!!
Daley Thompson once said "I'm not black, I'm British". Disqualified.
RE: 100 Great Black Britons - baggiebloke - 10-10-2020
He's defo black.
RE: 100 Great Black Britons - JOK - 10-10-2020
Who were on this selection ‘panel of experts’ and what are they experts of? I can find no reference to the make up of this ‘panel’ other than the two authors and ‘A N Other’.
On the list, and indeed placed first in the original list though this one, at least, doesn’t rank the selection, is Mary Seacole.
Seacole was born to a Scottish father and a mixed-race women in Jamaica. (she was described as a ‘Quadroon’ i.e. one quarter African decent) She spent less than 17 years altogether in Briton. (22% of her life) The longest period being the last eleven years of her life.
She spent over 54 years in the Caribbean. (72% of her life) So, having spent 3/4 of her life living where she was born and brought up, how is she classed as British? Let’s ignore the dubious claims of her being a black Florence Nightingale I’ve mentioned before.
Walter Tull, on the other hand was born and bred in Britain, only the third Black person to play in the top division of English professional football, volunteered for the British army as a private within four months of the First World War starting. He fought on the Somme. He gained a commission in 1917 (Possibly the first black persons to do so in a regular ‘British’ regiment). He was mentioned in dispatches and according to his Commanding officer and a lieutenant friend, writing commiserations letters to his mother, had been recommended for the Military Cross.
He was killed in action in 1918 and his body could not be recovered. (Interestingly, despite attempts by a former Leicester City goalkeeper [ I think] to retrieve it under fire)
So, a British born and bred man who achieved sporting success, against the odds, obtained military recognition, against the odds, in a much less enlightened time and fought and died bravely and with distinction for his country doesn’t make a list compiled by two authors and which exalts a rapper and an innumerate woman elected to Parliament in a safe seat; I don’t think I’ll take too much notice of said list.
RE: 100 Great Black Britons - baggiebloke - 10-10-2020
(10-10-2020, 10:30 AM)JOK Wrote: Who were on this selection ‘panel of experts’ and what are they experts of? I can find no reference to the make up of this ‘panel’ other than the two authors and ‘A N Other’.
On the list, and indeed placed first in the original list though this one, at least, doesn’t rank the selection, is Mary Seacole.
Seacole was born to a Scottish father and a mixed-race women in Jamaica. (she was described as a ‘Quadroon’ i.e. one quarter African decent) She spent less than 17 years altogether in Briton. (22% of her life) The longest period being the last eleven years of her life.
She spent over 54 years in the Caribbean. (72% of her life) So, having spent 3/4 of her life living where she was born and brought up, how is she classed as British? Let’s ignore the dubious claims of her being a black Florence Nightingale I’ve mentioned before.
Walter Tull, on the other hand was born and bred in Britain, only the third Black person to play in the top division of English professional football, volunteered for the British army as a private within four months of the First World War starting. He fought on the Somme. He gained a commission in 1917 (Possibly the first black persons to do so in a regular ‘British’ regiment). He was mentioned in dispatches and according to his Commanding officer and a lieutenant friend, writing commiserations letters to his mother, had been recommended for the Military Cross.
He was killed in action in 1918 and his body could not be recovered. (Interestingly, despite attempts by a former Leicester City goalkeeper [ I think] to retrieve it under fire)
So, a British born and bred man who achieved sporting success, against the odds, obtained military recognition, against the odds, in a much less enlightened time and fought and died bravely and with distinction for his country doesn’t make a list compiled by two authors and which exalts a rapper and an innumerate woman elected to Parliament in a safe seat; I don’t think I’ll take too much notice of said list.
Reading between the lines I think you think the list is shit.
RE: 100 Great Black Britons - Remi_Moses - 10-10-2020
Surely Lennox Lewis has to be in the hall of fame.
RE: 100 Great Black Britons - cornishbaggie - 10-10-2020
(10-10-2020, 11:18 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: (10-10-2020, 10:30 AM)JOK Wrote: Who were on this selection ‘panel of experts’ and what are they experts of? I can find no reference to the make up of this ‘panel’ other than the two authors and ‘A N Other’.
On the list, and indeed placed first in the original list though this one, at least, doesn’t rank the selection, is Mary Seacole.
Seacole was born to a Scottish father and a mixed-race women in Jamaica. (she was described as a ‘Quadroon’ i.e. one quarter African decent) She spent less than 17 years altogether in Briton. (22% of her life) The longest period being the last eleven years of her life.
She spent over 54 years in the Caribbean. (72% of her life) So, having spent 3/4 of her life living where she was born and brought up, how is she classed as British? Let’s ignore the dubious claims of her being a black Florence Nightingale I’ve mentioned before.
Walter Tull, on the other hand was born and bred in Britain, only the third Black person to play in the top division of English professional football, volunteered for the British army as a private within four months of the First World War starting. He fought on the Somme. He gained a commission in 1917 (Possibly the first black persons to do so in a regular ‘British’ regiment). He was mentioned in dispatches and according to his Commanding officer and a lieutenant friend, writing commiserations letters to his mother, had been recommended for the Military Cross.
He was killed in action in 1918 and his body could not be recovered. (Interestingly, despite attempts by a former Leicester City goalkeeper [ I think] to retrieve it under fire)
So, a British born and bred man who achieved sporting success, against the odds, obtained military recognition, against the odds, in a much less enlightened time and fought and died bravely and with distinction for his country doesn’t make a list compiled by two authors and which exalts a rapper and an innumerate woman elected to Parliament in a safe seat; I don’t think I’ll take too much notice of said list.
Reading between the lines I think you think the list is shit.
He's not happy about, tbf I'm with him, I'm off to the beach
RE: 100 Great Black Britons - baggiebloke - 10-10-2020
(10-10-2020, 12:06 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote: (10-10-2020, 11:18 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: (10-10-2020, 10:30 AM)JOK Wrote: Who were on this selection ‘panel of experts’ and what are they experts of? I can find no reference to the make up of this ‘panel’ other than the two authors and ‘A N Other’.
On the list, and indeed placed first in the original list though this one, at least, doesn’t rank the selection, is Mary Seacole.
Seacole was born to a Scottish father and a mixed-race women in Jamaica. (she was described as a ‘Quadroon’ i.e. one quarter African decent) She spent less than 17 years altogether in Briton. (22% of her life) The longest period being the last eleven years of her life.
She spent over 54 years in the Caribbean. (72% of her life) So, having spent 3/4 of her life living where she was born and brought up, how is she classed as British? Let’s ignore the dubious claims of her being a black Florence Nightingale I’ve mentioned before.
Walter Tull, on the other hand was born and bred in Britain, only the third Black person to play in the top division of English professional football, volunteered for the British army as a private within four months of the First World War starting. He fought on the Somme. He gained a commission in 1917 (Possibly the first black persons to do so in a regular ‘British’ regiment). He was mentioned in dispatches and according to his Commanding officer and a lieutenant friend, writing commiserations letters to his mother, had been recommended for the Military Cross.
He was killed in action in 1918 and his body could not be recovered. (Interestingly, despite attempts by a former Leicester City goalkeeper [ I think] to retrieve it under fire)
So, a British born and bred man who achieved sporting success, against the odds, obtained military recognition, against the odds, in a much less enlightened time and fought and died bravely and with distinction for his country doesn’t make a list compiled by two authors and which exalts a rapper and an innumerate woman elected to Parliament in a safe seat; I don’t think I’ll take too much notice of said list.
Reading between the lines I think you think the list is shit.
He's not happy about, tbf I'm with him, I'm off to the beach 
Bastard.
|