![]() |
|
Brexit Gains 2 - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Brexit Gains 2 (/showthread.php?tid=20905) |
RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Protheroe - 06-27-2022 (06-27-2022, 09:39 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(06-27-2022, 09:17 AM)Protheroe Wrote: When I voted for Brexit, I didn't vote for the big state socialism we appear to be ending up with. These are insane political choices. I'm not just referring to this issue. I didn't campaign to increase corporate taxes. I didn't campaign to retain agricultural subsidies. I didn't campaign for some spurious and futile notion of state-funded Levelling Up of economically moribund areas. I didn't campaign for a wholly ineffective migration policy. I could've done all that by campaigning for chaos with Ed Miliband in 2015. As it is Boris has parked his tanks all over Labour's lawn with the only difference being that we're outside the EU. These are all political choices. The wrong political choices. I didn't campaign to Leave the EU to retain and augment its worst aspects of sclerosis, subsidy and protectionism. Who on Earth would have? None of these policy decisions are an automatic response to Brexit, they are all political decisions by government obsessed with tomorrow's headlines rather than any coherent strategy. (06-27-2022, 10:55 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I can agree the original referendum question was inadequate, and that we should have been voting on a clear brexit plan, not a concept with no substance. Yet we entered a Common Market. Were reassured by every supporter of entry to the EEC that it was a Common Market, not an emerging political bloc. There was no "clear plan" when we entered and dissenting voices (and political giants) like Barbara Castle, Tony Benn, Enoch Powell and Peter Shore were derided as nutjobs for suggesting the trajectory of the EEC was not exactly benign. What's good for the goose is good for the gander, so what question should we have been asked on Entry? And what question on Exit? We call play that game. Watch Sturgeon play it next year. RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Borin' Baggie - 06-27-2022 Do you think the farmers that are reliant on EU funding and put up signs supporting Vote Leave on their land wanted removal of agricultural subsidies? Do you think those in economically declining areas reliant on an industrial manufacturing anchor business supported leaving to prop-up the London-centric service industry? Do you think the xenophobes who voted leave wanted a flexible and liberal immigration policy? Therein lies the problem, the whole idea of Brexit was built upon contradictions. It's fine getting it to work when the objective is to just leave the EU with no plan as to what that entails but when they want to implement policy the house of cards collapses and we end up with a government talking about liberal free trade and simultaneously ignoring the free trade government body to implement protectionist steel tariffs. Scottish independence is a good parallel, what policy framework do the Scottish protectionists, constitutionalist, isolationists and agrarians have in common exactly? RE: Brexit Gains 2 - baggy1 - 06-27-2022 So your view is that we made a mistake 50 years ago which saw the greatest increase in our quality of life ever and you want to put a stop to that. RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Ossian - 06-27-2022 There was never the slightest possibility that the landowning community would wind up disadvantaged by Brexit; at least not those with the most substantial aggregated holdings and the corresponding clout. Small hill farms and crofts - such as there are left - might well get left behind; the multi-thousand hectare agribusinesses and 'sporting' estates wield way too much connection and lobbying power. This is turning into a very odd definition of sticking it to the establishment. RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Protheroe - 06-27-2022 (06-27-2022, 12:56 PM)baggy1 Wrote: So your view is that we made a mistake 50 years ago which saw the greatest increase in our quality of life ever and you want to put a stop to that. I'm not convinced it was a mistake to join a common market. I am convinced that it was mistake to join a supra-national organisation with much broader aims that turned into something very different - something I have in common with prominent Socialists of the time (though they hated the Common Market too tbh). The common market certainly contributed to the rise in living standards in the UK, as did the domestic policies that followed our economic nadir in the 1970s. The rest of the political European project - not so much. In all this talk about contradictions I'm always amused that you adopt the Thatcherite position on the common market. (06-27-2022, 12:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: 1. Do you think the farmers that are reliant on EU funding and put up signs supporting Vote Leave on their land wanted removal of agricultural subsidies? 1. You'll have to ask them what their motivations were, but my own view is that if your business cannot generate a profit without a hefty subsidy then it is not a business. This is a feature of marginal farming in the UK and elsewhere and you have to ask yourself whether it's fair that the hard pressed taxpayer subsidises some agricultural lifestyles - particularly hill farming. I don't think it is. 2. London is an international City that just happens to be in the UK. If London grows and thrives we all grow and thrive. I'm far more concerned about the cake getting bigger rather being divided equally. There are far too many parts of our country that simply have ceased to have an economic reason to exist. This has happened everywhere in every age. Birmingham was muddy ditch until the advent of industrialisation. And if there's a lesson to be learned from regional policy it's the deliberate state-sponsored decline in Birmingham's post war growth and diversity which left it far too dependent on the automotive industry. You will not level up declining areas by levelling down other areas - particularly your most successful ones. 3. I can count the self confessed xenophobes I've met on one hand. What they have in common with any reasonable person is that they expect a country's border to actually mean something, even if for the real xenophobe the central aim is to keep people out. The very least the most liberal or the most extreme xenophobe should expect is consistency and the rule of law concerning immigration. RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Borin' Baggie - 06-27-2022 1. I'm not asking for your view. I'm pointing out that farmers would not vote for agricultural subsidies to removed and if the government were to do that they would lose a substantial amount of the rural vote. 2. I know London is an international city, I agree that forcing Birmingham into a city reliant on a singular anchor business was dumb and caused irreparable damage to the city and the wider regional economy as seen to this day. But areas that are reliant on a singular industry to act as an anchor want protections for those anchor industries and they thought Brexit would help ensure that, these areas are in the 'Red Wall' and the Tories have pandered to them. 3. We have operated with a liberal and flexible immigration policy for millenia, there were no immigration controls in England and Wales until after Victoria died - your talk about the countries borders "meaning something" only came into effect by virtue as a form of illiberal labour protectionism don't you know? - which enabled Russian Jews to escape persecution to this country amongst other communities. There was imperial preference after the fact which enabled a postwar recovery through free movement of labour from old imperial domains such as India (which is the reason I'm here, my granddad got a shit tonne of abuse from Black Country folk for having the temerity to helping keep the country running). Rigid border restrictions are very much against the norm in this country. The Tories have pandered to the xenophobic, close the border crusades with their arbitrary targets for electoral reasons and now they're acting on it by continuing to pander them (except now without an external entity to blame) as they know that that could swing a few marginal seats - productivity is already suffering, the shortage list is bollocks and artificially restricts wages in the earmarked sectors which don't even cover all the sectors there are shortages in. Thanks to these contradictions we are going to implement steel tariffs and our stupid government is also risking a trade war with our two biggest trading partners over a region that doesn't even want what the government is trying to do. As for Thatcher and the single market, you do realise this place is generally filled with people economically in the centre, right? Not socialists. I don't think B1 is very keen on centralised and planned economies. RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Ossian - 06-27-2022 (06-27-2022, 07:23 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: As for Thatcher and the single market, you do realise this place is generally filled with people economically in the centre, right? Not socialists. I don't think B1 is very keen on centralised and planned economies. Unfortunately that's one of the consequences of dealing in lazy and meaningless collective terminology, an example being 'the left'. Social Democrats - if such a thing dared even speak its name in the UK - have managed to be an integral part of the political landscape across most of Northern and Western Europe throughout the postwar era, without ever threatening to trigger the overthrow of capitalism. RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Rustynail - 07-22-2022 You can get a stamp in your passport now ... may involve queuing a few days in Dover though RE: Brexit Gains 2 - baggy1 - 07-22-2022 (07-22-2022, 10:56 AM)Rustynail Wrote: You can get a stamp in your passport now ... may involve queuing a few days in Dover though This! It is strangely satisfying collecting the stamps again I have to say. It was all worth it. RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Sotv - 07-22-2022 (07-22-2022, 10:56 AM)Rustynail Wrote: You can get a stamp in your passport now ... may involve queuing a few days in Dover though Didn’t holidaymakers have to show their passports pre Brexit then? How else did they check whoever was travelling to France was British or an EU citizen and not someone transiting through the UK? Genuine question btw, I seem to remember having mine checked when I travelled abroad pre withdrawal. |