![]() |
|
So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted (/showthread.php?tid=9466) |
RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - baggpuss - 03-14-2020 (03-14-2020, 08:56 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:(03-14-2020, 08:50 AM)ferencpuskas Wrote: IMO the sensible thing would be to revert to the "old" 2 up 2 down NO play offs. Play offs were only introduced to bring in more money anyway. The best 2 benefit the worst 2 lose out. QED. In this scenario - you could either award both teams 1 point each or their games to points average. RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - scotbaggie - 03-14-2020 They could just promote us and Leeds, and then do the normal playoff for Fulham and the other 3. There is plenty of time for that. In the PL, they could just relegate the bottom three, why not? Or they could do a playoff of the bottom 6, the three losers drop. Again even if the rest of the season is cancelled, there is still likely plenty of time for playoffs RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - Dreamkiller - 03-14-2020 Games behind closed doors (in an extreme, hopefully one-off situation) to fairly complete a competition is far more preferable than teams unfairly losing or gaining access to a multi-million pound league, or ending up in a lower league. I say that as someone who's team currently sit one place above the trapdoor. Voiding the league or relegating the three teams below us would give me almost zilch pleasure. It also has to be borne in mind that a few games played behind closed doors over the next few weeks would at least facilitate the supporters of every team being able to watch their team playing in the correct league next season. RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - Johnnykayeengland - 03-14-2020 (03-14-2020, 05:07 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Games behind closed doors (in an extreme, hopefully one-off situation) to fairly complete a competition is far more preferable than teams unfairly losing or gaining access to a multi-million pound league, or ending up in a lower league.All sensible. But what about teams in the lower leagues? No live TV coverage. No spectators, no income to pay staff. Outside contracts won't be honoured.... A very difficult situation. Anyone who says they have a solution hasn't thought it through! RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - SW4Baggie - 03-14-2020 I think the issue for me is that we’ve played over 80% of the season, and in that scenario every team has had ample opportunity to be in whatever position their aims were at the start of the year. I get that some teams may feel they have had tougher fixtures than others in their 80% played, but this is hardly going to be the difference between being 2nd of 5th. To void the season would be entirely unfair, so we either complete games behind closed doors, which I think opens all sorts of financial problems for lower league clubs in terms of salaries and insurances and is easily open for abuse, or we just conclude the season as it stands now with a handful of behind closed doors games to finalise games in hand. It may feel a little unfair should teams who know they can win one game and survive but it’s a damn sight fairer than rendering a season that’s over 3/4 complete null and void given the levels of investment that have been made into competing for trophies etc this year. RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - Dreamkiller - 03-14-2020 I'm just glad no one picked up on me saying that Stoke were one place above the relegation zone when we're actually in 17th position. Back to the point though, I'm not really in favour of the league finishing now, just because the league is 80% completed. I mean, look at Hull. They're dropping like an absolute stone where the teams below are picking up points. They looked absolutely nailed on to drop into the relegation zone, but as it stands, they'd survive. That can't be right or fair. Lower league teams will be badly hit. I've said previously I think this will finish a few off. But football at the top end is awash with money. I know it sounds naive to think that they would willingly help out to ensure teams below survive. But in order to ensure games can be played to complete the season and ensure that the integrity of the leagues is maintained, I don't see why with a little goodwill and commonsense, this can't be arranged. RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - Johnnykayeengland - 03-14-2020 (03-14-2020, 05:39 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: I'm just glad no one picked up on me saying that Stoke were one place above the relegation zone when we're actually in 17th position.Enlightened self interest? Hollow laugh... But the big teams need the medium, need the smaller, and down the pecking order . You could argue that without little Tranmere there's no Liverpool, without little Walsall, no Baggies, without little Stoke no Port Vale ... The top 6 don't want a 6 team league, nor even a 30 team EFL. So it makes sense to use the dosh sloshing around the PL to keep the leagues going... RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - Dreamkiller - 03-14-2020 (03-14-2020, 05:51 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:(03-14-2020, 05:39 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: I'm just glad no one picked up on me saying that Stoke were one place above the relegation zone when we're actually in 17th position.Enlightened self interest? Enlightened self interest? Pretty much. Would Liverpool vote to give up a small proportion of this season's Premier League money to ensure the lower league fixtures (and their own) can go ahead rather than the season being voided? Would Leicester? West Ham? Maybe not so much so. RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - Mickyfudge - 03-14-2020 (03-14-2020, 04:27 PM)Three Degrees Wrote: This proves theres to much football today , back when i were a lad you get matches postponed for weeks and they still finished the season , still before its pointed out to me money I think it was 1978 loads of games were postponed because of the ice and snow ,the season was still completed RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - 74bus - 03-14-2020 (03-14-2020, 06:28 PM)Mickyfudge Wrote:(03-14-2020, 04:27 PM)Three Degrees Wrote: This proves theres to much football today , back when i were a lad you get matches postponed for weeks and they still finished the season , still before its pointed out to me money 192/63 was even worse. Hardly a game was played from just after Christmas until the end of February, and the season was still completed. Obviously a completely different scenario now, but in fairness, every effort should be made to finish a season which is well over 80% through already. |