WBAUnofficial
Villa have spent how much????? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Villa have spent how much????? (/showthread.php?tid=5702)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Villa have spent how much????? - MassDebater - 08-01-2019

(08-01-2019, 11:51 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: FFP is an interesting one.

The cap on wages at Prem Level has now gone, so they can spunk whatever they want - and they have done.

If they are relegated though, the three year rolling loss rule will come in, and given what they have spent they will smash that. If they stay up, they are fine and dandy. if they are relegated, they have a fire sale and FFP to contend with - as I understand it.

Well you learn something new every day. I didn't know the Prem had no wage thing in place anymore. Do you know what kind of rules (if any) they do have?

If Villa do get relegated it'll be a fire sale of epic proportions. Fingers crossed!


RE: Villa have spent how much????? - SW4Baggie - 08-01-2019

(08-01-2019, 11:51 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: FFP is an interesting one.

The cap on wages at Prem Level has now gone, so they can spunk whatever they want - and they have done.

If they are relegated though, the three year rolling loss rule will come in, and given what they have spent they will smash that. If they stay up, they are fine and dandy. if they are relegated, they have a fire sale and FFP to contend with - as I understand it.

If they get relegated McGinn and Greasy get sold for £25m a piece and they're fine.

They've invested in assets that should give them sell on potential.

The rolling 3 years will show a break even for last season due to the ground sale, a loss for the coming season... which will probably be in line with the allowable losses.... so it's hardly going to be a crisis of what staying down this year would have given them.


RE: Villa have spent how much????? - Duffers - 08-01-2019

Makes you wonder what we would have spent had we gone up.


RE: Villa have spent how much????? - Fido - 08-01-2019

Given we’ve had a rolling commentary about this for the last year or so, of which no prophecies have come to fruition, can we just drop this fuggin topic?


RE: Villa have spent how much????? - SW4Baggie - 08-01-2019

(08-01-2019, 11:55 AM)Duffers Wrote: Makes you wonder what we would have spent had we gone up.

I think we had a better squad to work with than Villa.

I imagine the Gayle/Rondon swap would have happened and Benitez would probably still be at Newcastle... Rodriguez and Dawson would be on new deals, and it would be us looking for 3-4 signings of quality and supplementing with the likes of Holgate and potentially Tosin again.


RE: Villa have spent how much????? - 11amstart - 08-01-2019

I have to say, I don't give a fuck what Villa do! I'd rather read posts on our message board about our own team!


RE: Villa have spent how much????? - Duffers - 08-01-2019

(08-01-2019, 11:59 AM)Fido Wrote: Given we’ve had a rolling commentary about this for the last year or so, of which no prophecies have come to fruition, can we just drop this fuggin topic?

Are you new here?

(08-01-2019, 12:20 PM)11amstart Wrote: I have to say, I don't give a fuck what Villa do! I'd rather read posts on our message board about our own team!

There are only so many times someone can ask why we haven’t signed a striker yet.


RE: Villa have spent how much????? - Statto - 08-01-2019

This rewriting of history is brilliant. Using Mings as a big hindsight stick to beat Moore with is laughable.

Mings undoubtedly did well for Villa in the championship, but time will tell if he's a flat track bully. The jury is out because he looked very ordinary against proper strikers in three games against us. He made a massive difference to them as at the time they had Chester on one leg and Jedinak. He wouldn't have made such a difference as our defence was better. 

However, the following all applied:
  • Bournemouth whacked in a £1m loan fee when other interest emerged.
  • There was a massive question mark on his injuries
  • He'd played no football
  • Centre half was not a priority for us to use up a loan signing as we had gaping holes elsewhere
  • We were almost unanimously happy with our January business at the time (less so by May)
I think everyone fancied the mings deal but most understood not paying £1m at that time. The meltdown would have been epic if we'd chosen Mings over Hegazi. In hindsight we'd have taken him over Montero and Murphy, but not at the time.

You also have to factor in how lucky Villa were again. He should have been serving a minimum 6 game ban, probably 10, at the time they turned their form around.  The stamp on Oliveira was, and still is, an utter fucking disgrace.


RE: Villa have spent how much????? - tiptontown - 08-01-2019

(08-01-2019, 12:46 PM)Statto Wrote: This rewriting of history is brilliant. Using Mings as a big hindsight stick to beat Moore with is laughable.

Mings undoubtedly did well for Villa in the championship, but time will tell if he's a flat track bully. The jury is out because he looked very ordinary against proper strikers in three games against us. He made a massive difference to them as at the time they had Chester on one leg and Jedinak. He wouldn't have made such a difference as our defence was better. 

However, the following all applied:
  • Bournemouth whacked in a £1m loan fee when other interest emerged.
  • There was a massive question mark on his injuries
  • He'd played no football
  • Centre half was not a priority for us to use up a loan signing as we had gaping holes elsewhere
  • We were almost unanimously happy with our January business at the time (less so by May)
I think everyone fancied the mings deal but most understood not paying £1m at that time. The meltdown would have been epic if we'd chosen Mings over Hegazi. In hindsight we'd have taken him over Montero and Murphy, but not at the time.

You also have to factor in how lucky Villa were again. He should have been serving a minimum 6 game ban, probably 10, at the time they turned their form around.  The stamp on Oliveira was, and still is, an utter fucking disgrace.

Always thought he got off lightly with that. It was made out to be accidental, but watching the replay quite a few times, it looked as though he shortened his stride to catch him.


RE: Villa have spent how much????? - Birdman1811 - 08-01-2019

Villa have spent a lot and not really improved. Next week as clubs get desperate I see some feelers out for Grealish and McGinn which will unsettle them I reckon.

That defence isn't good enough in my opinion, no guaranteed scorers in that team at all. A decent Keeper but that won't keep you up, we had better in Foster.

I see them struggling, and they'll have turned on Smith by game 10, he won't last the season.